5 ms·
The war is already in the indiscriminate killing phase and moving towards just destroy city phase. Should be there in few days. Slav fellowship does not work i
by watwut 5y ago
The war is already in the indiscriminate killing phase and moving towards just destroy city phase. Should be there in few days.
Slav fellowship does not work in wars. No fellowship works in wars.
- whimsicalism 5y agoRespectfully, the indiscriminate killing we have seen so far - while awful - does not even remotely hold a candle to what happened in Syria. They are clearly pulling their punches, likely because of the ethnic/racial dynamics of this conflict.
- watwut 5y agoThey expected to win quickly and easily - and are shocked it did not happened. Whether they pull the punches will be seen later. Historically, there was not much holding back punches between Russia and Ukraine. You may start reading about Holodomor, which is still debated whether it counts as genocide or not. For that matter, historically, Russia holding punches was not exactly the thing. Not even toward Russians. The original propaganda line was that Ukrainians are basically Russians being taken home now. That nonsense was shattered by now. The idea that this will stop punches now that they are refusing, purely because both are white, is something only Americans can think. ----------- War in Syria did not started by indiscriminate bombing of cities. It got there through series of escalations when rebels refused to give up.
- _pd19 5y agoSo many mis-statements of fact here. > They expected to win quickly and easily - and are shocked it did not happened. Very possible, but neither you nor me are in the position to know that. > Holodomor, which is still debated whether it counts as genocide or not. For that matter, historically, Russia holding punches was not exactly the thing. Not even toward Russians. The Holodomor was clearly a completely orthogonal issue to this as it wasn't a military conflict. > Not even toward Russians. What are you referencing in terms of conflict? Probably not chechens, because that would only go in favor of GPs point. > War in Syria did not started by indiscriminate bombing of cities. It got there through series of escalations when rebels refused to give up. Russia started intervening in 2015, 4 years into the civil war, and immediately began with indiscriminate bombardment of cities like Raqqa (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_military_intervention_in_the_Syrian_civil_war#September%E2%80%93October_2015 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_military_intervention_...) > The idea that this will stop punches now that they are refusing, purely because both are white, is something only Americans can think. The domestic opposition in Russia over killing far fewer people is already much larger than it was to the intervention over Syria which killed far more civilians early on. It is not something "only Americans can think" that Russians care more about the lives of people of close ethnic relation to them as compared to Syrians.
- watwut 5y agoHolodomor is relevant, ot orthogonal. I meant purgers, internal thing toward Russians. Oh, and yes, 2011 to 2015 is long time of escalations. The question is whether they will pull punches when ennemy don't give up.
- MiroF 5y ago> Holodomor is relevant, ot orthogonal. > I meant purgers, internal thing toward Russians. Neither of those were covered on the TV. They are also from over half a century ago. > 2011 to 2015 is long time of escalations. But 2014 to 2022 isn't? The idea that Russians care equally about the lives of Syrians and the lives of ethnic Russians & Ukrainians is fantasy. It's obviously false, even if Russians killed Russians in purges 60 years ago.
- watwut 5y agoRussian TV is not broadcasting Ukraine war. For that matter, western tvs are not broadcasting full brutality of wars either. It is all sanitized for viewers good feelings. > 2014 to 2022 Sure, Ukraine actually got ready to defend. Russia actually got to the point of being ready to start war again. But, actual full war started last week with hope of 96 hours till victory, installation of puppet goverment and weak divided west. They wanted them to be kind of like Belarus, useful for further own plans. > The idea that Russians care equally about the lives of Syrians and the lives of ethnic Russians & Ukrainians is fantasy. It's obviously false, even if Russians killed Russians in purges 60 years ago. They don't care about Ukrainians lives at all. If they keep not winning, they will move to deep active hate. Ukrainians are already nazi for them and that includes the Jewish president. And that sentiment is real inside Russians who do believe oficial version. Purges were not 60 years ago. They were the thing Stalin shot himself into own leg right before WWII. But, fuckup at start is on brand here. Stalin has raising popularity as maligned father of Russia in Russia last 10-15 years.
- foverzar 5y ago> Historically, there was not much holding back punches between Russia and Ukraine. You may start reading about Holodomor, which is still debated whether it counts as genocide or not. This is such a demagogy and a narrow-sighted view of history. It is always brought up only for the purpose of pouring more oil on the flames and turning up nationalistic tensions. Holodomor has nothing to do with Ukrainians or Russians. It had happened all over the Soviet Union. Much more Kazakhs had died relatively to their total population, and almost the same amount of Russians in an absolute value. Hungers of 1930s were a global event, not something conjured by one particularly nasty Georgian.
- tapas73 5y agoSome proof would be nice. Wikipedia mentions that it is contested if it is intentional or not. Personaly for me, intentionality doesn't seem far fetched, given gulags, forced relocations to siberia without supplies and liberal presentation of history/facts (ussr guides said that kaliningrad is russian from olden times).
