9 ms·
A report on exercise and sleep (2021)
- sam_letter 5y agoThis might help somebody but it's not super related to the article: in 2012 I had very bad and worsening depression and anxiety even though I had great, stress-free life. My doctor immediately suspected some deficiency in minerals/vitamins. We did a million tests and nothing out of the ordinary. Long story short, we did a sleep test and turns out I had horrible sleep because of my congested nose caused by sinusitis! Sleep is incredibly important.
- dchuk 5y agoHow did you fix the sinusitis?
- sam_letter 5y agoMy case was very bad to the point I was also losing my sense of smell so I had to have a surgery. It's a laser procedure and it worked like a charm.
- sph 5y agoI have the same exact problem and my way of dealing with it is an extreme elimination diet. It's hard, but I can sleep, and I'd rather sleep than pig out on food. Gluten, sugar, spices and a myriad of vegetables and grains are triggers for me. Also daily saline nasal rinses and I can breathe better than ever, though diet is what does the most work. My pet theory is years of junk food precipitating into IBS and leaky gut, so only the food that cause fewer reactions are ok. In a healthy body some "toxins" are tolerated and don't cause issues, but when your gut is fucked you need to start from scratch.
- lr4444lr 5y agoWere you totally unaware of how bad you sleep was? Did you have any other symptoms related to poor sleep? I ask because I have structural nasal issues that I believe are affecting my sleep, but I'm terribly afraid of surgical correction due to the risk of Empty Nose Syndrome. My fitness tracker says my sleep is okay, but I'm starting to doubt it. What kind of sleep study did you get done?
- eurekin 5y agoI can recommend getting : https://www.amazon.com/Withings-Nokia-Sleep-Temperature-Compatible/dp/B078Z1B34S https://www.amazon.com/Withings-Nokia-Sleep-Temperature-Comp... It doesn't replace the true sleep study, but can still help
- sam_letter 5y agoI was completely unaware. in 2012 I DID feel more tired than usual but just chalked it up to depression and anxiety. Yes, I had muscle aches too! hence the doctor immediately suspecting lack of vitamins and minerals. I don't remember the sleep study type :(
- rubicon33 5y agoI wonder nowadays if an Apple watch and the AutoSleep app could tell you the same thing. It is such a great tool for tracking your sleep.
- _9omd 5y agoAs someone who's also suffered from poor sleep, related to nasal issues, I'm curious what you've tried. Have you tried mouth taping, chin straps, or breathe right strips? How about dietary changes to reduce congestion? What about breathing exercises and exercise in general? I've personally found mouth taping to be the most beneficial, along with breathing exercises (and general exercise) and eating a cleaner diet to reduce congestion. One thing I do is get in bed a bit early so I can do some breathing exercises and get my nasal breathing really dialed in before falling asleep. I lay in bed on my back and progressively slow my nasal breathing, focusing on very long and complete exhales. I roll over onto my side when I'm ready to fall asleep. I've tried box breathing, and 4-7-8 breathing for this purpose, but I find the extended inhales to be energizing, and not conductive to falling asleep. I actually did have a septoplasty and turbinate reduction back in 2015 before I'd ever even heard of empty nose syndrome. When I first listened to "Breath", by James Nestor and he talked about empty nose syndrome I recoiled in terror. I had anxiety for a bit, imagining I may have it and not have noticed and from imaging how my life could have turned out if I had a bad surgeon. After a few, I realized those fears were silly, and thanked my lucky stars that I didn't suffer that terrible fate. The surgery helped my nasal breathing slightly, but it wasn't dramatic or life changing. Knowing about empty nose syndrome now, I would definitely try all other possibilities before going under the knife. I think the surgery can be life changing for some, so it may just depend on how bad your structural issues are and how good the surgeon is.
- kowlo 5y agoCan't breath through my nose, makes my sleep paralysis much worse, can't smell properly and it impacts taste a little too Breath right strips help a little
- __turbobrew__ 5y agoI had something similar, but it was due to being disturbed by my partner throughout the night. We bought a SOLID king size bedframe and memory foam mattress and now I don't even notice when my partner is also in bed.
- specialist 5y agoSimilarly: My anxiety also had a physical cause: pinched spinal nerves. Resolved thru surgery, which was done for other reasons. I had wrestled with anxiety, insomnia, etc. for ages. Tried everything with no improvement. None of my care providers ever suggested a possible physical cause.
