11 ms·
How does perspective work in pictures?
- Gravityloss 5y agoMost of this article is not very informative, it boils down to the fact that to get better photos you should just use a longer focal length aka zoom in a bit and also take a few steps back.
- TremendousJudge 5y agodid you even read it? it says nothing of the sort
- dang 5y agoWould you kindly stop breaking the site guidelines? You've been doing it repeatedly, unfortunately, and we've had to ask you repeatedly not to. In this case you broke this one: "Please don't comment on whether someone read an article. "Did you even read the article? It mentions that" can be shortened to "The article mentions that."" More generally, you've been breaking this one: "Be kind. Don't be snarky." If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- TremendousJudge 5y agoMy apologies. I haven't been in the best of moods lately. I will stick more firmly to the guidelines in the future. I really appreciate the civility of the discussion here compared to the rest of the net, and I want to keep it that way.
- GabrielMtn 5y agoNo to be preachy, but if you’re struggling a lot make sure you’re doing enough self care, I like long walks, it’s so easy to forget to make time when so much is happening in the world.
- gfody 5y agoappreciate calling out middle brow dismissals which is a uniquely hn problem and probably too subjective to write a policy against
- dang 5y agoThat is hardly a "uniquely hn problem", that is a human nature problem! And there is a good guideline against it: "Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something." (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html) That's a direct reference to pg's original concept of middlebrow dismissal. We just changed the word from 'middlebrow' to 'shallow' because the word 'middlebrow' often comes across as a putdown and also often comes across as labeling a person rather than a post. Commenters who've actually read an article are always welcome to respond with accurate, interesting information from the article. That's a fine contribution. What's not fine is the "did you even read the article" internet trope.
- Gabriel_Martin 5y ago
- kingcharles 5y agoThere has been a lot of press around the HN moderation, mostly shock at the small size of the team doing it, but also around the bigger point, which is the care that HN shows about keeping its community in some sort of order. I've built and run huge online communities in the past, and they have died by 1000 paper cuts. Little bits of snark building up like fat on the walls of an artery until the clot ruptures. I've tried installing moderators I trusted, but without exception each one would turn into a fascist dictator stomping on accounts until everyone feared to speak. I had to fire them all. The biggest problem here is that HN moderators are not replicable or replaceable. There is a quote I can't find about how the type of person who wants to be a politician is exactly the sort you don't want. The reason HN mods are so good is because they didn't want the job, they fell into it. But it also has to be heartbreaking work, like those in the Third World who moderate the main social networks watching beheadings and child abuse all day. Eventually it will take its toll and I don't know how the fuck HN will operate when it has to find replacements.
- dang 5y agoI thought of some things to say in response to this but I'm late for a training I'm in. Hopefully I'll remember to come back here later.
- kragen 5y agoI'm interested.
- dang 5y agoI'm sorry - I just ran out of time and steam. It's a constant challenge. The topic will come up again sometime though.
- kragen 5y agoNo worries, I know you're busy, and the last couple of weeks must have been especially draining. You don't owe me the satisfaction of my curiosity. (And, just in case there's any misunderstanding, I am possibly the person worst suited for helping out with moderation that I know, so I'm not offering help --- though I wish I could.)
- shuntress 5y agoTo help contextualize this response: The entire opening of the article feels like an extremely heavy handed introduction to "Photography 103 - Focal Length and How to Use It" without ever really explaining focal length even while a basic understanding of focal length & "compression" remains relevant to the topic the article veers into.
- Gravityloss 5y agoThey do have a point. It's just "beating around the bush" so much. Focal length, distortion, projection. I guess I'm just too cranky for it.
- shuntress 5y agoI should have been more clear. I'm basically agreeing with you. It feels like the article is constantly about to say something like "Here's an example where I used a 50mm and you can see how much more closely it matches the painting and my recollection" or something like that before then going on to talk about how perspective in photography is essentially a tradeoff with field-of-view. But it... just doesn't do that and so ends up with this awkward feeling mismatch with reader expectation (for me, at least). I don't necessarily begrudge the article for it but I do share your frustration.
