8 ms·
Didn't Ukraine already give up nukes for security assurances in 1994? And here they are being invaded by one of the signatories?! Seems like nukes, NATO, or EU
by paulryanrogers 5y ago
Didn't Ukraine already give up nukes for security assurances in 1994? And here they are being invaded by one of the signatories?!
Seems like nukes, NATO, or EU membership are the only way to be sure Russia won't invade, if you're a neighbor.
- hbrav 5y agoIt's often framed as that, but Ukraine didn't really have nuclear weapons at the dissolution of USSR. There were nuclear weapons located on its territory, but they were all controlled by military units that regarded themselves as answerable to Moscow, not Kyiv. What Ukraine really agreed to was to agree that they didn't own them, and allow them to be physically removed, in exchange for the security guarantee. This podcast is well worth a listen: https://www.armscontrolwonk.com/archive/1215097/deterrence-in-ukraine/ https://www.armscontrolwonk.com/archive/1215097/deterrence-i...
- the_snooze 5y agoIn other words, Ukraine "had" nuclear weapons in the same sense that North Dakota does: the bombs were just parked there under someone else's control and authority. The locals were never in the position to use them.
- dundarious 5y agoBut approaching NATO membership is a huge factor in causing the invasion to happen (not to excuse Putin's aggression and other war crimes, but it is true, this was a foreseeable consequence, and many foresaw it). You can read Russia's public statements and Wikileaks' US diplomatic cables from 2007/2008 giving credit to this position, and the trail of evidence carries all the way to the present and to policy thinkers like Mearsheimer (who I don't agree with at all philosophically, but he's one of the "realists" who is excellent at analyzing where the pressure points lie and what are the degrees of freedom). Abkhazia and South Ossetia should also be taken as further evidence that leaning too heavily towards NATO membership is what spurs invasion in the first place. As for foreseeing things, I have to admit that I got several things horribly wrong in the lead up to the invasion. I was far too focused on criticizing NATO powers for ignoring the diplomatic track (where was the pressure to implement Minsk 2?) and for only shouting about invasion. The reason this deserved criticism is that such errant focus meant that eventually there might be an invasion. But my rhetoric and even train of thought focused almost exclusively on criticizing NATO on the basis of warnings that turned out to be quite accurate.
- SinParadise 5y agoWhy do people keep treating Russia as if it is some force of nature that is merely reacting to external stimuli instead of what it actually is: an actor with agency that can.. just not invade?
- psyc 5y agoBecause we can’t exercise their agency for them. Strategically it’s more useful to ask what would they do if we did such. Asking why can’t they just be peaceful isn’t that useful at this stage.
- SinParadise 5y agoBut here is the thing, typically we consider their agency when formulating a response. We would response more harshly to an agent willingly and knowingly commits acts that we deem inappropriate, and we would be less harsh against one that has no other recourse. By ascribing Russia as this entity with no agency, one gives pretext to the softening and appeasement that they do not deserve. In this case, Russia deserves none.
- dundarious 5y agoNot trying to hijack this thread, but I think that logic doesn't hold, because the US Monroe doctrine is backed up by a lot of "inappropriate" actions. There are no angels here, except in each side's propaganda. And regardless, I'm not convinced Russia can even carry out its current program in Ukraine. Those suggesting "appeasement" will "embolden" Putin to go on a wider campaign of war through Europe haven't justified the rationale for how that would even happen. And if it came to that (basically another World War), those making that claim have to justify how a World War later is worse than a World War now, which is often, though not always, the implied anti-"appeasement" approach.
- SinParadise 5y ago> There are no angels here, except in each side's propaganda. Sure, pick your poison. This time I'll have a shot of NATO. I may be in the mood for something different next time. > And regardless, I'm not convinced Russia can even carry out its current program in Ukraine. Those suggesting "appeasement" will "embolden" Putin to go on a wider campaign of war through Europe haven't justified the rationale for how that would even happen. Just brinksmanship with nukes I guess? I don't even necessarily care about emboldening. I just believe that they should walk out of this limping. Harder the better.
- pastacacioepepe 5y ago> Seems like nukes, NATO, or EU membership are the only way to be sure Russia won't invade, if you're a neighbor. Sorry, this is not true. Misinformed at best. Russia has been warning for years that they won't tolerate having another NATO country adjacent to their border. Every single analysist knew that offering NATO membership to Ukraine would have caused a conflict. And yet we went ahead and offered it. Without this expansionist step from our side the situation would have never escalated. This is well documented and confirmed by top notch geopolitical analyst and even NATO officials. So you want to keep Russia out of a country? Don't offer them the NATO membership. Why would we expand NATO anyway? It is only an aggressive move and I don't understand why we keep doing it, unless we have an interest in causing conflicts like this one and then polarizing the world into a new cold war. Check recent history. Who's waging unwarranted wars thousands of miles away from their borders all over the world? It's not Russia, it's us! We are the imperialist here, not them.
- nec4b 5y agoThe biggest country in the world trying to subjugate its smaller neighbors is not imperialist?
- rosndo 5y ago> Check recent history. Who's waging unwarranted wars thousands of miles away from their borders all over the world? How often has NATO done that? Care to name some examples?
- thoradam 5y ago> Without this expansionist step from our side the situation would have never escalated. Where do you put the annexation of Crimea in this timeline?
- blaser-waffle 5y agoHow many times were the Chechens offered to join NATO? This is more agitprop -- "it's NATO expanding, we had to do this, it's their fault". Bollocks. These are independent, sovereign countries who have a history of being abused by Russia and the Soviet Union. You know what happens if you're not in NATO? You get abused by Russia.