8 ms·
Microwave drilling. It's a known thing at small scale.[1] If it can be done at larger scale, it ought to have other applications. Doing it downhole at the end o
by Animats 5y ago
Microwave drilling. It's a known thing at small scale.[1] If it can be done at larger scale, it ought to have other applications. Doing it downhole at the end of a long pipe string is going to be much harder than doing it in a factory. So why isn't this an industrial machining process already, like plasma cutting?
GA Drilling was pushing plasma drilling back in 2018.[2] They're still pushing it, but not making holes.
The University of Minnesota was pushing electro-pulse boring in 2015.[3] Again, no deep holes.
There's something called ThermoDrilling, which, despite the name, is more like a water jet cutter.[4]
Successful projects are still using mechanical drilling.[5]
So there are a lot of deep hole drilling approaches being studied. Anything that works would be used by the oil and gas industry, and if they're not trying it, one suspects it might not be working.
[1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/270653673_Microwave_Drilling_of_Materials https://www.researchgate.net/publication/270653673_Microwave...
[2] https://www.gadrilling.com/ https://www.gadrilling.com/
[3] https://experts.umn.edu/en/publications/electro-pulse-boring-epb-novel-super-deep-drilling-technology-for https://experts.umn.edu/en/publications/electro-pulse-boring...
[4] https://www.geodrillinginternational.com/deep-geothermal/news/1385347/thermodrill-an-innovative-drilling-system-for-deep-geothermal https://www.geodrillinginternational.com/deep-geothermal/new...
[5] https://geothermalengineering.co.uk/united-downs/ https://geothermalengineering.co.uk/united-downs/
- leoedin 5y agoThis could also have good use for ground source heat pumps - they're the most efficient, robust and consistent source of domestic heating we have, but require fairly deep (60m ish) boreholes. If digging could be quicker, easier or faster these heat pumps could be installed everywhere.
- hectormalot 5y agoI have one of those. The well is 170m deep. Took 2 guys about half a day to drill it, so that actually doesn’t seem excessive in terms of time required (mostly sand, no rock below my house).
- NavinF 5y agoI assume you mean “2 guys and some heavy equipment”? As a kid it took me a whole summer of on-and-off digging to make a 1 meter deep hole for fun.
- oliveshell 5y agoThat’s what they mean. My neighbor had one drilled and the contractors showed up with a huge well-drilling truck. It’s just a huge vertical drill with segments you add on as it goes deeper, like an oil well drill.
- hectormalot 5y agoCorrect, it's big but I wouldn't say huge (maybe 4.5x2.5m). This is the machine they used: https://conrad-stanen.nl/nl/producten/boxer-200 https://conrad-stanen.nl/nl/producten/boxer-200
- oliveshell 5y agoMost drills I’ve used fit in your hand. Compared to that, it’s huge :) (although on rereading I didn’t mean to say ‘huge’ twice in my previous post)
- dpark 5y agoOut of curiosity, what were you digging with? Unless you were digging with a toy sand shovel or making a very large hole, that seems like a very long time. As a kid, my cousin, my sister, and myself were able to dig a hole deep enough for me to be completely inside in an hour or two using a post hole digger. (Yes, this is a very stupid idea.)
- jmacd 5y agoYou have to make sure it's straight, drop sheathing in to the hole, and then cap it if it isn't going to be used right away. More importantly, geothermal/ground source is rarely 1 well either, in our case it was 8.
- OJFord 5y agoThey can also be horizontal, covering a larger area at a much shallower depth.
- meltedcapacitor 5y agoIndeed horizontal (pipe network, like underfloor heating in reverse) is the most efficient solution, digging deep is for when the plot is too small or otherwise encumbered (or if one sits on top of a volcano).
- happytiger 5y agoExcept this technology is for after you get to the plate of rock at the bottom of topsoil unfortunately. They mentioned it in the article. You use conventional drilling to get to depth first.
- bjourne 5y agoCouldn't we have one big plant with a large hole that distributes heat to surrounding homes?
- tinco 5y agoA 60m borehole is not a source of energy, it is a store of energy. It only makes sense if you can sink enough heat into it in the summer, to use that energy in the winter. Or vice versa in warmer climates.
