7 ms·
The Ukranian social media propaganda operation is just incredible, and they should keep at it because I think it's been a big part of the massive popular suppor
by pjc50 5y ago
The Ukranian social media propaganda operation is just incredible, and they should keep at it because I think it's been a big part of the massive popular support in the West causing rapid government and NGO response to the invasion.
Conversely they've been pretty effective at stopping information about their own disposition of forces being posted to social media, or at least it's not being retweeted anywhere I've seen.
- yossarian1408 5y agoIt's not their propaganda operation, it's ours.
- emteycz 5y agoYou're flattering yourself too much. Ukrainians had the last 8 years to train and practice. They're one of the best now. Others will be coming to ask them for help, not the other way around.
- matwood 5y agoIt's a combination. The US releasing intelligence early on as it came out cut the knees out of the Russian disinformation campaign. So much so, I suspect it may become the new doctrine. Ukraine, and Zelensky in particular, have also taken full advantage of social media.
- pjc50 5y agohttps://en.interfax.com.ua/about.html https://en.interfax.com.ua/about.html looks pretty Ukranian to me?
- TMWNN 5y agoyossarian1408 means that CIA/MI6 are almost certainly running Ukraine's PR.
- fmajid 5y agoYour misplaced faith in the competence of the CIA is almost adorable. Small countries like Israel or Ukraine actually have to have competent intelligence services because their survival depends on it.
- acdha 5y agoWhich is a pretty bold claim, completely unsupported by evidence. The Ukraine has a ton of highly-proficient very online people, the idea that they need shadowy outside help seems like an attack more than a serious claim.
- dannyw 5y agoCome on, you literally think the Central Intelligence Agency, the poster child for psy-ops, is not doing psy-ops right now??? That's like saying there's no evidence the NSA has saved this exact message in Xkeyscore.
- watwut 5y agoWhich is entirely different claim then "CIA/MI6 are almost certainly running Ukraine's PR".
- drran 5y agoCIA cannot defend USA from Russian propaganda. CIA are noobs in this war. They used our (Ukrainian) help to catch Russians. I know Russians inside out. I have 15+ years of experience in defending of Ukrainian informational space. Who has more years of experience than me? Nobody.
- acdha 5y agoThem doing anything is not the same as them doing everything, as claimed. This shows every sign of being a lot of organic activity and the Ukrainian government – unsurprising as they have entire groups whose job it is to do this and more people who are mother-tongue fluent in Russian. This illustrates the danger of conspiracy theory thinking: you’ve got yourself arguing a more complicated explanation with absolutely no evidence, and if we’re going by institutional reputations as portrayed by Hollywood wouldn’t the same logic have lead you to expect a massive Russian counter-campaign?
- sva_ 5y ago> Conversely they've been pretty effective at stopping information about their own disposition of forces being posted to social media, or at least it's not being retweeted anywhere I've seen. I'm a bit twisted about this. In school, as a German, we were told that the Nazis only reported their wins, not their losses, and how this was such a terrible thing to do (I'm not saying Ukrainians are like Nazis of course.)
- djakaitis 5y agoWhat are you saying then?
- thejackgoode 5y agoEverybody does this during war, would you expect the opposite? Would you yourself voluntarily share news of your own country's losses during war?
- nkozyra 5y agoIt's often claimed that a loosening of media restrictions post-Korean war contributed to the domestic lack of support for the Vietnam War. But there are a lot of ways to shape a narrative in 2022 that involve amplification instead of censorship. https://www.rewire.org/vietnam-war-media-shapes-public-opinion/ https://www.rewire.org/vietnam-war-media-shapes-public-opini...
- thejackgoode 5y agoIf you are invading, it’s always a different story. The incentives are different
- nkozyra 5y agoSure, but what constitutes an "invasion" is also very vulnerable to the narrative.
- ilammy 5y ago
- ck2 5y agoIt's all fun and games until Putin totally rages and dials it up to 11 without even a "no fly zone" being offered by the rest of the world. They have almost the military power of the US and look at the total decimation we did to Iraq. I mean they are already bombing civilian areas so thousands are dying, just not being reported to keep moral up. Putin will threaten maybe nukes in response but there has to be a no-fly zone over Ukraine or they are going to be destroyed by end of March. Putin doesn't have to occupy Ukraine, he just has to destroy it, that's way easier. It will take at least a decade to rebuild if not multiple.
