12 ms·
My journey for dual displays with my M1 Pro Mac (2021)
- krnlpnc 5y agoWhile on the topic of Mac displays, is anyone aware of a method to enable or mimic the OS brightness keys/controls with a non-apple display? That's been my main gripe so far with an external display, that and also MacOS not allowing rotation of an inbuilt display.
- lloeki 5y agolunar, monitorcontrol https://lunar.fyi/ https://lunar.fyi/ https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl https://github.com/MonitorControl/MonitorControl
- jtthe13 5y agoAnd displaybuddy https://setapp.com/apps/displaybuddy https://setapp.com/apps/displaybuddy
- cosmotic 5y agoThere are a number of github projects for both MacOS and Windows that send DCC brightness signals to monitors https://github.com/topics/brightness-control https://github.com/topics/brightness-control
- robin_reala 5y ago(Unrelated to the subject, but this website is a perfect example of why reader mode is a required feature for web browsers.)
- superkuh 5y ago>However, I ran into a number of (firmware?) compatibility issues with Thunderbolt docks and dongles that made the journey harder than anticipated. The advertising and hype kind of masks this issue. The reality of the new Mac architecture is that it is a "gaming console" compared to a normal PC. It's hyper optimized for a specific type of use and cuts corners in implementing hardware protocols and IO because there's no need for the average apple customer. As long as you only use the M1 console how it was intended it's amazing and fast. But attempt to do anything outside the normal with it and the console's glaring hardware short-cuts come to light.
- jdlshore 5y agoIf you’re going to make claims like this, you should back them up. What hardware shortcuts were taken, specifically, and how do they relate to the topic at hand?
- dachryn 5y agothats just blatantly false claims. At least document those supposed hardware short-cuts then. The main problem is that specs nowadays have become meaningless. Thunderbolt has so many variations, same with displayport and hdmi and usb. Anything in the chain can choose to embed whatever spec in whatever way they want. Its almost impossible to predict upfront if someting will work out of the box or not, especially with things like docks and dongles.
- jsjohnst 5y ago> Thunderbolt has so many variations Actually, Thunderbolt doesn’t, where as the others are definitely true.
- superkuh 5y agoInability to boot exclusively off an external hard drive for one. https://eclecticlight.co/2021/02/10/external-boot-disks-still-dont-work-properly-with-m1-macs/ https://eclecticlight.co/2021/02/10/external-boot-disks-stil... , https://tidbits.com/2021/05/27/an-m1-mac-cant-boot-from-an-external-drive-if-its-internal-drive-is-dead/ https://tidbits.com/2021/05/27/an-m1-mac-cant-boot-from-an-e... This is a very common thing that all PCs can do and you'd expect a top end ($$$$) laptop to be able to do. But because of proprietary choices in the boot process M1 consoles can't.
- rcarmo 5y agoI'm plugging my M1 Pro directly into a 38" LG monitor with PD (which then has USB out, gigabit Ethernet, audio, etc), which saved me a lot of trouble. (also, what's with the weird, slow CSS transforms?)
- pelagicdev 5y agoThe monitor has an ethernet port or you're using a USB-C adapter for that?
- blakesterz 5y agoHas anyone else switched from using 2 monitors to just using one big extra wide one? I've found it to be just as good as two, if not better. Maybe a little more expensive than buying two, but it's been worth it.
- wil421 5y agoI switched to an ultrawide and will never look back. My last setup was 2 monitors. Having 2 1440p monitors basically stuck together to make an ultrawide is a dream come true. It’s 100% worth the switch. My M1 Air runs my ultrawide at 60hz and is buttery smooth.
- mattgreenrocks 5y agoI've long preferred one large monitor. Which ultrawide do you have?
- nsxwolf 5y agoI have an Acer XR382CQK which is 3840x1600 and can do 75hz. I can’t live without it now.
- wil421 5y agoI bought this one but it was overkill for my needs. I think the model below this one is a better buy. They were out when I bought it. https://www.microcenter.com/product/639902/lg-34gp950g-34-2k-uwqhd-(3440-x-1440)-144hz-gaming-monitor https://www.microcenter.com/product/639902/lg-34gp950g-34-2k...
- TwiztidK 5y agoI highly recommend the Dell UltraSharp U4919, of which I currently have four (two at home and two at work). Almost my entire department switch to them as soon as they came out. My other ultra-wide is an ASUS PG348Q. It's crazy how that monitor felt huge when I got it, but it just seems tiny now.
