3 ms·
> Do you mean they try to avoid breaking ABI in a forwards compatible way? Ok, I can see what I have written that could read this way, but the context is compl
by marcosdumay 5y ago
> Do you mean they try to avoid breaking ABI in a forwards compatible way?
Ok, I can see what I have written that could read this way, but the context is completely about backward compatibility. Forward compatibility isn't a concept that appears often in software.
- BeeOnRope 5y agoIt's not about how you wrote it, it's that the "single executable" concept needs both directions of compatibility if you dynamically link libc on any old distro. E.g., you might use a relatively recent distro in your GitHub action (or whatever) to build this binary, but then anyone running CentOS or whatever can't run it because they ship an older libc version and required symbols aren't available.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIf libc is backwards compatible, you immediately have a compatibility matrix that says where your code will run. Quite like you have for any kind of release on any environment. You seem to want some way to have your code run on any platform whatever features you use in it. That you can't have. Of course if you want to support CentOS 6, you have to avoid any new symbol.
- BeeOnRope 5y agoThe problem isn't new symbols, it's that existing symbols can get the new version depending on what version you compile it against. On my glibc ~200 symbols have the newest version (2.34) but these are largely all methods that have been around forever. A binary built here won't run in most places.