3 ms·
If someone leaves a pile of private records on a park bench, and I poke around with access I know I shouldn't have, that's not a felony, is it? When the access
by Dylan16807 5y ago
If someone leaves a pile of private records on a park bench, and I poke around with access I know I shouldn't have, that's not a felony, is it?
When the access is freely given out without any subterfuge, it's not my job to self-enforce my best guess at what my access level should have been.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 5y ago> If someone leaves a pile of private records on a park bench, and I poke around with access I know I shouldn't have, that's not a felony, is it? Personally, I would not bet my freedom on that assumption.
- superturkey650 5y agoAgreed, however if a government official says “These records are confidential, please don’t look at them” and then they leave them on a park bench in front of you, then it is a felony to for you to look at them. In this case, it would be like going through the UI and trying to access the record and getting denied because of a client side access block, so you make a direct call to the backend instead to retrieve the record. You’re making a perfectly legitimate HTTP request but for something you know you shouldn’t be able to access: illegal.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rosndo 5y ago> If someone leaves a pile of private records on a park bench, and I poke around with access I know I shouldn't have, that's not a felony, is it? CFAA covers unauthorized access to protected computers, not piles of records on park benches.
- tannedNerd 5y agoThe key being protected, seems like the the bar is trying to blame a misconfigured DB on a "vulnerability"
- rosndo 5y ago“Protected computer” has a specific legal definition which has nothing to do with technical protections, but legal protections.
- Dylan16807 5y agoObviously. But I was responding to a particular argument. Why is "knowingly accessing records that you know you shouldn't have access to" so different in this case? There's no trespassing or equivalent; the computer itself was set up for public access. And "protected computer" is basically all computers. Imagine if the records were on a kindle; that shouldn't change the legality and if the CFAA does so that's a bad thing.
- rosndo 5y ago> that shouldn't change the legality and if the CFAA does so that's a bad thing. Is it really though? What harm may come from legislation preventing you from rifling through somebody’s phone that they left on a park bench? I’m not saying CFAA isn’t problematic, but I’m very unconvinced that this is the problematic part.
- Dylan16807 5y agoA phone is a personal device and I'd like that to be treated differently in many ways. A public web server doesn't have such direct privacy issues. When it comes to records on a bench vs. a non-personal kindle on a bench, I think they should have equal and low protection. Abusing the data should face penalties, but not poking around.
- rosndo 5y agoWhy should you have any right to “poke around” a kindle you find on a park bench? Beyond any general rights you might have permitting you to take ownership of lost property, that is. I don’t see any obvious reason as to why this should be allowed, but it’s trivial to come up with a whole plethora of reasons for why you shouldn’t be allowed to poke around such devices.