4 ms·
> I don't really want universal healthcare [...] Most common definitions of "universal healthcare" say it is a system that assures that all citizens of some po
by tzs 5y ago
> I don't really want universal healthcare [...]
Most common definitions of "universal healthcare" say it is a system that assures that all citizens of some political grouping (country, region, state) have access to healthcare without it being an undue financial burden.
If you also use such a definition, then I'm curious what citizens you think should not be assured of such access?
If you are using a different definition, then I'm curious what that is.
- bpodgursky 5y agoI would create a per-capita federal refundable tax credit which is commensurate with the average cost of "comprehensive" market health coverage for an individual, but not mandate people to buy anything other than catastrophic care coverage. Dunno what you'd call that.
- tzs 5y agoIf the tax credit based on comprehensive coverage was $1000/month, and catastrophic coverage cost $400/month, would someone who chooses to only have catastrophic still receive the $1000/month (giving them $600/month they could use on anything regardless of whether or not it is related to healthcare), or just receive $400/month, or receive whatever their insurance and medical costs actually are each month up to $1000/month? If the later two it would be universal healthcare. Not sure how the first would be classified.
- plasticchris 5y agoHigh deductible health plans are a thing, and fulfill the current (weak) insurance requirement in the US so the last half of that is here today.
- sokoloff 5y agoI’d wager that a lot of people using HDHPs are doing so in order to be allowed to use HSAs as a stealth (but best) additional retirement account. https://www.madfientist.com/ultimate-retirement-account/ https://www.madfientist.com/ultimate-retirement-account/
- sokoloff 5y ago> a system that assures that all citizens of some political grouping (country, region, state) have access to healthcare without it being an undue financial burden In broad strokes, that’s how I’d define it as well but, as with many things, there are devils in the details. Should it be only “citizens” or should it cover all “lawful, permanent residents”, “anyone lawfully present”, or “anyone who can get themself into the covered territory”? If it’s only citizens and excludes mere residents, is that “universal”? [and in that case, this puts non-citizen residents at a huge disadvantage] Should all care be covered, in unlimited amounts? Only well-accepted, standard care? Or experimental treatments as well? Should expected life outcomes (either absolute or relative among the possible care plans) be factored into the approval process? Should public-paid care be metered in some way, with supplemental or elective care being paid out of pocket? Should healthcare-adjacent services be covered? (independent living, assisted living, or nursing homes, or travel to medical care [routine commute, ambulance, or medevac]) Who defines what “undue financial burden” is? It’s easy to imagine two people both strongly being “for universal healthcare” and disagreeing on many critical details.
- the_other 5y agoThese are all pointless questions dragging the conversation back towards healthcare tied to some arbitrary other function. Your caveats and “details” also move the administrative and management burden into some weird place based on factors that are difficult to manage and track (need, quota, citizenship etc). The answer is simple: everyone in the administrative region gets covered for everything. Anything else is discriminatory. Planning of care services can then respond to the medical and health need of the population at large rather than arbitrary permissions banding.
- renewiltord 5y agoOh that’s easy. Under certain other political conditions, the addition of a system of universal healthcare that is not market-based will harm the members of its society more than its absence. I think those conditions are met. With doctors having legalized limits on their numbers etc. I don’t think we’ll see a requisite increase in healthcare outcomes for the money spent. Given that, my preference is market-driven outcomes with deregulation of medicine, then the status quo, and finally the worst option: simply paying everyone who is doing the current job 10 times as much and expecting this to mean everyone can go see them.