11 ms·
Putin says Western sanctions are akin to declaration of war
- sto_hristo 5y ago[flagged]
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Putin says Western sanctions are akin to declaration of war If Putin views it that way, that removes the main obstacle to a NATO-enforced Not Fly Zone in Ukraine, which is that Putin would view it the same way. But, no, it's not a declaration of war. It’s more of a special economic operation for the demilitarization and deputinization of Russia.
- elforce002 5y agoWell, he might as well say that since he got nothing to lose right now. Russians are feeling it, more than half of all countries are against him. What I'm finding interesting is that there's no impartial news in this whole conflict. Either Russia (it seems any Russian leader on that position would act the same way) is somewhat justified on doing it (because of NATO's expansion to the east, etc...) or He's the next Hitler trying to expand the Russian empire and trample any democracy next to him. I only found one video explaining the conflict from both sides of the conflict on an impartial matter. The creator did his job explaining the economic, political and geographical aspects of the conflict. My two cents: The conflict is complex on both sides: - Russia thinks Europe and the US are their enemies. They don't want them as "neighbors" even though they do business together, play sports together, etc... - The right to self-determination of the Ukrainian people is a fact. They need to do what's good for them in all aspects of their lives and with this conflict escalating, they are more than willing to join NATO. Possible Outcomes: 1. Russia "wins": - 2/3 of the world won't be conducting any type of business with the country. - This will push a further polarization of the World, literally creating cold war 2 all over again just that this time we'll have 3 proxy powers: Western, Russia and China. 2. Russia "loses": - Government collapses: I don't even know what would happen with Russia if Putin is deposed. Chaos will be the least of the issues that Russia would be dealing with. - Government "caves" to Ukrainian demands: This will undoubtedly create bitterness from the Russian people to the West in general and will put nations to rethink their postures and form alliances to shield themselves from Western sanctions. 3. Russia agrees to cease fire if Ukraine doesn't enter to NATO: This would imply Russia not giving up Crimea nor the "independent" states formed after the war. 4. Putin goes nuclear: Not much to say... I can't imagine what Ukrainians are going through right now. It's easier to condemn and go to war with Russia but let's just think about it for a moment. The implications of a full scale war between NATO and Russia, when the latter is threating to use its nuclear weapons. I'm not from the US nor Europe and I'm looking a grim future all of us if this conflict keeps escalating. There has to be a diplomatic way for the sake of Ukraine, Russia and the rest of the World.
- Mikeb85 5y agoAnd people still argue for appeasement...
- 99_00 5y agoYes, some people still argue for appeasement. Are you for or against that? What are the reasons for your position? You need to expand on your comment for it to have meaning.
- causality0 5y agoProbably that taking Ukraine back from Putin will involve much more bloodshed and a higher potential for a nuclear exchange than using military force to defend it from the beginning would have.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> Are you for or against that? What are the reasons for your position? If Putin says its war then it's war, no? The west has justified not intervening to avoid war. If it's war anyway, then we should intervene. If this isn't explicit enough, we should intervene militarily in Ukraine. > You need to expand on your comment for it to have meaning. Not really, there's a lot implied by my comment...
- allisdust 5y agoWhat would happen if indeed NATO intervenes? Russia will quickly start losing a conventional war. They would turn to nukes. When it seems like Russia is losing, all nuclear nations would be on high alert. They being on high alert with fingers on triggers is bad not just for Nato and Russia but also for non participating countries like China, India, Pakistan, Israel, NK because when there is a nuclear war on the horizon, everyone wants to be on the alert. However, each country raising alert will cause suspicion on the other country. For example, China raising its alert level will trigger India to do the same followed by Pakistan. All it takes now is one nuke to fly (may be between Nato and Russia or even a false launch detection). Now all countries will trigger all their nukes purely out of suspicion in the fog of war due to panic. So that's why Russia can shoot/burn or destroy people /cities /infrastructure, NATO will not lift a single finger in terms of actual participation in war to help Ukraine (whatever the public opinion might be).
- chrononaut 5y agohttps://archive.ph/TL9jJ https://archive.ph/TL9jJ
- swagasaurus-rex 5y agoSounds like its working
- PeterisP 5y agoIf so, then let's finally send in planes.
- 99_00 5y agoWhy should we finally send in the planes?
- akmarinov 5y agoIf Putin thinks sanctions on Russia from the west is a war and declares it on the west - we’re good to go - that’s OP’s thinking.
- causality0 5y agoEven taking the nuclear threats out of the equation and pretending the war is won easily, the question of Ukraine's eastern regions remains. If a majority of citizens of Donbas want to be part of Russia, would NATO help Ukraine wage the same war against insurgency its been waging for years? It's a very messy question. I think I'd prefer Ukraine to cut their losses and recognize Luhansk and Donetsk as independent before supporting sending planes in.
