7 ms·
I've worked at a startup where everyone being there was essential in how we worked. (We were all pair programming.) It was great. It beats code reviews any day.
by skybrian 5y ago
I've worked at a startup where everyone being there was essential in how we worked. (We were all pair programming.) It was great. It beats code reviews any day. I learned a lot.
But when I was at Google, we would schedule VC meetings with people in a different part of campus just to avoid the walk. Also, I worked on teams that had people worked out in many offices, mostly not Mountain View. I was surrounded by Googlers in an open-plan office, but it was often lonely. I ate alone sometimes. It was often not worth the commute.
I think Google having a company-wide policy on this is nuts. Teams vary a lot. They should probably be left to make their own decisions.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoI tried pairing in an open office environment, and I'd go work at McDonald's for minimum wage before returning to that environment again. It was pure hell for me.
- notreallyserio 5y agoI've never tried it but I feel the same way. If people saw the sort of work I did to test/PoC ideas I think they'd either a) flip their shit or b) stop me in my tracks so they could do it their way. It sounds like an absolutely terrible way to learn and grow as a developer.
- tfsh 5y agoI believe there are teams which will be primarily remote
- UncleMeat 5y agoIndividuals as well. My team is going to mixed-remote. Every single application for full time remote work in my org of hundreds was approved.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> I think Google having a company-wide policy on this is nuts. Teams vary a lot. They should probably be left to make their own decisions. This seems rational until you are actually responsible for managing a large organization. First off, the article itself states that Google is giving a lot of flexibility ("Employees not prepared to return April 4 also can seek a remote-work extension, Google said. Since last June, Google has approved nearly 14,000 employees globally to transfer to a new location or go fully remote, Casey said. About 15% of applications have been denied, he added.") But it get's very difficult to manage a large company without at least some sort of consistent policy.
- bee_rider 5y ago> First off, the article itself states that Google is giving a lot of flexibility > But it get's very difficult to manage a large company without at least some sort of consistent policy. It isn't a contradiction but these two statements seem to at least be in a bit of tension, right?
- skybrian 5y agoYes, there is a great deal of flexibility and patience. I worked from home a couple days a week. In the old days, they drew the line at going full-remote. When the Atlanta office closed, everyone there had to either move somewhere else or, eventually, leave. I guess that's changed.
- Xcelerate 5y agoWhy did that office originally close? And haven’t they opened a new, larger one since then?
- hn_go_brrrrr 5y agoEngineering offices need an exec to serve as site lead. Whoever was there left or moved, and I guess they couldn't find a replacement. There is now an engineering office there again, so someone must have wanted (or been willing) to move there.
- dboreham 5y agoI worked on a Silicon Valley campus in 1999 and it was just the same: most of the people I interacted with _were_ on campus but it was seldom worth schlepping to whatever building they were in so we mostly used netnews and email.
- vl 5y agoThe irony, of course, that working conditions at Google, of all places, are truly atrocious. For years our desks were in hallways (KIR-C, KIR-D). When I left big G, there were desks literally in staircases (KIR-D). I have no idea how they passed fire inspections.
- bseidensticker 5y agoI worked at Google in KIR for the past 5 years. You calling the working conditions "atrocious" is hilarious. This is why people call Googlers entitled.
- Sebb767 5y agoThe OP is talking about tech people, obviously. I don't think we need to discuss that a table in a stair case is still awesome compared to working in a coal mine. But these conditions would be borderline even for a small company on the countryside. Disclaimer: Just going from your two comments, never saw Google's offices.
- nimchimpsky 5y ago
- vkou 5y agoKIR-D legitimately sucks. Giant rooms, fifty million desks in each, not a wall in sight.
- 1024core 5y agoLOL... reminds me of the time I went down to Overture's office in Pasadena. We were supposed to meet some senior engineering guy there. We got out of the elevator, and there was a sea of long tables in that giant floor, wall to wall, with people sitting elbow to elbow. "Wow, this looks like a call center; I'm glad I'm not in customer support", I thought to myself. And then one of guys sitting at those big tables stood up, extending his hand: "Hi, I'm ...., glad to meet you guys". It was that senior engineer. Yikes!
- contingencies 5y agoWhen you work at a startup, VC means venture capital: the lifeblood ever-requisite next-stage of your constant struggle to survive and grow as an early business. When you work at Google, it means technology for avoiding a walk.
- rodgerd 5y ago> But when I was at Google, we would schedule VC meetings with people in a different part of campus just to avoid the walk. This is a solid point; I work for a company that had four key buildings in two cities at the start of the pandemic; in reality, we were a "remote company" who were just rubbish at remote practises. The pandemic forced us to be remote-first, which fed back into being better organised for day-to-day. I suspect most companies have this sort of mixed-model, and are just shitty at remote work. (I will also note, as always, that there is a rich irony that big tech firms who push cloud-everything, remote collaboration tools and so on, won't eat their own dogfood. How much of Google watching Zoom walk away with the video calling market was due to their intransigence on this?)
- lolpython 5y ago> I've worked at a startup where everyone being there was essential in how we worked. (We were all pair programming.) It was great. It beats code reviews any day. I learned a lot. I do pair programming very frequently with my coworkers remotely. We share a VNC connection to a Linux host. It works great.
- jen20 5y agoIndeed - I pair program for much of the day with different people on the same team, and there is only (recently) one city which has two people in it. The notion that pairing need take place physically in the same room is just not correct.
- runevault 5y agoI'd argue pairing is BETTER remote where you both have comfortable access to all your screens. While one person is writing production code, the other can be googling/writing repl style experiments/whatever and in easy communcation while they have the person writing code up on a second screen or at least a background window easily brought back to the foreground.
- carom 5y agoLonely is an incredibly accurate way to describe working at Google. Everyone says the office perks are there to trick you to stay, but our work area was quieter than a library and no one hung around. If people were talking they'd legit catch themselves and be like, we should grab a conference room. Incredibly polite but also an uncomfortably quiet environment. I think a lot of people just wanted to put in their hours and get home to their families. I love pool but never played with anyone on the table one floor down because it just wasn't a make-friends environment. I think I shot the shit with someone when I got into work a handful of times in the more-than-a-year that I worked there. Huge reason I left. This isn't even coming from a social person. I prefer WFH. I don't particularly like going out. However, if I'm gonna be forced to be around people I'd at least like it to be pleasant.
- solididiot 5y agoWorked for a much lesser international company and it was exactly the same minus the politeness. I had to find a quiet corner to get some work done.
- tomcam 5y agoMan that's sad.
- inlined 5y agoI made more enduring friendships in each of my 3yr tenures at Facebook and Microsoft than I did at 8yrs of google
- 3np 5y agoWhy do you think that is?
- inlined 5y agoAt Microsoft there were a lot of discussion lists for niche passions like paintballing (we drove out to the boonies and just pulled into the woods where some people had built bunkers). It was also my first job out of college, so my cohorts were all looking for friendships. At Facebook I was part of a startup acquisition. Those members were battle buddies. Facebook also had a cultural value that you should bring your authentic self to work, which I think led to people bonding better. That or it’s because Facebook threw lots of parties with inappropriate amounts of alcohol
- nsonha 5y ago> pair programming... It was great. It beats code reviews... this false dichotomy again, who said that pair programming was to replace code review, or vice versa?
- scarface74 5y agoConstant pair programming is one of my deal breakers - along with open offices.
- nsonha 5y agoI doubt that this is something everyone has to follow. More likely they'll just keep the option for everyone to apply for approval and then they'll negotiate that with the employees they think don't have leverage. People who have options would quit if forced to be back in office, you can boomerang at Google so it's not like they risk much.