3 ms·
My nerves are showing here, but economic-policy-by-literary-allusion is, I kid you not, a bad idea. Policy questions should be decided by cause, effect, evidenc
by roenxi 5y ago
My nerves are showing here, but economic-policy-by-literary-allusion is, I kid you not, a bad idea. Policy questions should be decided by cause, effect, evidence and discussion. "You've got sympathies for Ebenezer Scrooge!" is possibly the bottom of the barrel of counters if you seriously want good outcomes.
- dTal 5y agoThat's kind of rich, considering you kicked off a discussion about minumum wage with "Bob Cratchit had it pretty good actually". How did you expect people to respond to that?
- romwell 5y agoIt's not your nerves that are showing here if you can't figure out that 98% of employees make more than the Federal minimum wage because state/city minimum wage is higher than Federal in many states and cities. That's ignoring a huge number of people making barely above minimum wage in their locality (enough to fall in that percentage, not enough to make a difference in quality of life). I'll take economic policy by allusion to literature over economic policy by ignorance and bad faith any time of the day, thank you.
- dalbasal 5y agoPerhaps, but perhaps not. We think in stories, and economists use the term "story" frequently as a quasi term of art. Well understood cause, effect and evidence are few and far between in social sciences.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>"You've got sympathies for Ebenezer Scrooge!" is possibly the bottom of the barrel of counters if you seriously want good outcomes. Honestly, I'm not so sure about that. Pointing out that someone is making the same arguments as an archetype of cruelty should be cause for reflection at the very least.
- roenxi 5y agoScrooge isn't an archetype for cruelty though, he is miserliness. And that also goes to why allusion is a bad approach - interpreting a story isn't that much less political than politics except the topic gets derailed into a literal fantasy hypothetical. Dickens didn't exactly take a statistical sample of the people in London to come up with the story, he had a conclusion and was constructing a situation where it made sense. The fact he did so in an eloquent and entertaining way is not basis for attempting to come up with a policy. Nobody should be using 1850s popular literature as a serious contribution. We've got more than 150 years of policy experiments and records of outcomes when it comes to labour policy since then. Someone who has read up on that should be leading the debate, not the Ghost of Christmas Past.
- AussieWog93 5y ago>Scrooge isn't an archetype for cruelty though, he is miserliness. He absolutely is an archetype of cruelty. Not in the sadistic sense, but in the sense that he was completely unsympathetic to the plight of those around him and allowed them to suffer needlessly (until the three visits). >Dickens didn't exactly take a statistical sample of the people in London to come up with the story He didn't need to. A statistical sample of the city of London "measured him", in a way, when they all read the book and it resonated with their experience. >Nobody should be using 1850s popular literature as a serious contribution. Nobody is suggesting we base economic policy on a fictional story from 150 years ago. I am, and I suspect parent is as well, reminding you that your argument sounds cruel and miserly. This is a valid and useful heuristic, especially considering that your argument is: - Deliberately misleading (or at best, ignorant) with the "2%" statistic - Completely ignorant of the human experience (You actually argued that people leaving behind their friends, family and community to "move to a low cost of living area in this era of fantastic communication and easy travel" was somehow progress, as well as suggesting that workers shouldn't be paid enough to support a family because not everyone has a family - the logical outcome being that people cannot afford to start a family and their lineage simply dies.) - Lacking in substance in general (you don't provide a single reason or shred of evidence as to how or why your ideal world would actually have a more prosperous, or stable, or healthy, or "better" society in any way - just that it would align better with the way you think the world should be.) >We've got more than 150 years of policy experiments and records of outcomes when it comes to labour policy since then. And yet the experts still fuck it up on a daily basis. Look at the response of the IMF to the Asian Crisis of 1997, or compare Europe's response to the GFC to Australia's. Lee Kuan Yew has openly stated in interviews before that part of the reason he was so successful was that he ignored international economic experts when they were trying to push numerically-backed bullshit ideology onto Singapore. >Someone who has read up on that should be leading the debate, not the Ghost of Christmas Past. In all seriousness, the fact that a book from 150 years ago is still seen as relevant today suggests that maybe we shouldn't just throw out its messages as worthless. Its ideas have survived almost two centuries of harsh memetic competition. How long have the current economic ideas been around for?
- pasquinelli 5y agoi wonder if this discussion thread on hacker news will influence economic policy, or if it willbe forgotten in a few minutes.