- jopsen 5y agoYeah, it's tempting to sell a few cruise missiles with "free delivery" to "alliviate" Russian traffic jams. But if we get involved, we probably can't just blow up stuff and walk away -- I think that only works in movies :)
- xdennis 5y agoUkraine hasn't waged a war against insurgents. They are Russians pretending to Ukrainians. How do you think they shot down the Dutch plane? With AK-47? No. With a Russian Buk.
- inter_netuser 5y agoSo Donbass was all good and wholesome Ukranianian nationalists before war, is what you are saying?
- martythemaniak 5y agoClearly refusing to do business with a murderer is the same as murder.
- vmception 5y agoHe has to say that https://youtu.be/rStL7niR7gs https://youtu.be/rStL7niR7gs
- londons_explore 5y agoIndeed. This is like a big geopolitical game of chess. Everyone can see a few moves ahead. There aren't many surprises. "Outrage" on the news really should be replaced with "thing we expected to happen has happened".
- tasha0663 5y ago... but thank God it has not come to that" Is the rest of the quote. Cherry-picking 101. Jesus, Reuters. WTF do you want me to pay for?
- DancesWTurtles 5y agoStrictly speaking, yes. Strictly speaking, invading a territory that is just a border away from the Atlantic Treaty's borders, with no clear indications that the advance will stop at any point, is very clearly 'akin to declaration of war', too.
- another_why 5y agoAnd what will be a clear indication?
- justinclift 5y agoPacking up and going home? :)
- another_why 5y ago> Packing up and going home? :) He already spent so much of his money and so many of my nerve cells. Let the guy finish already, i dont want it all to be for nothing but hysteria and skyhigh prices on everything. We need results
- dijonman2 5y ago
- m3kw9 5y agoThat’s just talk, but what he does as the response will show if he really took it as war
- blkhp19 5y agoI’d rather let those 2 problems play out than prematurely killing off huge numbers of humans. Was this a joke?
- prox 5y agoSays the guy who on his own accord and choice went to war.
- hotz 5y agoEveryone who's been following the events since 2014 predicted this. This isn't out of the blue, it's been a long time coming and the west could've prevented it.
- danbruc 5y agoThis didn't start in 2014, this started in 1990, when it was informally agreed that there would be no eastwards NATO expansion. Then NATO expanded eastwards anyway, after all there was no formal agreement, and Russia kind of accepted it. In 2008 with the Bucharest declaration Ukraine and Georgia started the process of becoming NATO members. Russia attacked Georgia. Until 2014 under Yanukovych Ukraine no longer pursued a NATO membership, after that this again became more and more a priority and Russia annexed Crimea, intervened in eastern Ukraine and finally now this war.
- monetus 5y agoPutin apparently considered joining NATO around 2000. It is hard to argue one definitive beginning outside of a narrow sense.
- danbruc 5y agoI can give you the sense in which I consider this the beginning, even though it is mostly restating what I already said. I think the primary reason for this war is that Putin does not want NATO at his borders. That this would not happen was informally agreed in 1990 but unfortunately did not make it into any official documents. After that each eastward expansion of NATO was seen by Russia as the violation of a promise. When in 2008 Ukraine and Georgia started their way to become NATO members this was the final straw and Putin attacked Georgia and eventually Ukraine. Sure, we can now argue whether the promise (1990), the first NATO expansion afterwards (1999), the Bucharest declaration that Ukraine and Georgia will become NATO members (2008) or Ukraine changing its stance from remaining unaligned to seeking a NATO membership (2014) should be labeled the beginning of the current situation, but I think it is fair to pick 1990 as this is where the situation that Russia does not want was laid out. There are most likely also other interest such as oil and gas in Ukraine but I don't think they are the primary reasons, even though they might have tipped the calculations. And I consequently think that this could have been avoided if the Ukraine would not have pursued a NATO membership or if Russia would also have joined.
- Brian_K_White 5y agoThen sanction us right back, fucker.
- oauea 5y agoAll the steroids must've finally gone to his head
- mabbo 5y agoWe're playing chicken with a lunatic. He knows that. We know that. He knows we know that. His only play is to act (?) even crazier. 'War' means nuclear war, means the death of probably a large portion of the world population. It's the thing we thought we could stop worrying about 30 years ago. He doesn't like that he's clearly losing, so he's decided to threaten the end times if he can't get his way. And it might even work, if we truly believe he'll do it. The problem is the best way he can prove that is to crack the atom over Kyiv.
- OmarIsmail 5y agoIf he drops a nuke on Kyiv I honestly don’t know how the world will or even “should” respond. It really goes to show that nukes just shouldn’t exist- there’s no “counter” to them if the other side is suicidal
- hutrdvnj 5y agoHonestly, if throwing nukes in Europe, including nuclear fallout over NATO states, is not the red line, then there isn't any. If you allow Putin to throw nukes and answer with more economic sanctions, then the West is a complete joke.
