4 ms·
I saw a comment on reddit that made me think, it was a Russian person saying that sanctions only hurt the average citizen when the ruling class has enough wealt
by stavros 5y ago
I saw a comment on reddit that made me think, it was a Russian person saying that sanctions only hurt the average citizen when the ruling class has enough wealth to not be affected much. They also said that popular opinion will either turn against the west (for imposing the sanctions) or not hurt Putin much because he doesn't really need popular approval (which I'm not sure I believe).
Do the sanctions actually hurt Putin, or are we hurting ourselves and the everyday Russian for nothing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- codazoda 5y agoBased on the fact that he said the sanctions are “an act of war”, I presume he’s feeling some pain from them.
- stavros 5y agoLet's hope so, though for that particular statement I'm not ruling out just him being belligerent.
- hbosch 5y agoI don’t know. Maybe it’s conspiracy minded, but in my opinion Putin will publicly pretend to be hurt by the sanctions (and acknowledge the depressed ruble and so on) as a so-called “act of war” so that the world can hear him acknowledging NATO countries as “doing something.” This serves many ways: Putin projects as vulnerable, sanctions are optically seen as successful measures, NATO countries get to say they’re helping, and all the way Russia gets to keep bombarding Ukraine… I’m inclined to believe the former opinion that gas price hikes ultimately affect the average person and elite persons need not care. Putin and his inner circle operate at a level of power that is above even money. To an oligarch money is a toy thing, the power they have is above any short term economic concern. I’m reminded of that old Weibo thread of Chinese people posting symbols of their wealth, one upping each other over and over, until the ultimate show of “wealth” was posted as being an invite to a dinner with the president (or something like that) which not even billionaires have access to. All this to say that theatre and public relations is a major tool of war and power, as much as soldiers and bombs.
- CuriouslyC 5y agoWhen the average Russian on the street has had enough, Putin's time will be over. He doesn't have the rapidly increasing standard of living that China has to cover his sins, he just has the threat of violence to scare people, which will stop working when their lives are so shit that they don't care anymore. If he doubles down on violence, the government under him will unravel as the good (or at least not evil) people stop obeying his orders. That will lead to mob justice unrestrained by the disillusioned Russians tasked with enforcing Putin's will.
- ARandomerDude 5y agoDeath threats kept impoverished Soviet citizens subdued for 70 years. Sadly, fear can be a very effective tool for tyranny.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoThe difference is that many of those Russians have seen the world outside and now know it can be different. It’s not 1950’s anymore.
- Retric 5y agoLess than 70 years after the last revolution. The USSR was extremely politically significant, but really didn’t last very long.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjeaff 5y agoAs far as Russian oligarchs go, without their money, their power does not extend outside of Russia. Which leaves them limited to a rather poor country with the gdp of Italy.
- zapataband1 5y agoPutin lives in a palace and no one even knows how rich him and his thug friends actually are. They don't like the sanctions but I doubt he's 'feeling pain' whilst sending people's kids to war from his personal hockey rink. We simply live in a different reality than the rich, money is nothing to them. I work at a startup and am constantly astounded that our rich investors will write up another 200k check without more than a 5 minute conversation.
- tartoran 5y agoThere’s no shortage of sushi Putin has on his dinner table. However, his chair started tilting a bit. His control is still above 90 degrees but that angle could take a sudden 180 turn. If he’s confident he’s most likely bluffing. If he’s scared i’d fear him more
- zapataband1 5y agoBoth solid points, but imo maybe that's more of a reason to approach the situation russia with more diplomacy than our current "leaders' are rather than force more sanctions and escalate the situation quickly. Some senators are openly calling for assassination.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoIf he was confident he wouldn’t be isolating the country.
- ushakov 5y agothey are meant to hurt oligarchs which in turn will want to hurt Putin
- throwawaylinux 5y agoIt has been "common knowledge" among a lot of the people calling for sanctions that they don't work well and mostly hurt the common people of the country. I'd hear this a lot in discussions about sanctions for Iran, NK, Cuba, etc. Now apparently _this_ time they'll work.
- purple_ferret 5y agoSanctions on Iran definitely caused a lot of pressure. I don't think these are comparable though. They're all unique circumstances and the people in power have varying capabilities of suppression and motivations. Remember, at one point recently Iran turned the lights off on an entire city and gunned down hundreds of protestors[0] [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932020_Iranian_protests https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019%E2%80%932020_Iranian_prot...
