3 ms·
That's one of the lessons, isn't it? First the West reneged on the Nuclear deal with Iran, now Russia invaded Ukraine. All the while North Korea is just simply
by hef19898 5y ago
That's one of the lessons, isn't it? First the West reneged on the Nuclear deal with Iran, now Russia invaded Ukraine. All the while North Korea is just simply left alone.
- gonzo41 5y agoNK is not really left alone. They face very tough sanctions daily. But I agree, broadly I think there will be an arms race for nuclear weapons amongst the smaller asian countries.
- hef19898 5y agoSanctions, sure. But no real military conflict, or attempted regime change by anyone, since the end of the Korean War. NK is at peace with its neighbors (meaning direct military conflict) almost as long as Europe is (ignoring the non-EU countries for now). On top of that, the nuclear arsenal allowed NK to get away with a ton of human rights abuses and all the other shit, like shooting missiles over Japan, for decades.
- dtech 5y agoI think it's simplistic to just put that on "NK have nukes". They also have support from China, who want them as a buffer and don't want to deal with the refugees from the state collapsing.
- einpoklum 5y ago> But no real military conflict NK and the US are still in a state of war, I believe. US vessels and other kinds of armaments are semi-surrounding it, and again IIRC there are occasional joint military exercises of the US and SK.
- throwaway6734 5y agoIirc NK also has the backing of China and has a ton of conventional arms aimed at Seoul which would cause mass casualties
- pelasaco 5y agoI think what he meant was that in 1994, in the Budapest Memorandum, it was decided that Ukraine would hand their nuclear weapons to Russia over and in return Russia promised never invade Ukraine. Interesting that the fact that it could be a mistake was raised back in the days already: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_weapons_and_Ukraine#Denuclearization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_weapons_and_Ukraine#De... I would be interesting to find out what the other "experts" said back in the day.
- hef19898 5y agoYeah, turned out that was mistake (or was it really?) almost 30 years later. Back the day the world was different. The former USSR countries were dirt poor, military hardware was sold left and right wholesale. The USSR was utterly defeated. So for everyone, it was much saver to have only one, potentially failed, state having the USSR's nukes instead of multiple ones. And it worked for almost 30 years, so back then it made sense for everyone. That might change going forward. Or might not, way to early to tell.
- pelasaco 5y agoLet us agree on that one: From the Geopolitical point of view was a mistake, from the practical point of view maybe not.
- hef19898 5y agoI'm not even sure geopolitical. Or do you think Ukraine would get all the NATO support if they had an arsenal of nukes outside of NATOs control? Culd easily be that NATO would tentatively ally with, un-officially of course, with Russia to get rid of a potentially rogue nuclear nation. Depending of the Ukrainian government of course. Or that Russia would have already annexed the whole lot during the Orange revolution. No way to tell. Personally, as bad as war is for those in the region, every war in which belligerents don't have nukes is better. Because there is less risk of "accidently" causing a nuclear exchange.
- 5y ago
- Adverblessly 5y agoCould you explain what you mean when you mention that "First the West reneged on the Nuclear deal with Iran"? I understand why the current situation would encourage Iran to pursue nuclear weaponry, but the agreement as far as I know did not include any defensive pact, so Iran didn't agree to forsake development of nuclear weaponry under the promise of protection from the west (which is now proving to be ineffective), it promised to forsake nuclear weaponry in order to be allowed to pursue peaceful nuclear technology. So what related lesson is to be learned from the West reneging on the deal? Or are you saying that since the deal would have made Iran into a [nuclear threshold state](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_latency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_latency), this is the West reneging on the deal to allow Iran the technology to defend itself, and the lesson is that they should never have relied on the West for that in the first place?
- hef19898 5y agoWell, the former US administration threw the deal between Iran and the "West" out. That's what I meant, Iran didn't do anything wrong there and still.
- einpoklum 5y ago> it promised to forsake nuclear weaponry in order to be allowed to pursue peaceful nuclear technology. Nope. The JCPOA agreement acknowledged (i.e. the US, the European signatories etc acknowledged) that Iran did _not_ have a nuclear weapons program. The JCPOA put in place stronger safeguards to ensure that remains the case.
- raxxorrax 5y agoNorth Korea has a big brother watching their backs. The country is used as a shield to ward of aggression.