8 ms·
Portugal announces immediate granting of visas for Ukrainian refugees
- b112 5y agoWomen are not vulnerable.
- lvass 5y agoTrue, but I feel it has more to do with foreign women historically being considered assets while men, liabilities. Vast majority of ME migrants are men.
- boston_clone 5y agoIn this context, they are. Not every facet of society has caught up to idealized equity. There is compulsory military service for Ukrainian men, and it should be fair to say that those without military training are objectively more vulnerable during a conflict.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- b112 5y agoRight, because the men involved are not vulnerable to harm, while being shot at? And because a 50 year old man, is alway more able than a 20 year old woman? Because he was trained 30 years ago? Maybe? Come on. The context was "women and children" as the vulnerables. And the order is, men must stay, not military trained men. I bet there are loads of "vulnerable" women who have stayed to fight.
- boston_clone 5y agoYou're welcome to play armchair general, but it's becoming obvious that you don't have much military experience. > the men involved are not vulnerable to harm [...]? That's not what I said. I'll restate my thought more plainly: in any kinetic conflict, you are more vulnerable without military training. Full stop. Again, service is compulsory for men in Ukraine. So, generally speaking, yes - a 50 year old man with a few years of military experience will be more capable in a conflict than a 20 year old woman with no military experience whatsoever. The ability to shoot, move, and communicate - under extreme pressure, and hopefully coordinated with others - is not something you can muster up on-the-fly. Are there exceptions to that? I'm sure of it. But we should try not to argue a position which hinges largely on outliers. > I bet there are loads of "vulnerable" women who have stayed to fight. You should feel welcome to find and provide data to support your assertion.
- b112 5y agoWomen can't have military training unless it is compulsory? And all women in the Ukraine are born there? Your attempts to explain away bias, are not very convincing. Not to mention the fact: https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/12/27/ukraine-requires-women-register-military-conscription-russia-threat-looms.html https://www.military.com/daily-news/2021/12/27/ukraine-requi... and https://nypost.com/2022/02/10/meet-ukraines-gun-toting-female-soldiers-fighting-the-propaganda-war-with-russia/ https://nypost.com/2022/02/10/meet-ukraines-gun-toting-femal... But yeah, sure, it's never sexist to think a woman can't possibly be doing something, right? Women are not vulnerable. Stop with the shifting sands, attempt to reframe the statement. Women are not vulnerable.
- boston_clone 5y agoAnyone in a war zone is vulnerable - woman or man, child or elder. Training helps makes it less so, but it's never zero. Recognizing that most of an army is comprised of men is not automatically sexist; clearly the Ukrainian military doesn't prohibit women from joining. Encouraging people with no military background or ability to leave a conflict zone is not sexist, neither is it ageist or ableist. It is purely a matter of survival. On that note, I'm going to take some breaths and be thankful for the privilege to argue about nuance on the internet.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoAll unarmed civilians are vulnerable, women slightly more so, and children especially.
- dang 5y agoPlease do not take HN threads into flamewar hell. It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30477450 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30477450.
- iamsaitam 5y agoNow we just have to stop giving passports to Russian oligarchs..
- belter 5y agoContext: Portugal has a large and extremely well integrated Ukrainian community. Ukrainians constitute the second-largest foreign community residing in Portugal. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainians_in_Portugal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainians_in_Portugal
- IgorPartola 5y agoAs a Ukrainian, I did not know that! Very cool.
- DoingIsLearning 5y agoPortugal has had a really amazing experience with both Ukranian and Moldovan immigrant communities, the general sentiment is that they work hard and are generally extremely well qualified/experienced. But not to take away from the solidarity which is indeed genuine. Portugal also has an extremely low birth rate problem and needs tax payers fast in order to prevent state pension funds' collapse in the next decades. So there is also a secondary motive here to attract families to Portugal.
- spaniard89277 5y agoThe problem I see in Portugal is that doing business is expensive. Also, their internal market has very low disposable income, with high taxes thus low savings. And they seem to go doubling down on it, unless you're a rich foreigner.
- belter 5y agoIf you are getting shot at by Russian soldiers, I don't think the solution involves business tax optimization...
- spaniard89277 5y agoI know I know, I apologize.
