7 ms·
This is surprisingly detailed: “ Weather: An invasion that begins in January or February would have the advantage of frozen ground to support the cross-country
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
This is surprisingly detailed:
“ Weather: An invasion that begins in January or February would have the advantage of frozen ground to support the cross-country movement of a large mechanized force. It would also mean operating in conditions of freezing cold and limited visibility. January is usually the coldest and snowiest month of the year in Ukraine, averaging 8.5 hours of daylight during the month and increasing to 10 hours by February.8 This would put a premium on night fighting capabilities to keep an advance moving forward. Should fighting continue into March, mechanized forces would have to deal with the infamous Rasputitsa, or thaw.”
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThat "surprising detail" is a second nature consideration for anyone operating mechanized forces or even just dealing with heavy machinery in that part of the world. It's as "goes without saying" to them as planning work to avoid scorching temperatures is to someone in the tropics. Anyone seeking to predict actions in that part of the world will naturally account for it the same way someone making an investment in a Saudi construction project will base their timelines around an expectation that concrete pads can't be poured 24/7 in summer. Russia knows it. Ukraine knows it. The Ottomans back in the 1400s knew it. Just because some other profession is a black box relative to your knowledge base doesn't mean every detail is one that anyone who begins obtaining knowledge of the field will not instantly pick up. Remember this next time someone on the internet tries to pass themself off as a professional roofer because they know not to peel the plastic off the bottom of the shingle (it literally says not to on it).
- saiya-jin 5y agoreality seems to strongly disagree with your statements
- mensetmanusman 5y agoKnowledge that comes as second nature can also be referred to as tacit knowledge, and is not usually written down for a variety of reasons. The ‘surprising’ part in my end comes from being jaded with how shallow so much media is today. It was refreshing to see details like this written down because it’s simultaneously obvious and true, and it lends credence to their analysis.
- pjc50 5y agoThey're not really "media", they're analysts. CSIS is a think tank funded by Bank of America, Northrop Grumman, etc. https://www.csis.org/corporation-and-trade-association-donors https://www.csis.org/corporation-and-trade-association-donor... A think tank can be there to manufacture support for an ideological position, but it can also be used to do actual thinking.
- CRConrad 5y ago> A think tank can be there to manufacture support for an ideological position, but it can also be used to do actual thinking. The latter kind is of course the origin of the whole concept, but one can't help feeling that the overwhelming majority nowadays is the former.
- baybal2 5y agoThere are very few real think tanks left. A typical Western "military analyst" these days often comes with a law degree, MBA, or even a financial guy, sometimes with few years of service, or a stint in Westpoint, clinging for a claim of being "serious subject matter expert," and making money off that. As I said few times over this week, a lot of them don't even know the difference in between a tank, and an APC, so bad it is really. And Western politicians listen to them...
- thereddaikon 5y agoOr put more correctly, think tanks are collections of analysts who get paid to do research and generate reports on said research. This is often done to support an agenda on behalf of the one paying for it. But doesn't automatically make the research invalid.
- baybal2 5y agoI myself rang the bell as well, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30453790 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30453790 This is what happens when politicians go straight deny military professionals eminence over military strategy just to make a point.
- ericmay 5y agoSame. I wish I had thought to short Russian index funds or just buy put options or something. I bet a friend a 6-pack it would happen within two weeks which ended on February 4th because Russia needed to move as fast as possible if they were going to go for it. Every day they waited was a day for Ukraine to organize and another shipment of missiles and supplies to land.
- kaesar14 5y agoApply that argument to Iraq in 2003 then, the military really got that one right. It’s a black stain so large it’s amazing you think anyone will ever trust the military-industrial complex again.
- seanw444 5y agoThe media will cook up a story so outrageous and angering, nobody will notice the MIC brewing underneath. I doubt many people learned from the middle-east.
- SantalBlush 5y ago>nobody will notice the MIC brewing underneath. Many people saw through the phony pretenses for the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. I'm not sure why so much of HN pretends otherwise. I guess they believe that if they were duped, and they're super smart, then surely everyone else must have been duped as well. This couldn't be further from the truth. There were many people calling these wars BS from the start.
- seanw444 5y ago
- arbuge 5y ago> Should fighting continue into March, mechanized forces would have to deal with the infamous Rasputitsa, or thaw.” That's a key point. It does go to show that the Russians expected this to be a very short affair. I wonder if they have any real contingency plans for when that thaw sets in.
- hef19898 5y agoIt would be almost ironic if, of all the armies in the world, the Russians would be caught unprepared by Rasputitsa. And quite embarrassing, to be honest.
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoglobal warming has its benefits.
- seanw444 5y agoThey'll never live it down.
- mattbrewsbytes 5y agoThere are reports of Russian forces running out of fuel and food. It sounds like with the thaw if Ukraine's forces focus on shutting down major roads then the current "siege warfare" approach by Russia may backfire badly. If their supply lines are easily cut off, they siege themselves.
- spiralx 5y agoHow do you invade somewhere and not have contingencies for being denied the use of major roads? That's in the top three essential (and obvious!) things the defending force will do. For a Russian force you'd also think dealing with a post-winter thaw would be part of their general military strategy, it's not like Ukraine has a vastly different climate than Russia after all.
- omgJustTest 5y agoThe current reports are fuel shortages are at least partially self-sabotage (hole in the gas tank), Russia has mandatory conscription. It does look like low morale and dissent are not insignificant. And when people stop “tanks with their hands” it’s not because of technical logistics.
- pjc50 5y agoMeanwhile social media has plenty of images of alleged Russian vehicles that have got stuck. It's not just ordinary squishy ground, the area between Belarus and Kyiv is the Pripyat marshes!
- llampx 5y agoI've seen many photos of Russian tanks and armored vehicles stuck in mud. Rasptitsa may have come early this year.
- T-A 5y agoI think February was unusually mild. Temperatures have been mostly above freezing for weeks in Kyiv: https://www.timeanddate.com/weather/ukraine/kyiv/historic https://www.timeanddate.com/weather/ukraine/kyiv/historic
- kqr 5y agoI'm still wondering whether the invasion was delayed into late February for concerns about omikron covid-19 rendering the army even less effective. I haven't heard that discussed but it seems like a plausible concern.
- sgc 5y agoThere is some chance that US and other countries making a lot of noise about false flags set back the timetable, just enough to allow the thaw to come into play in an early thaw year. They could have had logistical difficulties just getting into formation, etc. There does not need to be just one reason, but yes covid could be one such reason.
- okl 5y agoOr possibly not wanting to steal the thunder from the Olympics in China. Who knows, the important part is that Russia loses the war.
- jannes 5y agoWouldn't they wait for the Paralympics to finish as well then?
- __s 5y agoNo
- sgc 5y agoI agree, not so much about stealing the thunder, but trying to limit the bad optics to reduce sanctions. They clearly underestimated the way other countries would react if that is the case. They could also have made some sort of agreement with China specifically to secure limited response in exchange for waiting.
- lnsru 5y agoOlympic Games in China. My uneducated guess.