9 ms·
Cormac McCarthy’s tips on how to write a great science paper (2019)
- palindrome818 5y agoThe economist Richard Thaler is quite good at writing papers that don't make you want to off yourself. Are there any other examples of good academic writing?
- abcc8 5y agoI found the 'Hallmarks of Cancer' papers by Weinberg and Vogelstein to be very well written. While those are reviews, their research articles are well written as well.
- palindrome818 5y agocool will check it out usually good academic writing is an oxymoron
- abcc8 5y agoGiven that attitude, your mileage may vary with these suggestions. I utilize primary research all day every day for my job and my definition of good academic writing is clear, concise writing that enables me to answer the specific questions I am seeking to answers for quickly and in a manner that allows me to confidently cite the work (assuming the relevant information is present within the manuscript).
- ahartmetz 5y agoMost papers from before the 80s or so IME. After that, it seems like scientific papers became similar to patents: not written to elucidate, but to obscure and waste the time of readers. Readers are the competition in a big rat race, after all.
- kryptiskt 5y agoSimon Peyton Jones's papers are really clear and understandable. He actually did a talk on how to write papers: https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/academic-program/write-great-research-paper/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/academic-program/wr...
- pklausler 5y agoHis writing is extremely clear and worthy of emulation, but his presentations are always in Comic Sans.
- diarrhea 5y agoYou are really onto something here. I am in plain-old mechanical engineering. As a student, for the first years, I was simply intimidated. "These papers are so hard to read!". You have to read between the lines so much, fill in so many gaps, correct so many mental and grammatical knots. 10 years later and 2 years into a PhD, I think I am ready to admit that most papers are terrible. Most people are not native speakers. It makes a huge difference. Filler words, synonyms, long sentences, grammar errors... the list goes on. The only thing not on it are typos, because those are caught by software and are an easy fix. The rest takes genuine work and effort. Papers are so hard to read, they can be headache-inducing and I am often completely exhausted from them. And that's only touching on the stylistic part. Nowadays, everything is either all code or (strongly) relies on it (experimental work still needs collecting, evaluation, plotting, ...). But good luck finding actual, published source code (and if it's public, the sad-but-true adage of horrific academic coding takes effect). Methods are obscured and unclear. Sometimes, people can't even cite a single source properly almost verbatim -- fundamental reading comprehension seems to be lacking. Often, private data is used in private or public but unusable code, making papers entirely irreproducible. It's mental and frustrating. Coming across good papers in between the cruft really stands out, but happens at a low rate (10-20%?).
- mabub24 5y agoI find, in general, that philosophy tends to have the best overall quality of writing in academic writing. There are still examples of bad writing, but when it's good, the writing is crystal clear and a joy to read.
- anonymousDan 5y agoI disagree with the advice on not using transition words such as 'however'. These can be a useful signpost that e.g. the approach described in the previous sentence has a drawback and/or to build tension when describing a problem. Or maybe I'm just not a good enough writer to do it in some other way...
- FPGAhacker 5y agoI agree with your sentiment, however the author suggested minimizing. Not eliminating.
- tomlue 5y agoI read science papers to learn. Concise prose presented in a logical order is the best for this. Transition words often add unnecessary subjectivity and filler.
- dagw 5y agoThe subjectivity is be important to make the uncertainties clear. Papers and research results aren't always clear and objective. We did a thing, however it might not have been the best approach. We got some results which might be relevant, however there are these confounding factors that might mean they aren't. At the end of the project we realised that we probably should have started with doing X, however we didn't and I don't know if it would have made a difference or not. If you want information presented in a clear, unambiguous and logical order, it's best to wait for the textbook.
- auxym 5y agoWords like however and similar are often useful in the introduction of a paper to expose the context, current state of the art, and problem that your research is attacking. I'm in engineering though, so most research and papers follow the theme of "there exists this problem, current solutions are this and this, however they are not ideal because X, therefore we present this novel solution which is really great".
- 5y ago
- driggs 5y agoPunctuation is our best defense against the peculiar ambiguities of the English language. Cormac McCarthy's abhorrence to using punctuation is the worst facet of his writing, and made the dialog in `Blood Meridian` practically unfollowable. I kindly urge writers to use his subjective opinion here as an argument FOR rather than against the precision application of punctuation!
- adolph 5y agoEats, Shoots & Leaves would be a great line in BM https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/06/28/bad-comma https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2004/06/28/bad-comma
- mellosouls 5y agoCormac McCarthy's abhorrence to using punctuation is the worst facet of his writing, and made the dialog in `Blood Meridian` practically unfollowable. No. His (lack of) use of punctuation in his work is mesmerising and beautiful, and part of what made Blood Meridian one of the greatest novels of the last century. Obviously that technique is less likely to be constructive in science writing.
