6 ms·
Mitsubishi plans to include scene-aware interaction in cars
- ajross 5y agoThere doesn't seem to be any autonomy technology described. This is an article submitted by Mitsubishi about their work with AI-driven driver direction annunciation. Which sounds cool, but it's not "self-driving" at all. Which makes me question how much of this is actually showing off something interesting and how much is just marketing.
- efitz 5y agoI noticed that as well- “where’s the bit about self-driving”?
- stubish 5y agoSome hand wavy bits here: "For instance, it would be comforting for the passenger to know that the reason why the car is suddenly changing lanes is because it wants to avoid an obstacle on the road or avoid a traffic jam up ahead by getting off at the next exit. Additionally, we expect natural-language interfaces to be useful when the vehicle detects a situation it has not seen before, a problem that may require a high level of cognition. If, for instance, the car approaches a road blocked by construction, with no clear path around it, the car could ask the passenger for advice. The passenger might then say something like, “It seems possible to make a left turn after the second traffic cone.” Because the vehicle’s awareness of its surroundings is transparent to passengers, they are able to interpret and understand the actions being taken by the autonomous vehicle. Such understanding has been shown to establish a greater level of trust and perceived safety. "
- EarthIsHome 5y agoFrom the video: > Communication between humans and machines is hindered by a lack of shared awareness. Yeah... by the fact that humans aren't aware that AI is just a bunch of 1s and 0s and not actually aware. There's no intelligence here. > Scene understanding ... it cannot understand. It can only match. It does not understand in the way humans understand.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> AI is just a bunch of 1s and 0s and not actually aware. There's no intelligence here. And the human brain is just a bundle of electrical signals. Why's that any different?
- bangkoksbest 5y agoMore is different. Reductionism does not actually explain qualitative behavior.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anonymousab 5y ago> Why's that any different? Consciousness, sentience and sapience. Which is to say, that is indeed the multitrillion dollar question.
- chrisseaton 5y agoBut what makes you think binary vs analog is the key difference?
- Cerium 5y agoTo date, all systems composed of ones and zeros are not generally intelligent.
- chrisseaton 5y agoIs that why they’re not intelligent? Or an entirely unrelated factor? Would anything change if you implemented exactly the same algorithms on a decimal computer instead? I don’t think it would.
- Cerium 5y ago
- netsharc 5y agoNow I want a parking sensor with the cockpit voice that reads out numbers as you land "One hundred. Fifty. Forty. Thirty. Twenty. Retard, retard!"
- fouc 5y agoI think you've nailed the best possible UX
- daverol 5y agoI had a chatty passenger like this in my car once - never again!
- anxrn 5y agoThis article is written by Mitsubishi engineers but in the style of a news report with a sensationalized headline ("At last" ...). I'm noticing more of these - seems like a new (?) marketing trend. Nothing wrong with that objective, but does throw me off - I typically expect hard tech from the Spectrum.
- rexpop 5y ago> "Suits make a corporate comeback," says the New York Times. Why does this sound familiar? Maybe because the suit was also back in February, September 2004, June 2004, March 2004, September 2003, November 2002, April 2002, and February 2002. > Why do the media keep running stories saying suits are back? Because PR firms tell them to. http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- lowwave 5y ago>I typically expect hard tech from the Spectrum Maybe this one is bit more to your interest: https://yewtu.be/watch?v=JamDa-qNjPI https://yewtu.be/watch?v=JamDa-qNjPI
- uKVZe85V 5y ago> A conventional navigation system would tell the driver to turn right in 100 meters this is not very informative since drivers may not have an accurate sense of distance. So, this is for the subpopulation of car drivers that have no accurate sense of distance? Mmh, okay. > - follow the silver car to turn left > - I can't see it Not surprising. Colors are somewhat ambiguous, cultural and subjective. Greyish ("silver") is a very common color for a car. At this moment there were several car matching that description. So, using color, at least in this case, is not accurate. At least, with a distance, the information is somewhat well-defined. > - okay follow the silver car in the leftmost lane That's another silver car. Wait, what's the benefit of mentioning that car, compared to saying "join the leftmost lane and follow it to turn left"? Or simply, "turn left". Do they mean it is for drivers that can follow another car but not painted lanes? What happens in low traffic when there's no other car to follow? > turn left at the building with a billboard There are several buildings with a billboard. One at around 100 meters, one at around 300 meters. So, mentioning "a building with a billboard", at least in this case, is not accurate. At least, with a distance, the information is somewhat well-defined. > recent breakthroughs in object detection and recognition semantic segmentation motion analysis of dynamic objects and natural language processing technologies our system also makes use of high precision maps "recent buzzword in buzzword and buzzword buzzword buzzword buzzword of buzzword and buzzword buzzword our system also makes use of buzzword". > surveillance systems that understand complex scenes and interpret them for humans Ah, this may be the real deal. No, thanks.
