11 ms·
The Latest Crime Wave: Sending Your Child to a Better School
- shithead 15y agoused her father's address to enroll her two daughters in a better public school outside of their neighborhood. After spending nine days behind bars charged with grand theft, the single mother was convicted of two felony counts Slightly insane, eh, what? I can think of a few people roaming around foot-loose and fancy-free, and even pocketing scores of millions of dollars, who should be doing that.
- maxklein 15y agoAmerica is still a deeply segregated society. And the segregation is built in such a way that it tends to keep people where they always where.
- SoftwareMaven 15y agoThe segregation is not all systemic. I remember reading an article discussing research discussing how neighborhoods change as a result of very slight preferences of "I'd rather be by somebody of my race than a different race." This applied to black and white neighborhoods. Taken over time and populations, these very slight differences in preference (and, realistically, in the USA, it is unlikely to be "slight") lead to segregated neighborhoods. If anybody has the original, I'd love to see it again and find out what I've mis-remembered. I couldn't find it.
- burgerbrain 15y agoI compare it to boxing matches. If I'm watching a match between someone who is identified as German, and someone who is identified as Italian, without other influences, I am going to tend towards cheering for the Italian, because I identify more with Italians. Never mind the fact that I'm 3/4th German and only 1/4th Italian, and certainly don't have anything against Germans. It's purely a unconscious tribal reflex, rarely even noticed unless given a chance to magnify (time and numbers provides this magnifying factor in communities.)
- geekfactor 15y agoPG argued pretty effectively against this kind of "tribal reflex" in Keep Your Identity Small: http://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html http://www.paulgraham.com/identity.html
- burgerbrain 15y agoAs I read it, he may be arguing against this sort of "tribal reflex", but he's certainly not arguing against it's existence. My point is that I am agreeing with the parent of my original post, segregation can arise from phenomenon not necessarily codified into law or even recognized consciously by the participants. Whether this "tribal reflex" is "right or wrong" is irrelevant, the important and seemingly undisputed point is that it exists.
- akkartik 15y agoI know the article you mean but couldn't find it. But the Schelling Segregation Model seems to fit the bill: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Schelling#Models_of_Segregation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Schelling#Models_of_Segr...
- LoveLinux 15y agoIs there something wrong with groups of people wanting to self segregate?
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- andrewljohnson 15y agoIf by "wrong" you mean "leads to worse outcomes" - then very possibly yes.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- burgerbrain 15y agoHow do we define "segregate"? Is it just across 'skin color' / 'irrelevant heritage' lines? What if I identify with and want to live around entrepreneurs? atheists? 'survivalists'? Homosexuals? I think I can make a fairly strong argument for homosexuals preferring to live among themselves as being ultimately detrimental to society (reduced exposure to homosexuals allows intolerance and misunderstanding to fester), however I would never dream of calling the desire to isolate themselves from hatred "wrong". Edit: I take it from the downvotes that we're just talking about segregation across "'skin color' / 'irrelevant heritage'" lines for some reason...
- andrewljohnson 15y agoI'm not arguing preference here. All of your examples still apply. And I would simply say that right and wrong are poor constructs to let us formulate ideas about how we should live. There's a good chance that atheists who choose to live only among atheists are going to suffer worse outcomes. Living in a diverse society leads to more perspective and better ideas, and an eventually better society. Only living with other gay people or other Hacidic Jews or other white supremacists may feel comfortable, and it might lead to a functioning society. But is it ideal? Does it leave the people better off? Society at large? I don't actually know the answer tho these questions, but I suspect you're better off meeting all sorts of people, living in all sorts of places, and absorbing all sorts of ideas. I don't really believe in right and wrong.
- mattdeboard 15y agoI'm not sure if, as I progress through my 30s, I am becoming more liberal, more cynical or more jaded, or what, but it seems like every day I read some article about the United States which elicits a, "What the FUCK?" from me. This is one of those articles. Seriously? Prison??