- Gravityloss 5y agoYeah, I got that!
- feintruled 5y agoMust have been quite an event, the invention of perspective in art. Imagine the feeling of looking upon such a drawing when you had seen nothing like it before. I imagine it must have been utterly transformative to your perception of what is possible, like someone showing you a new colour. (Or did they just go, 'oh cool'?)
- peterfield 5y agoI think this illusion is based on the same effect: https://www.reddit.com/r/blackmagicfuckery/comments/t5xwts/flowers_appear_to_expand/ https://www.reddit.com/r/blackmagicfuckery/comments/t5xwts/f...
- amirmaleki 5y agoIt can be nice (and perhaps lucrative) if you present this to Rockstar or some other open-world game producer.
- agency 5y agoI've noticed this a lot at home. I live in western WA and am lucky to have, on a clear day, a pretty breathtaking view of Mt. Rainier. But pictures never do justice to the sense of scale you get in person. It looks enormous on the horizon but in pictures it's rather small and mundane.
- Kayou 5y agoWhat lense do you have to take your picture ? You might want to zoom a bit to make it look like you see it, at least a 100mm equivalent I would say.
- Forgeties79 5y ago100mm is far, far tighter than what the human eye sees. You need to be closer to 40-50mm on a full frame.
- function_seven 5y agoI think this is what separates a good photographer from... me. I've tried various zoom levels before—and aspect ratios, focal lengths, etc—but I can never capture in an image what I'm seeing with my eyes. Either the enormous mountain is a tiny feature off in the distance, or it fills the frame and all context is lost. I can't seem to find a framing that communicates both the grandness of the subject, and the larger context it's situated in. Obviously a 2D, cropped image of the landscape is going to have to lose information compared to my 3D, panoramic view of it. But I also know I've seen good photos of these types of things. What are those photographers doing to capture that?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Aaargh20318 5y ago> I can never capture in an image what I'm seeing with my eyes. Either the enormous mountain is a tiny feature off in the distance, or it fills the frame and all context is lost Try adding a sense of depth by having a foreground, middle and back. Look at good landscape photos of mountains or other large features and you’ll see they almost always do this. By having near, mid and far elements of interest you add a sense of scale to the photo.
- TehShrike 5y agoWell, this blew my mind. Are there any iOS camera apps that will let me experiment with taking "natural perspective" photos?
- namanyayg 5y ago+1. Any android apps? I've noticed this so much in landscape photography it hurts.
- spython 5y agoNot quite the same, but I quite enjoyed PicPlane https://blog.mattbierner.com/pic-plane-1-1/ https://blog.mattbierner.com/pic-plane-1-1/ by Matt Bierner who has quite a few of similar experimental visual perception apps.
- mabub24 5y agoThis is a topic where having knowledge of art history helps quite a lot. One could make an entire university course around the ways artists have grappled with perspective over time. Just coming to grips with the fact that linear perspective is something we learn to understand as "natural", as communicating a scene or image in such and such a way, despite it being an artistic technique for representing 3d shapes on a 2d surface from a fixed point(s) of view, can be a big way to get people over the hump and to appreciate non-representational art, or even just the works of 20th and 19th century modernist painters like Picasso or Cezanne.
- zokier 5y agoI remember reading bit more on the work from fovotec authors (Pepperell et al), and while there are some interesting ideas in there, the majority of papers etc had heavy snakeoil/pseudoscience smell. It would be nice if someone grabbed those ideas and took a more rigorous approach to solve the same problems. That being said, the blog post is nice survey of the wider field so that's nice at least. Previous discussion on "FOVO" rendering (which has high overlap with the topic) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26795290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26795290
- belfalas 5y agoReally interesting article! For anyone curious about perspective in art, see the book "Perspective Made Easy" by Ernest Norling. It is easy to follow and has simple helpful exercises. A more technical and challenging book is "How to Draw" by Scott Robertson. That one is good if you want more technical theory understanding (plus the illustrations are amazing).
