3 ms·
The standard argument in favor of FSD vehicles is that they perform better than the average human driver. Except it doesn't take into account the amount of adre
by amelius 5y ago
The standard argument in favor of FSD vehicles is that they perform better than the average human driver. Except it doesn't take into account the amount of adrenaline involved.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI do not see the point of conversing about full self driving when it is nowhere close to existing yet.
- simion314 5y agoTesla use this names unforunetly "FSD" and "Autopilot", instead of lane assist or driver assist... we need everyone including fanboys to demand Tesla stop push fake capabilities, maybe name it MFFSD = Maybe in future Full Self Driving
- lotsofpulp 5y agoYes, that was the point of my comment. Tesla does not unfortunately use the words “full self driving”, they intentionally use the words “full self driving” for marketing purposes to mislead people. How it is not a clear case of false advertising for regulators to go after, I do not know. I could even envision the plausible deniability/marketing bullshit behind “self driving”, but to go out of your way and declare FULL self driving, and not get smacked for false advertising is beyond me.
- rootusrootus 5y agoIt also doesn't take account how much the average is skewed by a minority of really terrible drivers.
- simion314 5y agoAnd the issue is the numbers are fake: different population, different car types are compared. Dis-engagements are not noted as "20K dis-engagements = 20K times the human saved himself from the bad AI. Would people get operated by an AI doctor that is better then the medicine students and the drunk doctors but only when a good doctor is paying attention and intervenes in case the AI shits itself?
- buran77 5y agoWhile AP is sometimes touted as "FSD safer than a human driver" in reality it's just a set of driver assists that can help a driver drive safer. Since AP doesn't drive itself except for very limited definitions of driving, it can't be itself safer than a human driver. Like when a pair of sneakers help a runner bit can't logically be called "better than a human runner". Let's not forget that the human does most of the work in either example. As long as any "self-driving" car operates only under human supervision it's not relevant to compare that system taken independently to the human. Compare the FSD alone with the human alone and then we have stats. Everything else is candy for people with more money than sense.