5 ms·
Families and students are not the only people exposed to COVID. Why shouldn’t teachers have a say in the risk they are asked to deal with?
by saagarjha 5y ago
Families and students are not the only people exposed to COVID. Why shouldn’t teachers have a say in the risk they are asked to deal with?
- colordrops 5y agoBecause no one else has a say. Seems like all groups should have a say, including teachers, students, and parents.
- jounker 5y agoWell that’s bullshit.
- britch 5y agoCan you elaborate a bit?
- britch 5y agoSeems like some parents are heard pretty loudly. High Schoolers have staged walkouts in response to omicron in some cities. Seems disingenuous to say only teachers have been heard.
- Pulcinella 5y agoYou do have a say! School board meetings are usually public and the board elections are democratic (usually. Some districts, usually in the south still have some at-large boards seats for racism reasons). When I was a teacher and blamed for things by parents I had no power over (e.g. standardized tests mandated by the state) I wished parents would direct their (justified & righteous) rage at the school board and state politicians instead. “School choice” isn’t school choice unless I’m free choose to send my kids to the rich district across town or the private school the politicians and elites send their kids to.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- another_story 5y agoYou won't be able to, though, because admissions will be full at those schools.
- Pulcinella 5y agoYep so it’s not really a choice, is it? People shouldn’t have to choose between “good schools” and “bad schools.” The idea of trying to find a home “with good schools” should be a thing of the past. All schools should good schools. I think that is the goal to work towards, not having parents fight for the too few remaining life-rafts.
- lettergram 5y agoSo give every kid $15k/year and be done with it. Schools will open in neighborhoods that have 8 students and one stellar teacher. You’ll have all the parents coming by and seeing the kids and joining in the education process. Other parents might want their kid to have a classical education. Other parents might want a traditional Islamic education. Others may want a massive university style education, with half online. All of these styles can be possible with school choice. I don’t really understand the vitriol. Its better for everyone if everyone is more involved and has a more tailored approach. Even those with special needs, it’s not unreasonable to double the credit. Have them get help. I think there’s plenty of ways to improve this.
- asoneth 5y ago> give every kid $15k/year and be done with it I like the idea in principle, but one challenge I haven't seen addressed is that the cost of educating a student is not uniform. Students on either end of the bell curve with special needs, unstable home situations, no/broken English, exceptional intelligence, ADHD, behavioral issues, etc cost more than average. Therefore, similar to health insurance, every organization is incentivized to attract cheaper-than-average students/patients and expel or discourage the expensive ones. You typically end up with the most expensive participants dumped onto the public schools/plans which results in a death spiral. In my experience, most people love this kind of libertarian approach right up until the moment they find out they're going to be one of the expensive ones, at which point they discover a newfound appreciation for public services.
- lmm 5y agoAll workers should have a say in dangerous working practices. Everyone needs a union.
- nradov 5y agoPublic employees don't need unions. If they want better working conditions then they should ask their elected political leaders, just like every other citizen. And teaching isn't dangerous. Everyone will be exposed to the virus so it hardly matters whether that happens in a classroom or some other setting. The teachers who want to get vaccinated have been for months now. https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646 https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646
- lmm 5y ago> Public employees don't need unions. If they want better working conditions then they should ask their elected political leaders, just like every other citizen. Workers anywhere need to be able to negotiate with organisational management on roughly equal terms, which means a comparable level of organisational backing. Most civil service management is not elected and nor should it be; making every superintendent or subject head an elected position would cause bigger problems. > And teaching isn't dangerous. Everyone will be exposed to the virus so it hardly matters whether that happens in a classroom or some other setting. The teachers who want to get vaccinated have been for months now. That's easy to say when you're not the one having to do it. Not everyone can safely be vaccinated, and not everyone has the same judgement of the risks. If there really is compelling medical evidence to support the position of those who want to return to in-person schooling, then they have nothing to fear from negotiating with the union on equal terms.
- SllX 5y agoAt the point where you are both a voter and paid out of public money, you shouldn’t get to also have a union. This is a choose two situation, and since I’m not going to tell anyone to give up their voting rights, this is more of a choose one situation.
- camhart 5y agoAs with many jobs, its take on the risk the job requires or find a new job. I'm not saying they shouldn't have a voice. But it shouldn't be an excuse.
- anon9384929 5y agoAnd who, exactly, do you suggest take their space? Is there a surplus of quality teachers in the US?
- x3n0ph3n3 5y agoThere would be if we shifted funds from administrators to teachers. Like in healthcare, administrators are hoarding most of the funds and driving up the cost.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> Is there a surplus of quality teachers in the US? There must be a surplus, at least of qualified teachers, if not quality ones. Otherwise how do we find enough people with a master's degree willing to take 45K a year to teach 25-30 rambunctious kids all day long? It baffles me that we still manage to find people willing to enter the career field, frankly.
- zdragnar 5y agoI imagine ot varies by region, but there are definitely more people looking for teaching jobs than there are jobs available where I live (my sister in law is a teacher and getting a new job is a very long process indeed).
- HarryHirsch 5y agoRural school districts have begun importing teachers from the Philippines: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSmtbSYE8pg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FSmtbSYE8pg Over there you can find educated people who are willing to work in Seely, MT for 30 kUSD/year. On a J-1 visa, with no possibility to settle permanently in the US. Good luck to all of us.