11 ms·
It's not just Mac software - desktop software in general seems to be stagnating. As noted, several app categories seem to have "matured" and/or ossified and ar
by musicale 5y ago
It's not just Mac software - desktop software in general seems to be stagnating.
As noted, several app categories seem to have "matured" and/or ossified and are dominated by one or two players. For example, Microsoft and Apple dominate the "office" productivity software market on macOS.
Moreover, apps like Discord, Teams, VS Code, etc. seem to be cross-platform web apps which are clunky and unsatisfying compared to native apps. (Other web apps don't even have desktop versions and only exist in the browser.)
That being said, Adobe's offerings are expensive subscriptions which have opened up a market for Affinity as well as Pixelmator and Acorn.
- duped 5y agoJust personally, I use several of those "clunky" apps daily and they're more seamless than native counterparts. Particularly VS Code. Its biggest struggle is input latency, but if I really cared about that I wouldn't have left editing in the terminal.
- clumsysmurf 5y agoI agree, some of the "clunk" apps feel real nice. Problem is, when you have 4 electron apps running, and your system starts grinding.
- datavirtue 5y agoYeah, I use VS Code as my terminal now. I love having the directory tree visible if I need or want to single click a file and play with it instantly with zero overhead. I use thunder client now instead of that dreadful postman obomination after learning about it here last week. VS Code is becoming my general purpose environment. I was working in PowerShell ISE today and was thinking "this has to go" the whole time. So if I have any PowerShell work in the future I'm going to try the VS Code tooling for that. I knew at least one person at Capital One who was using it for their Spring Boot project instead of Intellij.
- bdcravens 5y agoI have dedicated tools for most tasks like the terminal, git client, REST client, etc, but most of the time I use VS Code (built-ins or extensions); even when I'm making compromises, I prefer the workflow of staying on one screen.
- Semaphor 5y agoWhile I rarely use it, VS Code is great. But MS Teams? I feel as if I’m on a mobile device that’s running out of memory when I’m using it. (Windows PC)
- lostlogin 5y agoIt’s actually disgusting, and probably broken in several regards. Why is functionally so different between the native app, web and teams. How is this an industry standard? I edited a table, moved a picture and changed a footer. How can that be complex?
- aidos 5y agoWe had to use Teams for the kids school over lockdown. What a dumpster fire. On a daily basis you could never tell which method of extracting a document would or wouldn’t work. Sometimes they wouldn’t open at all. Or would only open on web, but not desktop (or the other way around).
- unfocussed_mike 5y agoI really have trouble with the idea that VS Code is "clunky". Not least because one of the apps I used to use -- Panic's Coda -- had really severe keyboard lag issues in some situations, on hardware that should have been fine with it. In my experience VS Code is plenty quick enough, not least when I am editing something inside a VM or on a remote server using the Remote SSH mode. It might show a bit of keyboard latency but the Remote SSH mode more than makes up for this, for me; the sheer flexibility it offers me as a developer means I am going to ignore a bit of general latency. And we've put up with worse in IDEs and programmers' editors, for sure. One thing I would observe about speed complaints in VS Code is that they come from people who navigate through text mostly through keys; people with a vi or emacs back-story. There is no doubt at all that it repaints more slowly than some editors when scrolling down through code line-by-line or page-by-page with the arrow keys etc., because of all the code actions that fire off when the cursor moves. But it is not noticeably laggy when scrolling with a trackpad, because the cursor does not move. This difference probably explains people's very polarised and simultaneously valid responses to VS Code.
- jahewson 5y agoI don’t think VSCode belongs on that list. I’d much rather use it than XCode. We could probably all agree on the others though.
- rimliu 5y agoI wonder, how many claiming preference for VS Code vs Xcode (yes, it is spelled like this) have actually used Xcode, not only heard about it.
