5 ms·
This is a great overview. They seem to be implying that banks that are otherwise not required to abide by sanctions (say, one located in China) can easily bypas
by paxys 5y ago
This is a great overview. They seem to be implying that banks that are otherwise not required to abide by sanctions (say, one located in China) can easily bypass SWIFT restrictions and transact with the affected Russian banks directly. How true is this part in practice?
I'm going to ignore the last bit since that is tangential to the topic and ripe for starting a flame war.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> can easily bypass SWIFT restrictions and transact with the affected Russian banks directly “Easily” is the squishy bit here. If they’re settling in dollars, probably not, unless someone’s carting around paper dollars. (This has been done.) If they’re settling in rubles or yuan, for most definitions of “easily,” yes.
- Galanwe 5y ago> If they’re settling in rubles or yuan, for most definitions of “easily,” yes. Completely agree with your comment, just wanted to add that the vast majority of international companies will require a settlement in DM currencies (mainly dollar). This ensures that the relative size of the deal stays stable, as these currencies are highly stable and not subject to domestic manipulation. For a deal to be settled in, say, yuan, you would have to be pretty darn sure that your exposure to yuan is highly predominant: your in/outflows will be yuan-relative.
- fuoqi 5y ago>these currencies are highly stable Can you truly call them stable with 7+% official inflation, negative real interest rates, and China owning 3+ trillion USD-nominated assets, which it probably will start to gradually sell in the wake of sanctions against the Central Bank of Russia?
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoNone of these factors, other than inflation, point to instability. With respect to inflation, that’s being directly addressed. Compared to every other currency, historical and extant, the major trading currencies of the day are highly stable across multiples of even the longest transaction time frames. They aren’t good long-term stores of value because that’s not what they’re built for.
- lowkey 5y ago> With respect to inflation, that’s being directly addressed. Please explain. I don’t understand how that’s true. In last night’s SOTU President Biden said inflation was mostly due to car prices or something equally silly. I don’t see any nation seriously addressing inflation which is officially 7.5% but I believe to be much higher for most.
- anonymoushn 5y agoI think there are multiple interest rate hikes planned for this year and the fed will cease marginal asset purchases (but not sell assets).
- lowkey 5y agoWhat if I told you that multiple 0.25% interest rate hikes are unlikely to meaningfully counter 7.5% inflation? The last time the US had inflation this high Volcker had to raise rates to double-digits in order to break the back of inflation. Also, don't forget that 20% of all USD ever printed were printed in the past year and the Fed has made no claims that they plan to taper the money printer anytime soon.
- WoahNoun 5y agoThe 7% inflation number is measured as an increase in prices in consumer goods. Used car prices are up >30% and are a significant piece of consumer spending.
- 5y ago
- imtringued 5y agoThere is truly nothing worse than China giving money to Russia so they can pay off their dollar denominated debts...
- Aperocky 5y agoyuan is highly stable over the past 2 decades, in fact it gained about 20% on the dollar over that time frame. The problem with Yuan are more with its low convertibility (read: usage rate outside China), but that may change eventually. Using currency sanctions to achieve political goals are simultaneously expending trust in those currencies.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> highly stable over the past 2 decades, in fact it gained about 20% Stable or gaining 20%? Also its not stable, nor trustworthy. You can't trust china to not manipulate it.
- CyanBird 5y ago> You can't trust china to not manipulate it. Rather you 'can* trust China to manipulate it when needed, they need the currency to serve specific macroeconomic policy decisions and they will use the levers on their power to achieve it, the fact that western speculators might get burned for it is not a core government interest at this time, maybe in the future
- Aperocky 5y ago> Also its not stable, nor trustworthy. The Euro had much larger fluctuation in the same time frame. Lecture me, are your definition of stable tied to data, or is it tied specifically to your own opinion? How long would it be until you admit it was actually stable? 10 more years? 100? A millennia?
- thematrixturtle 5y agoNot to put too fine a point on it, but the reason the US Federal Reserve exists is to "manipulate" the dollar. Personally, I've always liked Singapore's approach of anchoring the Singapore dollar to a basket of major currencies. However, they also give themselves leeway by not publishing the basket's constituents or weightings, meaning they can still make the dollar dance by tweaking those.
- 5y ago
- im3w1l 5y agoWhat about just... not settling. Like instead, just keep track of which sides owes the other how many dollars, and ensure it doesn't get crazy imbalanced. Or very similarly transact in dollar denominated Chinese/Russian issued bonds.
- lokar 5y agoThe flow won't balance out. One side will run a deficit, as that grows the other side will see growing credit risk. At some point you need to settle.
- webmobdev 5y agoKind of like bartering. India and Iran did something like that, when Iran was sanctioned. Both India and Iran kept track of their foreign trades and issued payment locally. India is also going to do something like that with Russia, if sanctions increase.
- asmithmd1 5y agoWhy does settling in dollars make any difference? Like he said, if the SWIFT secure messaging service goes down, someone at a bank in Japan has the phone number of someone at a bank in New York and can "wire" money with a phone call instead of sending a SWIFT message. Wires will be orders of magnitude slower, but money is not frozen. And the real effect is that someone in Mumbai receiving a phone call from a Russian bank today will be especially careful to cross every T and dot every I.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> someone at a bank in Japan has the phone number of someone at a bank in New York and can "wire" money with a phone call instead of sending a SWIFT message Wires, as the article explains, are just debits and credits. And all non-paper debits and credits of dollars are ultimately governed by the banks’ credits and debits with the Fed. So no, you can’t wire dollars with a phone number if the other side is sanctioned. You can if they’re off SWIFT, but you need someone with an account at the Fed to make those changes.
- sumanthvepa 5y agoBecause every single transaction in USD must result in a credit and debit to an account at the US Federal Reserve (except for transactions entirely in paper money -- this is the reason drug dealers like paper money.) For a transaction denominated Yuan(Renminbi) that transaction must eventually result in a debit and credit entry at the People's Bank of China (the central bank of China). In the latter case no US entity need be involved. The problem with the second transaction is that fewer people are willing transact in Yuan than are willing transact in USD. That is changing though, and quite rapidly. Many countries have switched to trading with Russia in other currencies. For example the Indian government purchases military equipment from Russia using the INR currency and therefore, its payment for such equipment does not flow through any US-connected financial system. The US can still stop such transactions though, through other forms of economic pressure: CAATSA regulation for example. Which is why India is particularly concerned about the Russia/Ukraine conflict. IF the US sanctions India through CAATSA to block it from purchasing Russian military equipment, India will be severely hurt and unable to defend itself against China (one of its two primary security concerns.) So bottom line, one can transact outside of the US financial system, but that is significantly less useful, and also does not mean that the US cannot stop such transactions. In the end the thing that enables the US to affect what other countries do, is the absolutely massive size of its economy relative to others and the absolute dominance of its military relative to that of others. As long as it maintains those two advantages, it will be able cripple any other country -- either through war or economic sanctions.