9 ms·
California has proven for decades now that getting rid of non-competes is good for the economy and good for workers. It's bizarre that this move hasn't been cop
by paxys 5y ago
California has proven for decades now that getting rid of non-competes is good for the economy and good for workers. It's bizarre that this move hasn't been copied in every other state, especially among those who routinely invest large amounts of money to try and become "the next silicon valley".
- jorblumesea 5y agoImplying that laws are made for the good of society... Ask US citizens why we still don't have paid maternity or paternity leave...
- chrismcb 5y agoI don't think it is surprising at all. It needs someone to champion the cause. While it isn't good, it doesn't really effect that many people. At least it isn't as obvious. So no one really takes up the cause
- marvy 5y agoWhy does it need a champion? Suppose some legislator is drunk one night and decides to introduce a bill banning non-competes. Who would vote against it?
- paxys 5y ago> Who would vote against it Every politician sponsored by a large corporation
- alistairSH 5y ago1/5 of American workers is a LOT of people.
- gotoeleven 5y agoThere are few trading firms in california because of the non-compete situation. There are costs to everything even feel-good populism that seems like a no-brainer.
- ruined 5y agogood. trading firms are useless. money should work. california is synonymous with venture
- londons_explore 5y agoThats because many trading firms have a handful of key algorithms that took a lot of time and money to develop the first time, but that could be re-implemented with not much effort at a new employer. This applies to pretty much any valuable information that fits in one person's head.
- sam0x17 5y agoThe trading center of the world is NYC and/or Greenwich, CT if you want to be cheeky about it. If the NYSE was in SF, you'd see a lot more trading firms there. Fintech is largely not in cali, as well.
- lostdog 5y ago> There are few trading firms in california because of the non-compete situation. That doesn't make sense. If that were true, there would be one trading firm in California that only existed to hire traders from other firms and copy results.
- Buge 5y agoFrom other firms located where?
- marvy 5y agoNew York presumably
- imajoredinecon 5y agoUnfortunately, you can’t get out of a noncompete with an employer in state A that allows noncompetes by taking a job with a competitor in a different state B that doesn’t allow noncompetes.
- 5y ago
- toomuchtodo 5y ago> It's bizarre that this move hasn't been copied in every other state, especially among those who routinely invest large amounts of money to try and become "the next silicon valley". Some states are more friendly to labor exploitation than others.
- downrightmike 5y agoEven in california, faang et all were all found to be colluding to keep compensation down
- dymk 5y agoFacebook was the exception, they did not partake in collusion. Adobe, Apple, Google, and Intel were the culprits. They were also caught.
- rrdharan 5y agoThey didn’t really exist yet (they did, but they were tiny, not on anybody’s radar, and not really competing for top end experienced / senior talent for example, they were just vacuuming up new college grads).. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust_Litigation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-Tech_Employee_Antitrust... The defendants were high-technology companies Adobe, Apple Inc., Google, Intel, Intuit, Pixar, Lucasfilm and eBay, each of which was headquartered in Silicon Valley, in the southern San Francisco Bay Area of California. The civil suit was filed by five plaintiffs. It accused the tech companies of collusion between 2005 and 2009 to refrain from recruiting each other's employees.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sneak 5y agoThe judge also threw out the initial settlement amount for being hilariously lowball. They stole billions of dollars from their staff. Eric Schmidt, one of the main conspirators, is still in a leadership role at Google.
- rrdharan 5y agoNo he’s not: https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/09/eric-schmidt-is-reportedly-no-longer-an-advisor-to-the-company.html https://www.cnbc.com/2020/05/09/eric-schmidt-is-reportedly-n...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dqpb 5y agoI think most people in positions of power aren’t creators. Control and ownership is the only thing they know.
- Diesel555 5y agoOne of the major assumptions of market economics is a competitive environment. Here is a study on the policy of non-competes from the Office of Economic Policy in the US treasury. https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/226/Non_Compete_Contracts_Econimic_Effects_and_Policy_Implications_MAR2016.pdf https://home.treasury.gov/system/files/226/Non_Compete_Contr... First I had no idea how prolific non-competes are. > Non-competes are a central labor market institution, with nearly one fifth of all American workers currently bound by such a contract. After the policy recommendations, here is the conclusion from that paper. > Though non-compete contracts can have important social benefits, principally related to the protection of trade secrets, a growing body of evidence suggests that they are frequently used in ways that are inimical to the interests of workers and the broader economy. Enhancing the transparency of non-competes, better aligning them with legitimate social purposes like protection of trade secrets, and instituting minimal worker protections can all help to ensure that non-compete contracts contribute to economic growth without unduly burdening workers.