- drran 5y ago> I mean they are already bombing civilian areas so thousands are dying, just not being reported to keep moral up. All dead Ukrainians are accounted and reported immediately, as time allows. We are doing that for last 8 years, day by day. We are outnumbered by Russians, so nobody interested in how many Russians died today, but every single dead Ukrainian soldier or civilian is a tragedy for us. Furthermore, we don't need to keep the moral up. I was second officer at my recruit center at day 1 of war. I was promised that I will be sent to front line on next day, but on next day some soldiers are returned back, because all military units are full to top. We need more weapons, armor, planes. We have plenty of man, who want to kill Russians, because after 8 years of war we all lost somebody we know.
- throwA29B 5y ago>It's all fun and games This. The war is treated as some kind of theatrical performance, with gags, magical heroes killing Russians by the thousands a day and God knows what else. It's crazy.
- koonsolo 5y ago> They have almost the military power of the US I thought so too, until I heard their economy is as big as the Benelux. Then I though, how can they be a "world power"? I looked at military spending: US: 778 bn China: 252 bn India: 72.9 bn Russia: 61.7 UK: 59.2 So in other words, they spend about the same as UK, and 12x less than US alone. They are still riding the old Soviet days. We believe their military is a world power, they (probably) believe their military is a world power. Until you look at the actual numbers. Their tanks are Soviet, their planes and helis are Soviet, their walkie-talkies are customer products. Their entire nuclear arsenal is inherited from the Soviets. It's all old, and they don't have the budget for a modern big army. That might als explain why they are struggling so much in Ukraine.
- dubblo 5y agoAny negative new related to ukraine is either shot down, assumed to be russian propaganda, not talked about. There has been widespread racism faced by blacks and indians. If you goto reddit any news related to it are downvoted as russian propaganda, uncivilized people not following orders etc. Even HN did not pick it up.
- pjc50 5y ago> There has been widespread racism faced by blacks and indians. This unfortunately appears to be true; there's a number of people there, especially international students, who've been trying to flee and report getting blocked at the borders. Ukraine is not a flawless guilt-free country, nowhere is, but that should not be used to distract people from the reality of the invasion.
- pjmlp 5y agoUnfortunely there are only so much that a country can take with an endless amount of tanks driving into it.
- thejackgoode 5y agoWe have a big country, they have 0/10 logistics. Rations and fuel of invading forces were reportedly at best for three days at invasion time. Supply chains are being disrupted due to civilian resistance and lack of air dominance. It's not only social media, it's a total war situation, unanticipated by invader. Let's see how "endless" it will look in a week or two.
- qazpot 5y agoThe amplification of this regional conflict by social media into a global conflict will backfire and can start a nuclear world war.
- oliwarner 5y agoAllowing Russia to do whatever the hell it likes because we're too afraid of MAD will be what kills the West. He'll push against a NATO member soon enough. If we can't stand up for them, he won't stop. And even non-military, these punitive sanctions drive us all closer to midnight, as we plunge the citizens of Russia into a deep economic depression. Short of a friendly and broadly supported coup or a complete ideological u-turn from Putin, there is no way forward here that doesn't risk everything. Trying to ignore it seems the least helpful.
- qazpot 5y ago> Allowing Russia to do whatever the hell it likes because we're too afraid of MAD will be what kills the West. He'll push against a NATO member soon enough. If we can't stand up for them, he won't stop. This is fear mongering, why the hell do you want a nuclear war so bad. I hope NATO officials keep sanity and do not start a war with russia. > there is no way forward here that doesn't risk everything. Yes there is, NATO can provide arms to ukrainian people and they need to fight for their freedom.
- oliwarner 5y agoSaying ~"don't take any direct action or he'll nuke us all" is also fear-mongering. He might. From what we've seen recently, we need to understand that he might anyway. Sitting on the sidelines and expecting the tiny countries that surround Russia to individually win wars, or expecting the beaten and suppressed peoples of Russia, Belarus, etc to rise up is inhumane… because they will fight. And die. And say we do sit it out. Do you think the restoration of the USSR is what's going to bring us nuclear peace? Or just another border, more tension, more of this? We've played this game before. As a European, my life would be extraordinarily different if the world hadn't eventually come together 81 years ago. Just imagine if Europe and the US had drawn together two years earlier. I don't want nuclear war but holding up the threat of that as a cause for inaction —heaping guns on Ukraine while they're outnumbered 20:1 doesn't count— is the rank cowardice that nuclear dictators count on to get away with murder. It's not good enough.