4 ms·
Putin mentioned nuclear weapons specifically when publicly warning specifically against the type of interference you describe. There is a nonzero chance that t
by sneak 5y ago
Putin mentioned nuclear weapons specifically when publicly warning specifically against the type of interference you describe.
There is a nonzero chance that the endgame of the decision you hope for results in gigadeaths within ten weeks.
Calling such a bluff risks the entire human civilization.
- VincentEvans 5y agoI don’t disagree, but I’ll refer you to this video from the show “Yes, prime minister” on the subject of salami tactics and nuclear deterrent: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=o861Ka9TtT4 https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=o861Ka9TtT4 Where is the red line? I’ve just read in the news that Kadyrov’s Chechen forces of islamist murderers are going to be deploying to Ukraine to assist Russian forces. Should the West continue to wait and see?
- jltsiren 5y agoIsn't that just Cold War 101? Both sides are supposed to know where the other side's red line is. And both sides are supposed to avoid creating ambiguous situations, where the other side may no longer know the red line. If the enemy does not know your red line, it's your fault. And if you don't know it yourself, your existence may be enough to start a nuclear war.
- corndoge 5y ago> Putin mentioned nuclear weapons specifically when publicly warning specifically against the type of interference you describe Can you provide a reference for that? I wasn't aware of this
- sneak 5y agohttps://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-vladimir-putin-europe-poland-nuclear-weapons-2503c0d7696a57db4f437c90d3894b18 https://apnews.com/article/russia-ukraine-vladimir-putin-eur...
- pupdogg 5y agoVideo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJXwLzII278 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJXwLzII278
- pupdogg 5y agoThis is absolutely correct! I've been watching Putin's public briefings for over 10 years and have to say that when he expressed his concern over NATO Allies invoking Article 5 to the reporters, he was out of his normal character (calm, collected, and thoughtful)...meaning that he was NOT KIDDING about using his hypersonic nuclear arsenal on anyone that wanted to interfere!
- pupdogg 5y agoVideo: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJXwLzII278 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJXwLzII278
- VincentEvans 5y agoSo what is your own red line then? Baltics? Moldova? Georgia? Probably not…? Czech Republic? Poland?
- justin66 5y agoI can’t imagine why you’re confused by this. The redline is aggression against a NATO member. Hint: it’s why the potential for Ukraine joining NATO was such a contentious issue. (It’s why troops and fighters are, one hopes only symbolically, moving in to reinforce those NATO states with their presence right now)
- adventured 5y agoThere's a very good reason the parent may be confused about it. The NATO red line is fraudulent, a lie. Russia goes into Sweden and Finland and it's not a red line? Yeah right. The case is actually that people are deciding Ukraine isn't as valuable - that the lives are not as valuable - as Finland and Sweden and they're too great of cowards to say it outright.
- justin66 5y ago> The NATO red line is fraudulent, a lie. I don’t understand why you think so. > Russia goes into Sweden and Finland and it's not a red line? Yeah right. This was a confusing comment but I don’t think the US would fight WWIII for Finland if they weren’t a NATO member (and they’re not). Do you? > The case is actually that people are deciding Ukraine isn't as valuable - that the lives are not as valuable - as Finland and Sweden and they're too great of cowards to say it outright. I guess that’s possible, but you’re entirely confused about its import. The NATO countries denying membership to Ukraine because they do not want to defend Ukrainians is an indication that NATO member countries take the “red line” associated with NATO membership seriously.
- adventured 5y agoThe bluff has to be called at some point. The Ukrainian life is less valuable than the Finn life (surely we'd respond to an invasion of Finland)? Where shall we finally call Putin's bluff? Putin is destroying a large country in Europe out of conquest and empire building, like the tsars of old. The Ukrainians deserve better than the modern, weak version of America they have 'helping' them. There were so many ways we could have easily helped them over the prior seven years and yet failed to do so. If the US is truly a superpower (that has no qualms picking fights with far weaker nations), let it begin acting like it. If not, then lie down, cower and fade from the pretension of superpower relevancy. It's either or and it's time for the US to demonstrate whether it still has the grit and strength of past generations or not, to demonstrate that it deserves the global position it has possessed post WW2. We'll bomb the hell out of numerous weaker nations. We'll shock and awe Iraq, bombing them back in time, invade and occupy Iraq and Afghanistan for two decades. We'll help destroy Libya and Syria because it's viewed as a convenient, low risk move on the global chess board. Then when it comes time to deal with a context involving a strong opponent where we'd have moral standing to act in the defense (no-fly zone over Ukraine) of innocent people that are being attacked, what do we do? Wave our hands furiously in the air and throw around impotent sanctions. Oh what a mighty superpower.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pbourke 5y agoWhat if enforcing a no-fly zone over Ukraine leads to a full nuclear exchange a.k.a. end of the world? We are actually seeing some strong early results from the soft power approach. The US under Trump all but abandoned this powerful and necessary tool. Give it a chance.
- notch656a 5y agoWe can't just be Putin's bitch because he threatens nuclear weapons. That can go on ad infinitum. If he uses them, that's on him. Time to level these dogs.