- projektfu 5y agoI guess I must be an idiot. I frequently can't tell what turn the navigation system expects me to take and I am never sure if it's really 100ft or more-or-less 100ft, maybe 60, maybe 140. When the navigator tells me I can be in the leftmost 3 lanes for the turn, I usually can't see whether I should be ready to turn left or right. If I can't see the turn, because there is a truck in my way, I will often miss it. But I must be in a subpopulation that doesn't need any support because we're so rare.
- uKVZe85V 5y agoYou seem irritated. Sorry if you think I caused this. I also happen to sometimes miss guidance directions (happened a few days ago). Still, I doubt ambiguously referring to environmental features is an actual progress. My feeling is that in both current and projected systems, the driver will need some experience to figure out the ambiguity. I also anticipate cases where the AI will mislabel an object and ask to turn left at the X while there's clearly no X, or maybe actually an X but further away, causing misguidance.
- efitz 5y agoSo the gist of the article is that instead of saying “in five hundred feet, turn right”, they’ve built a nav system that can say things like “follow the black car that is turning right at the tree”. Sounds better than what we have now, which is dumb systems that often repeat stuff unnecessarily and annoyingly: “In a quarter mile, turn right” “In 500 feet, turn right” “Turn right” I want it to pick one and shut up unless I’m about to miss the turn: “Turn right at the next light” “Are you going to turn or what?” This would be less annoying and also reduce the amount of assistance my wife feels compelled to provide. Ed: s/nab/nav/g
- hammock 5y ago>I want it to pick one and shut up unless I’m about to miss the turn: “Turn right at the next light” “Are you going to turn or what?” Easy solution here would be to have some feedback mechanism for the nav. Surprised it doesn't exist already. I miss what the nav says about half the time, because I'm paying attention to other things. But if i could say "ok, got it" or press a button that says "ok, got it" the first time she gives a new direction, that would shut up her reminders, that seems ideal.
- xahrepap 5y agoAlso, I want to be able to specify areas I’m familiar with somehow. So instead of it telling me turn by turn how to leave my neighborhood, for example, it just says “leave the neighborhood going east”. Then it could say “you want to be going north on I-whatever, you’ll end up North of CITY.” And then it shuts up until I’ve gone past CITY on I-whatever.
- robszumski 5y agoThis seems like such an easy win to me. Oh this person has driven the beginning of this route 500 times, just tell them to get on the interstate heading downtown. Plus just turn the "turn in 200ft" to "turn in two blocks". None of this needs fancy sensors.
- agentwiggles 5y ago
- scoot 5y agoThe title says "self driving", but the article is about a sat-nav
- dang 5y agoWe've replaced the article's baity title with representative language from the article.
- p1esk 5y agoHere’s a video that demonstrates what they built: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=t0izXoT_Aoc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=t0izXoT_Aoc
- sjg007 5y agoGreat, just what I want, a back seat driver.
- bob1029 5y ago> can explain itself I was hoping for some new take on the AI/ML blackbox approach that could allow for us to trace a vehicle decision back to deterministic rules. Ya know, something like SQL. This is still interesting on the UX side of the house though. A lot of people navigate better this way. It might actually reduce cognitive load and accidents by providing information in a more digestible format.
- black_13 5y ago
- beebeepka 5y agoInteresting. A combination of HUD and voice help might work better than what we have now. Of course, a good HUD would likely be ultimately better but much harder to implement
- erulabs 5y ago> After all, Apple’s Siri, Microsoft’s Cortana, Amazon’s Alexa and Google Home are all very impressive I mean - no? Google can’t track more than one timer at a time (and can’t subtract time from it either) and recognizes me maybe 80% of the time and my wife maybe 15%. Alexa let’s strangers talk to your kids and replies in memes and farts, Siri genuinely barely understands English, and I haven’t used Microsoft’s video game character but at least the other three are so far from “impressive” it’s hard to take the article seriously with an intro like that. Is anyone impressed by the state of voice recognition or the utility of voice assistance?