- throwawaylinux 5y agoThis seems to be pretty handwavy, they definitely did something and the situations are different. Sure, I'd like to know what they did and how the situations are different. Are you saying sanctions in Iran actually did work contrary to "common wisdom"? And that they may not work in Russia because the situations are different, or what? > Remember, at one point recently Iran turned the lights off on an entire city and gunned down hundreds of protestors[0] This wasn't supposed to be an example of how the ruling class was hurt by the sanctions, surely. Not sure what the relevance is.
- MattGaiser 5y agoSanctions seem to have worked quite well against North Korea and Iran, although not for the initial purpose. North Korea can't afford anything new for its military. Sure they have a sizable army of weapons your grandfather fought against, but they also operate bitcoin scams to fund their country, despite sitting on tremendous mineral wealth. Iran has to make ever more economic sacrifices to fund its nuclear program and again also struggles with procuring weapons due to the cost. We didn't get the regime change desired, but the enemy was substantially defanged as a result and they fall further behind as time goes on. I would argue sanctions against Russia succeed if the next time they invade somewhere, they send their troops with rusting weapons and no body armor and cannot really afford to replace their equipment losses in Ukraine.
- woodruffw 5y agoSanctions are a slow economic weapon, one that's only half of the current economic strategy (the other half being asset seizure and uncoupling of Russia's financial sector from global finance). It's hard to say whether any given sanction is "worth it." But the long term trend is a politically advantageous one for NATO: oligarchs now need to keep all of their money within Russia's borders, where it's both unstable and subject to court whims. That should worry them, and the hope is that it worries them enough to unmoor them from Putin.
- kitten_mittens_ 5y agohttps://www.amazon.com/Economic-Weapon-Rise-Sanctions-Modern/dp/0300259360/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=the+economic+weapon&qid=1646615764&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Economic-Weapon-Rise-Sanctions-Modern... makes the point that sanctions tend to have unintended consequences and originally were used as a weapon of war.
- MattGaiser 5y agoAt the very least the economy of Russia is being starved, so maintaining their military spending becomes more difficult over time unless they are willing to become like North Korea. Members of the ruling class also may not join the rest in struggling to afford day to day life, but they certainly cannot be happy with having all their money trapped in a country without the rule of law. There is a reason they have their children born in the West.
- lettergram 5y agoThe sanctions help Putin. Thus far they’re making a boat load off the oil. Sanctions only hurt if you import, look at what they’re importing — it’s not much. What they do import is primarily from trade partners who aren’t sanctioning (China, Belarus, etc).
- sdenton4 5y agoAs more trade partners are refusing to buy Russian oil, they're selling at steep discounts in auctions, and need to use non-pipeline delivery for the resulting nonstandard buyers (which greatly increases delivery costs). Germany has also scrapped a plan for a new pipeline, which will decrease future sales.
- jmcgough 5y agoPrices are rising on oil because people aren't buying Russian oil. Russia is even trying to sell it at a discount to offload it: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-60584798 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-60584798
- Retric 5y agoChina is Russia’s single largest trading partner but they import a lot of goods from the countries that added sanctions. https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/imports-by-country https://tradingeconomics.com/russia/imports-by-country Germany $23.38B United States $13.21B Italy $10.20B France $8.08B …
- nradov 5y agoThe point of sanctions is to protect our allies by making it harder for Russia to build up more military power. The poorer they are, the fewer weapons they can build. If people get hurt that's incidental.
- gfd 5y agoI found https://youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs https://youtube.com/watch?v=rStL7niR7gs very useful for understanding where dictators derive their power from. Adapted from 'The Dictator's Handbook'
- zapataband1 5y agoVery informative watch, humanity needs to evolve past rulers. We don't need senators, politicians etc in any capacity more than a custodial role. Social democratic systems like liquid-democracy which is both a direct and representative democracy should be a bigger part of conversation. It constantly feels like we are trying to run society via software made in 600BC but the hardware(agriculture, science, tech) has kept pace. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy
- stefan_ 5y agoWell, geez, do you have a suggestion then? No, there is no special mind weapon the president can activate to vaporize Putin and make Russia bloom into a beautiful peaceful democracy. Such is the world. In the meantime, we get to accelerate our transition away from fossil fuels and eliminate all kind of corrupt actors in the West that have been keeping us locked into gas. Win-win.
