5 ms·
I wonder would these actions be then applied equally. Let's say USA invades Iran. Should we then terminate all of the domains and tlds hold by any USA based en
by Ekaros 5y ago
I wonder would these actions be then applied equally. Let's say USA invades Iran.
Should we then terminate all of the domains and tlds hold by any USA based entity. Reclaim all of the IP space hold by them too? Surely it would solve some starvation issue, and be just, but do we want that?
- dainiusse 5y agoLets say aliena invade mars. This is bs...
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoYou don't have to wonder. The usa did invade irak against the vote of the UN and while lying about WMD. Nothing happened.
- horsawlarway 5y agoI would disagree that nothing happened. If anything, I'd say that Bin Laden actually mostly met his goals here - He mired the US in an unpopular and horrendously expensive set of wars, that made a LOT of everyday Americans much more mindful of the military industrial machine that is the US state (and I say that as an American). Not to mention we're seeing a more clear decline in US influence abroad because of it. Did we face a similar set of retaliatory sanctions? No, but that's because the cost/reward structure is hugely different. It's hard to sanction the largest economy in the world, which owns and prints the currency most of the world uses as its reserve, and which is also the military backer that has mostly kept Europe from becoming another series of land wars after WW2. Thats... just so significantly different from the challenges present with sanctioning Russia. Even this discussion about the internet - The ICANN is an american company. Hell - well more than half the sites people want to take action here are American companies. If you tried to saction the US by cutting off their internet... are you sanctioning the US or yourself?
- Karsteski 5y agoGoes back to my comment yesterday on the topic of ICANN not removing Russia from the internet: "It's interesting how the world rallied immediately to the aid of Ukraine in a big way, compared to the middle eastern countries that have been destroyed by the likes of the US and allies, or the South American countries that have been completely destabilized by the US government. Really makes you think..."
- thereddaikon 5y agoThe morals of US actions in the middle east are debatable but there is one massive objective difference between them and Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The US went through all the procedure and protocol to make it legal under international law. They got ascent from other nations and put together a broad international coalition. People always seem to forget that when they bring up Afghanistan and Iraq. That doesn't make it right but if you are going to condemn the US for it then you also have to condemn the UK, Canada, France, Germany, Belgium, Japan, Korea and a slew of other nations as well. And if you do also condemn them then cool, good for not being a hypocrite. But it was still legal under international law so sanctions of any kind don't really make sense.
- imwillofficial 5y agoThis is an absolute falsehood. The killing started far before any resolutions were passed, before any international consensus was reached.
- whatshisface 5y agoAssent obtained through diplomatic pressure from a much larger country does not count, the US getting its allies to OK its various invasions counts about as much as Belarus' support of the Ukraine invasion. (It's a complex comparison because Belarus is both subject to much more pressure and is getting involved in a very direct way, but I contend that the pressure/action ratio is similar between the two cases.) There is a reason the UN and the idea of international law is talked about more in the context of Africa than anywhere else[0], it is the only place where none of the countries involved are powerful enough to make a farce of it. [0] Look at some wikipedia articles describing various armed conflicts and see which ones mention the UN acting in a significant capacity.
- grumple 5y ago> Assent obtained through diplomatic pressure from a much larger country does not count This is a pretty absurd statement and use of the no true Scotsman fallacy. If that's the case, you'd just say "No diplomacy from the US ever 'counts' because they are bigger/more powerful / whatever".
- mc32 5y agoMost of these things are consensus driven (driven by international agreements) based on political alignment. It's not strictly driven by rationality or objectivity.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> invades Iran The difference between Ukraine and all the other countries invaded in the last 50 or so years is that Ukraine is a real democracy and liberal, modern society. Iran, Syria, Iraq, etc... are not the same as Ukraine.
- qersist3nce 5y ago3/10 bait
- from 5y agoThe difference is that it's in Europe. Ukraine is about as democratic as El Salvador. See https://freedomhouse.org/countries/freedom-world/scores?sort=desc&order=Political%20Rights https://freedomhouse.org/countries/freedom-world/scores?sort...
- Mikeb85 5y agoMore democratic than Mexico...
- femiagbabiaka 5y agoTruly amazing. This statement shows that you know very little about the history of Ukraine or Iran, Syria, Iraq.
- Mikeb85 5y agoIt's truly amazing how much whataboutism and Russian propaganda there is in the US.
- beardedetim 5y agoI thought Iran had some democratic elected leaders until US backed insurgents ousted them? Is that not true?
- Mikeb85 5y agoThat was 60 years ago... Also still not an invasion but yes, was shitty of the US. I'm not pro-US by any stretch, but I'm in support of anything they do to help Ukraine, where civilians are being directly targeted... We can talk about failed US policy when Russia isn't bombing apartment blocks and nuclear power plants... Or even their lack of an attempt to stop this war when they apparently knew it was coming...
- majormajor 5y agoI think a split internet is inevitable[0]. The "immune to borders" idea was one of those post-cold-war "end of history" ideas that will have a hard time holding up over more and more decades and more and more conflicts. A lot of power over the internet is controlled by Western nations that have demonstrated self-interest time and time again, so at some point there will be more and more breakaway groups to escape that one potential method of control. [0] it's actually already happened, of course, just not in a way most Westerners are impacted by.
- throw_m239339 5y ago> Should we then terminate all of the domains and tlds hold by any USA based entity. Reclaim all of the IP space hold by them too? Surely it would solve some starvation issue, and be just, but do we want that? who are we? The US government defacto invented the internet. Russia can have their "own internet" if they wanted to, and so does China and these countries probably will. Whatever US foreign policy is, USA can force corporations making businesses in US to basically do anything US wants. This isn't about equality or justice or whatever here. This is about economic power, who has it and who doesn't. Regardless what war is being waged. Right now Russia is finding out they have very little economic power. Organizations such as the EFF wouldn't be allowed to exist in Russia, at least in a form that independent from the whoever seats in the Kremlin.
- ianai 5y agoJust so we're clear: Until proven otherwise, Putin will be the last person to sit in his particular "chair" in Kremlin/Moscow. Their government is a dictatorship without a clearly defined process of succession. Putin == Russian government == Putin. Edit - Further, his "successor" might have his exact title, but still not quite have the same powers and sway as Putin. My point is their government is something distinctly different in its own right.
- tsol 5y ago>This isn't about equality or justice or whatever here. This is about economic power, who has it and who doesn't. The reason we oppose the Ukraine war is because of economic power? That's not the reasoning being used to justify and lionize this particular conflict >USA can force corporations making businesses in US to basically do anything US wants. Perhaps, but if the USA government makes businesses do something people find unjustifiable or even objectionable they'll soon find there aren't many more businesses. Not to mention they'll probably find themselves with a lot of protests and legal battles to deal with.
- trappist 5y agoBy what standard would it be just? The vast majority of the people who would be harmed by this will have been innocent.