- vindarel 5y agoBeautiful Portugal.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoWhen I was a child I remember some Hungarian refugees that my parents helped in the 1980s. I really hope we are not going to see an iron curtain v2! But there is hope: Finland, the Baltic States, Poland. Russian rule never lasts.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoPortugal is such an awesome country. I love going there and wouldn't mind staying there a bit longer at some point. More countries should do this; Germany and my home country the Netherlands in particular. I live in Berlin currently as a foreigner (perfect place for that). Lots of people from all over eastern Europe live here, lots of companies here outsource all over eastern Europe, lots of people that I know either come from or have friends/family from the Ukraine. Also, about 200k people of Russian origin live here that chose to move here after the wall fell. And I assume quite a few Ukranians. I remember meeting refugees from the former Yugoslavia in the nineties. I think 25 years later, a lot of those people did pretty well. I actually visited Bosnia for work last summer and met a guy that went to school in Munich. Likewise a lot of Syrian refugees that ended up in Germany seem to be doing OK. Quite a few ended up here in Berlin. In times of war, people are generally grateful if you accommodate them; even if it isn't always with open arms. It's usually the smart, free thinkers that need to flee. Incidentally those are also people likely to find a way to make it in life; start businesses; or otherwise be generally successful. The US is full of such people that emigrated there after various wars in the last century. Now is not a time to be xenophobic about this sort of thing.
- tluyben2 5y agoThe Netherlands (my birth country as well) should indeed do this but basically every other country has more and cheaper space to house them. I worked with people (100s) from the UA for the last 30 years and I think this is good for the EU even outside war.
- trasz 5y agoThis. It’s particularly good for my home country, Poland, which is extremely homogenic at the moment.
- weatherlite 5y agoThere's pros and cons to that. Some of the cons could be (not always, but definitely sometimes) the creation of parallel societies, high unemployment and crime rate and a possible decline of the welfare state (due to people not wanting to pay a lot of taxes to support people who are less "like them"). Success depends a lot on the host society, on the immigrants themselves and the values they grew up with and a whole bunch of other factors. And in general in times of economic hardships (which we are very fast heading into) it's hard to assimilate immigrants. Also we need to talk about volume and skills - the current Ukrianian diaspora in the EU is highly skilled, young and relatively small. What happens when you inject millions more (Ukraine has a population of 40+ million) including the elderly and the unskilled? It's a different ballgame. I think the best we can hope for is for the situation there to relax and for the poor Ukranians to be able to live peacefully in their home country. For most people - living in a foreign country is hard and not a blessing.
- tluyben2 5y agoExcellent news; I live in PT and already offered my house to UA friends but they were worried how to stay here longer term. There we go. Unfortunately most of my former colleagues cannot leave; they are men under 60 so they have to stay; the families that got out are looking for space.
- qnsi 5y agoSomething interesting I guess most people don't know, the pro-ukrainian mobilisations in Poland (I can only speak about Poland) is amazing. My FB wall is full of people providing their apartments for free, giving jobs etc. There is over 100 cars long queue at a border willing to transport Ukrainians escaping war where they want. They can travel by train for free in Poland. Now not so good tidbit. Just few months ago we had a lot of people lured into Belarus by Lukashenko trying to come to Europe. Poland treated them really really poorly. Catching them after crossing border and pushing them back. The society was split among pro-refugees and anti. The political parties almost all focused on "protecting our border". I was afraid that this natalist sentiment might repeat, even though Ukrainians are one of the closest people to Poland. I am very happy to note I haven't heard anyone speaking against refugees from Ukraine, not on twitter not on facebook not by far-right parties, altough I am sure some people are silent about their opinions.
- futharkshill 5y agoPoland has a collective memory of Russian oppression and aggression
- EugeneOZ 5y agoMaybe it's time to stop cultivating this hatred. Otherwise, you’ll have to keep hating other nations. It's a road to hatred hell - many countries and nations in Europe had conflicts. Separate a regime from a nation. I don't know any Russian (I’m Russian in Spain) who would have any negativity to the Poles. Maybe it would be better to stop the hatred from another side as well.
- publicola1990 5y agoWill Portugal do the same for Angolans?
- belter 5y agoIs Angola currently under Russian Invasion? Angola standards of living improved remarkably in the last few years, has oil reserves as big as Saudi Arabia. Oil production from Angola has increased so significantly that Angola now is China's biggest supplier of oil.
- refurb 5y agoThat’s fair. A touch indelicate, but fair.
- libertine 5y agoHmm I don't get this question... Why do the same for Angola, if Angola is in a completely different situation, plus it has it's own relationship with Portugal? There are plenty of protocols between Portugal and Angola, including visas, access to education, etc. Do you realize that by asking that question, you're undermining the situation in Ukraine, right?
