8 ms·
This sort of thing is just a terrible idea. The main people who will suffer are just regular Russian citizens, many of whom have been protesting the war. I kn
by kelnos 5y ago
This sort of thing is just a terrible idea. The main people who will suffer are just regular Russian citizens, many of whom have been protesting the war.
I know it's hard to target only the government and leadership with many of these punitive measures, but this broad-based measures that have a lot of collateral damage are pretty awful.
- givemeethekeys 5y agoI think the overall idea here is to piss off ordinary Russians enough to incentivize grassroots change.
- paganel 5y agoThis also risks convincing the Russian population still on the fence about the whole thing that Putin is indeed right and the West does indeed have something against Russia and against ordinary Russians, this being an excellent example.
- arcticbull 5y agoI'm completely in support of those types of measures - especially sanctions - but cutting off the internet means the only information many Russians will have is domestic propaganda. The Russians have already cut off most non-state-TV stations and are instituting 15 year prison terms for derogatory remarks about the army. The young folks in Russia are using TikTok et al to find out what's really going on. These are the ones who will most be hurt. Those seeking the truth. We need those folks to have information so they can push back. This is why the BBC has a Tor service. [1] [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-50150981 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-50150981
- earleybird 5y agoThe BBC also have shortwave - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30553243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30553243
- bogomipz 5y ago>" ... but cutting off the internet means the only information many Russians will have is domestic propaganda." I think the Roskomnadzor watchdog has pretty much preemptively done that already though no? And it's not just social media but things like the BBC and Deutsche Welle etc. See: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/04/russia-completely-blocks-access-to-facebook-and-twitter https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/mar/04/russia-complet... and https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-rferl-bbc-facebook-google-twitter-blocked/31735597.html https://www.rferl.org/a/russia-rferl-bbc-facebook-google-twi...
- miohtama 5y ago(Posted this earlier on another story.) If someone is going to disconnect Russia from Internet it is going to be Russian themselves, to limit the free flow of information that might be conflicting with the official truth. But like with the Chinese firewall, information find its way. Unless Russia wants to set itself back to 70s, they still need to access Github, Cloudflare, Amazon Cloudfront, etc. For the Russian IT business to work. It is going to be very inefficient to run anything with a pen and a paper. Software development and Internet were built on scientific principles, criticism, criticial thinking. This requires free flow of information. You cannot have one without the other, or you are going to end up with very inferior and inefficient software ecosystem.
- justsomehnguy 5y ago> they still need to access Github, Cloudflare, Amazon Cloudfront, etc LOL. Do you really think the brass even know what it is? Putin doesn't even know how the modern mobile phones look, he didn't needed one for more than 20 years. To give you a slight idea how long it is - the famous Nokia 3310 was announced 9 months later than his (acting) presidency.
- gspetr 5y agoThey do: https://scooptrade.com/mintsifry-called-for-stimulating-the-transition-to-domestic-software/ https://scooptrade.com/mintsifry-called-for-stimulating-the-...
- exclusiv 5y ago> We need those folks to have information so they can push back. They can't. And they won't. Nice in theory but it's 2022 and here we are. Nobody is pushing back at all, in any meaningful way over there.
- tiahura 5y agoWhy can’t they? They threw out the commies in ‘91.
- asats 5y agoThat would be organized how exactly? The internet is literally the only lifeline left right now to both get the true information about the recent events and to organize anti-government protests / help people that were already detained (8261 people as of today)
- exclusiv 5y agoThe idea of protests is grossly underestimating Putin and the regime.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoI also can't think of any examples where it worked - are there? I mean sanctions pushing a population into revolt?
- exclusiv 5y agoSanctions? Yes. Cold War
- johndevor 5y agoThe beatings will continue until morale improves.
- nevermindiguess 5y agoI think you summarized that best.
