11 ms·
The world economy is heading towards a black hole unless bold action taken
- asdkl234890 15y agoBold action might help us. This "bold action" depends on politicians. -> Forget about it! Strap in, change is opportunity, get ready for an exciting ride.
- zobzu 15y agoI don't think all the new homeless people, or whoever is going to get very poor are going to find the ride all that exciting. The guys who make money, the rich, however, certainly will. These recessions and all are always a pretty good opportunity to make more money.
- redthrowaway 15y agoRight, so with a deeper recession looming, those of us with the wherewithal to foresee it should be asking ourselves how best we can benefit from it. Look, it's shitty that it's going to hurt a lot of people. I wish it didn't. But, the fact that it will doesn't mean that it should hurt me.
- ChrisLTD 15y agoThey almost made it the entire article without throwing in a bit of Both Sides Do It nonsense. "In America the Republicans are guilty of outrageous obstructionism and misleading simplification, while Mr Obama has favoured class warfare over fiscal leadership."
- michaelochurch 15y agoObama class warfare? No sign of it. I think Obama's a great human being, but he's a essentially a conservative by any sane standard. With the economic stance he holds now, he'd have been a Republican in 1970 (a time in which Republicans were not all horrible).
- ellyagg 15y agoWow, as exemplified by this comment, this conversation is getting really inappropriate for hn.
- rick888 15y agoIf Obama is your idea of a Republican, I don't want your idea of a Democrat in office...ever.
- Confusion 15y agoThe horror... you might just end up like Germany or France.
- rick888 15y ago70%+ taxes, no thanks. I thought this was HN, not reddit...
- ChrisLTD 15y agoAccording to Wikipedia, the German and French personal tax rates are in the area of 50%: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_around_the_world http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tax_rates_around_the_world
- rick888 15y agoThis doesn't include VAT and increased taxes in other areas, so personal income tax might be 50%, but you are actually paying a much higher rate.
- Confusion 15y agoYou're making numbers up and don't actually know what the aggregate taxes for an average consumer in France, Germany and the US are.
- anigbrowl 15y agoAlthough the Economist tends to oscillate between sanguinity and (mild) hyperbole, this is as close to panicked as I have seen it in a decade. Situation downgraded from 'worrying' to 'grave.'
- bd_at_rivenhill 15y agobuilding a firewall around illiquid but solvent countries like Italy I'm not entirely sure I understand the distinction being made between illiquidity and insolvency here, could someone please explain it? It seems to me that if you are in a state in which a high enough interest rate on your debt will put you in a death spiral from which you cannot feasibly recover, then your problem is bigger than liquidity.
- cwp 15y agoThat's exactly the distinction being made. Italy's debt is highish but manageable; it budget deficit is small. If it can borrow at reasonable rates for the next few years, it's not in danger of default. That's illiquidity. Compare to Greece, which, even if it could get loans at low interest, is never going to be able to repay what it already owes. That's insolvent.
- bd_at_rivenhill 15y agoSo the only thing that really separates Italy from Greece is the market's expectation that Germany won't let any of the other sovereign nations default. Absent that expectation, Italy and Spain are one good speculative attack (a la Soros vs. the British Pound) away from insolvency.
- OstiaAntica 15y ago"Bold" action by the politicians and the central banks created much of the current mess. If we'd just cleared the pipes by letting the banks fail, recapitalizing new banks, and basically rebooting the financial system, we'd be much further along. Instead, we got bailouts and crony capitalism and ad hoc intervention, and today the global system is in many ways in worse shape now than in 2008. (Banking is more concentrated and national balance sheets are a mess from the bailouts)
- chopsueyar 15y agoYou mean like a free market economy?
- SkyMarshal 15y agoNot exactly. True free market economies would let the banks fail, but the government also wouldn't recapitalize new ones, it would let the market handle that, or not as the case may be.