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- notaddicted 15y agoThe article neglected to provide any rationale whatsoever for the "other side" which may be the triggering the WTFs. I'm not saying the logic is good, but here it is: A proportion of the school's budget comes from property tax. I found a pdf that says it is about 20% of the budget in California [1]. Thus: Expensive neighborhood -> lots of property tax -> rich school So essentially the laws punish freeloaders of education. Out of all the things a person can "freeload" education is probably the most noble, which I guess is why the law seems so dicey. [1] http://www.edsource.org/pub_QA_BudgetProcess06.html http://www.edsource.org/pub_QA_BudgetProcess06.html
- mattdeboard 15y agoI don't really care about the other side. Why are we putting people in prison over this? Having the law/rule is one thing, I guess, but the punishment is extremely excessive. 10 days in prison, and 3 years of probation? She's lucky she got commuted by the governor. Not everyone will be so.
- prodigal_erik 15y agoLifeboat ethics demand awful solutions like this. If the best school in the region is known to let this slide, it will be besieged by a population it won't have the resources to support. It's almost like tax evasion, only you're required to move before you'll be allowed to pay the tax, and that particular school is not in a position to fix that. The list of applicable laws must have been pretty short if they had to resort to "grand theft", and at that point the penalty was driven by the amount of money at issue, from a law mostly aimed at car thieves.
- LoveLinux 15y agoIn general, "Better school" means a school with more whites and or Asians. "Bad schools" means a school with more black and Hispanic students.
- showkiller 15y agoNot sure by your statement if you have children or not. But I just finished enrolling my children in a private school instead of the local public school. I really don't care if they are black or white I want my children to go to a school where the parents value education as much as I do.
- LoveLinux 15y agoI have mixed race children and do whatever it takes to make sure that they are in schools that made up of mostly white, Asian, or Indian (India) students. Black and Hispanic students have shown no signs of valuing education and the schools usually plagued with violence. I'm not alone in this thinking; every single Asian family I know does the same.
- pjscott 15y agoI don't think you two actually disagree. You want to send your kids to a place where the parents value education, and you're using ethnicity as an easy indirect way of measuring this. A lamentably reasonable strategy.
- mattdeboard 15y agoNo, they definitely do. LoveLinux is basing his/her decision on racial bias, the other guy is not.
- tzs 15y agoWhat decision? He simple stated, accurately, a fact. How can a fact be racially biased? White and Asian neighborhoods generally generate higher property taxes than black neighborhoods. Schools are largely funded by property taxes. Therefore it should come as no surprise that White and Asian schools are on average better.
- aik 15y ago>> In case you needed further proof of the American education system's failings, especially in poor and minority communities, consider the latest crime to spread across the country: educational theft. I'm not sure if it is entirely fair to single out the education system here (once again), or at least batch it in with "yet another failing". I believe more is at fault here. Unless I'm mistaken, tax payers in a particular school district (or county) fund the school district they're part of. A consequence of this fact, in the name of fairness for the parents, is the necessity for your child to attend a school that you are directly funding (and not attend a school you're not funding, which is what the mother in the story is doing). As long as we're sticking with this system of funding our own schools in this manner, we will naturally be encouraging segregation of classes and have no choice but to turn down those who try to get around it. So I agree a woman shouldn't be jailed for trying to circumvent the system in this manner, but with the above knowledge of how the system operates, it doesn't surprise me that she would be punished, as I'm sure many others are as well. Allowing people to attend any school they like (which this article is arguing for I believe?) is a pretty fundamental shift in the system.
- mtinkerhess 15y agoFunding varies state-by-state. For example, in Michigan most school district funding comes from the state level, and local districts are limited in their ability to raise more funds. http://www.michiganinbrief.org/edition07/Chapter5/K12Funding.htm http://www.michiganinbrief.org/edition07/Chapter5/K12Funding...
- guard-of-terra 15y agoHer father, registered in that school district, obviously pays the taxes; So there's no reason why it would not cover the tuition of her chidren. You're just dropped back from "it's fair that way" to "the rules say that way". It's not like that his taxes are of a different color than her taxes, right? So it should not matter where the children go to school, it's still fair.
- burgerbrain 15y ago"It's not like that his taxes are of a different color than her taxes, right?" I'm not sure, but I believe that people with children in their household pay more school taxes.