- kall 5y agoXcode has a nicer, more robust UI and I like it for that. I actually like that I don't have to configure every last thing via some text file. However, the syntax highlighting/autocomplete/language support seems to crash or slow down far too often. It's just one (or two) built in languages, not 3 different plugin LSPs running on the same file like VSCode, so it really should be better, not much worse.
- stby 5y agoBy now I would assume many people have at least once tried to build an app for iOS in one way or another. And it's easy to see why people prefer VSC which has a pretty classic UI for an IDE / editor, whereas Xcode tries to do so many things differently without good reason.
- alwillis 5y agoSome of what's in my /Applications folder: * Omnigroup's suite of apps for macOS and iOS * Craft * Drafts * Fantastical * Hook * Marked * Mela * Rectangle * Scrivener * Postbox [1]: https://www.omnigroup.com/blog/omni-roadmap-2022 https://www.omnigroup.com/blog/omni-roadmap-2022 [2]: https://www.craft.do https://www.craft.do [3]: https://getdrafts.com https://getdrafts.com [4]: https://flexibits.com/fantastical https://flexibits.com/fantastical [5]: https://hookproductivity.com https://hookproductivity.com [6]: https://marked2app.com https://marked2app.com [7]: https://mela.recipes https://mela.recipes [8]: https://rectangleapp.com https://rectangleapp.com [9]: https://www.literatureandlatte.com/scrivener/overview https://www.literatureandlatte.com/scrivener/overview [10]: https://www.postbox-inc.com https://www.postbox-inc.com [11]: https://www.macstories.net https://www.macstories.net [12]: https://sixcolors.com https://sixcolors.com The most useful apps still come from the indie developers; it's just not as high profile as it once was. It's become more artisanal. If you read MacStories [11], Six Colors [12] and other indie Mac websites, you'd see lots of innovative Mac and iOS apps.
- Forgeties79 5y agoI can’t imagine my life without audacity lol
- alwillis 5y agoForgot about Acorn and Retrobatch from Flying Meat: https://flyingmeat.com https://flyingmeat.com. iTerm2 is perhaps the best terminal app on any platform: https://iterm2.com https://iterm2.com.
- salmo 5y ago3rd party Mac apps that I like better than any of their counterparts on any OS are: - iTerm2 - it works right, it feels responsive. I don't have to futz with it but can - Pixelmator Pro - it's what Photoshop used to be to me 20 years ago - Omnigraffle - When I need to hand-layout a diagram it's my favorite ever - Postico - It's weird that I like a single DB UI. But it's nice over just pqsl sometimes. I have some handy utilities I like: - The UnArchiver - Flycut - SwiftBar - Disk Inventory X - Amphetamine - Skitch - Magnet I use Office 360 begrudgingly. But I do like it better on macos than Windows. The rest of my GUI stuff is largely cross platform (and some electron) - Firefox - Chrome - Notable - Signal - KiCAD - Wireshark - VirtualBox - IntelliJ (I use less and less) - Spotify The killer app for me in a lot of ways is just Homebrew. I live in the terminal. I love having up-to-date dev tools. I hate maintaining it. Even with Linux it can be a pain to hit the sweet spot between up-to-date and DIY. I'm happy running a FreeBSD server, but I want my workstation to not require a lot of planning. I also love that I can install/update native apps from it. I always use it before I hit the App Store. I've ditched making VSCode and IntelliJ like vim and made neovim like VSCode. It's glorious. I use git and text for almost everything I do, unless I can't or when a picture helps. And I don't play games on my laptop anymore. Really just Minecraft on my tablet. Sometimes I let my kids play with me :)
- mschuster91 5y ago> It's not just Mac software - desktop software in general seems to be stagnating. Well... the golden ages (which I'd say are the mid-90s to 2010-ish) are over. - Business software has pretty much consolidated and the existing tooling from office suites to data warehouse and workflow stuff (i.e. SAP) offers so many options that it's incredibly hard for new players to gain a foothold - you need to identify some niche, build it out well enough to offer an actual benefit and market the hell out of your idea, and maybe in 0.1% you have a chance at lucking out. - there are a bit of open-source efforts (e.g. Thunderbird, Mozilla, LibreOffice) but they lack funding so they struggle along, mostly used by those not wanting to spend money on the above-mentioned pay