- Riseed 5y agoI'd like to learn more about this (pinched spinal nerves causing anxiety) but am having trouble finding anything helpful online. Most results are along the lines of the pain making the patient anxious about their condition, with some hypochondria thrown in. Can you elaborate, or do you happen to have a relevant term or two I could search?
- specialist 5y agoSorry. Just my personal experience (anecdotal). I don't think any of my care providers quite believe me.
- Riseed 5y agoIt's so frustrating to not be believed by care providers. Thanks for sharing your personal experience. I'm glad you found a solution.
- math_denial 5y agoThank you for this anecdote. I think I have a pinched nerve in the neck, very painful and my anxiety and panic attacks started together with the pain but were unrelated, linked more with university workload. My totally unsupported and unscientific opinion is that the inflammation of the nerve make impossible for my nervous system to relax, hence the anxiety.
- jschulenklopper 5y ago… in which someone discovers that practical examples of physical exercise (walking, running) aren’t mentioned in the original research paper. It’s a valid observation, but it’s then also a critique of making scientific research accessible to a general audience. I don’t see a problem with providing implied examples after citing research that didn’t mention examples.
- RivieraKid 5y agoAbout 10 years ago, I started taking a 1h - 2h walk almost every day, before the walk I buy a coffee to go. It's easily the best part of my day which I look forward to after waking up.
- angrais 5y agoWhen do you take this walk and how do you spare 1-2h a day? Do you have kids?
- brandonmenc 5y agoYou can take your kids on the walk.
- rco8786 5y agoIm guessing you don’t have kids.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoIt’s doable, but harder from the psychological side than physical. I have three. Strollers, balance bikes, scooters, bikes… all huge for moving w kids. BUT.. Doing anything consistent daily seems laughable. But I have to get regular exercise for my mental health and so does my wife.
- rco8786 5y agoConsistent, daily, for 1-2 hours. Not happening with the kiddos.
- brandonmenc 5y agoNo, but when I was a kid my father was very, very busy and he managed to exercise every day and took us kids on walks and runs with him. Where there's a will, there's a way.
- 5y ago
- _9omd 5y agoI've long wondered why some people can get by with little or no exercise and yet seem to live relatively healthy/happy lives. My Mom who's 66 doesn't exercise, other than a little walking, and while she's overweight, she always has energy, a good mood, and seems really resistant to the negative impacts of stressful situations. On the other hand, If I don't get at least an hour of exercise a day, I start to slip into fatigue, anxiety, and depression. I usually walk for 1.5 hours a day and hit the gym 3-5 days a week for cardio and weight training. Fortunately, I do love being active, and I wouldn't want to be more sedentary anyway. I've never had the greatest sleep quality (falling/staying asleep isn't a problem, deep sleep is), and I wonder if I've just been compensating all this time, and those who naturally sleep really well can do better with a sedentary life.
- paulpauper 5y agoIt's called the fitness & health industry, not charity. It's in their financial interests to exaggerate or oversell the health consequences of not doing exercise. It comes down to genes. Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger are both in their 90s and do not exercise and have crappy diets yet both are healthy and productive. Another example is William Shatner, who is also obese and just went to space at 90.
- vocram 5y agoTrue, but you won’t be able to sustain any moderate physical effort later in your life if you never did anything for your fitness when younger.
- rajin444 5y agoI 100% agree with you and you should take everything the fitness industry says with a grain of salt. They lie all the time. That being said, it’s possible for both genetically lucky people to exist and for people who would greatly benefit from exercise to exist.
- Tenoke 5y agoPointing at outliers doesn't prove anything. They can easily be (and likely are) highly atypical genetically, that doesn't prove how much exercise helps or doesn't help the average person.
- dorianmariefr 5y ago~> exercise fish: Unknown command: exercise ~> sleep usage: sleep seconds
- robertlf 5y agoI find that if I get eight hours of sleep at night, I can move mountains. But if I only get 7.75 hours of sleep or less, my eyes feel tired all day and I'm only half as productive. I've never understood why there is such a marked difference between eight hours of sleep and almost anything less than eight hours. There's something chemically going on inside that I don't understand. The problem I'm having now is that I can get a good five or six hours but I wake up after that fifth or sixth hour and can't get back to sleep long enough to get that ideal eight. This problem is seriously affecting my career and I don't know what to do. I do do moderate to vigorous exercise five times a week but that doesn't always help.
- bytemilk 5y agoGet analytical with you sleep. Did you drink caffeine after 12pm? Make a log of foods you eat? Are you practicing good sleep hygiene? Cortisol levels can cause issues with sleep cycles.