- 5y ago
- tolle 5y agoI mean did he try to just daisy chain them? He claims that he wanted to use DisplayPort 1.4 for connectivity. But the monitors do support daisy chaining over thunderbolt, and he also states that. But why not daisy chain? I mean I get that it's frustrating to get the thing working with DisplayPort, dongles and docks. But the best solution was right in front of him?
- jamesfmilne 5y agoI believe macOS on Apple Silicon or Intel does not support DisplayPort MST (Multi-Stream Transport) which is required for daisy-chaining to work.
- jsjohnst 5y agoMacOS supports MST mirror (which imho is mostly useless outside niche uses), but not MST extend.
- ToniCipriani 5y agoI suppose it's the common knowledge that Mac OS doesn't support MST properly and author assumed it applied to Thunderbolt docks as well. This is on Apple for not implementing that, because it's not the hardware. Intel Macbooks work perfectly fine with regular DP Alt Mode docks in Boot Camp.
- 5y ago
- kitsunesoba 5y agoSurprised there was no mention of CalDigit docks. One of my desks has an old TS3+ that drives 2x 2560x1440 monitors perfectly from an M1 Pro machine, and it was rock solid when used with older Intel Macs and Windows PCs too. It’s Thunderbolt 3, but CalDigit recently released a TB4 version. I haven’t yet tried dual displays with it but my other desk is using a Lenovo ThinkPad Thunderbolt 4 Dock and it’s also been solid. I suspect that a lot of the more mass market oriented docks cut corners and don’t implement specs quite to full compliance which leads to weirdness like seen in the article.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _6n1 5y agoWhen I upgraded to an M1 MacBook Pro, my CalDigit TS3+ no longer supported dual external monitors and I had to buy a new dock: https://www.caldigit.com/apple-silicon-mac-and-caldigit-dock-compatibility/ https://www.caldigit.com/apple-silicon-mac-and-caldigit-dock...
- kitsunesoba 5y agoThat’s because regular M1’s can only support two displays. In the case of MacBooks, that’s the internal display and one external. M1 Pro and Max do not share this limitation.
- evgen 5y agoSounds like you didn't do enough research. I am using a CalDigit TS3+ with 2x4K and 1x1080p external displays on a M1 Macbook Pro to write this comment. It is not difficult at all to do and took less than five minutes of searching for me to find the guides and instruction videos when I decided to upgrade my Macbook to Apple Silicon.
- api 5y agoI got a regular M1 and then realized it couldn't support dual monitors, so I just sold my two monitors and bought an ultra wide. It's nicer anyway.
- jurmous 5y agoIt is possible to connect multiple screens to regular M1 Macs with DisplayLink: https://plugable.com/blogs/news/how-to-connect-more-external-displays-to-apple-silicon-m1-macs https://plugable.com/blogs/news/how-to-connect-more-external...
- Macha 5y agoAlthough my experience with DisplayLink in the past has been adapters that were buggy and caused weird issues.
- firecall 5y agoDisplayLink with M1 Macs is still not working properly! 4K support isn't fully capable, and scaled display modes are not hiDPI modes. If you have standard 2K or FHD displays, then DisplayLink is probably fine right now :-)
- DIVx0 5y agooff topic but in a similar Mac and display thing. I have an LG UltraFine 5k monitor that I love. I also have two MBPs, one for work (2019) and a personal 16" M1 Max. The monitor works great plugged directly into either machine however if I try to use any sort of DP 1.4 switch both machines will only see my 5k monitor as 4k. I've tried various cables, all of which say they are DP 1.4 certified. Anyone in this boat with me?
- Gatsky 5y agoI had persistent problems with mouse jitter on just one external monitor with the M1 Air. The problem was fixed with betterDummy. I mean, this is pretty disappointing, and wasted a lot of my time. Lucky the M1 macs are so good in every other way.
- jsjohnst 5y agoI’ve had zero issues using two 27” LG 5K monitors with my M1 Max (personal) or M1 Pro (work). Expensive setup for sure, but it just works and the amount of pixels is just glorious.
