8 ms·
> So, an individual Asian student needs to score much higher to have a chance at Harvard, compared to students of other ethnicities. That's very blatantly racia
by lelanthran 5y ago
> So, an individual Asian student needs to score much higher to have a chance at Harvard, compared to students of other ethnicities. That's very blatantly racial discrimination.
> This amounts to, "sorry, we have enough people of your color, so we're gonna make it harder for you to get in." That's wrong. Period.
"The law of unintended consequences" ... what are they going to do if the target demographic (in this case Asians) start their own merit-based and academic-based colleges and universities?
Sure, it's not cheap, but large communities have done much more expensive things in the educational space before, and of course being pure merit-based means that the graduates will (eventually) be more sought after than the standard colleges[1].
Will someone then cry racism then?
[1] Maybe not to the level that Harvard grads are.
- vt100 5y agoSuch universities already exist, for example Howard University and Albert Einstein. Just not for Asians yet.
- insickness 5y agoIf you're saying that we should allow individuals and companies to create their own identity policies free from government oversight, then we should allow individuals and companies to discriminate any way they want. Don't want to hire blacks, gays or Jews? Allowed. To be honest, there is a legitimate argument that this type of discrimination would be better handled through the free market. But I doubt the people who support Asian discrimination in academia would support this.
- lukas099 5y agoIs creating a purely merit-based institution really an identity policy though? I see it as an identity-blind policy, unless you define identity to include merit.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoThe fallacy of meritocracy. You stand on the shoulders of your parents. If you come from a family of crackheads on the bad side of the rail tracks you already lost the race long before 8th grade.
- lukas099 5y agoMerit, by definition, is what you deserve. I could see the case for merit-based applications that take into account how far you've come relative to where you started.
- raxxorrax 5y agoWhile this is very true, you cannot force all parents to become crackheads, so you will always have different outcomes. We have the same problem with wealth in that regard. You can only improve education in a way that is offers support for people in difficult homes. Perhaps their difficult childhood will ultimately hinder them from becoming the best. But then perhaps their children will fare better.
- bradlys 5y agoThis is why we can do things to make up for the fact that society has failed these children. If you make it so that only “merit” is considered - you’re only gonna get rich kids. (And I see this already through SV - it’s nothing but rich or well educated parents for the children here) What is the argument against letting children who have had a rough lot in their life get a slight lessening of their handicap when applying for colleges or other life changing scenarios that could pull them out of their rut for future generations? If you don’t and are unwilling to address the root cause (and we aren’t willing to address that in the US - we don’t even have universal healthcare yet guys) then you’re gonna keep having this shit continue.
- notSupplied 5y agoThe merit-based school such as Styuvesant in NYC and Lowell in SF are both filled with rather poor Asian kids. The demographic profile of these two schools are substantially lower income than the very expensive cities they reside in. Edit: Got the names of the schools wrong.
- someguydave 5y agoIn fact the Constitution insists on allowing exactly this kind of discrimination in the assembly clause of the first amendment.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThe freedom of assembly is specifically the freedom that was curtailed by the Civil Rights Act. Legally, it should be added... The freedom protected in the first amendment is the freedom of political assembly. The Civil Rights Act has been argued repeatedly in the Supreme Court, and the court has ruled repeatedly that the constitutionally protected freedom of assembly is not curtailed by requiring corporations, incorporated under the rules of the state, to be required to serve everyone in the protected classes.
- someguydave 5y agoAmazing that the first part of the first amendment does not only apply to political speech. The court was wrong and will be wrong again. I would ask how progressives square two contradictory interpretations of the first amendment but then I realized they don’t really support the freedom of non-progressive speech anymore.
- shadowgovt 5y agoSorry, that was an error on my part: freedom of association (in the context of providing public accomodation) was curtailed by the Civil Rights Act, not assembly. And your beef isn't with progressives if that's something you're taking issue with; it's with a couple generations of the Supreme Court, which is considered a relatively conservative branch of the government. (IANAL disclaimer) The freedom of association has been implied by analogy to be protected by the explicitly-enumerated freedom to peaceably assemble in the First Amendment, in some specific cases. But it's a loose protection by analogy; the letter of the First Amendment doesn't even mention a freedom of association. The SCOTUS has not ruled that the freedom of association extends to a freedom to exclude in public accommodation; in layman's terms, the reasoning is "You have the freedom to serve as many people as you want, but that does not imply a freedom to not serve other people if you want to operate under the corporate charter that the government grants." This overview describes things much better than I can. https://constitution.findlaw.com/amendment1/first-amendment-freedom-of-association.html https://constitution.findlaw.com/amendment1/first-amendment-... > The court was wrong and will be wrong again. No doubt, but I don't think you'll find a receptive ear (in the public or in legal circles) to the notion that the Court has been wrong regarding upholding the Civil Rights Act.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> "The law of unintended consequences" ... what are they going to do if the target demographic (in this case Asians) start their own merit-based and academic-based colleges and universities? You're asking what people would do if those who couldn't get into university address the issue by building a new university, thereby increasing supply? "Celebrate," I'd assume.
- yardstick 5y agoWould they though? I suspect they would want to apply non-merit/academic based policies to the new institutions too.
- lelanthran 5y ago> You're asking what people would do if those who couldn't get into university address the issue by building a new university, thereby increasing supply? No, I am asking what you would do if the people discriminated against built their own power structures (out of necessity) that, due to merit, was disproportionately made up of members of their community AND produced superior results for their graduates. Right now many people are basically ranting that Asians are performing too well, leading them to succeed well above other $GROUP. What do you think those people will say if the discriminated group sets up structures that further reinforce their success in succeeding generations? Segregation resulting from discriminating against a particular minority to the level that they go ahead and establish their own structures can backfire immensely. I've seen this (and currently living it firsthand) happen, to the point that the minority group is around 1.5% of the population but holds around 10% of executive and corporate positions[1]. And of course, the 90% majority is baying for blood... > "Celebrate," I'd assume. Segregation is never a reason to celebrate. [1] Last I checked, anyway, which was about a decade ago.
- shadowgovt 5y ago> What do you think those people will say if the discriminated group sets up structures that further reinforce their success in succeeding generations? "Congratulations on achieving the American Dream." The NAACP already exists. What you're describing as a nightmare scenario is basically the way this has been done historically in America. It's part of the "rugged individualism" mythology that a group that feels marginalized organizes to take care of itself.
- DocTomoe 5y ago> what are they going to do if the target demographic (in this case Asians) start their own merit-based and academic-based colleges and universities? I would expect setting up Asian-American universities in which non-Asians need not apply to be highly illegal due to the Civil Rights Act.
- lelanthran 5y ago> I would expect setting up Asian-American universities in which non-Asians need not apply to be highly illegal due to the Civil Rights Act. Who said anything about non-Asians? I said "merit-based" and "academic-based". Is it inconceivable that a university that accepts only on academic performance and focuses only on academic performance will end up disproportionally Asian? [EDIT: Actually, they can make it so that the "merit" test is not in English, but a selection of Asian languages. That'd very quickly make it into an Asian-only university without specifying Capital-R Race]
- DocTomoe 5y agoWell, if you first racially discriminate against a subset of the public, then propose they can set up their own structures at great expense (which only will become similarly prestigious after decades if not centuries, even if they somehow manage to churn out nobel prize winners and presidents almost immediately), it may be a tall order to also demand they be "racially fair". At the same time you will push out Asian kids from regular Ivy-League school admission processes, after all "they can go to that Asian school". If you promote the parallel polis, you will get more segregation, not less. That's the very reason you create a parallel polis.