3 ms·
> because approaches like this often have virtually no explanatory power. the famous feynman have produced a response to this train of thought - usually from t
by chii 5y ago
> because approaches like this often have virtually no explanatory power.
the famous feynman have produced a response to this train of thought - usually from the laymen - where they demand an "explanatory theory". The answer is usually "don't know"; why gravity work the way it does? - don't know, but we can calculate orbits to great precision; why does photons or electrons travel the way it does? - don't know, but we can make very precise predictions via Quantum Electrodynamics theory.
The laymen demands an explanatory theory, because there's an underlying assumption they don't even verbalize - that such an explanatory theory can be understood _without the maths_, that the principles of the laws of physics operate on basic, understandable lego pieces. What is somewhat unconceivable is that the explanation _is_ the maths. To whit, we don't even have an explanation for the idea of inertia! We just observe it, and measure it (as mass). There's no explanatory theory.
- kayamon 5y agoFeynman must have driven his wife mad. "Honey did you take the garbage out?" "When you say garbage, have you considered if garbage can even really exist?"
- wwweston 5y agoIn analogy to this discussion, it'd be the opposite, actually -- situational Feynman would be the person who knew he could practically gather specific unwanted matter into a bin or sack and take it out to the collection bin for most practical volumes, while situational wife would be the person asking for an explanation "but how do you know that what you have taken out is the garbage and that it has in fact been removed"? Still, it's fun to play with this idea via figures who are a little more philosophically rarified as it were: https://www.tiktok.com/@davecolumbo/video/7060855732090178862 https://www.tiktok.com/@davecolumbo/video/706085573209017886...
- jfengel 5y agoYou could say that the "explanation" of inertia is that which preserves the symmetry of space translations under Noether's theorem. But that doesn't tell a physicist any more than they already knew, and it tells a layman even less.
- somenameforme 5y agoConfounding variables are a strong argument against this. Give me two sets of data that have no causal relationship, and it's very possible (if not likely) I will be able to demonstrate not only a causal relationship but also observational predictability through the existence of confounding variables. Let me use ML models and this becomes trivial. Do school names determine how good a school will be? Of course not. However, schools have names which tend to be reused: cultural icons, scientists, etc.. And schools in low performing areas are going to have a different distribution of chosen names than schools in high performing areas. So you can create a model that will not only demonstrate this but also offer legitimate observational predictability that a school's name will, on average, determine how well it will do. The only way you could really refute this hypothesis is by understanding the true confounding variable, or by running some huge scale multiple decades long experiment where you changed the names of new schools and measured the performance difference. That experiment is clearly not really practicable, so all you're left with is understanding. And this is really where the risk is. If we ever begin to build upon something that is unsound then it risks everything from that point onward being also invalid. At best everything collapses and you realize you must have made a mistake. At worse, you simply end up adding endless epicycles until at some point everything starts to completely stall out muddled in its own invalid fundamentals and irreconcilable complexity.
- jiggawatts 5y ago"don't know" -- that doesn't mean we can't know, it just means we don't currently have an explanation. If you had asked similar fundamental questions about the "why" of beetle species a few centuries ago, even the most prolific beetle collector in the world would have answered "don't know". "The laymen demands an explanatory theory" -- and so do scientists! Why do you assume scientists are somehow "above" explanations, and are content in ignorance? "explanation _is_ the maths." -- People had good rules of thumb for evolution (such as dog breeding practices), and Gregor Mendel could have come up with his mathematical rules for selection before Darwin published his explanatory theory of natural selection. That doesn't mean that it's worthless to try to aim for an explanatory theory of QM instead of a purely numerical / observational one.
- BeFlatXIII 5y agoI'm trying to remember which textbook or professor was the one who said that "shut up and calculate" was the Feynman interpretation of QM.