4 ms·
HN readers might be interested in this section: The video and audio from your call are transmitted to other participants with the help of a Video Bridge server
by wolverine876 5y ago
HN readers might be interested in this section:
The video and audio from your call are transmitted to other participants with the help of a Video Bridge server that’s run by Brave’s partner, 8x8. When you enable Video Bridge Encryption in Security Options, your browser exchanges keys with other call participants, and these keys are used to encrypt the video and audio streams. Only people with keys can see your calls. Assuming no malevolence, neither Brave nor its partner, 8x8, have this key by default.
However, there are some important limits to Video Bridge Encryption. If you want to include a phone participant in your call, have more than 20 participants, or want to include users with incompatible browsers (Safari, most iOS browsers, and browsers based on Chromium version 83 or below), this encryption setting will not work. If you record a call, 8x8’s servers will receive a set of keys to decrypt the video/audio stream in order to process and store that recording. Brave will continue to improve Brave Talk’s encryption properties and work to remove some of these limitations.
Read a more detailed description of Jitsi encryption (the open source basis for Brave Talk).
- sebmellen 5y agoJitsi has been around for quite a while. Now I'm not sure what makes Brave Talk any different. https://meet.jit.si https://meet.jit.si for those who are interested.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Jitsi has been around for quite a while. Now I'm not sure what makes Brave Talk any different. It makes Jitsi available to many people who wouldn't otherwise use it. If you care about Jitsi and people communicating, that's great. If you care about marketshare and fame, that's not.
- wolverine876 5y agoA few observations: * Encryption is not enabled by default. * They call it private, but I don't see how the metadata - who you talk to, which is as important as what you say - is private. * "Assuming no malevolence ...": Assuming no malevolence, we don't need to encrypt anything. Though even if we assume malevolence, if we trust Brave to make the browser, they can do almost anything they want regardless, without our knowing much about it.
- cato_the_elder 5y agoI think they specifically mean assuming no malevolence by Brave and 8x8. TLS, which is probably the most widely used form of encryption, is also more or less dependent on assuming no malevolence by the certificate authorities. Your points about possible metadata collection, and end-to-end encryption not being the default are valid though.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- danhab99 5y ago> is also more or less dependent on assuming no malevolence by the certificate authorities It doesn't have to be. Nothing's stopping you from signing your own certificates, just like nothing is stopping you from trusting the certificate your friend gave you, whether its by printing out the certificate on paper and then "handing" it to you, or sending it in an email. You're also 100% welcome to trust that your friend isn't a moron and lost control of his private key. AT THE SAME TIME, nothing stops you and abunch of your friends from trusting one or 2 dudes to be a certificate authority for your group. Cryptography wasn't (and never tried to be) ever an alternative to not being stupid. Any 2 people can setup maximum 100% encrypted end-to-end communication using tools older than I am (or about my age). I feel like we let security and centralization blind us to solutions that we already have because those solutions are hard to onboard too. IRC is free, GPG is free, TOR is free, Email is still free.
- baobabKoodaa 5y agoIn this case we would be assuming no malevolence on an additional party, in addition to Brave, so it does somewhat increase risk of bad things happening.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 3np 5y agoApart from the "no malevolence" assumption effectively making any assertions meaningless, “by default” are key words here. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/09/privacy-focused-protonmail-provided-a-users-ip-address-to-authorities/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2021/09/priva...