- bmj 15y agoThis is hardly anything new. 20+ years ago, I knew kids with parents that did the same thing (though often for athletics instead of academics). Even within the city (where, at the time, you were required to attend the neighborhood school), parents found ways to game the system.
- mchusma 15y agoGood examples of the effects of government getting involved in education, particularly tying it to location. The solution to this problem is clear but politically difficult: limit government involvement in education to vouchers at most, preferably none at all.
- jleyank 15y agoIf government is not involved in education "at all", then you have the situation that people pay $$ for schools and then have no say in how the money is spent. This would not go down well...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- JupiterJazz 15y agoAre you kidding me? Parents will give their money to the schools who do a good job and will stop giving money to schools that do a bad job.
- delinka 15y agoI suppose the Free Market would make sure that their 'customers' had input into how tuition money is spent. After all, if the government isn't involved and you're free (Free Market, remember) to move your student, then the school needs to cater to your expectations or lose tuition money.
- lurker19 15y agoYeah so it turns out that the education consumer doesn't tend to spend the education dollar on quality education. Consider the current mess in privately-paid higher education. Education is the vegetables on the dinner plate of life. I is a complicated long term investment to make good choices, but those choices have huge externalities. Parents make choices that affect their children (that is an externality) and those children grow up to affect society (another externality)
- guard-of-terra 15y agoAS if anybody cared - how it works in Russia: - There are virtually no private schools, every school is public. - There are better schools and worse schools. In a big city there are a few really good ones and a bunch of mediocre ones. - A school have to accept anyone living in a proximity, but it may also accept anyone else. So the good ones set up entry exams. Mediocre ones enroll everybody. - I guess there are some bad schools, some really poor ones, but there are probably none or a very few "failing" ones, with meaning as in article. By the way, where do illegal immigrants' children go to?
- LoveLinux 15y agoThe problem with that in America is that allowing entrance to schools based entirely on tests scores results in large numbers of Asians and whites and very few black and Hispanics and you end up with this racial discrimination mess.
- guard-of-terra 15y agoThe solution is that you perhaps should be making bad schools less bad, instead of making the awesome schools more shiny and then digging moats around those.
- pyre 15y agoTherein lies the problem. How? In general, bad schools suffer from a lack of funding and the political will to do something about it.
- 0x12 15y agoOnly in the US will you find people that go to prison for arranging better education for their children. Utterly ridiculous. The best way to ensure that people do not do stuff like this is to make sure that all schools are held to the same high standards.
- mattdeboard 15y agoI agree with you that it's ridiculous they'd go to prison over it. However, "holding all schools to the same high standard" is impractical with the way the system is now.
- NY_Entrepreneur 15y agoDon't try to send them to a 'good' school, certainly not an 'academically good' school. Bluntly, the K-12 teachers don't know anything worth much serious study or effort. The best can hope for from a K-12 school is that it will do no harm. Find a school that has a nice 'social atmosphere' and otherwise is RELAXED, e.g., with as little homework as possible. Then for the real learning, have your children do that at home -- evenings, weekends, summers, and/or school study hall. What materials? Sure, academically by far the crown jewel is just math. So, get them through math to the college sophomore level ASAP. The next best subject is physics. So, get them through freshman physics based on calculus ASAP. How? Get the best texts (good used copies are FINE, especially for the math) and work through them. If need some help, ask some friends who know the material well and/or find an appropriate, helpful college prof. Or have one parent enroll in, say, a community college course and there learn enough to guide their children and be able to ask the prof questions. After math and physics, emphasize writing, say, letters, notes, blogs, whatever. Sure, get 'computer literacy' and also learn the basics of programming. Then emphasize geography, history, and art history. For English literature, at least learn about the basics of 'drama' and 'formula fiction' and touch on the more famous works. For as many of the works as can, start by watching a movie of the work. For more in drama, understand how movie and TV dramas work. Somewhere get some basic coverage of 'people and personality', especially about human emotions. E.g., lacking anything else, read E. Fromm, 'The Art of Loving'. For more, have the child take some community college courses, e.g., biochemistry and biology. For more, look at the International Baccalaureate program and pick and choose from that or, maybe, just go through the whole thing. During the last 2-3 years of the 'high school' time, review what else, if anything, is required to do well on the SAT tests. For more? Maybe learn piano? Likely could study accounting and take the CPA exam. A CPA would be nice to have. For more? Jump into college material at the junior level and keep going. Get through college ASAP and then go for graduate or professional school. For K-12? Don't ask for much and mostly just circumvent it.
