4 ms·
Can we stop comparing Putin to Hitler (and calling this war a genocide while we're at it). Words have meaning, you can be a piece of shit blood thirsty autocrat
by lm28469 5y ago
Can we stop comparing Putin to Hitler (and calling this war a genocide while we're at it). Words have meaning, you can be a piece of shit blood thirsty autocrat without being Hitler or nazi, you can kill civilians without it being a genocide
- debo_ 5y agoNothing in the comment you replied to does this.
- ortusdux 5y ago> Putler
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vlovich123 5y agoFor me the comparison is more towards how Hitler captured territories around him and the policy of appeasement of his neighboring powers (& also how those same powers could have neutered his domestic political support very early through intervention and forcing a loss of the war rather than appeasement). From that perspective it seems apt. Also, unless OP edited their post, you're the only one to bring up genocide or the comparison to Hitler.
- frumper 5y agoOP called him Putler as a melding of Hitler and Putin
- lm28469 5y ago> you're the only one to bring up genocide or the comparison to Hitler. I put it in parenthesis because of that, but I've seen both the Hitler comparison and genocide accusation popping up hundreds of times in the last few days, usually by the same people. We get it, Putin is bad, and Hitler is the baddest of the bad guys, but still, it doesn't make any sense whatsoever. We can call him Putinéon or Putin Khan while we're at it
- vlovich123 5y agoIt does make sense to me from a military strategy perspective. You've got a belligerent government in Europe in charge of a major military power that's attacking it's neighbors. The parallels to German's invasion of Austria in 1938 & the events leading up to that seem pretty clear to me.
- lm28469 5y ago> You've got a belligerent government in Europe in charge of a major military power that's attacking it's neighbors That's the History of Europe since there are people in Europe though. I don't get why people get so fixated on Hitler to be honest. The Russians fought him in ww2 do you think they identify as him ? Why not compare Putin to Stalin ? Soviets also invaded Ukraine. I think the comparison is much dumber than that. People think Putin is bad, they also think Hitler is the badest of the bad, and that's enough for them to start calling him "Putler". Meanwhile you have literal neo nazis fighting for Ukraine against Russians right now, ironic.
- cols 5y agoJust checking that you are aware that Putin has been murdering fleeing civilians, targeting health facilities including a maternity ward, and using dumb bombs to level entire cities? At what point does this cross into genocide for you? Edit: People on this thread seem very confused as to what the word 'genocide' means. Here is the definition from un.org. In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: - Killing members of the group; - Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; - Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; - Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; - Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml https://www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/genocide.shtml
- School-Cotton 5y agoIt would be genocide if the Russians were murdering a significant chunk of the population in order to eradicate the Ukrainians as a distinct ethnic group. There is no evidence of that happening. Yes, Russia has been committing atrocities. Not all atrocities are genocide.
- cols 5y agoIncorrect. See the definition above of genocide as defined by the Genocide Convention.
- School-Cotton 5y agoYour own definition says it has to be an attempt to destroy the group. Killing people from a group doesn’t necessarily mean you are attempting to destroy it. Otherwise all murders would be genocide.
- lm28469 5y agoAccording to your definition any war is a genocide... what matters is the scale and intent, none of which points to a genocide in Ukraine right now
- danielvaughn 5y agoYeah I'm not an expert on this conflict, but have been following it closely enough. I'm pretty confused as to why people are invoking genocide, because I haven't seen any evidence to indicate that's what is happening. There was the bombing of the children's hospital, which may turn out to be a war crime, but I don't see how anyone can know whether it was intentional. And if collateral civilian deaths are equated with genocide, then what should we call the US wars in the middle east?
- giraffe_lady 5y ago> then what should we call the US wars in the middle east? almost there keep going.
- danielvaughn 5y agoBut they weren't genocide.
- slibhb 5y agoPeople use "genocide" to mean "thing I don't like" and "Hitler" to mean "person I don't like".
- zpeti 5y agoBecause Ukraine are clearly playing a very good social media game, and on social media words like Hitler and genocide work very well.
- yks 5y agoWhat is "genocide" to you if not erasure of cultural identity and physical eradication of peoples? Putin literally told us himself that "there are no distinct Ukrainian people" which is erasure of cultural identity, and the indiscriminate killing of civilians is the physical eradication. It's not just about the hospital, the scale of atrocities against civilians is already way beyond the US wars in the Middle East and it's done on purpose. They haven't setup the gas chambers, I give you that, but the future of Ukrainian identity if Russia prevails is grim.
- qdog 5y agoHitler didn't start out running concentration camps, there was a long lead up to that. The Knight of Long Knives, where 'opponents' of the Nazis were assassinated was in 1934. Kristallnacht happened in late 1938. There are a number of similarities between Hitler and Putin, and we may yet see the beginning of pogroms against Jews, but I would say that the bans on homosexuality are showing us where this ends up going. Putin also seems to be bent on returning to a former empire (see Third Reich comparisons).
- flavius29663 5y agoExcept the genocide piece, he is pretty much Hitler though: - no opposition parties at home - few leaders that oppose him get killed - all protests are quickly ended by the police (brown shirts) - uses fascism to expand his country: outside threat, we must defend ourselves, focus is on the nation, not the individuals - uses rich private businessmen to further his goals, when this fails he just nationalizes what he needs - boosts military spending and might - keep expanding territory and keeps expanding control He is different than from the previous, communist dictators in that he is alone at the levers. The high ranking commies were able to remove insane autocrats (Khrushchev), nobody in Russia can remove Putin now.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoSo Xi Jinping is Hitler too?
- HillRat 5y agoAlternatively, this is (arguably) the most paradigmatic example of genocide on European soil since the post-Yugoslav wars: the official line of the Russian government is that there is no such thing as a "Ukrainian people," only a "little Russia" (Malorossiya) that has no distinct identity, and the war is intended to destroy the Ukrainian nation itself and absorb it through violence into Russia, through some combination of direct absorption and tightly-controlled puppet states. This is hardly unprecedented in Russian-Ukrainian relations, even in the last century; in a 1953 speech, Raphael Lemkin, who coined the term "genocide" and foundationally established international law against it, called the Holodomor and post-Holodomor Soviet control of Ukraine "the classic example of Soviet genocide ... the destruction of the Ukrainian nation. [I]f the Soviet program succeeds completely, if the intelligentsia, the priests, and the peasants can be eliminated, Ukraine will be as dead as if every Ukrainian were killed, for it will have lost that part of it ... which, in short, made it a nation rather than a mass of people."
- ccdan 5y agoNo, that's far from anything related to genocide and Putin is actually right: Russians and Ukrainians(and Belarussians) have the same common root in the Kievan Rus. The idea of Ukraine didn't even exit until about 1700s and the country itself was founded in 1917.
- LichenStone 5y agoArticle scheduled to be published 2 days after the start of the invasion, was promptly removed when it became clear the 'special operation' wasn't going to plan - http://web.archive.org/web/20220226051154/https://ria.ru/20220226/rossiya-1775162336.html http://web.archive.org/web/20220226051154/https://ria.ru/202... Translation - https://pastebin.com/rWEqsGe2 https://pastebin.com/rWEqsGe2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_and_soil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blood_and_soil Also > "...solution of the Ukrainian question..." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Solution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Final_Solution
- lm28469 5y agoYeah he called it a special operation because "war" sounds bad and he's taunting the west. And using the word "solution" isn't always a reference to Hitler (it virtually never is)... The mental gymnastic is insane... The US had plenty of "military operations"/"special operations" and "solutions" for Iraq and Afghanistan, they killed plenty of civilians yet they're no Nazi and the president isn't Hitler.