- dsign 5y agoAhh, I love this article. I'm among those that dislike all my photos with small objects that don't look as I see them. I guess building photo optics that do not use linear perspective is out of the question. I haven't got time to read all the papers they are referencing (currently searching for a new computer vision job, and there is so much in that area that I can't really read everything), but I wonder how many techniques to computationally change the perspective of the image depend on LIDAR depth information, how many on guessing depth via some other means (e.g. neural networks), and how many on neither?
- gfody 5y agothis is fascinating stuff, the software experiments made me wonder if lightfield cameras will do better or at least enable smarter perspective algorithms
- Cieric 5y agoI ended up reading one of the referenced articles too since it captured my interest https://www.gamedeveloper.com/disciplines/fovo-a-new-3d-rendering-technique-based-on-human-vision https://www.gamedeveloper.com/disciplines/fovo-a-new-3d-rend... all of this looks interesting. I would love to add these correction and similar to my game engine to experiment with it, but fovotec seems to have to be paid/contacted for. I might try and replicate what the author of the main article showed at the end. Does anyone know of any more references to the 3d rendering side of this topic? Edit: Added words for clarity.
- kwertyops 5y agoIt looks like Unreal Engine (which is not open source, but you can get access to the source code) has a "Panini Projection" which does something similar: https://docs.unrealengine.com/4.27/en-US/RenderingAndGraphics/PostProcessEffects/PaniniProjection/ https://docs.unrealengine.com/4.27/en-US/RenderingAndGraphic...
- ISL 5y agoPerspective is a huge challenge in photography, in some respects a central challenge. Here's [1] an image, made with a rectilinear lens, which manages to convey oodles of depth and structure. It is difficult to overstate how challenging it can be to express that level of depth in a flat image. When people talk about how a focal-length "compresses" or "exaggerates" an image, what they're really talking about is perspective. Each field of view carries with it its own perspective. Variable focal-length ("zoom") lenses encourage us to select our subject and composition first, then choose a perspective to match. Frequently, it is more important to begin with our desired subject and the perspective with which we wish the viewer to see it (focal-length), then figure out how to build a composition to match. A 24-70 mm lens isn't really a lens, it is at least six lenses with significantly-different perspectives: 24, 28, 35, 40, 50, and 70mm, each of which can take a lifetime to master. One can deliver the perception that Hertzmann is after with a rectilinear lens, but it isn't easy. Composition, lighting, and dodging/burning are all tools to that end. Think about your memory of the Tank Man in Tiananmen Square, now look at the image [2]. I bet he's a much smaller part of the frame than you recall, yet he utterly dominates your perception of the image, even when you look at the actual rectilinear image. [1] https://www.phillips.com/detail/HENRI-CARTIER-BRESSON/NY040517/37 https://www.phillips.com/detail/HENRI-CARTIER-BRESSON/NY0405... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_Man https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tank_Man
- spoonjim 5y agoNo, the Tank Man picture isn't surprising at all. The defining property of that image is that he is small, but willing to stand up to those tanks. My memory was correct -- it is a picture of a very small object standing in front of several extremely large objects.
- formerly_proven 5y ago> When people talk about how a focal-length "compresses" or "exaggerates" an image, what they're really talking about is perspective. Each field of view carries with it its own perspective. This is kind of a misconception because what creates perspective distortion is not a given field of view, but the distance to the subject. That's why short (50-100 mm) macro lenses have a lot of perspective despite a clearly tele angle of view; you get very close to the subject. Someone using a 55 mm macro lens for photography of small products tends to be pretty obvious because of the strong perspective, things look distorted and "bulging". Of course subject size / angle of view => distance so it still kinda works.
- f154hfds 5y agoLinear perspective has some fun implications that I think about a lot. Apply a linear operator to a line and you get another line. This is obvious but the inverse is also true: if a line is a result of a linear operator the input was also a line. This is fun to think about when looking at jet contrails and bridges, the milkyway and pretty much any curve you have looked at your whole life. If it isn't straight as you see it then it's not straight in reality.