- bd_at_rivenhill 15y agoI think these parents are trying to get their kids out of schools that can't even enforce basic discipline in the classroom. There's a big difference between an environment where teachers don't know anything worth much serious study or effort and an environment where teachers spend almost all of their time trying prevent a riot from breaking out in the classroom and thus spend almost no time actually instructing students. Also, it can be very hard to support real learning at home if you are a single parent working two or three jobs to make ends meet.
- cafard 15y agoForty years ago, I remember hearing from a neighbor that the Arizona school district she had worked for took some pains to see that the snowbirds didn't just drop their kids off for instruction. Her oldest child was probably born in 1951 or 1952, which suggests a terminus ad quem for her teaching days of about 60 years ago. Now and again the New York Times will write about the efforts New Jersey districts will take to investigate suspicious enrollments. I've never read of such investigations resulting in more than a kid shipped from one school to another. And it strikes me as utterly disingenuous for the WSJ to be going on about this.
- lhnn 15y agoHow is it disingenuous for the WSJ to talk about this issue?
- zeteo 15y ago>Ms. Williams-Bolar last year used her father's address to enroll her two daughters in a better public school outside of their neighborhood. This is not civil disobedience, it's just plain old falsification of records. If she had falsified another crucial piece of information - say, income level on a scholarship application - would Ms. Williams-Bolar still get all of this "end justifies the means" sympathy?
- jxcole 15y agoObviously not. The whole point of the article is that poor, intelligent children do not have any way to enroll in schools that would allow them to excel. Presumably if you lied on the income level on a scholarship application, you would have the funds to send your kid to a nice school but you wouldn't want to pay for it. Note that if you were very poor lying about your income on your scholarship application would not be necessary. If you're still not convinced, let me ask you: Would you not lie about where you lived if it meant you could get a better life for your child? I am not sure you could be called a good parent if the answer to that question is no.
- zeteo 15y agoNo matter how worthy the purpose, falsehood is falsehood. Is it really such good education for your children to demonstrate that lying should be used to obtain the important things in life?
- timtadh 15y agoSince you are purporting that falsehood is never wrong... exodus 1:15-20 (NRSV) The king of Egypt said to the Hebrew midwives, one of whom was named Shiphrah and the other Puah, ‘When you act as midwives to the Hebrew women, and see them on the birthstool, if it is a boy, kill him; but if it is a girl, she shall live.’ But the midwives feared God; they did not do as the king of Egypt commanded them, but they let the boys live. So the king of Egypt summoned the midwives and said to them, ‘Why have you done this, and allowed the boys to live?’ The midwives said to Pharaoh, ‘Because the Hebrew women are not like the Egyptian women; for they are vigorous and give birth before the midwife comes to them.’ So God dealt well with the midwives; and the people multiplied and became very strong. tl;dr : The king told midwives to kill baby boys. The midwives did not. When asked by the king why the boys still lived, they lied.
- maxxxxx 15y agoI am not sure this is the whole story. The Wall Steet Journal lately seems to be on a mission to discredit any form of government. Of course it's different when they wear a uniform, do things in secret and tell us they are there to protect us...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- rdl 15y agoThis is sad -- there is a need to restrict access to a limited resource, but for any individual parent, it's the right choice. The ultimate solution is to improve the quality of the bad districts, but that will take a long time. For now, I think the best approach is strict enforcement of residency, but three tracks in for out of district students: cash payment substantially in excess of per-student marginal cost; competitive entrance for a limited number of students based on objective merit (not race based, like the PA/EPA system); and children of employees of the district (or maybe of city government in general). I'd be fine with a parent who really wants to give a child a chance taking a job with the district primarily to get children into the schools. Maybe a second job, maybe part time, but the sacrifice should be made by the parent, not by other residents of the school taxing district. If this lets the district hire people more cheaply, or of better quality (which DOES happen in Palo Alto for just this reason), it's win/win.