- i_no_can_eat 5y agoI'm not sure what you're trying to say... Is Angola under invasion right now?
- publicola1990 5y agoAngola was a Portuguese colonial possession, and the question is if this sort of warm welcome was ever extended to those people of Angola who were under distress, who experienced subjugation under Portuguese rule itself. What is happening in Ukraine, Portugal is not complicit in anyway. But in Angola and other places where Portuguese complicity was involved were such warm gestures and measures so forthcoming is the question.
- i_no_can_eat 5y ago
- dr_faustus 5y agoIt’s horrible to consider this angle, but this could turn out to be a blessing for many European countries. There is a massive shortage of labour in large parts of Europe. There are large, well integrated Ukrainian minorities already in many European countries and many Ukrainians are well educated (esp. in the much needed STEM fields). So not to put Portugal down but it is certainly to some point self serving and I could actually see competition between Euro countries for those people in the medium term.
- trasz 5y agoThere’s no such thing as “shortage of labor”. What you are thinking of is shortage of wages.
- impossiblefork 5y agoI don't think that's true. Even skilled immigration depresses wages of skilled workers. There's an analysis from the Dutch government Bureau for Economic Policy Analysis on this, which shows essentially this, which can be found in English translation on https://www.cpb.nl/sites/default/files/publicaties/download/immigration-and-dutch-economy.pdf https://www.cpb.nl/sites/default/files/publicaties/download/.... One thing that I think is neglected even in this study however, is that bringing in even a very productive person increases things like housing competition, and even just bringing in a few people can cause prices to balloon, just as a tiny shortage can cause prices to balloon. It would therefore almost certainly be better to have Ukraine functioning and for Europe to trade with an ever more integrated and ever more well-functioning Ukraine. Letting these people in isn't something is good for the economy, it's a matter of protecting people from war-- i.e. they're refugees.
- weatherlite 5y ago> It would therefore almost certainly be better to have Ukraine functioning and for Europe Indeed, it sound crazy to me for Europe to be able to successfully absorb 40+ million Ukraianians. And even if the guy is only talking about absorbing the young and skilled, it's just gonna hurt those in the Ukraine who will be left behind.
- lispm 5y agoWar refugees won't need a visa. EU will take them without visa - because there will be so many - they get asylum. Poland already has several 10k refugees. But there will be a million or more. Germany took more than 700000 refugees from Syria, last time. We will see similar numbers of refugees coming from the Ukraine. It's Putin's war. He is destroying lives. He is a war criminal.
- belter 5y agoA war criminal that the EU keeps funding by continuing to buy gas. It used to be illegal to fund terrorist organizations but Germans and other EU countries dependent on Russian gas keep funding a terrorist country. I would rather be cold than see Russians at the end of my street.
- DoingIsLearning 5y ago> the EU keeps funding by continuing to buy gas. That is a bit of a broad generalization. The baltic countries, Bulgaria, Hungary, Slovenia, Slovakia, Austria and Germany are the main dependents on Russian gas, most of the EU27 are not energy dependent on Russia.
- reducesuffering 5y agoItaly too, with 46% of gas from Russia, just under Germany's 49%.
- zx85wes 5y agoWe buy oil from Saudi Arabia too.
- lispm 5y agoLots of countries are buying oil or gas from Russia. Including the Ukraine and the USA. The USA imports around 22 million barrels oil per month from Russia.
- buybackoff 5y agoAnd Portugal should cancel Abramovich citizenship, who is one of the closest to Putin oligarchs. My guess is at the time when he applied for citizenship he knew about what was going to happen, at least in general. Now as a citizen of EU member state he is exempt from yesterday's EU sanctions and probably any future sanctions. I'm afraid EU will not be able to impose personalized sections on him while he has this citizenship.
- belter 5y agoAlready being discussed: https://www.theportugalnews.com/news/2022-02-24/golden-visas-granted-to-russians-in-portugal-attacked/65468 https://www.theportugalnews.com/news/2022-02-24/golden-visas... The UK government has in that domain a lot of work to do.
- Tsiklon 5y agoThe party which forms the current UK government has received significant investment from wealthy Russian individuals. I do not trust them to make credible changes in this regard. Instead I expect them to punish regular Russian citizens who wish to visit or do business in the UK, and who cannot avail of the privilege afforded to those with significant wealth.