- deadbeeves 5y agoThe article is close, but doesn't quite get there. The problem is not the image itself or how it's taken, but rather how it's displayed. When you look at the world through your eyeballs, your brain recreates the scene so that it wraps around an imaginary point in mental space, so to speak. Things that are to your right "appear to your right" in your mind. When you're looking at a photograph, regardless of how much field of view it was taken with, it's displayed in a very small portion of your entire field of vision, even if you're looking at it on a computer monitor; it's even worse if you're looking at it on a phone. You're basically always looking at it zoomed out. It would be possible to recreate the scene exactly as it would have appeared if your eye was where the camera was when the photo was taken, but you'd need to blow it up on a huge screen, like a movie theater screen, and stand fairly close to it. Then you'd be able to see that actually most lenses other than fisheyes have fairly narrow field of views.
- hoseja 5y agoI love photospheres for this reason. Damn, I haven't been outside properly and taken a nice photosphere in a long time.
- blocko 5y agoThey mention this under the "What if there is no true perspective?" section: Second, they point out that viewers almost always view pictures from the “wrong” location. A cornerstone of linear perspective is the idea that the viewer must be at the focal center of the image to view it correctly. If you view a linear perspective image from the focal center, it should be like looking through a window—indeed, Leonardo da Vinci wrote that linear perspective images only work from the focal center. Yet, in reality we don’t do this. Most of the photos we look at would have to be viewed with one’s eye a few inches from the page. People in art galleries walk all around and view paintings from all sorts of angles. Hence, the whole idea of linear perspective falls apart.
- radlad 5y agoPhotography + VR headsets will be interesting.
- egypturnash 5y agoAn important thing missed here: according to the EXIF data in them, these photos are all taken with an iPhone XS. That means they are taken with a tiny wide angle lens. You'd get a very different shot if you took out a dedicated camera with a physically larger lens and a smaller angle. The overall thrust of this article touches on this when it starts discussing different focal lengths, but the fact that the engineers at Apple made a particular set of choices with their lenses that are a compromise between "what can be achieved with a tiny flat lens measured in millimeters" and "what provides a mostly-acceptable image in any situation", and are very not the choices one might make for specifically photographing a portrait or a landscape or whatever, is really never remarked on.
- user-the-name 5y ago
- shuntress 5y agoThe article mentions "Correct" perspective several times and seems like it is leading into an explanation of why 50mm is generally accepted as the most natural match to the human eye's perspective. But, it never really gets there.
- Forgeties79 5y agoYeah, it’s sort of a semi-conventional (and somewhat controversial) statement in the film/photo world to say that 50mm lens on a full frame sensor/35mm stock is “what people see.” Some argue it’s closer to 35-40mm. Some argue it’s all moot. Maybe he ultimately just decided not to firmly stick by it haha
- thequux 5y agoYou can figure out "natural" focal length by taking a printed photograph, holding it at a comfortable viewing distance, and measuring that distance. Now, scale all of those distances down until the photo is the size of your imaging surface (24x36mm for 135 film, better known these days as "full-frame"). Normally, for a 4x5" photo, you'll naturally hold it about 6" from your face, which is pretty close to 150mm. Ergo, the "normal" lens for 4x5 cameras was 150mm. If you scale that down to the "35mm" 24x36 frame, though, you'll discover that that's closer to 40mm. This is not a mistake; IIRC, one of the early 135 camera makers found it easier to make a 50mm lens than a 40mm lens, and it's stuck ever since. It so happens that a normal lens has a FOV of about 1 radian, so the normal focal length is approximately the diagonal of the image surface. A proof of that is left as an exercise for the reader.
- TrevorJ 5y agoThis is dancing around the real issue - there are many different district processes that our eyes use which fuse into a sense of 'being there'. Any attempt to compress this into a single monographic static image will be a compromise.
- kingcharles 5y agoThis article was fascinating and I can easily see this being the next feature that smartphone manufacturers will add to their camera apps. Most of the time I'm taking a photo I'm trying for something that will look really cool when I post it online, I'm not after a scientifically "accurate" representation of the scene. Smartphone hardware has hit a temporary wall that might last another 5 or 10 years, software is the only battleground right now.
