3 ms·
but is a renewable project that matches the capabilities of a nuclear project (to the same degree of reliability and availability) really the same cost? you go
by chii 5y ago
but is a renewable project that matches the capabilities of a nuclear project (to the same degree of reliability and availability) really the same cost?
you gotta compare like-for-like. If the solar project that takes 2 years only provide power half the time, then you need double the size to provide the same amortized level of power at night. You also need some form of storage. And that's if you don't have a spate of bad weather preventing it from working - so to amortize that problem you'd need to build yet larger...
- Gwypaas 5y agoNo point comparing like for like. The end game is a stabile balanced grid. If that is fulfilled by 100% intermittent or 100% deterministically dispatchable does not affect anything in regards to the end user. All they want is reliably the cheapest power at the time of consumption.
- kuhewa 5y agoThat follows if you are playing Sim-City, or I suppose if you think giving the government absolute control over energy production and you want to leave the market completely out of it. I'm just talking the world we live in. To answer more directly though, yeah the power is the same cost. Perhaps when renewable penetration into the energy market is saturated, there will be a greater demand for base load at all those times renewables aren't producing at peak, and that will be reflected in those nuclear MWHs becoming very profitable even at a higher unit cost.
- nl 5y agoThe South Australian grid is a great example of how well this approach works. It's mostly (>60%) a mix of solar and wind power, with some gas that fills in the gaps - as well as batteries for grid stability. Still importing some coal power from interstate, but that is decreasing too. The investment has been incremental - so much smaller amounts, with much less risk and therefor more attractive to investors. A large part of this (since 2018) has been done by a conservative state government, who have been highly supportive of the renewable transition. https://theconversation.com/against-the-odds-south-australia-is-a-renewable-energy-powerhouse-how-on-earth-did-they-do-it-153789 https://theconversation.com/against-the-odds-south-australia...