7 ms·
The sad thing is that this obviously manufactured reality, combined with a long history of oppression and betrayal, has eroded any national pride among a signif
by throwaway290 5y ago
The sad thing is that this obviously manufactured reality, combined with a long history of oppression and betrayal, has eroded any national pride among a significant slice of population. For years we survived in a state of having emotionally given up on the country, state of mild cognitive dissonance, seeing those who genuinely cared labeled by the authorities as 'foreign agents'.
To fight now is to fight against the system and against your fellow citizens, your friends and classmates imbued with nostalgia about the USSR by their parents.
And what will this fight be for?
Would you definitely see the Western system, that erodes the environment and feeds people microplastics in the name of maximising shareholder value, as the obvious "side of the light"[0]?
Once you have been betrayed enough times, can you really go all in and believe that whoever rises to power thanks to your fight will act in your interests (maintaining freedom and democracy, not abusing power) thereafter?
[0] I happen to believe that capitalism is fundamentally the best form of peaceful cooperation and abuses of it can be regulated, but I can't count the hours I spent in philosophical arguments making my point to lucid, independently thinking friends.
- Kinrany 5y ago> abuses of it can be regulated That's the whole problem, isn't it. Coming up with and installing regulations every time the system is abused is no easier than inventing and installing a new system of governance. When the system is sufficiently complex, you can't patch it.
- throwaway290 5y agoThe regulations are only necessary while there are rogue actors who are motivated to abuse the environment and others, exploring the limits of the law, following the letter but not the spirit, in order to secure themselves. These people often grew up in adverse conditions (mentally or physically) and are coping with the resulting mental issues. Elon Musk with his South African upbringing and history of extreme bullying is one example; there are many more less obvious ones. Once we improve the mental well-being of the population as a whole, there would be no incentive for one to ruin things for others for personal gain, and free market would be able to work as intended.
- mach1ne 5y agoI'm guessing you're aware of this, but it's not so simple. There's no indication that after a baseline level of prosperity, greed and malice will simply disappear. While I agree that capitalism is the best system altogether which we have seen in action, I don't believe it is the best one. My hope is that in the long run, technological progress will eliminate scarcicity, and we will see some combination of capitalism and communism to realize utopia.
- andrepd 5y agoAbsolutely. "best so far" != "best there can ever be". Western liberal capitalism is heavily flawed, it's just marginally better than the alternatives currently in existance and therefore the best starting point to build an even better one.
- throwaway290 5y agoApplying abstract thinking from first principles, what kind of approach could theoretically be better?
- throwaway290 5y agoI am aware it's not so simple, but I strongly believe that fundamentally greed and malice arise from mental issues and insecurities. There is no incentive for a healthy mind that is calm, confident, and knows that others are the same, to maximise own security at the expense of the society.
- mach1ne 5y agoInteresting. I hope you are right. I'm afraid I am a bit more cynical.
- frostwarrior 5y agoI disagree. Greed and malice are just consequences of an unfair society. The more the people know that rules don't apply to the powerful, then the more the people try to climb the social ladder to become the powerful. Ideally, on a fair system, you are respected because of your skills or your contributions to society. On an unfair one, you are respected because you have a higher hierarchy than them and nothing more. My concern with western people criticizing non-western and non-democratic countries is that, aside from some exceptions like South Korea, Costa Rica or Japan, unfair societies that adopted the western-style model of democratic government didn't become more fair in average. On the contrary, western societies got more unfair over time.
- Mizza 5y agoI don't see the alternative though, it's not like Putin is a hardcore Leninist. There's no real ideology there, he doesn't care for the people. What's the attraction? Maybe people don't like what is pejoratively called "globohomo", plenty of people in the West don't either, but having everything dictated by a mafia thug and his oil-rich cronies seems far, far worse. I don't get it.
- throwaway290 5y agoAttraction to what? Putin? Did you misread my comment? > "globohomo" I do not know what that refers to.
- ginko 5y agoIt's a derogatory 4chan /pol/ term for supporters of globalization. IMF, World Economic Forum, Soros etc.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoWhat a buncha dead-enders.
- pixl97 5y agoglobal homogeneity. Of course being 4chan they associate it with homosexuality.
- 0a3feeb 5y agoAleksandr Dugin's work is the philosophical/ideological cover for whatever Putin's doing. The gist is to create a conservative Eurasian state/alliance to combat Western liberalism.
- ChemSpider 5y ago"that erodes the environment and feeds people microplastics"... yes, the "Tragedy of the commons". But the issue is, the environment in non-free societies (=> no free press) is in much worse shape.
- throwaway290 5y agoYou don't need to tell me that. I'm just saying it's not an obvious thing to many (thinking) people.
- sandworm101 5y agoNothing in politics is ever obvious. That is why we should shun leaders who rely on gut insticts, "common sense" and napkin math. The real world is messy. Answers are hard. Ideology must always remain an ideal, not a howto guidebook.
