8 ms·
Researchers train an algorithm to interpret pig grunts as emotions
- beached_whale 5y agoLink to SoundWel project referenced in article https://www.soundwel-project.eu https://www.soundwel-project.eu
- ASalazarMX 5y agoTo build the equivalent of a grunts-emotions dictionary, the researchers recorded over 7,400 sounds from 411 pigs, tracing their life experiences from birth through death. The team correlated the different calls with the pigs' activities and body language. > The animals had positive emotions when nursing, reuniting with family, cuddling with litter mates and running freely. Negative emotions came from situations involving social isolation, fights, castration and waiting in a slaughterhouse. They cracked pig grunts, and are building a translator for the rest of us. Nice.
- axiosgunnar 5y ago> building a translator This would be groundbreaking, civilization changing even
- lukeasrodgers 5y agoThis would be pretty cool, but I don't see how it could go beyond translations like "I feel positive emotion related to nursing" and "I feel negative emotion related to pain." What if an adult pig makes "positive emotion related to nursing" grunts? Does that mean they are thinking about nursing? Or has the meaning of the grunt has changed over time? Are they reliving a childhood pig-fantasy? Is the meaning of their adult-pig desire structured by their child-pig experiences in a vaguely Freudian way? Does the grunt mean "food enjoyment" or "food enjoyment + recollection of nursing" or "food enjoyment + recollection of nursing + nostalgia for the Jungian archetypal teat"? These questions may seem ridiculous (and I suppose I am stretching them a bit for humour's sake), but I think ignoring them just leads to an impoverished behavioural science. Maybe that's the best we can do. I just don't see how we can make the leap from correlating events with acoustics to saying that we understand the meaning of a pig grunt. The idea that we could somehow discover a rich, nuanced emotional/meaningful life of pigs via such a means seems to me fundamentally misguided. We would need to be able to ask a pig what such and such a grunt meant, which obviously presupposes a fairly complex shared language. In the absence of this, we are just making assumptions. On the other hand, these assumptions certainly may be very plausible, and it seems reasonable to think that it would be very cosmically odd if such assumptions were dramatically off-base, due to our shared evolutionary history, physiology, and neural circuitry.
- zozbot234 5y ago> The idea that we could somehow discover a rich, nuanced emotional/meaningful life of pigs via such a means seems to me fundamentally misguided. Decoding vocal communication and basic emotional states, however simple and unstructured both of these might be, could easily enable us to bootstrap training of pigs for other forms of communication, such as computer-assisted button boards. AIUI, this has been done wrt. other comparable mammals, with some measure of success.
- pishpash 5y agoFirst application would be for babies.
- mft_ 5y ago> The animals had positive emotions when nursing, reuniting with family, cuddling with litter mates and running freely. Negative emotions came from situations involving social isolation, fights, castration and waiting in a slaughterhouse. Not to be negative about the research, but I’m pretty sure I could have surmised the pigs’ emotional state in many of these situations (castration?!) without the benefit of a translator! But I hope it’s successful, and they then develop beyond just positive vs. negative. And then do cats. Please.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoI think the most important thing is that people/scientists are slowly acknowledging that animals can have emotions and aren't just machines. I hope this acknowledgment will help improving conditions for animals in farms.
- giantg2 5y agoI think anyone who has worked on the topic or had any experience with animals knows that, to varying degrees, animals can be happy or sad/distressed. Most people simply don't know about or would rather ignore the realities of industrial meat production.
- trentgreene 5y agoI don’t disagree with you, but to the parents point, there’s a pretty long philosophical -> scientific history which held that animals didn’t have emotions
- giantg2 5y agoIs there? My understanding is that the widely held belief was that they didn't have fine grained emotions that were comparable to our own. So far this research doesn't change that, but might lay the ground work for exploring that further.