- olliej 5y agoYes, the ability to prohibit an employee from choosing who to work for, while costing the company nothing at all does indeed lead to worse outcomes for the worker. Any non-compete clause must come with a requirement to pay that employee to not compete. That will quickly get rid of non-competes that aren't actually their for the purpose of protecting trade secrets.
- pottertheotter 5y agoOn Wall Street we often have Garden Leave, where an employee continues to receive salary and benefits for a period of time after resigning to go to a competitor. Seems pretty fair to me.
- david38 5y agoOnly if the pay is what he would be getting elsewhere and if the garden leave isn’t so long his skills will be considered old.
- bushbaba 5y agoMakes you wonder if removing the patent system would have similar benefits.
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoI sure think so! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30512363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30512363
- heavyset_go 5y agoI can think of several patented medicines that are not being pursued commercially in the US despite their approval in other countries and proven efficacy. I can think of one that's sat on by a company that already produces a similar medication. Companies will sit on new medications until right before/after the similar, but older, medications they own/license are off patent, that way they always have another patented medication waiting in the wings for when they're done squeezing every cent they can out of their old ones.
- Talanes 5y agoIt would be nice if patents were "use it or lose it" like trademarks.
- refurb 5y agoAs someone who has worked in the industry, this hasn't been my observation at all. There is never "one" patent for a drug and candidates tend to be patented quite early, so the clock starts ticking. A company may be lucky to get several more patents, but it's not guaranteed. Plus, there is nothing stopping another company from making a similar drug and beating you to market - there were over 6 -statin drugs in the market at one point.
- namibj 5y agoBeware of trade secrets. That said, patents should probably at least get mandatory FRAND.
- hristov 5y agoUnfortunately sometimes laws are made not for the best benefit of society as a whole but for the benefit of a powerful or well positioned minority. Now check out the Colorado law. It says that non-competes are forbidden except for four exceptions. Check out the fourth exception: 4. Contracts with executive and management personnel and employees who constitute professional staff to executive and management personnel. There is an actual clause covering secretaries! So you can be sure your secretary will not go working for a competitor. You do not have to think hard to guess who had this law written for themselves.
- binkHN 5y agoIn relation to the exceptions: Even when one of these exceptions applies, Colorado courts insist that the non-compete provisions be reasonable in duration and scope.
- forum_ghost 5y agothe word "reasonable" is the largest loophole ever invented, aside perhaps from "interstate commerce".
- kube-system 5y agoThis is a common misconception. “Reasonable” does have a specific meaning in many legal contexts, and courts typically have a more specific test for what constitutes “reasonable” For example, a state that has a law which says non-competes much be “reasonable”, may be enforced by the courts as “1 year in duration and within 50 miles”.
- garciasn 5y agoThe problem is that 50 miles seems reasonable on its face; however, it ignores context. Let's say you work for a consultancy in a large metropolitan area covering 5MM+ people and this area has 100+ consultancies. There are many groups of these consultancies and they all service different verticals. There are no other major areas with concentrations of business within hundreds of miles (see middle America). A person may have been working exclusively within the healthcare vertical at one consultancy and would move to another to work in a completely different vertical (e.g., retail). Would 'reasonable' cover this nuance? Probably not, particularly not in the favor of the worker.
- wpietri 5y agoI can only hope that California follows Colorado's lead here. We cannot have a competitive gap. More jail time for labor exploitation, please! Especially given all the news stories about people leaving California, I think vigorously enforced criminal penalties for execs mistreating workers would be great for the economy, great for workers, and something states like Texas and Florida would have hard time getting passed. (I'm kidding. But I'm not.)
- FateOfNations 5y agoCalifornia has long banned non-compete agreements.
- wpietri 5y agoBut never with jail time, which is my point.
- Trias11 5y agoSecond thing California ought to be loved for. First one is the weather.
- bottled_poe 5y agoProven? What proof?