4 ms·
A few observations: * Encryption is not enabled by default. * They call it private, but I don't see how the metadata - who you talk to, which is as important
by wolverine876 5y ago
A few observations:
* Encryption is not enabled by default.
* They call it private, but I don't see how the metadata - who you talk to, which is as important as what you say - is private.
* "Assuming no malevolence ...": Assuming no malevolence, we don't need to encrypt anything. Though even if we assume malevolence, if we trust Brave to make the browser, they can do almost anything they want regardless, without our knowing much about it.
- cato_the_elder 5y agoI think they specifically mean assuming no malevolence by Brave and 8x8. TLS, which is probably the most widely used form of encryption, is also more or less dependent on assuming no malevolence by the certificate authorities. Your points about possible metadata collection, and end-to-end encryption not being the default are valid though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danhab99 5y ago> is also more or less dependent on assuming no malevolence by the certificate authorities It doesn't have to be. Nothing's stopping you from signing your own certificates, just like nothing is stopping you from trusting the certificate your friend gave you, whether its by printing out the certificate on paper and then "handing" it to you, or sending it in an email. You're also 100% welcome to trust that your friend isn't a moron and lost control of his private key. AT THE SAME TIME, nothing stops you and abunch of your friends from trusting one or 2 dudes to be a certificate authority for your group. Cryptography wasn't (and never tried to be) ever an alternative to not being stupid. Any 2 people can setup maximum 100% encrypted end-to-end communication using tools older than I am (or about my age). I feel like we let security and centralization blind us to solutions that we already have because those solutions are hard to onboard too. IRC is free, GPG is free, TOR is free, Email is still free.
- baobabKoodaa 5y agoIn this case we would be assuming no malevolence on an additional party, in addition to Brave, so it does somewhat increase risk of bad things happening.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 3np 5y agoApart from the "no malevolence" assumption effectively making any assertions meaningless, “by default” are key words here. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/09/privacy-focused-protonmail-provided-a-users-ip-address-to-authorities/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/09/priva...
- fastball 5y agoIt's basically impossible to have a trustless E2EE experience if you didn't build it yourself.
- wolverine876 5y ago> the "no malevolence" assumption effectively making any assertions meaningless I strongly disagree or all assertions in humanity are meaningless. Everything we do and think relies on trusting others.
- 3np 5y agoNot at all. But if you assume 0 malevolence from any party, there is no need for security in the first place, is there? Security models commonly explicitly assume the possibility of malicious actors. For two well-known examples, Bitcoin PoW assumes the possibility that a malicious actor can spin up arbitrary amounts of malicious nodes. TLS assumes that the intermediary nodes in underlying network (e.g. ISPs) can be malicious. The assertions still hold.
- tialaramex 5y agoEven with zero malevolence security isolates systems from mishap. If Jim can't delete the user database then Jim also can't delete the user database by mistake. We accidentally made librarians Owners of Teams associated with courses students were taking where that librarian was subject specialist, so e.g. Modern History librarian finds they are now Owner of dozens of teams full of teenage students. That's annoying, so they click Delete. Are you sure? Says Teams. Of course they're sure. And the Team is deleted. If security prevented them doing that, they'd have complained "Why am I in all these teams?" instead of deleting the teams. No malevolence involved.
- samsin 5y ago> if we trust Brave to make the browser, they can do almost anything they want regardless, without our knowing much about it. like automatically adding affiliate links to URLs without notifying their users https://www.cpomagazine.com/data-privacy/brave-privacy-browser-caught-automatically-adding-affiliate-links-to-cryptocurrency-urls/ https://www.cpomagazine.com/data-privacy/brave-privacy-brows...
- stevenicr 5y agoI too have some concerns about the privacy statements. It would be easy for an average person to assume that they are anonymous and hidden from all things - but this system using webrtc that exposes your IP addy to the person you are prank calling / harassing / threatening or whatever and this can be connected by more than just the person on the other end, but one may not assume such a thing when they read: Video calling, with Brave privacy at its core No tracking. No data collection. Nothing linking you (or anyone else) to a call. Period. With Brave Talk, your conversations stay private to you. ----- Don't get me wrong, am really glad they are releasing this and I hope a lot of people use it! I just think we need to educate the end users more about how even private / encrypted things are not tracking-proof .. the "No tracking" to you/me/brave may be 'no advertiser big fang tracking' in our mind - but that's not how it's written or read / understood by the average person I would guess.