- throwaway290 5y agoIt's not obvious in itself, that's why I have a barrage of supporting arguments. However, it takes time to understand and adopt this viewpoint, especially if many people around you are conditioned to believe in the opposite and consider capitalism as evil or evil-adjacent.
- cmurf 5y agoDare we forget anytime soon the ~75 million fools who voted for a fool with autocratic tendencies, who's still giving Putin's ego lap dances this week. There's a pile of fools at Fox News being Putin apologists. Out of all the harm done by billionaires, Rupert Murdoch has been a worse menace to America than any of Putin's oligarchs. So yeah, it certainly remains very messy in the U.S. too.
- robinsoh 5y ago> I happen to believe that capitalism is fundamentally the best form of peaceful cooperation and abuses of it can be regulated I would not be so confident of that claim. I believe you're assessing that based on capitalism from the perspective of the predator states that exploit victim states. If there were no victim states, then capitalism would not work as well as it has for the predator states. Is everyone in the world better off with the current version of capitalism and the 'global order'? Steven Pinker may say yes but I'm not that convinced. The more I read about his research and some of the flaws like bias in the Yanomami analysis, the less I am convinced that things are better overall for everyone.
- darkerside 5y agoAre you talking about sweat shops in third world countries, some of which (not all) people choose to work at because they are such an economic improvement over any other jobs available to them? Sorry to make an assumption about your argument, but you honestly didn't supply much.
- pydry 5y agoPeople also choose to sell organs and prostitute themselves in desperate economic circumstances. Are Johns and organ harvesters providing economic improvement or are they exploiting economic suffering?
- roenxi 5y ago> People also choose to sell organs... I haven't heard of any systemic selling of organs; my understanding was the go-to for organs was illegally harvested ones out of certain authoritarian states. Where is this semi-voluntary sale of organs happening?
- orwin 5y agoIndia, SEA countries mostly, but i've heard of cases in SA AND in europe too. It is not systemic however, opportunistic at best?
- grishka 5y agoCapitalism isn't bad, but there must be constant pressure from market competition for it to work for the benefit of the society at large. What we see now with companies like Apple (wrt app store) and Facebook is that the US government protects their monopolistic status and doesn't let people compete with them. You can't build a Facebook app that's better than the official one because Facebook would sue you, and there unfortunately are laws that would protect them. In a saner legal system, Facebook would've been laughed out of the court building with this case. 99% of my friends consider the current Russian government completely dysfunctional and in dire need of replacement. And we would totally accept the Western values. USSR was a mistake and there needs to be a clean break from that ideology, no continuity.
- zwkrt 5y agoThis is a nice tech bubble way of framing it but the oil, plastic, logging, chemical, and agricultural industries will be the ones that get us in the end, and heavy market competition would only make it happen faster.
- sandworm101 5y ago90+% of americans think thier government is disfunctional. Russia is no great outlier there. The better question is what will those people put in its place the day after the revolution. Few have a reasonable answer beyond some other person they think is somehow above reproach.
- grishka 5y agoRussians' patience is maddening really. Soviet generations would accept anything the government throws at them and say thanks. They view the government like the weather: you have to just accept it but don't you dare try to change or even understand anything about it. Many Soviet people have no idea who runs their city district for example. They don't know that they can have the government serve them and be accountable to them, so it naturally evolves away from serving them, instead serving its own interests. Like territorial expansion for its own sake. Americans, from what I see, are quite different. There's actually fierce competition both on elections and when controversial bills are discussed. There are representatives that do legit represent people's interests (but also some that do not). US government has its own share of problems ("lobbying" aka legalized bribery being one), but it's still better than the dictatorship we have.
- virgilp 5y ago> And what will this fight be for? For your honour. So that you do not become a citizen of North Korea; so that you do not take part in <this>. Honour systems developed independently in many chaotic/violent societies - not irrationally, but because they are _good_ systems, perhaps the only way to protect yourself from fates worse than death. Kamil Galeev explains it fairly well here: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1498692916511924232.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1498692916511924232.html
- throwaway290 5y agoMy honour is supposed to compel me to quit software, go back and start a bloody fight with my fellow citizens (on whose side the tanks and the truth, for all they know, are)? For a country I have no pride in, to facilitate the next dictator to trample on our blood up the throne if we succeed, while you watch with popcorn from your office?
- virgilp 5y agoNot you, personally; those who choose (or are compelled) to stay .
- throwaway290 5y agoSome people may be compelled. I will look at them in awe.
- bsedlm 5y agoByung-Chul Han seems to share your opinion about capistalism there's a quote along the lines of "capitalism is not a political question it is a force of nature which must be tamed" [1] [1] https://apposition.substack.com/p/the-burnout-society https://apposition.substack.com/p/the-burnout-society I think that when a cooperative relationship is reduced market-trade (money in exchange for goods by well defined contract laws) it's at its minimum. for example, one may trade with a rival or somebody whom one deeply dislikes, hence you just give them the money and they give you your goods or services and that is it. no pleasantries no nothing, bare minimum. The point is that this is a degraded form of cooperative relation. If things degrade even more that ceases to be cooperative and becomes enmity.