- smt88 5y agoThe purpose of the sanctions is for morale not to improve. Some Russian citizens were saying they don't support the war and have nothing to do with it. These sanctions make it personal for them in a non-violent, non-lethal way. We are trading Russians' convenience for Ukrainians' lives and, judging by Putin's tone today, it is working.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lostmsu 5y agoWhat did Putin say today?
- smt88 5y agoSome details here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/03/04/putin-russia-ukraine-normalization-sanctions/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2022/03/04/putin-russia... You will have to decide how to interpret it and whether he really believes it. It's not exactly a "let's de-escalate together" statement, but it certainly suggests sanctions are working.
- lisnake 5y agoI'm in Russia, an let me tell you, this does not have that effect at all. Most folks are just getting angry at collective west for all these bans, undeserved in their opinion. Big news: people are shortsighted and irrational, especially during crisis. I'm afraid this will just help Putin in uniting Russians in hatred.
- throw123123123 5y agoI think its pretty rational to blame your censor, not your censor's enemy.
- javajosh 5y agoIt's important to recognize that most people in the world are hicks. They are low information, and not rational in the way you mean it. (America is unusual because our hicks are rich, but we're mostly hicks, too.)
- waffleiron 5y agoI think the anger is also understandable, there have been so many illegal wars, interventions and invasions that didn’t cause all these bans. If I were in Russia I’d probably be easily swept up by that anger. It’d be hard to see how it’s fair when this is happening to you, even if it feels deserved from an outside perspective.
- pastor_bob 5y agoYour sentiment is normally valid, but most Russians supposedly literally don't believe they're at war because of the content Putin feeds them. They think it's a small operation in the Donbas. It has nothing to do with being 'illegal' or whatever.
- waffleiron 5y agoDo you have a (recent) source for that? I can’t imagine that to be true with the impact this war has had on daily life for Russian. The Russian government acknowledged that hundreds of soldiers died, publicly. That’s not a tiny mission.
- justsomehnguy 5y agoAh, probably from the same people who think what the best way to prevent teenage pregnancies and STDs is to practice abstinence. As we know that works well too.
- croes 5y agoHas this ever worked?
- bogomipz 5y agoYes. See "13 times that economic sanctions really worked" from this Washington Post article from 8 years ago when the questions of sanctions efficacy surfaced as a result of Putin's then invasion of Crimea: https://archive.ph/KPwJH https://archive.ph/KPwJH
- tillinghast 5y agoSo… begging the question. How did those sanctions go then?
- bogomipz 5y agoThe article clearly states what the outcomes were in each of the cases. It's literally a summary.
- kelnos 5y agoIt's interesting to note that the last successful thing they can come up with was 27 years ago. Sanctions (or threats of sanctions) have been wielded many times since then, and I guess they haven't been working all that well in more recent history? Also consider that sanctions as a result of the Crimea annexation haven't done anything. We're still here, today, 8 years later, and Putin is waging war again. The funny thing is that when I was looking for something about this, I found an article[0] that is generally positive about the effects of sanctions on Russia post-Crimea. Which I find kinda hilarious, because I think it really proves the point here that these sanctions don't actually work. The Russian economy slowed quite a bit, but it seems clear Putin and the oligarchs don't care all that much; the harm from those sanctions were disproportionately borne by regular Russian citizens, who were powerless to change the country's foreign policy. And, regardless, Russia is still in control of Crimea, and has not deterred Putin from this current war, so... that's a pretty big hint the sanctions did not do what they were supposed to. [0] https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2015/07/13/sanctions-after-crimea-have-they-worked/index.html https://www.nato.int/docu/review/articles/2015/07/13/sanctio...
- malandrew 5y agoIt's pretty hard to grass roots organize when you don't have internet though.
- javajosh 5y agoIt's almost as if people need an option for mesh networking and communication software that works without requiring access to remote servers, especially beyond nation state boundaries.
