4 ms·
Yeah, there have been some quiet yet serious proposals about personal carbon rationing in recent years. People on the farther left are uncomfortable with carbon
by wmf 5y ago
Yeah, there have been some quiet yet serious proposals about personal carbon rationing in recent years. People on the farther left are uncomfortable with carbon taxes or tradable credits because of inequality.
- hellojesus 5y agoTradable credits will happen no matter what. Let's say we impose a $100/week gas limit via CBDC. Immediately I would list ads on CL to trade my $100 credits for $200. Gov can't stop it. Rationing just breeds further market inefficiencies.
- abecedarius 5y agoIn this scenario, gov could easily penalize or ration conversions to cash, limiting this escape hatch. They wouldn't go that way immediately because outrage, but it'd get increasingly doable and tempting as people get used to CBDC. (Lots of precedent for this pattern.) I've already read one economist's proposal to tax cash withdrawals in order to support negative interest rates, a couple years ago.
- hellojesus 5y agoAgreed. It would be a cat & mouse game. Instead of cash trades, the gas-consumer could buy me a $200 Amazon gift card, etc. with their CBDC. There are always ways around restrictions, especially when people that aren't deterred by illegality and jail time like me exist. It would be an arms race.
- imtringued 5y agoYou can use damn carbon taxes to pay out a carbon ubi that democratized pollution rights. For some reason everyone wants an autocratic economy.
- deutschew 5y agoor the HN comment I read that said something along the lines of "if you buy a ferrari and it's not electric, you should be arrested"