- anigbrowl 15y agoletting the banks fail, recapitalizing new banks, and basically rebooting the financial system Please tell us how that works in practice rather than in theory. I really, really want to know how you just 'reboot' the financial system without massive disruption to retail banking or the payments system. How do you 're'capitalize a new bank? If you just mean create new banks, who is running these banks? I mean, I'd like to have seen a complete reboot of the system as well, but it looks like the sort of thing that is much easier said than actually done. If you're going to mention Sweden, provide specifics of how long it took and how much capital was involved.
- sliverstorm 15y agoOh, it's not a big deal, you just need everbody to go without money and food for a few years while you get the things off the ground. No sweat.
- silverbax88 15y agoThat article has almost zero factual content to back up it's assertions. This kind of nonsensical ravings really grate me. Don't write something like 'witness the increasingly dark economic backdrop' or 'America’s economy is still limping along' without some hard numbers. This article attempts to support those statements with broad general commentary like 'summer slump in share prices and consumer confidence suggest future spending will weaken further'...that's not proof, that's an interpretation of data that the author isn't sharing. The worst part about that article is that the meatiest statement 'That could change if Congress came to its senses, passed Barack Obama’s jobs plan and agreed on a medium-term deficit-reduction deal by November' is dead on, but delivered in such a clumsy manner it's almost a throwaway piece.
- mcphilip 15y agoThis is an online version of an article in the Leaders section of the Economist magazine. The articles in that section are mostly short summaries of topics discussed in greater detail in the relevant subsections of the issue. For instance, the same print issue as this 'nonsensical raving' has a much more detailed summary of the euro crisis in the Briefings section if you're looking for the gory details alluded to in the leader[1]. [1]http://www.economist.com/node/21530960 http://www.economist.com/node/21530960
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- nradov 15y agoLet me guess: the "bold action" they want is to throw a few more trillions at bank shareholders and prodigal borrowers. No thanks. We would be better off to head straight through the black hole, full speed ahead. It will be painful for a few years but we'll come through the other side with cleaner balance sheets and sustainable government budgets.
- dmfdmf 15y agoI agree with OstiaAntica. This Economist article is a thinly veiled call for more debt and more inflationary spending. Who stands in the way of "recovery" ? The obstinate Germans (who learned the lesson of hyperinflation last century) with the only sound Euro economy, i.e. they will be paying for the bailouts. In the USA its the Tea Party and the few Republicans with a spine who recognize that the problem is the massive debt and adding to it is only going to delay the inevitable and make it worse. The bold action (that will never happen) is to let the zombie banks and businesses fail, then pickup the pieces and start over. It won't happen and everyone had better prepare for high, if not, hyper-inflation because politically that is the road we are on.
- yequalsx 15y agoThe are numerous examples of countries having a larger debt to GDP ratio than the United States who recovered nicely from such debt ratio. In the U.S. taxes are around 24% GDP which is quite low relative to the rest of the industrialized world and quite low relative to our recent past (50 years). Raising taxes will counteract any hyper inflationary forces. Increasing the debt for the U.S., given that the borrowing rate is ridiculously low and tax rates are similarly low, will not lead to hyper inflation. Inflation is a not a problem in the U.S. right now.
- TomOfTTB 15y agoWith all due respect raising taxes that high is a straw man. I'd be all for raising taxes if it worked but it doesn't. Nation states are competitive entities and they compete for the world's resources. If the U.S. dramatically raises taxes on the rich then emerging countries like Hong Kong see an opportunity and lower their tax rates. Then you start to see capital flee the U.S. for overseas. That's why per capita tax receipts have stayed fairly consistent over time even though the tax rate has fluctuated: http://www.angrybearblog.com/2007/09/comparing-presidents-real-tax-receipts.html http://www.angrybearblog.com/2007/09/comparing-presidents-re... Don't get me wrong. We could and should raise taxes to the highest levels we can. But there's a threshold where it becomes cheaper for rich people to hide their money than it is for them to pay higher tax rates. When we cross that threshold we see tax revenue start to drop. So while I'm in favor of raising taxes I don't think we can raise taxes to the point where it would get us out of this mess.