- throw123123123 5y agoIs this an acceptable strategy? There's an ethical argument against it: "hey lets punish innocent civilians so they attack the real enemy" and a practical argument: "hey russia started the conflict, but didnt cut-off your internet, that was a US company that sees you as their enemy"
- gameswithgo 5y agoMan, you people who when babies are being exploded and apartment buildings attacked with missiles, an entire nation being invaded, who ask these questions about inconveniencing citizens of the attacking nation, are you even real? The next time the USA invades someone I welcome for you to destroy my financial life and drive my family and I into subsistence farming if it helps to stop us. You have my permissions. stop doing war.
- xkqd 5y agoUltimately if we need to pick sides, I’m going to apply pressure to the Russian citizens who will need to apply pressure to their own dictator. That’s kinda how war works. I think a lot of the folks criticizing you are in a position of privilege, or have an interesting perspective on what open warfare really means. Apply pressure to the country until you get the results you want. I can appreciate the focus on Putin and his cronies, but no one gets out untouched.
- atlantas 5y agoEasy to say from the comfort of your keyboard and within a democracy that responds to polling data and protest. In Russia you'll get thrown in jail for 15 years. Also realize that statistically speaking you likely didn't dissent when we invaded Iraq. We were propagandized and consent was manufactured via the NYT and others. If your family was driven into poverty as a result, I don't believe you would have welcomed it whatsoever.
- manigandham 5y ago> "stop doing war" That's not how war works. Have you considered that these actions might provoke and prolong greater conflict?
- rdtsc 5y agoTrying to think when this worked well. Iran and North Korea had sanctions imposed on them for quite a bit of time, and they seem to have a pretty stable leadership structure for years. Perhaps some of the colored revolutions or Arab Spring movements but not sure how much sanctions played into those... As long as Putin can re-interpret this as an external aggression from the $insert_pejorative West, and broadcast that better than Twitter, CNN, etc, I can see those sanctions having an opposite effect and further solidify his power. On the other hand, I can see attacking those who are closer to him being a lot more effective. His billionaire friends not being able to travel to south of France for vacation is a much more serious threat than a regular person who cannot use Apple Pay or watch Netflix any longer.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThe example everybody brings up is South Africa. The claim is that sanctions were instrumental against apartheid. It's hard to evaluate that claim.
- rdtsc 5y agoThat's a good example. Thanks for brining it up. I hadn't thought of it.
- from 5y agoStudies have consistently shown that sanctions only result in a change in behavior of governments 30-35% of the time. Sanctions designed to cause regime change have an effectiveness even lower than that. Also worth noting that this effectiveness rate has been declining since the 90s. See: http://www.pages.drexel.edu/~cas86/GSDB_FKSYY.pdf http://www.pages.drexel.edu/~cas86/GSDB_FKSYY.pdf
- analogdreams 5y agoThat requires a lot of confidence that the replacement will be better. I think this is a 'be careful what you wish for' scenario.
- odessacubbage 5y agocan anyone point to an instance where these kinds of sanctions actually lead to grassroots change?
- kerneloftruth 5y agoGrassroots change in an autocracy (dictatorship), where protest is banned and criticizing the leader can get you killed is a lot to ask for, much less expect, as a result. Such actions may just rally ordinary Russians against the sanctioners
- kelnos 5y agoAnd in fact that's pretty much what's been happening in Iran over the past few decades. I think we can expect Russia to be a bit different, but I'm not sure that difference will be enough to get your average Russian to direct their anger at Putin rather than the West.
- kelnos 5y agoCertainly this is not the same situation, and these are not the same places with the same government structure, but let's take a look at how well that worked in Iran: that is, it hasn't worked at all. Government propaganda has caused most Iranian citizens to blame the US & the West for sanctions, and support for their government seems strong. Of course Russia is a different situation, and there are already plenty of Russian citizens there protesting the war, but I find it a little hard to believe that peaceful protest works all that well in what is effectively a dictatorship. (Hell, consider how ineffective -- or at best, excruciatingly slow-acting -- anti-war protests have been in even the US since WWII.) I expect the only thing that could get Putin to stop would be his oligarch cronies getting financially destroyed to the point that they can't take it anymore. But it seems like they've been preparing for this for a while, and might not be hurt by sanctions as much as we'd expect. Regardless, if we assume that the oligarchs and government officials are the right people to target, broad-based measures that hurt regular Russians are just cruel and probably not that effective.