- yowlingcat 5y agoI've found that as I get older if I ingest any remotely psychoactive substances (caffeine, alcohol), I'll have difficulty getting a full 8 hours of sleep. Same applies with stress. The problem is compounded if I'm not exercising regularly or if there are any gaps with my nutrition.
- vocram 5y agoYou sounds like me. I’m seasonally suffering of the same problem. And AFAICS it doesn’t correlate with my sleep hygiene. What’s worse, I feel tired the whole day, but not that much anymore towards night.
- mupuff1234 5y agoWhat's your sleeping environment like? I find that making sure the room is still fairly dark in the morning makes it much easier for me to fall back asleep in case i've woken up "too early". I also started sleeping with earplugs in the last 2 years or so to make sure morning city traffic noises don't wake me up. And lastly, don't reach to the phone to look at the time, better have a regular clock which doesn't have all that extra stimuli.
- chrisbrandow 5y agoIt’s really tough when the first summary of a study is incorrect because it sets the tone for all subsequent coverage. It is so common with scientific studies.
- marifjeren 5y agoAm I the only one reading the original study and not finding the word "sleep" in it at all?
- SamBam 5y agoI'm honestly so confused. Are people reading a different paper? The article linked above says > Anyway I downloaded the report [1] [...]. The full conclusion, with the widely-quote section in bold, is below: > > Poor sleep was associated with a higher risk for all-cause and cause-specific mortality... And yet this "quoted" section is not in the linked report at all. Ctr-f "sleep" find no mention of the word. 1. https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/54/20/1195 https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/54/20/1195
- Terry_Roll 5y agoNo mention of diet. There is a chemical which can be taken in 1-2gram amounts daily that will give you a six pack just from a couple hours of walking, its legal and its used for other things but it has its "side effects" so needs to be complimented with other chemicals in order to mitigate said "side effects", and thats when you start going down a long path of chemical and biological pathways. The thing with chemicals is you need to take them at the right time of day in the right amount, take them at the wrong time and your sleep will not be good and/or you will be feeling tired all day. Most multivitamins can be considered harmful for the above reason but the range of chemicals will offset some of that harm. Sure exercise can help for pumping blood, raising body temperature, but could you get away with little or not exercise? Probably, if you can control the chemical intake to compliment your food/drink intake, whilst bearing in mind that food/drink already limits your lifespan.
- The_rationalist 5y agoWhich chemical are you talking about??
- Tagbert 5y agoSubscribe to my newsletter to find out more…. /s
- Terry_Roll 5y agoNicotinic acid aka vitamin b3, but your will get the prostaglandin "sunburn" flush and it is also a perfectly food statin, but it will destroy other parts of your body so use with extreme caution.
- tsol 5y agoNicotinic acid gives you a six pack? Where's the reasoning there?
- Terry_Roll 5y ago
- kvhdude 5y agoI have always had insomnia for 20+ years. It all started with becoming hyperthyroid and subsequently hypo (with radio iodide). I was able to bring it under control with cbt-i. But i find that if i have a special event (it could be a day trip, meeting etc) next day, i cannot sleep even a wink. And sure enough suffer the next day. The best i can describe the feeling when trying to sleep is either sitting in a tree branch and not trying to fall or driving and trying to stay alert. I have managed so far, but i am not able to sleep before any job interview while i am trying to change job. (all the leetcode questions are not helping)
- Dwolb 5y agoHave you tried any exercise or diet combinations? Curious to understand what didn’t work.
- kvhdude 5y agoDue to health conditions, i do cardio 60 min/day every day. dumbbell weight training 3x/week. Vegetarian by bringup, didnt try anything new nutritional, because no one suggested.
- kvhdude 5y agoa sleep specialist told me, i am ovetthinking and i cannot will sleep into existence. He recommended that i do cbt-i. He emphatically ruled out physical tiredness does not necessarily mean mental tiredeness. As i mentioned cbt-i for most part worked, but when the next day there is a significant event, i cannot sleep a wink. I was told (by my primary) to take some anti anxiety pills that did not help much. i dont like sleeping pills as i feel groggy next day almost as if i never slept, even melatonin has that effect.
- Dwolb 5y agoFWIW I did a keto cycle and found myself sleeping much better when I was getting into the fat adaption phase. Also after wearing my Garmin to gauge heart rate and sleep effectiveness I found refined carbs eaten late in the evening keep me up at night. So might be worth experimenting and seeing if anything effects your sleep positively.