products - Utilities from file management (Winrar, Winzip, Total Commander) over media players (Winamp) to task managers have been absorbed by the operating systems. These days, particularly Apple is known for outright ripping off ideas from popular App Store apps. - the people who made the really innovative apps in the golden age were highschool and college students. These people have since found employment at big companies, removing both the time and the ability to work on side gigs (hard to do a side gig when you're staring at a screen for 40+ hours a week, and why bother with side gigs when your employer demands copyright even over stuff you do on your own time?). Today's young people aren't interested in programming any more, they're more interested in Tiktok or to fight on the political level. - All major OS platforms have alienated developers. Microsoft with win32 -> .net/WPF -> UWP -> WTF, Apple with Cocoa -> WTF, and Linux never got around to settle on one way of packaging applications and dependencies or on window managers or on <insert long list of forks, disagreements and other crap that happens without a central steward here>. - it seems like the flurry of cheap or free high-quality IDEs and the consolidation (basically it's VS Code, IntelliJ or Eclipse these days) directly coincided with the end of big-corporate desktop app developments. Basically when no one pays four figures for an IDE any more because no one wants to develop for desktop, it makes sense that the others go down in price (Visual Studio/VS Code) or vanish (Borland). - Mobile, web-based SaaS and subscription based stuff lured a part of said alienated developers with better pay and actual innovation - ETA: Games... that's a different beast. Can't argue that there is innovation present. But most of the attention of the major actors seems to be focused on console-exclusive or other walled-garden deals, and the mobile market draws in the f2p whales. There are rare gems (e.g. Factorio) that simply would not work on a console due to a lack of a keyboard, but that's it.
- robomc 5y agoIn a professional context, desktop software is a pain, and so it's largely dying off now that browser based tools can do so much of it. It's fiddly and annoying (and usually expensive) to license for a team (compared to SaaS subscriptions). It tends to be less "online" - more likely for work to exist only on staff laptops and more difficult to share and collaborate on work (compared to software where all of the "work" exists online and live collaboration is expected). My work situation is just VSCode (which I'll probably use in the browser half the time going froward via codespaces), Chrome and whatever Terminal app comes with the OS. And 10 tabs open for email, chat, calendar, docs, video calls, project boards, version control, devops stuff etc. I assume that's pretty typical.
- dangus 5y agoThe truth of the matter is that people do most of their computing on phones. People conduct serious business on phones. Mobile apps and sites are more important to products that we would all assume are “sit down at a desktop computer” type of products. Any effort you put into a desktop-only app is basically leaving most of the money on the table, unless it’s a desktop computing specific niche (and if it is, it was probably already thought up 10 years ago).
- Gigachad 5y agoThis is one of the hard pills for HN to swallow. The age of desktop computing for general consumers is shrinking. It'll probably always have a place but everything that can be done on a phone is getting done on a phone these days.
- copperx 5y agoMany of the things that are more comfortable to do on a desktop computer is because many web app/site developers consider mobile devices as crippled computers and often such sites do not offer the user all of the options. The "request desktop site" shouldn't still be a thing in 2022.
- bilalq 5y agoHonestly, these cross-platform apps are way better than the native apps of yore. I'd take VSCode any day over XCode or Sublime. Slack pretty much just works and is way less finicky than LimeChat ever was. The reality is that the browser has become the OS that everyone targets. In many ways, this is a good thing. The apps I run on my Mac work just as well on Windows and Linux. You mention Microsoft/Apple dominating office software. But there's a whole new world built on top of things like Notion and Google Docs/Sheets now. Web apps are more than capable enough today outside of niche scenarios.
