7 ms·
> I suspect the venom is because people are assuming that its a binary situation, you're either a remote company or not. That's because it's true. You're eithe
by stavros 5y ago
> I suspect the venom is because people are assuming that its a binary situation, you're either a remote company or not.
That's because it's true. You're either a remote company or the remote people find that they routinely hear about things much later than everyone in the office knows about them.
- cm2012 5y agoYeah, hybrid is worst of both worlds. You still have to live near the office (so little labor market advantage), and remote workers become second class.
- KaiserPro 5y ago> little labour market advantage The market advantage only works where there is a lack of labour. In cities with a big scene, there will be a lack of labour for a given industry. everyone remote will depress your labour's value because you are competing against a much bigger pool of talent. In tech its not so apparent yet, because there is a short supply of staff generally. But that wont persist for ever.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> In tech its not so apparent yet, because there is a short supply of staff generally. But that wont persist for ever. There's a lot more programmers on the market right now than 10 years ago thanks to bootcamps and short degrees. Honestly, for each one hired you generally need a proper engineer to cleanup the mess afterward. I'm not worried about an oversupplied of qualified engineers anytime soon.
- krageon 5y ago> that wont persist for ever. Being good tech staff is a hard skill. This idea that there will ever be enough just because the demand is high (and therefore there are many people getting schooling) is not healthy. Even when there are a lot of tech workers, there will be sourcing trouble. Instead of not finding anyone at all, companies will find very poor tech folks. In a very real sense this is already a problem today.
- PaulKeeble 5y agoIf anyone is remote everyone has to behave like everyone is remote. I have done this once with a company where I was the only remote developer and it didn't work at all. They did nothing extra to make it work and it made it impossible to do the job.
- beaconstudios 5y agoIt's ironic because when I've worked in the office (basically all my life until covid) the management would often try to encourage people to more actively document their work in tickets or Confluence, and keep their ticket status updated in real time. It would seem that making the company remote-first would drive the exact changes that managers often want to make anyway.
- noasaservice 5y agoIn my experiences (multiple), in-person work is primarily about the appearance of work, and not nearly as much about the actual work. I've tried to properly document basic reasonings and how-to's for future people in the roles, and told that wasn't really the work needed done. Then again, management failed to understand that onboardinng and more routine-ish tasks could be documented and sped up. I jumped ship from my previous job (that was forced WfH with grumblings of returning any day now), to a 100% true remotework position. I'll *NEVER* go back to a hybrid or WfW job again.
- baby 5y agoExactly! When we switched to remote at the start of COVID all our communication issues seemed way less important as people were communicating more on slack.
- yashap 5y agoMy current company is hybrid, and I haven’t found this to be true. But, it’s majority remote - maybe 1/3 of employees actually live elsewhere, and of the 2/3 who live in the same city as the office, most just don’t come in to the office super frequently. I think this notion is built on pre-pandemic reality, when it was like 95% in office, 5% remote. Then remote was a 2nd class citizen, in-person conversations reigned, and remote ppl were fairly out of the loop. But when 50% or more of people are remote, everything is “remote first”, basically all communication happening in Slack (or at least being summarized online), and I just haven’t seen this happen.
- asd88 5y agoWe are still in the “pandemic reality” and just starting to transition out of it. If/when the majority of that 2/3 of people go back to the same office, remote employees will go back to being second class citizens. Basically, I agree that your company is currently remote-first, even if they have offices and most people are in one location, but only time will tell if it stays that way after coming out of the pandemic (strongly depends on company culture and their policies).
- yashap 5y agoYeah, I agree that for companies that go back to ~95% in-person, remote will be a 2nd class citizen. But I think hybrid can totally work, as it’s currently working well at a tonne of companies. Remote has to be common, and the company has to be legitimately cool with in-person or remote, but if that’s all true, hybrid works great IMO. It does need to be a culture of “remote first” communication, with the office primarily being a place for people who want a more social work experience. But I suspect this will be a lasting, common setup for many tech companies, that works well.
- karaterobot 5y ago> the remote people find that they routinely hear about things much later than everyone in the office knows about them. I'm not sure this tracks with my experience. It seems like the organizational structure of a company is what keeps people from learning about things, not their location. The common case I can think of is that some meeting occurs in which a decision is made, and that decision and the context around it are not communicated outside the meeting (in a timely or efficient way, that is). Some people are "in the know" and others are not, but it's a function of who they work with, not who they meet in the hallway. If you mean gossip, watercooler chat, that kind of thing, sure. But, I don't miss that stuff. Maybe you're thinking of some other example that I'm not.
- stormbrew 5y agoDecisions get made at the water cooler, at lunch, in meetings where no one is taking notes, when one person stops by another person's desk... In person there are many opportunities for this information to spread by grapevine, because you actively see what other people are doing and you can ask. Being remote often means you have more unknown unknowns, because you can't see the daily goings-on. If you haven't experienced this, you're either very lucky or your company is a lot more remote-centric than you think it is.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xwdv 5y agoI don’t understand this issue with remote people hearing about things much later than in office people. Are you satisfied with your job? Are you being paid the amount you want? If yes, who cares? I try to avoid being too informed about certain things anyway because it ends up making me a target for added responsibilities that I don’t care about.
- stavros 5y agoI'm not satisfied with my job if I'm not being consulted and decisions I should be a part of are made because the five out of six people in the team "had a chat over lunch", no.
- xwdv 5y agoSo for you it’s not just about the money. It’s the prestige.
- stavros 5y agoYes, different people have different wants.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noirbot 5y agoIt's also about stability. I've had decisions as major as what language to use for a project done without input from the whole team, and now I have to live with writing in a framework I strongly dislike and had good arguments against using because I didn't find out for 3 weeks that it had been decided without me. You're not working on a team if decisions are made by 5/6 of the people most of time without even a consideration that the other person might have input. At that point you're a weird internal contractor, and to your point, if they wanted me to be a contractor and just deal with whatever choices the team makes without input, I'd expect to be paid as a contractor.
- amyjess 5y agoThe latter is what working at every multinational is like, remote or no. Your company may not have any remote employees, but if four people on a team are at the company's US headquarters and the fifth is in the company's office in Ireland, expect the Irish employee to get cut out of the loop constantly.
- bluefirebrand 5y agoThis seems like a timezone problem at that point. Even remote teams can't function too well together if some of them are sleeping while others are working.
- amyjess 5y agoI only used "the US" and "Ireland" as examples. It also happens at companies where both offices are in the same timezone or if employees in one location work on the other location's time (the latter was the case at my last company: we had an office in the Philippines where most employees worked on US Central time to match with HQ, except for the support departments where they did shift work for 24/7 coverage).
- phendrenad2 5y agoYou can switch jobs. Or you can stick it out until the boss realizes that they are losing employees to companies that didn't mandate in-office, and undoes the mandate. It's really quite easy.
- jupp0r 5y agoOr the labor market will split into companies and employees who insist on in-person and those who demand/offer flexible arrangements. The question is what the size ratio between both markets would be.
- ipaddr 5y agoWhat I've noticed is the local in person jobs are easy to get with very little interview prepareness. But they also pay local rates. Remote roles ask for so much more interviewing but offer more money.
- swores 5y agoIt's not really an "or" imo, that's been the case for a long time and will surely remain so short of something far crazier than the current pandemic. But agree that the question is what size ratio we'll end up on, as surely won't feature quite as much WFH as right now, and equally unlikely to go all the way back to pre-pandemic levels.