- gip 5y agoI have family in Ukraine and Russia. From the data points that I have, I'd say that most people in Russia support Putin (including in my family). While the average citizen will be impacted first by the current situation, it will have an effect on the leadership IN TIME (e.g. in years, not days). In fact, severe sanctions should have started in 2014 [1]. As for the argument that popular opinion will turn against the west: it already has [2] and I think we should not talk about sanctions any longer, but of separate blocks with minimal exchange and interaction. I understand that going back to an iron curtain of some sort may be shocking for some, but at least that will severely limit the risk of miscalculation and nuclear war. Putin is a dictator and we have to act. [1] Says a former Russian diplomat: "They also thought the EU was weak because of how toothless their sanctions were in 2014" https://twitter.com/andreivkozyrev/status/1500610676926005251 https://twitter.com/andreivkozyrev/status/150061067692600525... [2] https://twitter.com/ABCNewsLive/status/1499449302728462342 https://twitter.com/ABCNewsLive/status/1499449302728462342
- jll29 5y ago> From the data points that I have, I'd say that most people in Russia support Putin (including in my family). Russians are bi-modaly distributed: there are people who approve of him (many Russians like strong leaders, which explains photographs of topless Putin riding a horse, Putin in an expensive car etc.) and there are also Russian people who demonstrate and speak out despite the clearly severe consequences that come with that attitude (4,300 arrests of protesters against the invasion of Ukraine to date). In this thread on sanctions versus non sanctions it is discussed whether the sanctions hit only ordinary people or also the super-rich. What we need to also mention is that a large part of the pro-Putin people are only supportive because of government propaganda bias, and the absence of any high-quality international media. Finding more effective ways to make ordinary Russians aware of what is going on might be the least painful path to ending the nightmare (but it's still a long game).
- gip 5y ago> Russians are bi-modaly distributed Sure. I applaud the people who protest. However I also want people reading this to understand that most people support Putin. At least I have strong data points that support this and denying that fact doesn't help anyone. > Finding more effective ways to make ordinary Russians aware of what is going on might be the least painful path Maybe. The US tried to build a western society in Afghanistan for 20 years and that failed. I'm not convinced "educating" Russians to what we (the West) think is happening will work either.
- gruez 5y ago>I saw a comment on reddit that made me think, it was a Russian person saying that sanctions only hurt the average citizen when the ruling class has enough wealth to not be affected much. They also said that popular opinion will either turn against the west (for imposing the sanctions) I'm not so sure about the official sanctions (based on a quick skim[1] they seem to be mostly banking bans and bans on high tech exports), but the sanctions enacted by western companies (eg. netflix pulling out of russia), are definitely hurting the average citizen more than the oligarchs. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_sanctions_during_the_Russo-Ukrainian_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_sanctions_during...
- purple_ferret 5y agoIn Russia, most of these companies are at least partially state owned. Aeroflot, Gazprom, etc. Sanctions against them are meant to hurt the state.
- Guvante 5y agoUntil the West is happy with how this ends billions of capital are cut off from Russia and it's place on the mostly economic world stage will dwindle as it loses trade deals from companies and countries being unwilling to work with it. Stopping the sanctions to pretect the average Russian would be like refusing arms to Ukraine to protect Russian soldiers. While technically that would do that you are sending a very different message but taking that action. A country is a collection of natural resources and people. Unfortunately that means punishing a country will nearly always punish the people in it. That doesn't mean it is wrong to do so. Also Putin isn't invincible and it isn't just ordinary citizens hurt by this. After all if the rich didn't care if they were worth $10m or $100m the world would not look like it does today.
- Ericson2314 5y agoSanctions have a terrible track record, but they might actually work somewhat against an aggressor waging a drawn out conventional war with its high materiel needs. Normally the US uses them against countries who are not doing such a thing.
- Afforess 5y ago>Do the sanctions actually hurt Putin, or are we hurting ourselves and the everyday Russian for nothing? This conversation will go nowhere unless you define "hurting ourselves" vs "hurting everyday Russians" in actual definable terms. What would you say is evidence that would support that we are only hurting ourselves, and what evidence would distinguish that from the view that sanctions hurt "everyday Russians"? > for nothing? Also this is a separate point. Whether sanctions work or they don't, there is the separate point of whether sanctions _work_. Do they work? What evidence is there for that?
- notatoad 5y agoit's easy to think of sanctions as an abstract thing meant to apply pressure, but in this case that's not all they are. Russian oil is at least partially state-owned, and a major source of revenue for the russian government. yes, the sanctions probably aren't impacting Putin's day-to-day quality of life, nor that of any of the other oligarch's. but that's kind of beside the point. they are cutting off a source of funding for the russian military that is currently invading ukraine. that is really not "for nothing".