4 ms·
While it is correct that Ukraine did not have operational control over the nuclear weapons, anybody who have nuclear weapons in their possession, and who have t
by adrian_b 5y ago
While it is correct that Ukraine did not have operational control over the nuclear weapons, anybody who have nuclear weapons in their possession, and who have the engineering resources of an entire state, would be easily able to disassemble the weapons, reverse engineer the connections to the devices that initiate the detonation and substitute the control units in order to gain operational control.
Such an operation cannot need more than a few months at most.
Therefore Ukraine, and any country which would have been in the same situation and would have chosen to give up their own nuclear weapons, really made willingly a choice to act in this way, because they also had the alternative choice of gaining control over the weapons and the Russians would not have been able to stop them.
- dane-pgp 5y ago> Such an operation cannot need more than a few months at most. But how much would it have cost to keep those warheads and their rocket engines and all the associated infrastructure in good working order, and secure from accidental launch or denotation, for decades up to the present day? When the decision was made, I suspect it was not at all clear that having the ability to nuke Russia might be an option worth spending billions on, and at the end of the Cold War many Ukrainians might have thought that the real threat would be from the West (so they could rely on Russian nukes to protect them). The point still stands, though, that nuclear weapons are a powerful (if expensive) insurance policy for a sovereign nation against unforeseeable future geopolitical risks.
- XorNot 5y agoUkraine has a space industry. Just this week a rocket went up which was Russian engines, on a Ukranian second stage, with a US payload. So while it would be expensive..history pretty much shows it would've been cheaper for Ukraine then what's currently happening, and they definitely have the knowledge and skills locally to do it.
- Aeolun 5y ago> But how much would it have cost to keep those warheads and their rocket engines and all the associated infrastructure in good working order, and secure from accidental launch or denotation, for decades up to the present day? If Russia can do it for a few thousand warheads, Ukraine can too. It’s not like their economies are that different.
- dane-pgp 5y agoI suspect that developing, maintaining, and securing a few thousand nuclear missiles is not 1000 times more expensive than doing so for just a few nuclear missiles. To give some figures, the IMF estimates that the sizes of the economies in 2021 (in US$ million, PPP) were: * Russia 4,328,122 * Ukraine 576,106 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PPP%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_%28PP...
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>would be easily able to disassemble the weapons, reverse engineer the connections to the devices that initiate the detonation and substitute the control units in order to gain operational control. Such an operation cannot need more than a few months at most. I think you're massively underestimating the effort needed to have operational nuclear weapons. Nuclear missiles aren't like a car that you can just hotwire and jump start and something you can store and forget in their silos for years and then dust them off when you need them, but require constant and ludicrously expensive maintenance to stay operational. First you need to have the rockets well maintained and tested to make sure then can have successful lift-off, then make sure the guidance systems are accurate enough to deliver your payload to the target. Secondly and probably the most difficult, you need the detonation mechanism well maintained and tested, as the nuclear reaction needs super precise timing of the fissile material inside the chamber. Otherwise, even if you're lucky and hit your target, if the nuclear reaction is off, the explosion will be a dud and not cause much damage. This is not something trivial that can be pulled off successfully in a few months notice, but you need a coordinated round the clock, and very costly, national program like the nuclear programs of France, UK, US, etc.
- hef19898 5y agoUkraine had all the necessary resources, except funds maybe. Not that transforming your fancy missle warheads into free-falling bombs wouldn't work. Or artillery shells, a country running quite a few nuclear reactors should be able to do so if it really wants.
- baybal2 5y agoRussia actually had much harder time to maintain its arsenal than Ukraine because most of USSR's nuclear industry was in Ukraine.
- einpoklum 5y ago> and who have the engineering resources of an entire state It's not at all clear Ukraine had that kind of resources to invest in a nuclear weapons program, even if its government decided it would like to have one. Not to mention the fact that, were a decision like this taken, a Russian invasion would have been put into motion within the week. > Such an operation cannot need more than a few months at most. I believe you are massively underestimating here.