- jmuguy 5y agoIts best to assume that Apple just wants everyone to use a single external monitor with their notebooks. Anytime you go beyond that, bad things start to happen. I had a 2017 MacBook Pro and two 27 inch 4k monitors. I connected these through a variety of different dongles and configurations but always had a similar issue - after being in use for a while, no matter what I was doing, the system started to thermal throttle to the point of becoming unusable. After many hours of hair pulling I discovered that using display scaling was the issue. Apparently using anything beyond the "default for display" option was taxing the GPU, which causes heat, which then heats the rest of the system to the point of it throttling the CPU. When I finally realized this I moved to using an eGPU. So basically something like 700 bucks for a Razer Core eGPU and AMD video card to function as a dock. Oh and cherry on top is the Razer Core's NIC doesn't work in macOS, Razer knows this and isn't planning on fixing it. I was really excited about the M1 systems but I absolutely do not want to go through the hell of figuring out how to get two displays working. Particularly considering that I can't just sidestep the issue by using my eGPU since those aren't supported.
- cschep 5y agoThe author just figured it out and shared already, no need to figure it out!
- GeekyBear 5y ago> Its best to assume that Apple just wants everyone to use a single external monitor It's just a matter of different products having different specs. Barring the use of workarounds: The older Macbook Pro with the plain M1 supports one external display. The newer Macbook Pro with the M1 Pro supports two external displays. The newer Macbook Pro with the M1 Max supports four external displays.
- Kalanos 5y agoit's absurd that a $2K machine is dependent on plastic dongles to do basic stuff
- cschep 5y agoThe material they are made of is an interesting thing to call out here. Does it offend you that this $2k machine also relies on plastic keys on its keyboard?
- nicoburns 5y agoNot sure that's really a fair criticism of the latest MacBooks. They have an HDMI port and 3 usb-c/thunderbolt4 ports that all support display port output. The only case you need a dongle for is support multiple displays while using only one port.
- firecall 5y agoHe doesn't need a dongle. You can literally just buy cheap USB-C to DP cables on Amazon that work perfectly fine. No Dongles or Docks required.
- hammock 5y agoTo add another data point for anyone looking for help- I connected two Displayport monitors to my M1 macbook with a Plugable Displaylink hub. The hub I chose also has 2 HDMI ports if I ever got new monitors, plus 6 USB-A ports, an ethernet port and an audio jack. What it doesn't do, is power your laptop. I don't believe any Displaylink hub can do that. $159 and Plugable has other port configurations to choose from as well: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08B6CZ29Q/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1 https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08B6CZ29Q/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b...
- costcofries 5y agoI've had great success with dual monitors using DisplayLink Manager, really handy little app - https://www.synaptics.com/products/displaylink-graphics/downloads/macos https://www.synaptics.com/products/displaylink-graphics/down...
- mastax 5y agoIt's kind-of crazy that macOS still doesn't support DisplayPort Multi Stream Transport - the ability to drive multiple displays with a single DisplayPort cable. That kind of thing fits Apple's ethos very well, and they are heavily involved in the DisplayPort spec and support.
- bombcar 5y agoMy MacBook Pro (15-inch, 2017) has two 34UM88s chained on a single Thunderbolt port somehow.
- lloeki 5y agoThat's TB daisy chaining, not DP's multi thing
- throwoutway 5y agoWhoa, how?! Everything I’ve read indicates that Apple MacOS does not support TB (or was it USB-C?) daisy chaining
- lancebeet 5y agoI have a USB C monitor and a second monitor connected to the first monitor with a DP cable. The USB C cable is connected to a ThinkPad x270 (a machine from 2017) running linux. Am I missing something regarding TB vs USB C + DP, or are you saying that this setup wouldn't work on a newly released MacBook? It sounds pretty unbelievable to me.
- goosedragons 5y agoYes. Apple doesn't support DP daisy chaining and they only recently added support for variable refresh rates on Macs despite it being a thing in the monitor space for 8 years. If their own products don't use it they don't care about it.
- olyjohn 5y agoMy theory is they want to you buy Thunderbolt displays. They get a cut of sales of Thunderbolt, but not a cut of DisplayPort, since it's a standard that is free of royalties. There's literally no other reason I can think of not to support MST out of the box on these laptops. Especially if they are involved in working on the spec.