- JerkyTreatz 15y agoNothing new here. What I find interesting is how an impending Chinese squeeze would affect American markets. Their economy has been steadily dropping, but with all eyes on Europe no one has really looked into it. http://macro-man.blogspot.com/2011/09/china-squeeze.html http://macro-man.blogspot.com/2011/09/china-squeeze.html
- jcromartie 15y agoLately, I've noticed that political and financial systems seem to behave according to the laws of increasing entropy in closed systems. For that reason, sometimes I fear that there is no fixing it, and that only a new system will be better.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Duff 15y agoBold action would be allowing toxic institutions like Bank of America to collapse. Bold action would force the proprietrary trades of institutions like Goldman Sachs to take place in public, on an open, regulated market. Bold action would halt the free trade policies that are building up Asia at the expense of the west. Bold action would be ceasing the subsidy of suburban housing, the student loans and failed local/regional governments.
- pnathan 15y agoI find the preaching of fear distasteful. It is better to gravely recognize the scope of the problem, assemble facts regarding the situation, and then to move to positively affect the situation on all levels, from globally to locally. The bold action that is needed is to not panic, but to take measured steps regardless of ideology and re-election chances. I wish I was in a position to do more than work hard, invest, and not panic.
- wtvanhest 15y agoThis article has no depth and is not worth discussing. Here are two quotes taken from the article: 1) "That could change if Congress came to its senses, passed Barack Obama’s jobs plan and agreed on a medium-term deficit-reduction deal by November." - Author favors Obama's plan and says it will fix the problem. 2)"while Mr Obama has favoured class warfare over fiscal leadership." - Author refers to the exact same policy, but now calls it favoured class warfare. This has a ton of link bate and zero information anyone actually cares about.
- Sym3tri 15y agoI feel like I've heard that headline before.
- blackhole 15y agoI am continuously amused by people vehemently arguing about topics they have almost no expertise in and thinking whatever insane batshit theory they have is better than a PhD doctorate's advice.
- learc83 15y agoWhen it comes to economics, you can find a set of PhDs to support whatever wild theory you happen to fancy.
- Tyrannosaurs 15y agoThe great quote "Economists have successfully predicted seven out of the last three recessions".
- naeem 15y agoThe scariest part of all this, is that for the first time in the past century, we no longer have any options. Less regulation, more regulation, centralization, de-centralization, it's all been tried. We're out of options, and the policy makers and central bankers have clued in (Bernanke's recent speeches have been dreadful to listen to). Maybe, just maybe, things are going to go really, really badly this time around. Maybe.
- nhebb 15y ago"That could change if Congress came to its senses, passed Barack Obama’s jobs plan" The jobs plan doesn't even have enough Democratic support to pass the Senate, so the likelihood of it making it through both houses is nil. It's more of a political plan than an economic one. I also think that we have limited capability to make expedient investments in infrastructure with a positive ROI. Take a look at the Columbia River Crossing project between Oregon and Washington states - six years after project inception, the final environmental impact study still hasn't been released. Construction would start in 2013 at the earliest and is estimated to take 5-7 years. Time lines like that are common with large infrastructure projects in the US.
- chernevik 15y agoAll HN threads attract posts with excess ratios of certainty to knowledge. On the technical stuff, the excesses are met with really knowledgeable rebuttal, driving up the denominator. People are afraid of embarrassment, so they write more carefully, driving down the numerator. The dynamic drives the overall ratio to something like one. On economics, everyone is really sure the other guy is crazy. They make posts that drive up the numerator, as that's the only way to get heard, and drive down the denominator, as they must address the other guy, whether they know anything about the matter or not. The average blows out hyperbolically -- if there's a limit, the signal / noise drops too low for even the craziest people before that limit is approached. It's kind of remarkable to see how quickly those ratios go to their logical endpoints.
