6 ms·
If you bought a dishwasher one part at a time, how much more is it reasonable to expect for it to cost? I think a $500 dishwasher costing $2500 if ordered one
by sokoloff 5y ago
If you bought a dishwasher one part at a time, how much more is it reasonable to expect for it to cost?
I think a $500 dishwasher costing $2500 if ordered one part at a time is reasonable. Your car is likely well over $100K if you ordered it one part at a time.
If you want to insist that the sum of the parts costs no more than the MSRP of the dishwasher, you won’t find the parts falling to 1/5 their current cost, but rather the dishwasher now listing for $2500 (and likely having frequent deep-discount sales).
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago>Your car is likely well over $100K if you ordered it one part at a time. I guess I agree, but when I read it I couldn't help but think that Johnny Cash built his Cadillac one part at a time and it didn't cost him a thing!
- DarylZero 5y agodidn't cost him a DIME
- buran77 5y agoAnd yet if you buy a computer one part at a time, through the magic of standardization you may end up even cheaper than the fully build OEM option. You won't see too many industries attempting this kind of standardization anytime soon.
- ghaff 5y agoThat was maybe once true. If you're literally starting from zero today and buying new parts? I sort of doubt it. (Though I don't really disagree that it's generally easier to swap out parts on a (home-built) tower computer than it is with most things because of standards.)
- buran77 5y agoIt's perfectly true today if you ignore the recent price hikes which happen under different forces (silicon shortage, crypto stuff). An OEM might be cheaper because they will put in lower quality stuff you'd never buy yourself (the absolute cheapest part that fits the bill, the cheapest motherboard, the worst thermal paste), and they have to cover extra services, warranty, building and distributing the systems, etc. I think you can still get cheaper and/or better systems by yourself.
- ghaff 5y agoComparisons are a bit hard because (perhaps outside of some specialty--and more expensive--gaming systems) what you build yourself is arguably "better"/more optimized than a random HP or Dell box. At the same time, the percentage of people who care about optimization at that level is pretty small. I built/upgraded PCs for years and now I pretty much have zero interest. But again to the basic point, it's certainly close to a wash which wouldn't be true with most things.
- Tenoke 5y agoIt's definitely true for PCs. At best you can get the same price for pre-assembled but usually it's more expensive. Not sure about laptops though.
- sokoloff 5y agoI bought a Chromebook for $92 delivered to my door this winter. It’s definitely not the case there.
- ghaff 5y agoRealistically, you can't even really build your own laptop from scratch in the sense of buying a case, motherboard, etc. OK--maybe someone offers this--but it's hardly mainstream. And you can buy a Dell desktop for ~$800 and I'm sure I could find cheaper deals elsewhere. No, it's not an optimized gaming machine but most people don't have any use for that.
- bobthepanda 5y agoAdmittedly it’s been a while, but the last I checked crypto-driven GPU scarcity made it much harder and more expensive to build a gaming PC than to buy premade.
- II2II 5y agoThere is value in building with a combination of new and used parts. Why do you need a new case each time you build a new PC. There may be cosmetic benefits, but an old case will rarely affect anything else. Likewise, I have a couple if bike frames laying around. I could pretty much build a bike to my spec and not bother with the expense of a frame.
- ghaff 5y agoThough bikes are another good example of something with a lot of standardization/interchangeability of parts. Most mechanical/electronic things around the house aren't like that to the same degree. ADDED: I suspect people who say that it's cheaper to build your own PC are mostly thinking in terms of it can certainly be cheaper to upgrade a DIY system than to buy a new one off the shelf.
- II2II 5y agoThere are a couple of scenarios where you can possibly build cheaper. Consider when the purchaser is looking for certain components or to meet a particular specification. In those situations they would have to pay someone to build a custom system or pay the vendor to customize the system (in those cases the vendor frequently charges a premium). Of course the big question is, why aren't household devices/appliances using standardized and interchangeable components? In many cases, it could probably be done. I suspect the main differentiator is consumer expectation. A significant number of consumers of bikes and desktop computers will repair, upgrade, and accessorize their purchase. Very few people will expect to do the same with their blender or television.
- zucker42 5y agoIt's still completely true, except for the GPU shortage.
- jaclaz 5y agoMany years ago, I believe late eighties, a documentary was made in Italy, sponsored by FIAT (basically to show how good was their new automated warehouse) when a group of people, members of an automobile club, built a Fiat 131 completely from the body buying everything through the "normal" spare parts channels, ordering parts as the rebuilding went on. It came out that the built car costed more than 500% without counting any of the man work/hours. And FIAT (at least here in Italy) was famous for having rather cheap spare parts (when compared to - say - Volkswagen). Most probably the 500% is nowadays not enough, at least for cars.
- dsego 5y agoA lot of people discover this when they try to build a custom bicycle from the frame up with off-the-shelf components.
- DarylZero 5y agoSimilarly, if you want to build your own furniture, you'll find that Ikea furniture shipped overseas is cheaper even than wood bought locally!
- BizarroLand 5y agoYou could probably build a decent chair with a saw and an axe and a tree if you had to. It may not be very comfortable or sturdy and if you didn't allow the wood to dry first it would probably break in a matter of months just from the wood shrinking as it dried, but if you had to you could do it.
- dsego 5y agoMy father built a large sturdy shelf unit from reclaimed planks he sourced from left over ammo crates after the war. It can be done cheaply if you are concerned about functionality more than looks. Get some lumber and wood paint. First, you don't care about weight, easy assembly process and shipping costs, so you can use heavier materials, proper metal screws, profiles, brackets, etc. But you do need some tools, like a drill, jigsaw/circular, etc.
- pessimizer 5y agoI disagree with using "what sokoloff thinks is reasonable" as a standard.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> I think a $500 dishwasher costing $2500 if ordered one part at a time is reasonable. So the cost of assembly line, robots, power and salaries of workers is -400%? Why do you feel the need to come with excuses for whats is ibviously a cash-cow?
- sokoloff 5y agoMaybe you should go into business to undercut this obvious cash-cow? I bet if you start with $10M and undercut the current suppliers, you could become a millionaire.
- treis 5y agoProbably shouldn't be quite so snarky when you're wrong. There's a huge industry of non-oem parts that do undercut the OEM and presumably make money.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoDo you think you can start a dishwasher business for $10M? My preferred modus would be to buy a current manufacturer, then strip out the high paid execs and minimise the profits in the form of very cheap repairs.
- sokoloff 5y agoNo, but you can start a business that manufactures the parts that HN experts have identified as "cash cows" for less than $10M.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoYour whole attitude indicates that you are largely unaware of the shenanigans manufacturers have been pulling to cutoff supply of repair parts. our taxes pay for customs to seize components of iPhones and file charges on behalf of apple for counterfeit goods. If you take your iphone, travel to china, take it apart there, and send to to the US by post, the customs will seize it as counterfeit. Honest people are going to jail to preserve Apple's profits. https://www.vice.com/en/article/a3yadk/apple-sued-an-independent-iphone-repair-shop-owner-and-lost https://www.vice.com/en/article/a3yadk/apple-sued-an-indepen... You also probably don't know about part serialisation and other efforts that mean that even if you product a compatiable part, the device will reject it. This is the case with tractors and phones. I am not 100% up to date with dishwashers.
- goodpoint 5y ago> a $500 dishwasher costing $2500 if ordered one part at a time is reasonable A 5x multiplier is in no way reasonable unless the replacement parts are being shipped to the moon.