- themacguffinman 5y agoIt doesn't really matter who the citizens blame, people really over-emphasize the revolutionary potential of sanctions but the far more important & practical purpose of sanctions is to limit state's economic and technological capability to continue its destructive behavior. Look at Iran now: a pariah state whose power has been effectively contained, limited in its ability to fund a substantial warchest or buy modern weapons & technology. It's currently working with the US on a new nuclear deal to ameliorate its heavy sanctions. Russia can look forward to a similar future. Military invasions cost a lot of resources, the current invasion is largely funded by European gas sales and a variety of foreign trade. Aside from weapons & tech, military morale is an important factor in combat effectiveness, but it's also affected by resource availability. A less resourced military is a less capable one. We're beyond just deterrence now. Russian citizens can blame everyone except Putin, it doesn't matter. What does matter is that when Putin's military lackeys draw up plans, when they threaten others, they do so with a fraction of the tech and resources they are used to. Let's see them bully a 21st century world with a 20th century economy.
- coolso 5y agoYeah, generally speaking, when a foreign country screws you over, either directly or indirectly through a company based in said foreign country... you tend to hate the foreign country and its people, not your own country. Unless you already hate your own country (most people don't, outside of the American left).
- kmeisthax 5y agoThey've been pissed off since Putin started this thing. The people aren't complicit here, they're just being overruled. Same for Belarus, too.
- justnotworthit 5y agoAKA, "Collective Punishment".
- GameOfFrowns 5y agoI rather see history repeating itself with the rise of Hitler as consequence of the excessively punitive treaty of Versailles after World War 1. At the risk of invoking Godwin's law, I wouldn't be surprised seeing Putin going fully fascist to hold together a Russia that's disintegrating.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> many of whom have been protesting the war. So more of them can protest. Not sure if you've seen the latest news and videos, Russians aren't even trying to fight soldiers anymore, they're just straight-up bombing apartment complexes... I have absolutely no sympathy for any Russian until there's no more bombs killing Ukrainian civilians. Maybe more incentive to depose Putin.
- nevermindiguess 5y ago
- Mikeb85 5y agoI literally live in 2 countries and my family is spread across 5 or so. I've been to a dozen or so countries. Speak 2.5 languages (2 fluent, 1 poorly). My kid will have 2 nationalities when they're born and hopefully speak 3+ languages. No, I feel that way because people need to stop enabling evil through inaction. If babushkas can happily protest this war and go to jail then so can every Russian. And what's the risk? The quicker Putin is deposed the less jail time... But yes, I'm sure chilling on a beach in Thailand or visiting Africa will make me be OK with power hungry dictators killing civilians while citizens enable it... I've got many friends who are refugees, from Congo, Kosovo, Syria as well as friends from Ukraine, Russia, Ethiopia, Egypt and many other hot spots. People enable it by not standing up and for once a country actually is (Ukraine).
- outworlder 5y ago> This sort of thing is just a terrible idea. It's not an idea. US-based companies have to comply with sanctions.
- absurddoctor 5y agoSure, but for most of the service cutoffs so far, including this one, there were no relevant US sanctions in place.
- Moru 5y agoIt's more a publicity stunt, they have to look like they are doing their thing to help the cause. In this case it's counter productive but that doesn't really matter, they look good.
- hackinthebochs 5y agoWhen cancel-culture comes to geopolitics. It will be interesting to look back at how all these bad moralistic takes on geopolitics influenced the media narrative and pressured leaders and companies into hard-line stances against Russia, thus helping to cause whatever escalation is coming down the line. No longer can nations quietly engage in realpolitik to avert disaster. The populace is too engaged and information is too widespread, and the demand for retribution is universal. It would be naive to think the decision makers are immune to the moral narratives coming out of the media.
