5 ms·
Covid-19: Why Are We Ignoring Infection-Acquired Immunity?
- edmcnulty101 5y agoThis has been an ongoing question for years.
- brianmcc 5y agoIt's not being ignored. It's long been a valid legal "immunity indicator" here in the UK where this is published. I don't know what end game is being sought here tbh, given that England has abolished all legal restrictions, the rest of the UK likely will do in the next few weeks, and nobody is even talking about mandatory vaccines any more. Overall this feels like something of an agenda piece, not an entirely science based piece, which is trying to build consensus round something really quite ill defined...
- Arnt 5y agoIt is being suppressed to some degree in my experience, and I think that's because it's so easily misunderstood. "Do not lead people's attention towards that which they can easily misunderstand" is a good principle. The crucial misunderstandable point is that even if the immunity is fine, acquiring this immunity is bad (the acquisition process involves considerable risk of death and long covid). That's subtle, too subtle for many people.
- brianmcc 5y agoYeah I suppose it comes down to what people are expected to actually do with the information. It's one thing to have a message "if you get covid, and come out OK, the silver lining is some ongoing immunity". I'm not sure there's any other take: "get covid to avoid getting covid" doesn't really work. Finally I imagine there's a bit of ongoing analysis, the science on antibodies and other immune responses vs actual real world protection perhaps not concluded. Not least due to the future emergence of new variants which could substantially change things for either the better or for the worse.
- native_samples 5y agoCOVID does not present a "considerable risk of death" for any age group even before Omicron, and now it's so trivial that when the Queen (aged 95) got it, the entire UK just shrugged and ignored it. The real reason governments like to ignore infection acquired immunity is that it's incompatible with prevailing ideology in public health and the "science as saviour" narrative. It's certainly got nothing to do with what people can understand. My god no. The average member of the public is far smarter and less biased than the average public health official!
- ceejayoz 5y agoBecause “I got sick last year, stayed home, never got tested, but am certain it was COVID” puts verifiers in an impossible position.
- tunap 5y agoAs does the surge in influenza negative, 'flu-like' cases much earlier in 2019 than reported. Certain narratives would have to be reassessed, or discarded.
- thenerdhead 5y agoYeah but you can get an antibody test to verify. I did this when I suspected I had COVID but no access to testing at the time and many months later still had antibodies. Would an antibody test be valid enough to accept infection-acquired immunity? (I live in the US)
- ceejayoz 5y agoThe FDA says no; that it's potentially too variable versus the more known quantity of vaccination. https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/safety-communications/antibody-testing-not-currently-recommended-assess-immunity-after-covid-19-vaccination-fda-safety https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/safety-communications/an... > Be aware that a positive result from an antibody test does not mean you have a specific amount of immunity or protection from SARS-CoV-2 infection. From a cost and logistics standpoint, you'd be testing a whopping amount of people, and the recommendation would still be "go get the vaccine".
- thenerdhead 5y agoThe messaging is still clear as mud. Digging deeper... I think the real message is here: > none of the currently authorized tests have been specifically authorized to assess immunity or protection of persons who have received a COVID-19 vaccine. In other words, the authorized test isn't "authorized" to inform someone of their immunity although they may be immune. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/lab/resources/antibody-tests-guidelines.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/lab/resources/anti...
- msarrel 5y agoWhat a strange article! No one's ignoring immunity from infection, it's what half the world is counting on. Perhaps new ones talking about it and that leads the author to conclude that we're ignoring it, but no one's talking about it because it's what everyone is counting on.
- thenerdhead 5y agoI'm glad that this article talks about the absurdity of the US policy. For a country that supposedly "follows the science", we sure do not follow other countries in their research. I'm quite glad in retrospect that I stuck to my citizen scientist perspective.
- peteradio 5y agoI've come to see it as a blessing. By never really bringing it into the fold we never set the strong precedent of immunity based passports.