- 5y ago
- nemo44x 5y agoWhat I’m most interested in is if there is a correlation between between their emotional lifetime grunt series (or subset) and the consensus taste of their meat as opined by tastemakers and aficionados. It would be great to use this animals emotional state to influence the succulence of its tender flesh.
- cardosof 5y ago"Grumpy pig meat, now on sale! 20% off all depressed ribs!" Can't wait for the future. /s
- apatters 5y agoActually the idea is brilliant. If you can demonstrate empirically that meat from happy pigs tastes better, now you have the beginnings of a commercial case for raising the pigs ethically, which has the potential to drive far more improvement in livestock well-being than a million Internet virtue signals about animal cruelty.
- cardosof 5y agoI agree with you, my concern is about what happens if the data doesn't point in that direction (tortured pigs taste the same) or if the market just accepts a trade-off (less quality for less price) disregarding their suffering. I believe technology is inexorable and we'll just have to see what happens next.
- Mondialisation 5y agoEthically killing someone for (taste) pleasure sounds like an oxymoron to me.
- knighthack 5y agoThere were some videos a while back on a butcher torturing pigs in a slaughterhouse, which was leaked and showed inhuman practices. The pigs were squealing and grunting in absolute horror as they were tortured. It scares me to know exactly what emotions they were displaying during the torture.
- sacrosancty 5y agoWhile I don't know what happened in that case, was it worse than castration without anesthesia? Or is this fear you have more about the human intent than the effect on the animal?
- klyrs 5y agoSo you're saying we shouldn't hook this into gpt3 to write poetry based on the pigs' emotional state?
- hutzlibu 5y ago"They cracked pig grunts, and are building a translator for the rest of us. Nice." Let's assume humans grow up in meat farms, disconnected from all former culture developements. They are born into it. Get fed and separated by machines, castrated and in the end slaughtered. Would they develope meaningful language under these circumstances? I doubt it. So you still could then build a translator for human gutural noises. But not for human language. You would have to analyse a normal human culture for that. Likewise, I would be much more interested in analyzing the grunts of free wild pigs.
- puzzlepursuer 5y agoReplying to this for visibility. Curious why this submission reached the front page. I’ve linked prior posts on the same topic, including my own. Does time of day affect ranking that much, or perhaps there’s an algorithm at work? The person who posted this article has >30 submissions over the past week. Maybe people recognizing a username has a big influence too. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30588423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30588423 - 4 days prior https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30594902 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30594902 - 4 days prior https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30612740 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30612740 - 2 days prior https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30639933 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30639933 - 8 hours prior
- cstejerean 5y agoTime of day definitely seems to affect ranking.
- redleader55 5y agoReading this I was reminded of a novella by Phillip K. Dick, Beyond Lies the Wub - https://www.gutenberg.org/files/28554/28554-h/28554-h.htm https://www.gutenberg.org/files/28554/28554-h/28554-h.htm.
- austinjp 5y agoAmazing, I was thinking of this only yesterday. I read it as a child [0], didn't realise it was PKD! [0] Edited to add the book: "Peter Davison's Book of Alien Monsters", highly recommended. http://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/pl.cgi?25965 http://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/pl.cgi?25965
- nonrandomstring 5y agoWhen they're unhappy, they're disgruntled. And gruntled when they're happy.
- contingencies 5y agoGreat Scrabble word :) According to https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/gruntled https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/gruntled gruntled is a humorous neologism introduced as a back-construction by P. G. Wodehouse in The Code of the Woosters (1938): He spoke with a certain what-is-it in his voice, and I could see that, if not actually disgruntled, he was far from being gruntled.
- pcthrowaway 5y agoin case you missed it, the play on words was "happy grunts == gruntled"
- azifali 5y agoWow!
- cushychicken 5y agoMy wife and I have a Reductress day to day calendar, and I can't help but think it's not a coincidence that this frontpaged HN the same day as this article came up on the calendar: https://reductress.com/post/how-to-get-your-boyfriend-to-brush-you-like-the-trophy-hog-you-are/ https://reductress.com/post/how-to-get-your-boyfriend-to-bru...