- jmacd 5y agoWe have a ground source heat pump and one summer we were away and did not use out air conditioning that year much at all. Mid winter our return loop temperatures (the glycol being brought in to our heat pump after circulating in the ground) was at one point 3 degrees C cooler than it had been any other year. Quite a noticeable difference. For reference, our loops are 8 vertical at 250ft.
- FredPret 5y agoWait, do you need eight 250ft wells?
- derefr 5y ago> Anything that works would be used by the oil and gas industry, and if they're not trying it, one suspects it might not be working. To flip that around: this would imply that the most under-investigated-in-industry approaches to deep hole boring would be the ones that destroy the economic value of any oil-and-gas in the ground, no? Ones that make the ground radioactive, perhaps. Or that would set any potential oil fields on fire, or react them away, or irrevocably mix a combustion-inhibiting azeotropic solvent into them.
- WJW 5y ago> this would imply that the most under-investigated-in-industry approaches to deep hole boring would be the ones that destroy the economic value of any oil-and-gas in the ground, That is only one explanation to why a technology would be among the most under-investigated-in-industry approaches. There are many others, such as: - It does not work at all. - It is more expensive than traditional methods - It is illegal in some way - It is incompatible with the rest of oil&gas processing.
- XorNot 5y agoOption C: it doesn't solve enough problems for oil and gas to have been worth pursuing compared to iterative improvements to existing systems. Whereas for geothermal, conventional drilling isn't useful enough for it.
- peterburkimsher 5y agoOil companies sell finite fuel for energy to people in cars, on the move. Geothermal heating provides unlimited fuel for people in houses, staying still. The technology is similar, and it's boring ;-) The market is different. This is an opportunity for entrepreneurs to hire expert drilling engineers out of the oil industry!
- ijidak 5y ago> Geothermal heating provides unlimited fuel for people in houses, staying still This sounds like the beginning of a great sci-fi novel. A future where Earth's core has cooled because of excess draws to power humanity. Now, the planet is losing it's magnetic field. To save humanity, humans need to re-heat the core, build biospheres, or leave the planet.
- kragen 5y agoConventional “mechanical” drilling isn’t very heat tolerant because heat softens metal. For oil and even gas drilling it doesn’t need to be; they’re located in cooler rock. For supercritical steam EGS heat tolerance is a sine qua non. Conventional approaches might still work best, but it’s also plausible that what’s best for gas isn’t best for EGS.
- raducu 5y agoBut if we get to temperatures that destory metals, isn't it enough? Why don't we drill to whatever is the termal limit, make a big cavity there, install radiators there and just heat the watter to that temperature and take it out to surface where we can heat homes. I know this is done in Bucharest for a water park (to much lesser depths because apparently we have hot springs near Bucharest). Do we need to reach magma?
- Retric 5y agoMetals start to get weaker at relatively low temperatures. https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/metal-temperature-strength-d_1353.html https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/metal-temperature-strengt... We want to extract 100’s of MW of heat which presents several issues. You need a thermal gradient to move heat from the surrounding rock to the water your pumping in. The higher the initial temperature the larger the difference and therefore faster you can extract heat. Aka even if the working fluid is at a constant temperature you can simply pump it faster. Also, Carnot efficiency limits means you want the hottest steam you can handle. Further, you have various inefficiencies such as losing heat as water moves back up a borehole.
- kragen 5y agoThis is about running your air conditioner, charging your Tesla, and molding your kitchen sink, not heating homes. Think Carnot efficiency, power density, supercritical steam, and shutting down gas pipelines. And the temperature to destroy steel under the immense mechanical stress of a drill string is surprisingly modest. Jet fuel can’t melt steel beams, but softening them is enough.
- theptip 5y agoVery interesting context here, thanks. Do you know of any write-ups that give a deeper picture of the progress of any of these (or other similar) projects? It seems that there are tough problems to be solved, but we're just seeing the marketing materials.
- fly-guy 5y agoAnother thing that should be considered: how do you keep the hole open while drilling? At extreme P and T, the hole will close in on the drillstring. Also, fluids turn very nasty in those conditions. You'll need some unobtanium and some of Superman's suit material.