7 ms·
Texas man wins $75K suing telemarketers for illegal robo-calls
- fortran77 5y ago> Many of his early attempts failed, but eventually, he began to win decisions that resulted in thousands of dollars in penalties for the offending companies. I'd love to know what the strategy is to succeed.
- wildrhythms 5y agoVery frustrating how vague this article is. And searching "Dan Graham telemarketers" on Google returns countless nearly word-for-word syndications of the same exact article.
- olliej 5y agoI know it’s a correct title but for some reason I don’t like “win” in cases like this. It feels like it should be “criminals found guilty and must pay damages to state and victim”, e.g. put emphasis on the people committing crimes rather than the victim beating the criminals in court.
- walterbell 5y agoSadly, the story here is that the existing law is rarely enforced, requiring outlier efforts to even acknowledge that a law was broken. Any 'win' here is against flawed systems.
- arc-in-space 5y agoYou might be interested in what I like to think of as "the Karen manifesto" https://www.gwern.net/docs/economics/2020-arbel.pdf https://www.gwern.net/docs/economics/2020-arbel.pdf
- walterbell 5y agoFascinating article, thanks for the pointer. > Sellers, however, do not remain passive. They have long tried to minimize the legal and reputational risks posed by nudniks. The advent of big data and predictive analytics provides sellers with a game changer: the ability to identify which consumer is a potential nudnik (that is, which consumer is likely to complain publicly and draw attention to seller underperformance), before that consumer even sets foot in their store. Sellers can then silently disarm nudniks or avoid selling to them altogether. This development benefits sellers, as it reduces the legal and reputational risks from nudniks. It may even benefit nudniks themselves, to the extent sellers disarm them by offering them preferential treatment. Yet the development poses a large risk to the greater consumer body, as it deprives consumers of a valuable source of information on seller misbehavior, thereby reducing the effectiveness of market discipline.
- amelius 5y ago> It may even benefit nudniks themselves, to the extent sellers disarm them by offering them preferential treatment. How is that different from simply complying if they complain, and offering them a modest compensation?
- walterbell 5y agoMaybe it avoids the need to offer the same quality of service to all consumers?
- seanp2k2 5y agoSounds like automating personalized sales to me. Marketeers would love to get some kind of AI capable of this. I would personally love to see those “Hi! Any questions about anything?!” bottom-right corner chat dialogues go away forever, but alas.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> put emphasis on the people committing crimes rather than the victim beating the criminals in court. The sense of "win" here doesn't involve defeating anyone. It's the same sense in which you "win" money at a casino or "win" someone's heart. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/win https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/win > 1a: to get possession of by effort or fortune > 1b: to obtain by work: EARN
- Narkov 5y agoHe will almost certainly collect none of it which makes the process largely useless unfortunately. These are shell companies that will never pay up.
- Retric 5y agoShell companies cost money to fold up and move on. He’s probably just inside the cost of business side of thing right now.
- jagged-chisel 5y agoDo they though? You want to stop using your LLC? My state’s advice is “don’t renew the registration next year.” It’s called “administrative dissoluton” and requires no money.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoThis isn't ubiquitous.
- sonicggg 5y agoMore than USD$75K? I find it hard to believe.
- Retric 5y agoNo one company got a 75k bill.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoI see that some of this hinges on the federal Do Not Call list. I wish you could do the same for political spam. I want to vote in primaries, and I want to not get spammed with “vote for X” all the time. But as far as I can tell that’s not possible anymore since I stupidly gave my phone number when registering to vote.
- seibelj 5y agoI just respond that I will not vote for them because they texted me. Often a real human responds very apologetic. Maybe it will affect their behavior.
- aaaaaaaaata 5y agoThey'll just send texts to other people on the list of people they're being paid their grocery money to text...
- nebula8804 5y agoMany of them are unpaid volunteers. Source: I volunteered for multiple campaigns and texted people.
- ______-_-______ 5y agoI'm curious. What were the ratios of: - people who ignored the text - people who were annoyed - people who changed who they were voting for after receiving a text ?
- nebula8804 5y agoGOTV efforts increase turnout without a doubt. The biggest problem is that people don't even know who is running in a given election season(obviously does not apply to presidential given they get untold amounts of free advertising on TV). Turnout is abysmal for anything other than Presidential, (even then there is like what ~40% of people not participating?) Because of this, text campaigns help spread the word. Even more effective is actually knocking on peoples doors and having a friendly conversation with them. COVID minimized that last election but I suspect future campaigns will go back to that in favor of mass texting.
- username3 5y ago> "If people knew how to push back and started doing so, we could make this kind of endless spam unaffordable for the people who do it," Graham told Doost. "The hope is that there's enough of us who stand up, start pushing back, that it becomes more expensive for companies to negligently hire these telemarketers and participate in these telemarketing practices." Is there a tutorial with templates for suing robocalls?
- walterbell 5y agoThere was a parking ticket chatbot which expanded into other template-driven legal interactions, https://donotpay.com/ https://donotpay.com/. Looks like they have workflows for robocalls, including a honeypot virtual credit card number, https://donotpay.com/learn/robocalls-cash/ https://donotpay.com/learn/robocalls-cash/ & https://donotpay.com/learn/robocall-revenge/ https://donotpay.com/learn/robocall-revenge/ It's not obvious from their website if they still offer free services, maybe we need OSS templates that can be improved over time. There's an OSS framework for generating legal documents from a template and interactive interview. https://docassemble.org https://docassemble.org & https://github.com/jhpyle/docassemble https://github.com/jhpyle/docassemble
- e40 5y agoI'd like to know this, too. They spoof caller id. When you try to ask them about anything that could be used against them, they hang up. I'd seriously like to know how he did this.
- radford-neal 5y agoOr one could just change the phone system so if you press "5" during a call, the caller gets charged 25 cents (going either to you, the phone company, or charity, it matters little). Phone spam would stop instantly. It would require some technical changes, but nothing impossible.
- mhzsh 5y agoThen phone spam would be replaced by fraud, similar to what already happens with premium number fraud: https://www.twilio.com/learn/voice-and-video/toll-fraud https://www.twilio.com/learn/voice-and-video/toll-fraud A bot tricks a voice service to call them, then rakes in fees.
- 300bps 5y agoI think there are many middle-men involved in these robocalls. The pattern I’ve seen personally is: 1. Offshore screeners asking basic information to pre-qualify the called party 2. Commission sales people adept at identifying actually interested people vs people just trying to waste their time For some companies it stops there as they try to close their offer (ex: extended car warranty) with you directly but for others they seem to then sell the lead to: 3. Third parties that buy the leads Impossible going after #1. Slim chances going after #2. I think the best bet is to go after #3. I actually feigned interest long enough with one to get to a local Allstate insurance agent. I explained the leads she was paying for were contributing to the 20+ spam calls I get per day. She didn’t care. She said the leads the company provided were good so she was going to keep buying them. I think that’s the person to go after. According to the law, they’re as guilty as anyone else in the chain.
- fortran77 5y agoAlso, semi-legitimate companies have affiliate sales programs. So the person making the call may be removed from the company ultimately offering the service. And you'll never find out who they are.
- sydbarrett74 5y ago