- kokey 15y agoYou say that with a lot of certainty. You must be crazy. Jokes aside, you have a good point.
- scarmig 15y agoOn one hand, I really hate the Economist. It's a magazine that thinks an ideology, a smart tone, and providing the only decent coverage of world events widely available makes for a compelling magazine. Even if that coverage is ridiculously biased and not really knowledgeable about facts on the ground. On the other, it's perhaps the pre-eminent mouthpiece for the ruling Anglo-American elite, and it's comforting that they're sounding the alarms to what's happening. I think it's too little too late, but I genuinely hope that people and policymakers hear them. Because this is really bad, folks. Really, really bad. It's pretty clear the dominoes that will fall: Greece fails, setting off markets and destroying banks across the continent, causing Spain to fail, doing the same, causing Italy, Belgium, maybe even France to fail. Who knows what after that. The EU's demise will signal the financial collapse of an economy larger than the United States; it's already either at the brink or already in a new recession, and this will be the deathblow. The quick succession of collapses, happening all within the span of a month or two, reverberate throughout the entire world, throwing the USA back into a second, possibly harsher recession than the first we have yet to recover from. The only other solution is converting the European Union into a fiscal union. On the face of it this is implausible: you'd be asking Germans, who in their self imagination see themselves as pure as snow, to pony up hundreds of billions of dollars to subsidize what they see as the lavish lifestyles of lazy unproductive Mediterranean types. Even if you could form some political consensus to do this, though, it's not even clear that politicians could coordinate the solution in time to cut off the collapse. Effectively consolidating dozens of countries into the same fiscal union isn't a change you can implement by sheer willpower; it'd be a herculean task even with years of preparation. And, stateside, any attempt to counteract or prepare for this tidal wave is simply doomed because of our ridiculously broken institutions. One side has the ability to co-operate and try to fix the situation, but because of how our government is set up all the incentives on their side are to actively sabotage the economy--regardless of causes, if it does badly, the party of the current President will be blamed. Because people (Americans, Germans, Greeks, Chinese) are all idiots, from the man on the street to the upper echelons of power.
- chernevik 15y agoThe Economist would be a lot more credible if it admitted that yes, they want the Germans to subsidize the Greeks and no, there is no plausible scenario under which those subsidies end. Absent that, they look as rhetorical as anyone, if somewhat better written.
- capkutay 15y agoWhen discussing "bold action" to save the economy, we should really be reevaluating the incentives of the traders on Wall Street. This makes me think of Mark Cuban's article "What Business is Wall Street In?" http://blogmaverick.com/2011/08/08/what-business-is-wall-street-in-2/ http://blogmaverick.com/2011/08/08/what-business-is-wall-str... These traders on Wall Street have little interest in creating capital for the companies that stem innovation. Their main incentive is profit, even if it means making money off economic downswings. We need to put them back on the proper track via taxes or a complete restructuring of the capital gains system.
- sandee 15y agoWhy the date is shown as "Oct 1st 2011" ? (Current GMT is Sept 30, 6:06 am)
- sateesh 15y agoIt is the date of the print edition.
- crag 15y agoMy god this article is spot on: "If Democrats and Republicans fail to hash out a compromise on the deficit, draconian spending cuts will follow in 2013. For all the tirades against the Europeans, America’s economy risks being pushed into recession by its own fiscal policy—and by the fact that both parties are more interested in positioning themselves for the 2012 elections than in reaching the compromises needed to steer away from that hazardous course." Says it all right there.
- yaix 15y agoScary news sell newspapers. This article is way to sensationalist for my taste. The one thing I find worrying is the large shift in power from people to financial corporations that has happened in the past decade.
- skrebbel 15y agoBold action is for sissies. We'll deal with the black hole when it comes!
- jwingy 15y agoGet money out of politics so politicians can make unbiased, level-headed decisions. I don't doubt the complexity of our current economic situation, but the way our government is currently run by lobbyists who naturally have their own myopic view, I think it would be more an accident than on purpose that our economy gets better.