- driggs 5y ago`Blood Meridian` is a great novel in spite of, not because of his lack of punctuation. Do you not see the irony in his own use of four commas and a colon while telling us to minimize our punctuation use in this article? > While you are writing, ask yourself: is it possible to preserve my original message without that punctuation mark, that word, that sentence, that paragraph or that section? Remove extra words or commas whenever you can. Perhaps he merely considered the "Oxford comma" unnecessary!
- sritchie 5y agoDon't you think he does too, and is winking at you with that sentence? Especially given the spare "Remove extra words or commas whenever you can."
- 5y ago
- gbjw 5y agoSomewhat tangential, but McCarthy is publishing two new novels (after a 16 year break): https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/08/books/cormac-mccarthy-new-novels.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/08/books/cormac-mccarthy-new....
- pklausler 5y agoOh, that's such good news. Thanks!
- AlwaysRock 5y agoSo exciting. I cant wait. I love how he is willing to explore new genres. These books are going to be really interesting.
- YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago>> And don’t use the same word repeatedly — it’s boring. This is the worst possible advice to give about technical writing! What you should absolutely do if you want your readers to know what you're talking about is a) define your terminology before you use it and b) stick to the terminology you defined throughout the entire paper. Don't call a thing "red noppertock" the first time you mention it and then "crimson nopper with a tock" the next time. Call the same object, the same concept, the same method by the same name, always. Otherwise, you will only create confusion and make your reader tired and impatient. "Boring" is not a flaw, in technical writing. The purpose of technical writing is not to entertain, but to explain and clarify. Creative writing is a completely different thing. The worst mistake you can ever make is confuse the two and treat a paper like a short story, or such. Trust me, I know. What McCarthy advises above is exactly the mistake I made in my first research papers and they all got rejected with frustrated comments by confused reviewers who pointed out they had no idea what I meant when I used a particular term. I had to take a course with an academic writing expert at my university, to realise what I was doing wrong: I was trying to add variety to my writing, just like in literary, creative writing. I stopped that as soon as I realised how wrong it was and now I actually get reviewer comments about the clarity and quality of the writing in my papers. And as _writing_ goes, it's boring as all hell, but it gets the point across without doubt. That's its purpose.
- jackallis 5y agoi agree with you here. technical paper/writing is "boring" for a reason.
- diarrhea 5y agoGrading theses, this is a very common trap. Students believe they have to be creative, change it up and use a Thesaurus. Because that is in fact what everyone is taught in school! Yet, technical writing doesn't work that way. Synonyms are almost always wrong. We have the luxury of precision, where most often one term means one concept or thing. A 1:1 mapping with little ambiguity. Deviating from that is almost always the wrong decision. Also notice the style I am writing this comment in. Short, concise, to-the-point sentences. Sparing use of filler words (thus, however, ...). I wish all technical writing was more like that (and I find that good technical writing either is, or is on such a high level that they can get away with longer sentences). I believe it a boon: you get a style of "Statement. Statement. Idea. Question. Idea. Statement. Solution. Conclusion.", if that makes sense, allowing easier mental access and partitioning. Technical topics are hard, and writing should accommodate the reader, making it as easy as possible.
- zeec123 5y agoI like the notes on Knuth lecture “Mathematical Writing” https://jmlr.csail.mit.edu/reviewing-papers/knuth_mathematical_writing.pdf https://jmlr.csail.mit.edu/reviewing-papers/knuth_mathematic...
- coastflow 5y ago> Don’t slow the reader down. Avoid footnotes because they break the flow of thoughts and send your eyes darting back and forth while your hands are turning pages or clicking on links. This sounds reasonable for technical writing, though it's interesting to read McCarthy's recommendation after considering David Foster Wallace's work, where there is a very frequent usage of footnotes. In his non-fictional essays essays—often in the role of a reporter like in his well-known "Consider the Lobster" for Gourmet magazine [0]—Wallace uses extensive footnotes. This isn't technical writing, though the quality of Wallace's convinced me that footnotes can have a useful place in fictional writing. > And don’t worry too much about readers who want to find a way to argue about every tangential point and list all possible qualifications for every statement. Just enjoy writing. From Hacker News discussions (and also speaking to a colleague who competed at a high level on a debate team in high school), I learned the opposite lesson. If there is a weakness in an argument, it's likely it will be pointed out. I've found it important to consider weaknesses in logic and try to anticipate counter-arguments whenever possible, when writing for readers from more technical problems. [0] [PDF] http://www.columbia.edu/~col8/lobsterarticle.pdf http://www.columbia.edu/~col8/lobsterarticle.pdf
- jcranberry 5y agoI think the footnotes emphasize the meandering and exhaustive aspects of his informationally dense style of writing. I think its a stylistic choice which emphasizes his unique voice. I don't think hacker news is representative of the type of communication that papers communicate. A lot of times the communication on this website can default to adversarial, which I think is not the default for academic discourse. Plus I imagine there are other forums in academia aside from published studies (I think there are published discussion journals, and you also have blogs and such) that are suitable for that type of communication.