- reducesuffering 5y agoIt is quite interesting that two people very close to Putin, Press Secretary Peskov and Abramovich, both have daughters that went on social media decrying the war. The way Sergei speaks to the public here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9A-u8EoWcI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9A-u8EoWcI in front of Putin is pretty damning too. Already a Duma member has denounced the war. It's looking more and more like Putin has basically gone rogue mad and even his inner circle is showing immense cracks of support for this insanity. Also in insanely damning excerpt from that conversion with Putin and Sergei: Sergei: "I support the proposal about entry of Donetsk and Luhansk into Russian Federation." Putin: "We are not talking about that. We are not discussing that. We're talking about recognizing their independence or not. Yes or no?" Sergei: "Yes. I support the proposal to recognize their independence." Also both Donetsk and Luhansk leaders became members of Putin's United Russia political party in 2021. Just in case anyone had any doubts about Russian's intentions for independent states.
- mderazon 5y agoWhen Covid started, Portugal told everyone with temporary visas that they can stay and not worry about their visa being expired for the time being. Now this.. They seem to have their priorities right
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoHow about granting visas for Russian refugees??! We've been under Putin's heel far longer. :(
- nickpp 5y ago
- heavenlyblue 5y agoI like how it is said Putin when there’s 200K (numbers approximate ?) Russian kids who are currently shooting at Ukrainians
- reducesuffering 5y agoYou have to keep in mind that these are human beings, who generally grew up in relative poverty (around 1/10th of the income of the average westerner), are fed constant Russian propaganda on TV, and by many recent reports, thought they were doing military drills until within days notice they were suddenly sent across the border with sugar-coated justifications (there's on outbreak of Nazis, go save the Ukrainian people and Donbas from them).
- birdyrooster 5y agoI think the West expects you to stay to work stop and generally burden and disrupt the regime internally.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoYeah yeah. What forces Putin throws against the Ukraine he always had at his disposal in Russia, and he wouldn't hesitate to open fire on unarmed civilians. So far stopping giving us visas is quite like how European countries were turning away jews fleeing the Nazi Germany. Jews should have stayed and 'disrupted the regime internally'.
- 5y ago
- chris_overseas 5y agoMeanwhile the UK has done the opposite and suspended visas[0] for Ukrainians stuck in the UK. What the hell... [0] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/ukraine-war-refugees-uk-visas-b2022567.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/ukraine-war-... [Edit: see my response further down, this looks to have been addressed by a change in the Home Office's wording]
- hhmc 5y agoI haven't dug especially deep on this, but I thought what was actually happening here is that visas are no longer being processed in kyiv or further east (due to consulate staff have been evacuated). However they are still being processed in e.g lviv (or in, say, poland).
- chris_overseas 5y agoI think you're right. Looking at the Home Office website it appears that they have clarified the wording compared to what was quoted in the Independent article. The quoted text in the article was: > "Ukrainian nationals in Ukraine (who aren’t immediate family members of British nationals normally living in Ukraine, or where the British national is living in the UK), are currently unable to make visa applications to visit, work, study or join family in the UK.” The Home Office site[0] now says: > "Ukrainian nationals in Ukraine (who aren’t immediate family members of British nationals normally living in Ukraine, or where the British national is living in the UK), are currently unable to make visa applications to visit, work, study or join family in the UK through a VAC in Ukraine. If you are able to safely travel, you can apply through a VAC in one of the nearby countries." Which of course is in line with the reality of the consulate being closed in Kyiv. [0] https://www.gov.uk/guidance/support-for-family-members-of-british-nationals-in-ukraine-and-ukrainian-nationals-in-ukraine-and-the-uk https://www.gov.uk/guidance/support-for-family-members-of-br...
- mhh__ 5y agoI'm not familiar with this article yet but the British home office's political purpose to Tory governments is to antagonize immigrants and similar acts to appease hardline (racist, I won't mince my words) elements of British society. Priti Patel is taking this particularly seriously, so as a result of her own incompetence and fascistic tendencies, we might do something really quite stupid. There's geopolitics to play here, so I expect the UK will take on Ukrainians regardless of domestic pandering (Eastern European migration is not seen positively by many British people).
- quattrofan 5y ago[dead]
- alberth 5y agoPieter Levels of Nomadlist.com fame lives in Portugal and even started a new company making it easier to gain residency in Portugal. https://rebase.co/ https://rebase.co/ Portugal is extremely welcoming of new residents.
- nxmnxm99 5y agoSomehow I don't think there will be as much outrage as there was with Middle Eastern refugees.
- zx85wes 5y agoDuring the 2015 crisis only 1.3 million people requested asylum. I think many many more people will come this time. This will lead to severe housing shortages, building activity causing stress, shortage of jobs, etc ,etc.