- jl6 5y agoOn the red line: https://youtu.be/o861Ka9TtT4 https://youtu.be/o861Ka9TtT4
- belter 5y agoNo worries, there is the hotline: https://youtu.be/1OitCT1KT4k https://youtu.be/1OitCT1KT4k
- HstryrsrBttn 5y ago
- chakhs 5y ago
- diego_moita 5y agoNice. If he screams then it is a sign it hurts.
- beloch 5y agoPutin has lied constantly during this conflict. He said his troops were not on Ukraine's border when they were. When called out on that, he said they weren't going to invade right up until they did invade. The latest is that Russia agreed to honour a limited ceasefire around civilian evacuation corridors but then broke that ceasefire. Evidently, all we can do is respond to what Putin does. One must assume that, if the West declared war on Russia, Russia would take specific military actions. Since Russia has not responded to sanctions with those military actions, Putin evidently does not view sanctions as a declaration of war, no matter what noises come out of his mouth. This is the downside of constant prevarication for state leaders. If Putin ever truthfully tells the West where there is line past which he will respond with force, nobody will know he's telling the truth. e.g. Putin has repeatedly implied that instituting a "no fly" zone would result in nuclear war, but it's clear we can't trust that. It may be a lie. If NATO planes move in Russian planes may simply move out with no further response from Russia.
- 331c8c71 5y agoHow do we know that it were the Russians who didn't respect the ceasefire? EDIT: this point is being repeated over and over but I have not seen anything that would corroborate the ukranian side of the story (neither the russian to be fair).
- another_why 5y agoIf you've seen it in the news or read in twitter - it's truth.
- 331c8c71 5y agoThe Western media plainly won't report what the Russian side says. https://tass.com/society/1417395 https://tass.com/society/1417395
- another_why 5y agoI cant even open it. Clearly something important which my government doesnt want me to know
- jabl 5y agoDear Vladimir, they are not sanctions, they are a "special financial operation".
- guilhas 5y agoAnd the US must agree as they have the same policy in case Iran blocks the Strait of Hormuz trading route for example https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strait_of_Hormuz https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strait_of_Hormuz Some of the sanctions are definitely too much, as they will worsen the life of regular Russians and Europeans too much, without many strategic benefit, since both sides believe they are right, making them antagonize each other, leading only to further escalation
- another_why 5y ago>Some of the sanctions are definitely too much, as they will worsen the life of regular Russians and Europeans too much, And no one knew that before introducing them. Considering that they say that they already knew about the invasion a year ago.
- qsort 5y ago> Some of the sanctions are definitely too much, as they will worsen the life of regular Russians and Europeans too much As a regular European: good. We are at war, I'm more than willing to pay personal costs to inflict pain and casualties to Russia, even more so if those costs are "only" financial. I absolutely want my government to hurt us if that means hurting Russians even more.
- another_why 5y ago> We are at war, I'm more than willing to pay personal costs to inflict pain and casualties to Russia, even more so if those costs are "only" financial. I absolutely want my government to hurt us if that means hurting Russians even more. Tell that to people who live on minimum salary, maybe they will explain you something about "financial price"
- qsort 5y agoWhile I have some sympathy for those who are less lucky than me, in the long run playing the appeasement game will hurt them even more. Furthermore, government can take ad-hoc redistributive actions, such as increased or reworked taxation. Our government is already spending 46% of the GDP in random crap for far less noble reasons. OTOH I hate from the bottom of my heart the entire wave of pseudo-intellectuals and anti-western useful idiots who push the "two-sides" narrative. (Just to be clear because this is the internet -- I'm not implying anything about you specifically)
- hedora 5y agoWell, we may as well set up a no fly zone and admit Ukraine into NATO then.
- warlog 5y agoHahahaha.. and then article 5 ourselves into a full blown world war?
- hedora 5y agoPutin claims we're already in one. Their military is crumbling. Create some safe air corridors in Ukraine to supply the cities, just like we did with Berlin in the cold war. Also, he's shown too many cards. His military is incompetent and/or looting itself. Probably better to announce we're going to do this unless he "clairifes" his position. Edit: Also, his strategy only works if the US behaves rationally, and also assumes that he will not behave rationally because he's senile and dying of cancer. Call (his subbordinates') bluff by making it clear Biden's battier than Regan.