- grork 5y agoI think I’m a unicorn. 14” M1 Max, triple displays, albeit with two cables. We also have an M1 Pro in the house w/ CalDigit TS3 (non-plus), which is driving dual 4k’s without issue. I’m confused why the author didn’t just purchase one of the cornucopia of Thunderbolt 3 (or 4) docks that do everything including display output. Triple config (M1 Max): - OWC Thunderbolt 4 dock, connected to 2 4k displays, network, speakers, USB devices - 5k display connected direct to the mac Dual Config (M1 Pro): - CalDigit TS3 dock, connected to 2 4k displays, speakers, ethernet, USB devices Works perfectly, and we have no complaints about either config. Why Is the 5k direct connect? Because there aren’t any TB docks that support 3x displays when pushing > 4k; I’m unclear if it’s technically possible. I had previously run triple displays on a 13” Intel MBP using an eGPU. I wrote about that journey here: https://www.codevoid.net/ruminations/2020/09/27/three-displays-three-times-the-fun.html https://www.codevoid.net/ruminations/2020/09/27/three-displa...
- jsjohnst 5y ago> Because there aren’t any TB docks that support 3x displays when pushing > 4k; I’m unclear if it’s technically possible. It’s not technically possible given the bandwidth available on a TB3/TB4 port. 5K display requires 22Gbps, the port overall is limited to 40Gbps, so not possible to get more than one on a single cable. Due to the way TB uses the available lanes in the cable, it’s also not possible to my knowledge to support a USB-C 4K monitor daisy chained off a 5K monitor either even though there’s sufficient bandwidth (22 + 15 < 40) to do so. Thunderbolt 5 w/ it’s supposed 80Gbps support will change that.
- n42 5y agomy caldigit dock “works perfectly”. it consistently requires plug and unplug, opening laptop lid to unlock then unplugging and waiting and replugging then closing laptop lid, trying different usb-c port, and having to reboot to support higher than 60hz refresh rates. perfectly.
- mshaler 5y agoExactly my M1 MBA 4K external display experience: "works perfectly."
- wataban 5y ago
- protomyth 5y agoI really don't like dual displays, but I will say the Dell UltraSharp U4919DW is amazing hooked to my MacBook. The 32x9 is effectively two displays and it works very well as long as you do not try to use the HDMI port. Still not sure, why. I'm hoping someone does a true 4K version (well 2 4Ks side by side I guess)
- lmilcin 5y agoI am running 2 external 27" 4k HDMI displays (LG 27UK650_600) with no problem on my M1 Macbook Pro. I am using them either with the Macbook closed or with all three screens at the same time. One of the monitors is connected using built in HDMI and this one works super stable. The other is connected through Belkin adapter that I bought from Apple. It sometimes experiences problems (it shows noise) and has to be disconnected and reconnected. This usually happens only after the monitor has been turned off for the night but the laptop was on (I keep it on due to various experiments I am running). Overall I am super happy.
- radicality 5y agoI’m using the fully specced M1 Pro Max with the laptop screen, 6k Pro Display XDR connected directly and 2x4k Dell monitors connected via the Caldigit thunderbolt hub (HDMI). It’s working great, haven’t had any major issues, the newest M1 MacBooks are quite impressive. Apple’s default screen management tooling is awful though so I can highly recommend SwitchResX for that. Also have a TB4 dock from Sonnettech (3 TB4 inputs / one output), to which I have a 10Gb/s qnap tb3 adapter plugged in. (The qnap works great btw if you are on the lookout for 10Gb/s networking for your MacBook. Make sure to get the sfp+ and not the ethernet version)
- sylens 5y agoBeen using a CalDigit TS3 dock for years with Intel 13” MBPs and now a 14” M1 Pro MBP and have had no issues. I did try a 16” 2019 Intel MBP with it, and there was some issue where it would not wake the monitors when coming out of sleep - I speculated due to the dedicated gpu
- Gelob 5y agoSatechi makes great products. I bought this usb-c multiport adapter and the main reason i love it is because all the other usb-c hubs have a fixed length cable attached to it that when im mobile or walking around a datacenter, they fall out. With this I can either use the short included cabled or any long usb-c cable to keep the adapter further away from my computer so it doesnt hang off the side and come loose. https://satechi.net/products/usb-c-on-the-go-multiport-adapter?variant=33736080523352 https://satechi.net/products/usb-c-on-the-go-multiport-adapt...
- ttfkam 5y agoBought this a few months back. Simple and cheap. Instead of complex circuitry and drivers, they just punted and connected to the two adjacent Thunderbolt ports. No regrets. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BFHDST3 https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BFHDST3