3 ms·
I have played a game called prosperous universe. The fact that there are money printers that encourage you to engage in economic activity, i.e. the additional m
by imtringued 5y ago
I have played a game called prosperous universe. The fact that there are money printers that encourage you to engage in economic activity, i.e. the additional money encourages you to invest is something that I tried to question.
Why does an increase in the money supply encourage people to produce more? From the perspective of the community, producing more is certainly a good thing as the economy is not very well developed and there are some progression cliffs as getting engineers and technicians are basically a form of luxury as only ship building is really dependent on their products.
So, more money is somehow good, but why? One idea I had is that creating new money rewards people for doing something they would have otherwise not done. In other words, people receive a share of the economy in return for their economic activity even if half the economic activity is simply being throwing into an NPC dumpster. If you were to represent that share as a percentage of the economy, then your percentage grows as you obtain more created money. It also means that the share of the economy of others shrinks. One could say that this is a way of decentralizing power.
When you think about the opposite idea. A fixed money supply. The economic share of all players may effectively be frozen. Since your power may never shrink, unless you want it to shrink, it becomes very easy for the system to be dominated by a few players.
So ultimately, the problem is the fact that those who need money cannot get it and those who have too much want to keep it. Redistribution among players somehow ends up benefiting both yet this is not the natural order of things. If one person had too much wheat and another too little and the first one has too few tomatoes and the second one has too many, one would obviously see the opportunity for a trade, the market apparently solves the exchange of goods but why does it fail to solve the exchange of money properly? New players are obviously dependent on older players to give them money, but the older players have no incentive to buy from new players, they can just buy from other old players. Lots of people give up at the start, precisely because they don't feel they are being needed.
In fact, I think I would describe the biggest fear that I have experienced in life that I am not needed by anyone. Yes my boss pay me a salary. My parents like me. I have some nice friends. I have had plenty of experiences that make me glad I was born. If reality was a game I probably would have quit, not because of some angry capitalists exploiting me or because of violence against me. I would have thought, this is a nice game but I feel out of place, enjoy your time here, I unfortunately won't be participating.
In fact, a lot of males are sent to fight wars to keep them busy and feel needed. A lot of child soldiers start that way.
What's the solution? Well, the solution doesn't sound that bad or even impossible, it may even sound obvious. Essentially, there must be a purpose for every life. The supply of labor must drive the demand for labor. Interestingly, there is even a law that postulates such a thing to occur. It is known as says' law and yet full employment has remained elusive. If economics predicts that supply and demand will balance themselves automatically, then the only reason for that to not happen is that we have built a machine that prevents this from happening. Money, when used as a store of value, is essentially the ability to decouple supply and demand and we have decided that one should be allowed to do so eternally. Imagine if everyone saves half their salary and nobody borrows that money and money is saved until that person dies. Half the supply would fail to generate demand! Half the people in the economy would be redundant!
This is the ugly truth, we are trying to make each other redundant for fear of becoming redundant ourselves as someone must be redundant at the end of the day the moment the economy is saturated. It's not really a lump of labor fallacy. Those who save, will at some point spend their money even if they do so in a single second at the end of their life. The problem is the mismatch between when the money must be spent and when it is actually spent. A negative interest rate effectively indicates the point at which spending can no longer be delayed and savings must be reduced.