6 ms·
This would require military action by Moldova/Georgia/Ukraine because the territories you mention are ethnically different and do not want to be part of those c
by mytailorisrich 5y ago
This would require military action by Moldova/Georgia/Ukraine because the territories you mention are ethnically different and do not want to be part of those countries to start with.
Abkhazia fought a war in the early 90s to split from Georgia. South Ossetia also fought several wars to become independent. So both those territories might strive to become fully independent but will absolutely refuse to be re-absorbed by Georgia.
Moldovans are actually a minority in Transnistria, which has also seen open tensions since the fall of the USSR.
Lastly, Crimea, which was Russian until 1954, will definitely require a war and ethnic cleansing if Ukraine want to take it again and to keep it.
- inglor_cz 5y agoCrimea could turn into an independent, mostly Russian speaking, fully demilitarized country living off tourism. Possibly joining the EU later. I bet they would be much richer than today. Being a part of Russia sucks from the economic point of view. IDK if Crimean Russians are so nationalistic that they would rather live in a semi-starved, heavily sanctioned, economically isolated country.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoWhy can't they remain part of Russia like they historically were (well, I mean since Russia took over form the Tatars, of course) and seem to want? It's not because Russia has taken Crimea back in a rather cavalier way that they should be split again just to weaken Russia. This can only perpetuate resentment and problems.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThey can, if they prefer to, but in order to achieve lasting peace in the Black Sea, Crimea should IMHO be demilitarized. Having Russian military bases on their south flank is a major security problem for Ukraine.
- nullifidian 5y agoOn what basis are you fantasizing about demilitarization of a nuclear state? How would that work? I hate Putin as much as the next person, but nothing will happen to the Russia proper -- they'll start throwing nukes, tactical first, then strategic.
- inglor_cz 5y agoPeace treaties in the past contained all sorts of demilitarization clauses. It is not unprecedented.
- nullifidian 5y agoCounties sign such peace treaties when they lose hard enough to start losing their territory proper, or they are forced to capitulate, are occupied. How would a nuclear state lose their territory proper? There were indeed various peace treaties in the past, but not a nuclear state losing their territory proper.
- Navarr 5y agoSpeaking only as an American, I don't think we really know what Crimeans want. Russia isn't well-known for legitimate democratic voting, and the Crimean referendum has never been acknowledged by Western Democracies. I would not be starkly opposed to Crimean independence, nor even Russian-integration, but in essence it looks like Russia took Crimea and then held a fake referendum to legitimize it. But the question always goes - where do we draw lines. Should we support the concept of the Confederate States of America seceding from the United States? If California or Texas wanted to secede, should we support it? Wales? Okinawa? Quebec? How should governments determine actual stake and determination over a specific part of land?
- mytailorisrich 5y agoCrimea it at least 70% ethnic Russian and was Russian until moved to Ukraine without consultation. So I think this is a case where Putin's actions did align with what the people actually wanted even if that's too hard for the West to acknowledge publicly (I'm sure that they accept that Crimea is not going back to Ukraine).
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Crimea it at least 70% ethnic Russian So are parts of Ukraine who are vigorously resisting the Russian invasion. Identity is tricky. Many once ethnic and/or linguistic Russians may choose to identify differently, to be governed differently, and that’s their right. The modern “Russian” ethnicity, as one distinct from e.g. Ukraine, is only a few hundred years old [1]. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kievan_Rus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kievan_Rus'
- nullifidian 5y ago>So are parts of Ukraine who are vigorously resisting the Russian invasion. To be pedantic, Ukraine's regular military forces are vigorously resisting the Russian invasion, not parts of Ukraine. Regarding the ethnic and identity composition of Ukraine's military forces -- I have no idea.
- Giorgi 5y agoThis is inaccurate information, Russia fought both wars in Georgia, currently Abkhazians and Ossetians are Russian citizens (they grabbed Russian passports as soon as they become available) so they will go back to their motherland Russia, Georgia will re-absorb it's own historical territory. Looks like you are spreading Russian propaganda in bad faith.
- mytailorisrich 5y agoOh so you're saying that Georgia wants to forcibly take those territories and go full ethnic cleansing (That's how I read what you wrote, I'm not trying it on)? If so, they might indeed prefer to have the Russian army around...
- Giorgi 5y agoAgain, you are spreading Russian propaganda, Hacker News is not a place for Russian shills.
- orwin 5y agoI've hosted Ossetians (well, my mother did) back in the days. There is actually a huge diaspora in France, and even when they are deeply religious, they do hate Russia with a passion I've never felt with anyone else. So I'm quite disbelieving this kind of statements, maybe my vision is skewed by my experience.
- jhbadger 5y agoAbkhazians and Ossetians aren't "Russians" ethnically, culturally, or linguistically though. Why would they want to go "back" to Russia (not their homeland)? The whole point of their struggle is ultimately to get their own countries just as other ethnic groups have. They merely accepted Russian aid and citizenship as a way to get out of Georgian rule. Which of course may ultimately be going from the frying pan into the fire.
- Giorgi 5y agoThey rushed to took Russian passports thus they are Russian citizens and can go back to their homeland Russia. The whole point of their struggle was Russian invasion so Russians could build military bases there (which they eventually did)
- jcfrei 5y agoIndependent countries are one way to go. A mostly independent region within a federalized republic could be another.
- toyg 5y agoIsn't technically Russia a federation already...?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WilTimSon 5y ago> This would require military action by Moldova/Georgia/Ukraine because the territories you mention are ethnically different and do not want to be part of those countries to start with. Curious that, at least in the case of Georgia and Ukraine, those territories only decided they didn't want to be part of their countries when Russian troops rolled in and made totally non-threatening offers.
- nullifidian 5y ago>Curious that, at least in the case of Georgia That's not entirely true. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abkhaz%E2%80%93Georgian_conflict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abkhaz%E2%80%93Georgian_confli...
- WilTimSon 5y agoWell, from the Wiki: "a militia composed of ethnic Georgians who lived in Abkhazia and Russian-backed separatist forces". Sure, there may be a slice of population that wants to leave but how can that be gouged properly when Russia keeps influencing the people and supplying weapons to separatists? There's a cause and effect here.
- nullifidian 5y agoThe fact is that Abkhazians haven't been fans of the idea of being part of Georgia, even before they were forcibly incorporated into Georgia by the Soviets, and the ethnic strife started before the collapse of the SU, and before the armed conflict (and Russian military assistance) has started. In Spain's Catalonia separatist sentiment can be gauged properly, but does that help with an actual realization of that sentiment? Not much. And that's a highly developed European country, from which Georgia is still very far institutionally, and was even farther in the 90ies.
- darebak 5y agoNot true.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- atdrummond 5y agoCan people who downvoted this explain why? I don't know much about Crimea and its situation but I've spent considerable time in both Abkhazia and Transnistria; I have a number of businesses that I have based out of Tiraspol and Sokhumi. While far from a fan of Russia's interventions in both regions, I have long felt, form talking to as many people as possible in both nations, that the majority (although not necessarily an overwhelming one) support the countries being independent from Tbilisi and Chișinău, respectively. I'm more than happy to have my priors re-adjusted here.