- tptacek 5y agoWallace is deliberately breaking up the flow of thoughts, though.
- gowld 5y agoLacking footnotes slows the reader down with distacting asides.
- setgree 5y agoI am a big fan of McCarhty's and I think Blood Meridian is absolutely transcendent. The advice in this article seems apt if you are writing a 'great' paper, in the sense of 'going to be a classic in your field.' But it doesn't seem like very good advice for writing a 'good' paper, meaning one that advances the state of knowledge in one particular direction. True classics in the fields I know best (political science and economics) tend to be written very memorably, meaning the author's perspective is obvious. But not everyone is Gary Becker [0] or Kenneth Waltz [1], and if everyone tried to write like them, we'd have a lot less dialogue between papers -- a lot of the stuff people find boring in academic research is authors' trying very hard to situate their contributions within the broader literature -- and more people trying to strike out as stylistically distinct iconoclasts. Another comment here [2] makes this point well about the repetition of words. Repeating a technical term might make for a boring read, and if you are writing a paper that's going to revolutionize your field, perhaps you don't need to repeat yourself much because your main point can (should?) be made in a few different of ways. But if you're writing a typical science paper, which makes a narrow point about a new finding, then yes, you should repeat yourself as much as you need to create precise buttressing around that new finding. [0] https://www.jstor.org/stable/1807222 https://www.jstor.org/stable/1807222 [1] https://direct.mit.edu/isec/article-abstract/18/2/44/11449/The-Emerging-Structure-of-International-Politics?redirectedFrom=fulltext https://direct.mit.edu/isec/article-abstract/18/2/44/11449/T... [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30616522 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30616522
- bluenose69 5y ago> Avoid placing equations in the middle of sentences This is strange advice. In many fields, following this suggestion can make it harder for the reader to understand the message.
- gowld 5y agoWhy is "Avoid placing equations in the middle of sentences" strange advice?
- beanjuice 5y agoSome equations can be incredibly simple, and explained as a part of text. I'm sure Cormac McCarthy is speaking about some abstract proof that would jolt the reader no matter what. But "Writing quality is a product of clarity and simplicity, (q = c*s)" doesn't have to be the high crime McCarthy claims.
- aerovistae 5y agoSide note but I am so excited for his new books later this year. It's been so long since he wrote a new book, and statistically these are almost certain to be his final novels given his age (88). I found the prose of Blood Meridian and The Road absolutely extraordinary, so I'm eager for more of it. I haven't read his other past novels yet, don't ask why. Maybe because I saw the movie of No Country For Old Men, and I wasn't sure if the horses trilogy would interest me.
- dointheatl 5y agoHighly recommend The Border Trilogy as well as No Country for Old Men. The Coen Brothers did a fantastic job adapting the latter, but it just can't compare to the book.
- savanaly 5y agoDon't forget to give a watch to The Counselor. It had dreadful reviews because as a movie it's a total failure. But taken as a Cormac Mccarthy novel narrated by skilled actors and visually imagined by Ridley Scott it's a success, in my opinion.
- Arkadin 5y agoLove The Counselor. The screenplay was also published in book form and is worth reading with or without having seen the movie.
- teddyh 5y agoI vastly prefer Larry McEnerney’s lecture The Craft of Writing Effectively: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtIzMaLkCaM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vtIzMaLkCaM
- guyomes 5y agoFor further reading, this list [0] of resources on how to write scientific articles includes notably this excellent set of slides [1]. The author notably presents full fledge examples of rewritten sentences and paragraphs that are enlightening. [0]: https://people.csail.mit.edu/fredo/student.html https://people.csail.mit.edu/fredo/student.html [1]: http://www.principiae.be/pdfs/UGent-X-003-slideshow.pdf http://www.principiae.be/pdfs/UGent-X-003-slideshow.pdf