3 ms·
It feels like there are almost as many CAD programs as there are programming languages with the big caveat that all the opensource CAD programs are terrible (Fr
by imtringued 5y ago
It feels like there are almost as many CAD programs as there are programming languages with the big caveat that all the opensource CAD programs are terrible (FreeCAD), barely used by anyone (think SALOME) or underdeveloped.
FreeCAD isn't even terrible for any good reasons. If I had to dumb it down it would be "politics" because FreeCAD insists on certain puritanical design choices that have no practical reason to exist.
In FreeCAD, "Body" is a single solid, if you have an operation that fails to create a single solid, you just get an uninspiring error message, you don't even get to see a locked preview that shows you how far off you are from a valid single solid! Ever wondered why the 3D view of FreeCAD and Catia look so similar? Because FreeCAD is using opencascade. Catia has no single solid restriction so this artificial restriction is twice as enraging!
In FreeCAD datum planes must live up to their mathematical counterparts! Officially planes have no orientation i.e. a default direction. Yet when you try to attach a sketch, it will align the sketch based on a random position and you can even use the transform feature to rotate the plane! The first thing I have to do when I make a new sketch is draw an arrow that points up and then rotate the sketch so it actually points up! The demands to let planes show their hidden internal orientation have been shot down because planes have no orientation! Fantastic!
It's very similar to how relational algebra specifies sets of tuples but actual RDBMS allow you to have duplicates. Break the damn eggs, omelette tastes good.
- foobarbecue 5y agoAgree about FreeCAD, but I'm hoping it will follow a similar path to Blender: an idiosyncratic program that consistently improved to the point that it's now really competitive with the $$$ alternatives. Or... maybe we should fork it and fix it?
- criddell 5y agoHobbyists can use Fusion 360 for free. I think part of the motivation behind that offer is to remove a little of the energy behind developing a good genuinely free CAD program.