- troyvit 5y agoThere is actually the beginning of a pig dictionary in this article. A "little oink of appreciation." Squeals of direction. Yeah I think they've cracked it.
- cushychicken 5y agoYeah I think they've cracked it. Reductress is perhaps the best comedy writing on the internet.
- jupp0r 5y ago"train an algorithm" is actually a pretty good description of what machine learning is doing (vs calling it artificial intelligence).
- alar44 5y ago"train a biological algorithm" is actually a pretty good description of what humans are doing (vs calling it intelligence).
- dymk 5y agojust gonna short-circuit a couple dozen reply discussion about the distinction and leave this here - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turing_test
- jupp0r 5y agoThere is nothing biological about this. If you want biological, take a look at this: https://www.humanbrainproject.eu/en/about/project-structure/partnering-projects/macaque-vision/ https://www.humanbrainproject.eu/en/about/project-structure/...
- stakkur 5y agoLearning to interpret the grunts of pigs, animals that only exist to be killed and eaten (we domesticated them for food), is peak human.
- voakbasda 5y agoActually I expect this is sponsored by the likes of PETA. It obviously aims to make the animals appear more anthropomorphic, so no one will want to eat them anymore.
- notjulianjaynes 5y agoThe intelligence of pigs is fairly well established. Is your argument here that the act of domesticating pigs has increased their intelligence over time?
- jamestimmins 5y ago> The animals had positive emotions when nursing, reuniting with family, cuddling with litter mates and running freely. Negative emotions came from situations involving social isolation, fights, castration and waiting in a slaughterhouse. There's something deeply sad about this. Speaking as someone that regularly eats meat (I had bacon this morning), the prospect of animals have emotional inner lives is the #1 thing that makes me consider vegetarianism.
- penneyd 5y agoAgreed - and it was the positive emotions that got to me, do I really want to take that away from another living being, tough.
- oh_sigh 5y agoThey definitely do. Spend some time with a pig and you'll stop eating them
- giantg2 5y agoWell... maybe not. I would have no trouble giving a pig a good life and then eating it.
- tsol 5y agoI think it's having to watch it die that really horrifies people. I know someone who took his kids to a small farm to see a cow get slaughtered and help prepare the meat. At first I thought it was kind of messed up and unnecessary. But honestly after thinking about it, everyone should be doing that. People should see where their meat comes from, realize something had to lose it's life for that meal. People would care more about mistreatment in factory farmed meat if they had to see the real emotions of farm animals
- cute_boi 5y agoI agree. I remember the following saying: "If slaughterhouses had glass walls, everyone would be vegetarian." I don't know if it is 100% true, but I am certain most people would turn into vegetarian. As time has passed due to ruthless industries, I think we should replace vegetarianism with veganism.
- motohagiography 5y agoI'd wonder if it was enough information to create a pig UX for a machine. Starts with flashing a light or making a sound when it hears certain patterns of noises, becomes stimulus response like Pavlov experiments, but adapts to a more sophisticated command language for food, water, flavors, nutrients, etc. Then see if the initial group can teach new pigs to use the grunt language system, or if nursing sows teach their piglets the grunting system. Eventually, there will probably be groups of pigs who use the grunting system to identify each other and align based on learned behaviors, only driven by stimulus response and perhaps without true sapience or consciousness, and it will basically be twitter for pigs. But more seriously, the idea of using ML to adapt to building complex interfaces for animals driven by more subtle stimulus response is pretty fascinating.
- kovek 5y agoOne day, animals will be part of our parliaments.
- voakbasda 5y agoYou’d think cows already live in government, what with all the bullshit….
- motohagiography 5y agoIf we could eat them, perhaps it would finally make politicians useful for something?
- charlysl 5y agoIg Nobel Prize right here
- giantg2 5y agoWhy?