- jeremyjh 5y agoWhy not just launch the nukes ? A "no fly zone" in this context is open warfare, and that can only lead somewhere we don't want to go.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dkersten 5y agoDeclaring war on Ukraine is also a declaration of war. Putin started this and no matter what happens, world war 3, nuclear, whatever: Putin started it. Putin escalated it. He was already threatening nuclear if he doesn't get what he wants. If he's serious about that, nothing the west does besides rolling over and just giving him the world will stop him from doing that and giving in to him will, in my opinion, only embolden him by showing him that his threats get him results. If he wants to end the sanctions, then he can withdraw from Ukraine and we'll go from there. Remember also that Putin lied multiple times: its just a military exercise, not invading, you're crazy (then he invaded); civilians won't be targeted or harmed (and then he started targeting and killing civilians). Nothing he promises or says can be trusted. Having said that, its all rather difficult. If he's backed into a corner and sees no other way out, what's stopping him from going "Fuck it, I'm screwed either way, launch the nukes"...
- forum_ghost 5y ago
- dkersten 5y ago> The same article the US entered Iraq under. So? Many people equally believe that the Iraq war was unjustified. Just because someone else does something bad, doesn't give you the right or an excuse to also do something bad. > Nobody is going to launch nukes, that’s just silly. Right up until Putin invaded Ukraine, everybody was saying he won't invade Ukraine, that's just silly. But he did anyway. You don't know what Putin will or won't do, especially now that Ukraine turned out to not be so easy to take and the world has largely banded together against him. If he's backed into a corner and feels that he's doomed either way, then who knows what he is willing to do. > He will likely just void IP rights and patents in retaliation to sanctions. He can go for it.
- forum_ghost 5y ago
- 5y ago
- BMc2020 5y agoWhy not look at nuclear war as an opportunity to tackle global warming and overpopulation at the same time?
- Nexxxeh 5y agoThe planet will survive, but it's occupants? Less so.
- polishdude20 5y agoAnd after all, what does it mean for a planet to "survive" when most life on it dies? Now it's just a big lifeless poisoned piece of rock.
- hedora 5y agoIt worked out OK for the monkeys last time it happened, and well for the aerobes before that.
- kr433223 5y agoI highly recommend this lecture by a Finnish military intelligence expert for anybody looking to understand Russia's actions better. It was very enlightening at least to me, goes in depth to how Russia's history has shaped its culture and thinking in bad ways. English subtitles available. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kF9KretXqJw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kF9KretXqJw Based on the lecture it's evident that the Russian government only respects force. Soft measures will only encourage them.
- anonporridge 5y agoI think there is a philosophical question of whether the act of severing relations without active, pointed violence, could be considered an act of war. After all, trade and increasing cooperation and communication is commonly believed to be the antidote to war. When we trade with each other for things we need, then it makes taking what we need with violence a less economically attractive option. So, by instigating sanctions and cutting off trade relations, how could that be construed as anything other than "we're taking all options for settling disputes off the table, except violence"? I'm not taking Russia's side here, and the situation is obviously more complicated since they were the ones to initiate violence in Ukraine, but it does seem like the West has effectively made a strong alliance with Ukraine and declared war on Russia, even if they have yet to exchange bullets (or nukes) directly.
- mirekrusin 5y agoHistory is always written by the winners.
- anonporridge 5y agoMight makes right. Might does not exclusively mean kinetic might.
- mcphage 5y ago> how could that be construed as anything other than "we're taking all options for settling disputes off the table, except violence? Because is it explicitly an option for settling disputes that is not violence? If you don’t want countries to go to war, you need solutions to settle disputes that aren’t violence. Trade sanctions are one such solution.
- nahuel0x 5y agoKarl Kautsky had the same idea about trade and communication making war impossible. Named that peaceful capitalism last phase as "Ultra-imperialism" [1], but then... WWI happened. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-imperialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ultra-imperialism
- TT-392 5y agoI'd love to see putin be hit in the head with a frying pan, in like, a very cartoonish way
- erdos4d 5y agoMy gut says Putin dies if he loses this war. Everything about how it is being conducted makes me believe he has no plan B at all. I expect that he will actually use his nuclear forces if he can't win, it is the one area that Russia has parity and maybe an actual advantage over NATO.
- alkonaut 5y agoI think we need to stop worrying about what he says and just focus on what he does. He said he wouldn’t invade Ukraine. If he thinks this is war and it’s a war he’s willing to fight then he should fire the first bullet or shut up. There will be crippling sanctions for long enough to change Russia as we know it. And there will be endless supplies of arms to anyone in conflict with an ever poorer Russia. If Putin wants any other future then he better start negotiating.
- nuallian 5y agoNo, not war. It’s just a…special operation. Not war, definitely.
- lr1970 5y ago<sarcasm> Russians can get up to 15 years in prison for calling war in Ukraine for what it is - a war. Instead they are supposed to call it "special military operation". By the same token economic sanctions on Russia should not be called economic war. Instead, they are "special economic operation". Let's make putin eat his own words. </sarcasm>