3 ms·
A corollary is looking at the prices of things that have declined the most. Like software - it's declined to $0. And it's completely unregulated.
by WalterBright 5y ago
A corollary is looking at the prices of things that have declined the most. Like software - it's declined to $0.
And it's completely unregulated.
- iancmceachern 5y agoI use software that costs $10k+ per seat, every day. I recently reviewed some that was $50k a seat. There are companies that have workforces if hundreds using this software to design our modern world every day. I don't get this comment.
- robertlagrant 5y agoYour boat might be expensive, but it's floating in a sea of free software.
- WalterBright 5y agohttps://www.linux.org/pages/download/ https://www.linux.org/pages/download/
- iancmceachern 5y agohttps://www.3ds.com/products-services/catia/ https://www.3ds.com/products-services/catia/ https://www.ansys.com/ https://www.ansys.com/ https://www.solidworks.com/ https://www.solidworks.com/ Comsole, Matlab, etc. If you want to do complex product design competitively there is no substitute for software packages like these. Yes, there are open source alternatives, but they are not competitive, not tome efficient for the folks using it (it's cheaper to just buy the commercial packages because they save more than their cost in labor during the design process). If you can spend 10k to get your product to market 2 months quicker, that's a no brainer when your burn rate is millions a month.
- WalterBright 5y agoI don't disagree with you, but Linux is an enormously complex piece of software. I also never said all software was free. Of course some software is paid for. But how much of the software you use is free? My bet is quite a bit. Including HackerNews and browser you access it with. Quite a bit of paid software is built by all free dev tools. This didn't use to be true - good compilers were very expensive. At least a couple grand in modern dollars.
- dwaltrip 5y agoYou said “software costs $0” without caveats. Not “some software”. You are now trying to pretend you didn’t take such a hard stance. It’s ok and good to admit when you say something wrong. I really respect when people do that. P.S. I’ve been trying to get into less silly arguments like this on the internet… alas I couldn’t help myself here.
- WalterBright 5y agoConsider "people like ice cream". True or false? It's true even if you reply that your friend Fred doesn't like ice cream. That's why the word "all" exists. If I meant 100% of people like ice cream, I would have said "100%" or "all" people like ice cream. This is basic English semantics. > silly arguments It becomes a silly argument when one party decides to treat English with an overly literal interpretation as a rhetorical tactic.
- dwaltrip 5y agoHmmm... I think there is an implicit "most" in these sentences. Most people like ice cream, so I agree it is pedantic to argue that "people like ice cream" is false. When writing my comment, I guess I had an assumption that most software costs more than $0. After thinking about more, I'm not sure that is true. It think it is probably the case that most software is free to use. Interesting to think about. However, there is a wrinkle in your analogy, which I think may be a driver of some of the intense debate in this comment thread. It's rare for someone to "hate" ice cream -- I actually can't think of anyone I know who does. But it's very common to find software that costs A LOT more than $0. So, in a sense, "software costs $0" is much less true than "people like ice cream". As of right now, I think I'm still on the side of it being more false than true. But I'll admit it is more nuanced than I thought. Regardless, I recant the harshness from my previous comment. Thanks for thoughtfully explaining yourself. I do agree with another sibling commenter that you could have been clearer in your original statement :)
- alar44 5y agoThis is just patently false. The company I work for, roughly 200 people, spends roughly $10k/month on software. Personally, I spend maybe $50/month.
- barry-cotter 5y ago$50 a month per employee per month sounds very cheap to me. It rounds to zero considering you’re probably doing things with the software that would be impossible without it. Unless you have astonishingly and uniformly high quality employees you probably couldn’t get to half the quality or efficiency you have with software without it. $50 per person is less than four hours of minimum wage labor per employee.
- WalterBright 5y agoAnd yet if you used Linux, the operating system would be free. Linux is very heavily used in industry. I read now and then about how paid software relies heavily on the free stuff, and how those vendors should donate to the people writing the free stuff.
- alar44 5y agoThere's no way we'd be able to use Linux. We might be able to make it work, but we'd be then kissing vendor support goodbye. That's suicide.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"Like software - it's declined to $0." Juxtapose this statement with the one further downthread: "What do the most ambitious do in the US? Go into software or Wall Street." How can there be money to be made in something that costs zero dollars. That is a rhetorical question, i.e., no answer is being requested.
- hhjinks 5y agoBut it's not a very good rhetorical question. Money can be made in something that costs zero dollars by harvesting user data and utilizing it correctly, for example to sell ad space, or sell directly to other interested parties. It is literally the strategy of some of the biggest tech companies in the world.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoThe question evoked exactly the points I wanted to evoke. Not bad for a rhetorical question. Harvesting user data. Sell ad space. Sell user data to interested parties. This as a "strategy". Biggest "tech" companies. Thank you. Is this practice really best-described as "software". Is the (free) software merely a Trojan Horse for something else. The commenter could have written "What do the most ambitious do in the US? Go into harvesting personal data from people's use of computers and online ad sales, or Wall Street." This would have been more accurate in terms of describing the money-making aspect.
- hhjinks 5y agoOops, I interpreted it the other way around, that you can't make money off something that is free because you don't take any money for it. My bad.
- SkittyDog 5y agoI think this guy is a troll... Take a look through his comment history. He's prolific, but seems inclined to say ridiculous stuff to get under people's skins.
- SkittyDog 5y agoNeither of those statements is true... Are games priced at $0? Will Amazon give you AWS for free? Do Apple and Google let you use all their mobile apps for free? Sure, FOSS is a thing... but plenty of software ain't FOSS. Re: regulation... Plenty of software is regulated by law. Ever heard of PCI compliance? Banking? Insurance? Tax prep? Medicine? Military? Flight avionics? ... All of those industries are heavily regulated by law, and some ofbthose regulations govern their software, too.
- WalterBright 5y ago> Are games priced at $0? Plenty are, like the one I wrote: https://classicempire.com/ https://classicempire.com/ Doom, one of the most famous and played games of all time, is also free. https://www.dosgamesarchive.com/download/doom/ https://www.dosgamesarchive.com/download/doom/ > AWS is a hardware service. > Do Apple and Google let you use all their mobile apps for free? Do you see the word "all" in your sentence? I didn't say "all". You modified what I wrote. > All of those industries are heavily regulated by law And the software under those regulations is expensive. See a pattern there?
- SkittyDog 5y agoMost game are not priced at zero... And games are definitely not a regulated part of the software industry in America. Also, your original statements are both phrased in a way that implies "all". You failed to qualify blanket statements by saying (e.g.) "some". So if you don't want to admit you're wrong, fine: You're doing a poor job of communicating your thoughts. As to evidence of that, just count the number of replies you got that came to the same conclusion I did about an implied "all" versus an implied "some". Not like it matters, anyway... The counter-example if games alone pretty much kills your whole argument about regulation being correlated with higher prices. I think you are clearly a very smart person, and a very good programmer, who is suffering from the Dunning Krueger Effect in relation to the topic of Economics. Regulation can effect costs, but it's far from the only factor, and it's not even necessarily an important factor depending on the situation.
- 5y ago