- kelnos 5y agoAs a sibling points out, Cogent is not required to do this. Regardless, I was more talking about the overall situation: hurting your enemy's citizens when those citizens have essentially zero power to affect the situation is just cruel and pointless. And can turn those citizens -- many of whom may be anti-war themselves -- against you.
- ajsnigrutin 5y agoThis is good for russian propaganda, since only internal media (news, communications,...) will be accessible. Bad for everyone wanting to see the other view. On the other hand, by banning RT, europe is not much better at this... But we're also in the middle of propaganda war, and the west has to be "doing something", if the result is good or bad, it doesn't really matter.
- bob66 5y ago
- tmp_anon_22 5y agoPeople are coming at this from the perspective that it will hurt recreational internet usage and access to non-state news sources - which is absolutely true. Another angle which I think people are missing out on is the impact to business. For all the economic sanctions around payments, lack of internet access will prevent many Russian companies from functioning AT ALL even internally to Russia. I still don't support this move, but its interesting to think about just how many company processes would be bricked as a result of this action - picture tens of thousands of employees sitting in an empty chair or being sent home without any work to do.
- rapind 5y ago> The main people who will suffer are just regular Russian citizens, many of whom have been protesting the war. This is exactly what sanctions do.
- mardifoufs 5y agoTo me it feels like since the covid pandemic, there is this widespread desire to "Do something" amongst corporations and pretty much every group in general. It's not just enough for them to comply by the legal sanctions put in place by the state, they have to feel involved and socially engaged in every single widely mediatized issue. You could also see that with how a lot of corporations went overboard with covid restrictions and measures "just in case and because we are all in this together". It's a bit maddening because the reactions are mostly trash and completely unhelpful since the people who take these decisions are usually clueless when it comes to foreign relations. It can even be counter productive, because I'm sure that if this would've hurt russia in any meaningful way the state department would've probably pushed for these sanctions in the first place. Maybe this is not a recent trend at all but from my perspective it has been much more apparent in the past 2 years. Just compare this to back when corporations/non profits were pretty keen to open businesses in say, the Soviet Union or China with every loophole they can find instead of doing the exact opposite like we see now. Or internet corps trying to open new markets and connect as many people as they could instead of...this?
- native_samples 5y agoDecline of religion (maybe). People aren't sure what makes someone a good person, so they latch on to whatever fashionable cause is being promoted as GoodThink by the media this week and then try to make everything about that. An amusing example I just read about is Tony's Chocoloney, an "edible virtue signal": https://thenewconservative.co.uk/tonys-chocbaloney/ https://thenewconservative.co.uk/tonys-chocbaloney/ What's interesting is how often this blows up in the faces of the people doing it. Tony's Chocolate seems to have mostly just infuriated customers with its actions. If anyone is actually buying this chocolate bar because it makes them feel virtuous it's hard to notice. At some point smart CEOs are going to crack down on this stuff. It was the founder of Hacker News who said "keep your identity small". Probably that'll come back into fashion as awareness grows of how destructive letting insecure marketing interns emotionally bully executives is.
- pvaldes 5y agoAll here is pretty awful. The sad reality is that if the Russian army (composed by Russians) is successful, all Russian citizens including those who suffer would gladly "inherit" the raw resources, land and properties (those left intact) from Ukrainians without passing a tear. Putin's "Make Russia great again" plan would be cheered unanimously in Russia If the Russian army fails, Russians have an unique in life opportunity of having Putin out of power. Ukraine instead keeps a country partially destroyed, or totally destroyed, or with big chunks unlivable for decades, and take huge loses in all their infrastructures and lives. Some Russian people seem to want the gain without the pain.
- DougN7 5y agoIt’s also bad because the world needs to get the truth into them. Russia is blocking a lot of sites but discussion about the war is all over. Cutting them off leaves them with just one information source - the Russian government.