4 ms·
You can find the in-progress list of checks in this source file: https://github.com/troyhunt/password-purgatory-api/blob/master/index.js https://github.com/tro
by MBCook 5y ago
You can find the in-progress list of checks in this source file:
https://github.com/troyhunt/password-purgatory-api/blob/master/index.js https://github.com/troyhunt/password-purgatory-api/blob/mast...
It includes such gems as requiring the sum of all digits in the password to be divisible by 3, requiring passwords to contain Simpsons/Family Guy character names, emoticons, ending with “dog”, and all sorts of other craziness.
Can’t wait to see his results.
- hayd 5y agoeven worse than the sum: "Password when stripped of non-numeric characters must be a number divisible by 3", considering it needs a valid zip and three digits of pi that starts to get non-trivial!
- WayToDoor 5y agoCan't you just add an extra number?
- ssl232 5y agoLooking at the list I think it might be possible to pass all the tests (please correct me if I'm wrong). Maybe there needs to be a catch-all test that always fails?
- petesergeant 5y ago“Sorry, another user in our system has that password”
- ssl232 5y agoIt lacks the most infuriating rule found in the wild, an upper limit on the length of the password (that's not at least in the thousands due to e.g. request size limits).
- charcircuit 5y agoAssuming an random alphanumeric password and a 256 bit hash there is no benefit going above a 55 character password. Even if you aren't just using random characters I think 100 is a fine limit. Most people are not going to be using a password that long without a password manager. If they are using a password manager they might as well just use a random password. For there to be more security in allowing passwords thousands of digits long the host would very likely being storing your password in plain text as opposed to pulling out a few thousand bytes out of an XOF (extendable output function).
- ssl232 5y agoI am aware that there is an upper limit on security provided by longer passwords, but websites should still not set arbitrary upper limits on length from a usability point of view. If I want to use a longer password because that's the default my manager generates, let me.
- erik_seaberg 5y agoI think most people complaining about this on real sites are trying to use a passphrase of thirty-ish letters and spaces, and finding they can't.