- kovek 5y ago“Train an algorithm” sounds better than “train an AI”
- Maursault 5y agoI'm not all that up to defending my straw man, but I am horrified by the treatment of livestock, and the Iowa Select Farms stories made me realize, that level of cruelty has been extant for probably (tens of) thousands of years. If only 130,000 years ago, evil pigs used humans for livestock, not only ate them, but ensured their cruel short lives, and humans revolted and turned the tables on the pigs, so they deserve cruel treatment, because they're adverse to human existence. But that is scifi. In truth, a number of people have been killed by pigs, but as a species, pigs don't really threaten humans. We don't need to eat pigs, and even more cruelly, pigs are just business. But once you realize how much these interesting animals have in common with people, which is not apparent by their unflattering names nor our general familiarity with them having vague knowledge of various farm animals since childhood, the idea of consuming one or part of one becomes revolting in the same way that cannibalism is revolting. I used to eat pork steaks, and even though I could talk about taste, I don't care what it tastes like anymore. Taste is just not that important, and, most importantly, it can be and has been entirely simulated so that no one could tell the difference. I'll just say it, I don't think humans should eat pigs anymore, period, let alone continue to treat them so horrifically. We should, through ethical programs (not killing) reduce their population over generations to a healthy representative of the species, and just let them go and not mess with them any more unless nuisance animals need to be moved. Because they're mentally absolutely no different than human children, and we should, as a species, have compassion for others like us, that experience the world in pretty much the same, mammalian way. And all the other animals, too, we should stop killing everything immediately, and back out of encroaching on the remaining wild habitats. And we should, over generations, massively reduce the Earth's human population, but let the off-world human population grow as much as practical. Because, otherwise, very soon, in two generations, maybe ten, Earth is totally going to suck, the whole stinking place, because of humans and terrible things done and caused by humans. If Earth succeeds in ridding itself of humankind, life will go on beautifully for a long time before another species becomes like humans and destroys all the environments. I try to stay positive. I feel good knowing I lived at a time when the Amazon Rainforest still existed and there were still glaciers in some places. And maybe, just maybe, this research can generate compassion for living creatures that are mentally a lot like humans, and we know this for sure because their brains are just like human brains. Duh.
- mizzao 5y agoUm, how do you get ground truth labels for this data?
- Mondialisation 5y ago> "The next step could be a pig translation app for farmers." Or just not exploit and slaughter sentient individuals for (taste) pleasure.
- enchiridion 5y agoNope, I’d like to continue eating meat. If this can help it be done more humanely than great!
- demopathos 5y agoI think it would be preferable if you didn't phrase comments like this in the inflammatory way you chose to phrase it. Specifically using the word "nope" to open a sentence in response to another comment that communicates empathy is inflammatory. This is because it is dismissive of the other individual's feelings/opinions.
- enchiridion 5y agoThat’s fair, you’re right. I suppose I’m just tired of the same arguments. I’m all for personal agency, so eat whatever you want, but it irks me when carnivores are admonished.
- pawsforthought 5y agoWatch either of these documentaries and tell me whether you’re still irked [0][1]. [0]:https://youtu.be/8gqwpfEcBjI https://youtu.be/8gqwpfEcBjI [1]:https://youtu.be/dvtVkNofcq8 https://youtu.be/dvtVkNofcq8
- cute_boi 5y agoMaybe that person is also tired with such egregious violation of animal right? Pigs are smart animal, and I think they deserve good life and the best way to help them is not eat them. Nobody chooses the genes they are born with. Its a discrimination at its best. We stopped slavery probably 50 years ago. At past, I bet there were people like "Nope! I am not going to do menial job. Its my personal agent, so do whatever you want....".
- datavirtue 5y agoThere is a wife joke, or two, at the tip of my tongue.
- datavirtue 5y agoOh come on, my meta-joke was hilarious.
- jimbobimbo 5y agoI hear Green Acres has a lot of training material!
- xtiansimon 5y agoDon’t eat me.