- doomlaser 5y agoOne of the coolest things about the Renaissance was the discovery of how to render perspective in drawings and paintings. The technique was spread greatly by the Italian book de Pictura, written by the humanist and artist Leon Battista Alberti in 1435. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_pictura https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/De_pictura It reminds me of viral art tutorials you see spread on Twitter today, for things like video game artists and developers. The illustrations still hold up, hundreds of years later: https://twitter.com/Doomlaser/status/978211776167923712 https://twitter.com/Doomlaser/status/978211776167923712 Prior to this discovery and the book, Italian paintings had a very muddled perspective, because people just didn't know how it worked. You'd also often see Madonna and Child paintings with an absurdly large baby, to signal divinity: https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/api/collection/v1/iiif/459136/914067/main-image https://collectionapi.metmuseum.org/api/collection/v1/iiif/4... https://www.1st-art-gallery.com/frame-preview/7859545.jpg?sku=Unframed&thumb=0&huge=1 https://www.1st-art-gallery.com/frame-preview/7859545.jpg?sk...
- leni536 5y ago> For example, here’s Turner’s High Street, Oxford and a photograph from the same spot, taken 200 years later Those are not from the same spot. The painting is from further back, and captures a narrower field of view.
- cpcallen 5y agoYes, exactly. You need only look at the angles of the crenellated roof of the tower on the left. While the kinds of photographic manipulations that the article ends up discussing are technically and artistically interesting, almost everything else discussed seems to be based on a fundamental misapprehension about what is really going on.
- bsenftner 5y agoReminds me of this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26795290 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26795290 the FOVO Renderer that uses a variable zoom based on 2D distance from the center of focus, which is more similar to human vision.
- samatman 5y agoA sentence at the end of the article helped me understand why looking at photos on a 12.9" iPad feels uniquely pleasurable to me: I can, and naturally do, hold the device such that the image fills my focal length. Phones are of course too small, but my laptop screen, while larger, isn't as nice, even for photos in landscape perspective, because it's subjectively smaller in terms of the field of view it fills. I'm estimating I naturally use a laptop about twice as far from my eyes as an iPad.
- globular-toast 5y agoThis makes me think of cinema. Most people who watch films at home watch them on a far smaller screen than they were made for and the picture encompasses a far smaller portion of the field of view. Cinemascope films are supposed to fill almost all of the horizontal field of view. IMAX films are supposed to fill your entire field of view (extending right into the peripheral). I'm sure many people have tried, like me, to sit closer to the screen so it fills more of your field of view. But even though the angle might be the same, the experience is not. This is true even if you view with one eye. So it makes me think there is something else at play other than just viewing angles.
- pier25 5y agoOff topic but the lighthouse in the video is at the Cap de Formentor in Mallorca. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formentor_Lighthouse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formentor_Lighthouse
- aeturnum 5y agoIf you like this there's actually a lot of work on this kind of topic in media studies! I particularly liked Nonhuman Photography[1] by Joanna Zylinska. [1] https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/nonhuman-photography https://mitpress.mit.edu/books/nonhuman-photography
- fungiblecog 5y agoThis is all very interesting but it’s not really about perspective. Perspective is fixed based on the relative positions of the objects. What changes is how we perceive perspective when we squash a representation of a wide angle of view - ie what our eyes actually see - into a much smaller area (ie a photo or painting). Stated like that it’s obvious that they can’t possibly look the same and you either get disappointment - the photo doesn’t look how you saw the scene - or if you’re an artist you deviate from reality to make a better painting. If you make a really big photo and stand at the right viewing distance everything will look right
- nayuki 5y agoCorrect. Perspective only depends on where the eye is in relation to where the objects are. The fact that the drawings don't match the photos isn't because of perspective, but instead because of projection. Similarly, a fisheye lens has the same perspective as a rectilinear lens, but has a different projection.
- foxhop 5y agoi <3 ur "life art".