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoI refuse to "update" any software now. Just been burnt by loss of features too many times. Once I have something working as i like, I will not update. It seems that long term stability and continuity became a dirty word and now we are forced to update every year because someone has new hardware to sell you or a new subscription service to push you into.
- hammyhavoc 5y agoThat's fine and dandy until you need to update to target x new OS version with builds, or need y bug fix, or support for z hardware.
- 5350-uiop-1130 5y agoi'm not an app dev but generally i avoid itoy ecosystem for this reason. having to install 12gb xcode so i can convert my chrome extension to safari. or my local env/build system stop working because i update from catalina to big sur for a new uglier flatter design. and why they have to give these stupid arbitrary names to their os, its all marketing, it makes it confusing to know what was previous and what next...
- ricardobeat 5y agoVSCode at this point has so many optimizations that it can’t be put in the same bag as the others. Its main rendering surface is not using the DOM, most of the work happens in other processes, it can even use native tabs in MacOS now. As a result it really feels snappy, unlike Slack and other common electron apps.
- zuhsetaqi 5y agoIt may feel snappy compared to other electron apps but is still a lot slower than native apps. Especially the startup time.
- nielsbot 5y agoI just dislike how non-native it feels and looks.
- treeman79 5y agoAs a single part developer, If I wanted to build a native app for windows and Mac, maybe Linux. Also iOS and android. How many good options are there.
- criddell 5y agoI'm going to assume you want to make the best applications you can on each platform and are not willing to accept a lowest common denominator solution that is sub-optimal everywhere. The only good option is to separate your UI and logic and write a new UI layer for each platform. It is hard work and there's no easy out. On a phone, the UI has to be touch only. On Windows you probably need to support touch and keyboard/mouse. Linux may lead you to develop a TUI and GUI. Your macOS version should probably be a GUI. Then on each platform, there are significant differences for things like where the settings UI should be and where the settings should be persisted.
- stnmtn 5y agoYour case here feels wrong. The goal is shipping something that provides value and can have features added to it at a pace customers expect, fixing bugs quickly, etc. Having a separate UI layer and needing domain knowledge for every single platform, coordinating releases accross all these different platforms, and everything else that comes with a cross platform app is quite simply not worth it from a business perspective. Especially with the idea that if you spend half the effort you would from developing 4 native UIs on wrangling the performance hit from Electron to maybe only 20% worse than native, it' just not even a consideration anymore.
- samgaw 5y agoOnivim (https://onivim.io https://onivim.io) solved input latency for anyone that felt VSCode was too slow while keeping plugin compatibility. Sadly though the project stalled when the dev had to pay bills (https://github.com/onivim/oni2/issues/3811 https://github.com/onivim/oni2/issues/3811).
- yakubin 5y agoI've taken up photography as a hobby (quite some time now) and Affinity is sure worth its price. Surprisingly, there is even an open source app (RawTherapee) which beats Lightroom with no sweat. I still don't have a solution for organizing photos, but I think I'm going to settle on ACDSee, which seems pretty well geared towards my needs. So while the desktop doesn't feel as vibrant as it used to, there is still quite a bunch of players in this field who keep up the good work. I'm not going to buy any subscriptions. And luckily I don't need to, since the classic funding model in this space still brings better apps.
- mkr-hn 5y agoDigikam appears to have a Mac version, but I don't know if the port is any good. It has a lot of what was lost when Google killed Picasa. https://www.digikam.org/ https://www.digikam.org/
- yakubin 5y agoI tried it on Linux and it appeared quite buggy, and unpolished. Although it may have been the fault of Debian patches (it's quite obvious that it's not the vanilla version). From videos on YouTube, it seemed that ACDSee is quite polished and exactly what I want on the other hand, so I'm going to try that - first with a trial version and then if I like it, I'll buy it.
- TheRealDunkirk 5y ago> VS Code You can have my Sublime Text when you pry it from my cold, head hands. Shoutout for Tower Git, Kaleidescope, and TablePlus as well.