- mckoss 15y agoWhy not use a lotery? I don't see why any public district shouldn't be available to any state resident. What would be the rationale for any preference to residents or district workers? Any other policy serves only to preserve the inequality of the education offered between districts.
- rdl 15y agoThey're funded locally, not by the state (in most states). There's just as much of an argument for a national lottery as a state lottery, if you want people outside the funding area to have an even shot of coming in.
- tokenadult 15y agoMy state has a more rational state law. For more than twenty years now, all public schools anywhere in the state offer open enrollment to all students anywhere in the state, up to the limits of the capacity of each school district to receive students. http://education.state.mn.us/MDE/Academic_Excellence/School_Choice/Public_School_Choice/Open_Enrollment/index.html http://education.state.mn.us/MDE/Academic_Excellence/School_... Funding of course is based on enrollment. http://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/hrd/pubs/mnschfin.pdf http://www.house.leg.state.mn.us/hrd/pubs/mnschfin.pdf More students means more enrollment, so school districts make efforts to provide attractive programs that will bring students across district lines. This competition among school districts has promoted innovation in programs and resulted in a fair amount of interchange among students who live in different neighborhoods. For example, the first public school program for "highly gifted" students in our state http://www.invergrove.k12.mn.us/atheneum.html http://www.invergrove.k12.mn.us/atheneum.html began precisely because the offering district knew it could build a program that would attract in new students to the district (which was losing student population because it was in an inner-ring suburb with an aging population). That district enjoyed such success with its program that soon other school districts set up similar programs. http://www.springlakeparkschools.org/schools/la/la_lighthouse.asp http://www.springlakeparkschools.org/schools/la/la_lighthous... http://department.services.bloomington.k12.mn.us/modules/cms/pages.phtml?pageid=201931&sessionid=7ed12a7f68aafbb779daff0c410248ec=bb1f727f0c37c2c7a6f2b98cb942232c&sessionid=7ed12a7f68aafbb779daff0c410248ec%3Dbb1f727f0c37c2c7a6f2b98cb942232c http://department.services.bloomington.k12.mn.us/modules/cms... http://www.minnetonka.k12.mn.us/ACADEMICS/NAVIGATORPROGRAM/Pages/default.aspx http://www.minnetonka.k12.mn.us/ACADEMICS/NAVIGATORPROGRAM/P... And the main point is that school districts don't just compete with programs for "highly gifted" students, but also with programs for fine-arts-inclined students, or students who desire language immersion programs (Spanish immersion and Chinese immersion programs are both hot programs in Minnesota), and students with many other characteristics. Some school districts gain almost half of their enrollment from open enrollment, and correspondingly some of the historically worst school districts in Minnesota have lost large percentages of enrollment to families crossing district boundaries to look for better schools. (Minnesota also has a huge number of charter schools, which is a distinct form of competition for publicly subsidized students, but they cannot offer some of the programs that public school districts can.) This competition keeps all districts accountable for providing a good learning environment, and helps change the psychology of teachers and principals dealing with families from one of treating learners as a burden to one of treating learners as an opportunity to be grateful for. Any other state in the United States could do the same, and a few already have. http://educateiowa.gov/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=649&Itemid=636 http://educateiowa.gov/index.php?option=com_content&task... http://www.ecs.org/html/offsite.asp?document=http%3A%2F%2Fwww%2Eecs%2Eorg%2FOpenEnrollmentDatabase http://www.ecs.org/html/offsite.asp?document=http%3A%2F%2Fww...
- nazgulnarsil 15y agounderground history of american education and an econ 101 textbook. These are the bare minimum of material you should be familiar with before spouting policy prescriptions on this subject.
- nasmorn 15y agoThis reminds me of how european peasants could not move to a different parish then the one they were born in unless the priest would accept a transfer. The land of the free. Free to move to any trailer park in the whole country.
- callmeed 15y agoI was so close to doing this for 2 of my kids this year—we were to the point of signing the papers. Our neighborhood was in the region of the worst-performing school in the district (not even the closest, either). My mom owns a house 3 blocks from a great school and we were going to use that address. My mom wasn't comfortable with it so we opted for private school.