- cagey 5y ago> Hungers of 1930s were a global event, not something conjured by one particularly nasty Georgian. Aside from Ukraine and Kazakhstan (both under the control of "one particularly nasty Georgian") which other regions of the globe suffered from mass (1+ million) deaths caused by famine in the 1930s?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- geoka9 5y ago> They are clearly pulling their punches, likely because of the ethnic/racial dynamics of this conflict. The goals are different. It's not like they are trying to make Syria part of the new Russian Empire.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoAt 80% conscription rate, the RF army is seriously vulnerable to mass-realization of international views. Many young Russians were deceived into this war and would rather be with their families.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoIs this something we, hackers/information technology specialists, could try to achieve?
- spacemanmatt 5y agoYou can donate money directly to the Ukraine army. Sometimes there are browser-hosted DDoS links posted here but they don't always last. You can lobby satellite firms to provide real-time video to Ukrainians.
- nonrandomstring 5y agoYes, I'd love to see more chatter on here about creative info/psyops. The fact that Russian troops are using smartphones and Google leaves them wide open. We have starlink sats above them and control DNS. Hell, we could probably convince them they'd already won and been ordered home.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoIt won't be here. The community here is organized along principles of startup capitalism, not activism.
- nonrandomstring 5y ago> It won't be here. The community here is organized along principles of startup capitalism, not activism. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30528382 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30528382 Is it possible this community you claim to speak for is not everything you think it is?
- jeffreyrogers 5y ago> Slav fellowship does not work in wars. No fellowship works in wars. Historically combatants have treated their opponents differently based on race and existing cultural attitudes. Don't see why it would be any different this time around.
- edmundsauto 5y agoThat doesn’t mean it’s predictable. Could be they treat their fellow Slavs worse!
- jazzyjackson 5y agoTim Dillon had a Ukrainian comedian call in to his podcast who made the quip, yes we are family, but families can hate each other even more than strangers.
- adventured 5y agoThere's plenty of history for how the Russians treat the people of Ukraine, we don't need to guess.
- Banana699 5y ago>Historically combatants have treated their opponents differently based on race and existing cultural attitudes Huh? when have that ever been true? European religious wars have been huge bloodsheds, communist regimes routinely genocided their own (often quite homogenous) populations, Lebanon's civil war saw neighbors shooting at each other. The truth of the matter is : when people want to fight, they will find something that makes their enemies different and alien, because it's uncomfortable to imagine yourself in the place of the dead body that was previously a living human. Race and Blood just so happen to be very convenient to latch on, because they're immutable (for now) genetic characteristics that make the gulf between you and your enemies look huge, a very desirable property in a dehumanization tactic. When people don't have those, they start latching on less immutable but nonetheless difficult-to-change things like religion, language and culture. And when people don't have those either, they start latching onto who their enemies voted for in the last election or their stance on <insert pet issue>, which are very mutable but also very numerous and can always be found and used as basis for dehumanization, their mutabilitiy and arbitrariness notwithstanding.
- glogla 5y agoYes, after Grozny and Aleppo, anyone saying Russians are trying to limit destruction is deluded or a shill. Russian military strategy has been to force surrender through causing as much civilian death as possible for a while now. Based on his speeches, both before invasion and the leaked one that was supposed to go out after a win, Putins objective is genocide. "The Ukrainian question", dude is literally quoting Hitler.
- platinumrad 5y agoThere is a huge difference between what people are willing to do to racial and cultural others v.s. what they are willing to do to people who look, speak, and live more or less just like them. Yes, Russia was extremely brutal in Chechnya and in Syria. But consider how brutal the US was in Iraq, and consider how we would operate in a hypothetical war against Canada.
- phicoh 5y agoThere is not much difference bwtween people from Germany, France and the UK, yet, World War I was one of the most horrible wars in history. A few decades later, there still was not much difference between people from the UK and Germany yet the bombings of the German cities by the allied forces were some of the horrible in history. Read https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Dresden_in_World_War_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Dresden_in_World_Wa... for one of the full horror stories.
- SyzygistSix 5y agoIf the US was taking over Canada, I think we might approach it in a gentler way then Iraq or Afghanistan.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> Slav fellowship does not work in wars. No fellowship works in wars. There's plenty of videos of Russian troops not attacking civilians and surrendering. But there's also videos of them attacking civilian targets... It seems there's some Slavic fellowship at play but that it's mostly among regular soldiers, not the leadership. Then again, maybe the gross incompetence shown by the Russians is a result of said fellowship + plausible deniability... Either way, the war's gone shockingly bad for the Russians. Whether or not Ukraine's reports are entirely correct, everyone can agree it's embarrassing to the Russians.
- squarefoot 5y agoAlso the number of Russian news sources closed and journalists arrested, fired from govt aligned media, or willing to leave the country is increasing daily. That would be an indicator that the Russian regime is deeply concerned about the public not falling for that propaganda anymore.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]