14 ms·
Finland or Sweden joining NATO would spark Russian response, Russia warns
- lawn 5y agoThen if they did join NATO, then Russia would declare an attack on NATO? Or the more likely explanation is that this threat makes it less likely NATO would accept them.
- sharken 5y agoThis is an empty threat from Putin, he may be close to a madman but he is not stupid. Attacking NATO will mean his removal from power, most likely by someone within his own ranks. If Sweden or Finland wants in, then NATO should comply as fast as possible.
- belter 5y agoTechnically, if there were attacked this evening, nobody in the US or EU would come to help them. They would be AND are in the same situation as Ukraine.
- jacquesm 5y agoYou may be right about the US, but you are probably wrong about the EU.
- belter 5y agoEverybody would wish them well, argue they have a strong army and can resist the Russian army, but no sorry, no Spanish or German or French troops dying for Finland or Sweden any time soon. They better hurry up.
- jacquesm 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Security_and_Defence_Policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Security_and_Defence_Po...
- FrenchAmerican 5y agoThanks for the reference, I has not heard of this CSDP. However, if I was quite sure nobody would sent troops to Ukraine, Sweden sounds very close to my French ears. Finland is more difficult to defend but the Southern part of Sweden, the most inhabited, is close enough to project troops rapidly. The USA would also be able to send fighters and bombers from the Thule airbase to bomb troups on the northern part of Sweden, as well as English airforce from Scotland. Other smaller airforces from Norway, Belgium, etc will help avoiding air superiority to Russia. The USA, the UK and France would deploy their fleet with their aircraft carriers. Furthermore, my feeling is that France and the UK would send troops to Sweden. Germany would provide at least transport and material support as it did in previous cases (first war against Iraq, current anti-djihadist operations in Sahel). Germany avoid sending troops abroad but discreetly enables France and the USA for example with support. The public opinions of at least those three countries would be strong against Russia now that Putin's intentions have been revealed. Southern countries of EU would react too, at minimum by blocking access to the Atlantic through the Mediterranean sea, as well as support of all kinds. I don't feel being culturally close to Ukraine. Attacking Sweden is just a direct attack to the West. I feel closer to Sweden than to the Baltic states. Not that I don't support Ukraine 100% against Russia. I don't know if France is secretly sending large amounts of weapons to Ukraine. I wish we were but I doubt it - Macron always sides with big corporate's interests and French are the first investors in Russia. Germany also tends to put business first towards Russia. But Sweden is different. It's the West. Finland has its own strategy towards Russia. If Sweden ask.for help, I don't see western countries react as they do these days with Ukraine (eg ineffective economic sanctions). I think it would have been the same before Ukraine's invasion but because of it, my opinion is that we would send troops. Even I would enlist (boy, I'd need training just to get in shape and learn to shoot - so I'd probably be put somewhere at the supply chain or driving some truck.
- foogazi 5y agoDo Sweden or Finland have any mutual defense agreements themselves or with other countries (Norway?) - or is NATO the only club in Europe ?
- jacquesm 5y agoNo, Europe is the only club in Europe and both Sweden and Finland are part of the EU Security pact. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Security_and_Defence_Policy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Security_and_Defence_Po... NATO is trans continental.
- jopsen 5y ago> Technically, if there were attacked this evening, nobody in the US or EU would come to help them. Nobody would bound by a public alliance to help them. We don't know if secret agreements exists? But I guess such agreements would be easier to not honor. And just because NATO isn't required to intervene, that's not the same as they wouldn't. In theory it's a bit like Ukraine, except Finland and Sweden are less corrupt, more wealthy, etc.
- toxik 5y agoLet me get this straight, you believe that if Russia invaded northern Europe outright, central and south Europe would not intervene? I guess some topics aren’t great to discuss on HN.
- belter 5y agoIts two non NATO members. Europe would not do for them what does not do for Ukraine.
- toxik 5y agoYou are completely ignorant of the current status and history of Europe. An attempted invasion of Finland and Sweden would be an unambiguous declaration of war on the European Union, there is no other interpretation. China would, no doubt, take such an opportunity to move on its military goals (eg Taiwan). It would mark the beginning of a third world war. If you don't even believe that the EU would defend its own territory, well, you are just simply insane.
- belter 5y agoIts not a question of being insane. It's different if you can have your boys back in body bags. You forgot this is the second war in European territory after the Yugoslavian wars. For months Sarajevo was being shelled and nothing was done until the US decided it was time to bomb. The Netherlands had a full battalion protecting a Bosnian enclave and let 7000 men be killed in front of their eyes. The Dutch government was not willing to order an air strike to protect their own troops. Unless it's NATO, I guarantee you, nothing will be done. They are not even willing to cut gas import from Russia....
- toxik 5y agoThe Balkan situation was much more similar to what's going on in Ukraine right now, there was really no immediate threat to the rest of Europe. Invading especially Sweden is completely different in this regard. If Sweden, why not Denmark, the Baltics, etc. Finland is unique as it has historically been both Swedish and Russian territory, and borders both, but it is still nowhere near as ambiguous as Ukraine. There will be no breakaway provinces in Finland like Donetsk and Luhansk, there was no mass movement of Russian nationals to Finland during Soviet times as there was throughout the Soviet union. There is very little footing for Russian sentiment in Finland, and Finnish culture is at its core defined by the atrocities committed in the Civil War following the fall of the Tzar, and later the Winter War and Continuation Wars with the Soviet Union. Wars with Russia is part of Finnish DNA. It is just a completely different situation to what goes on in the former east bloc.
- ceejayoz 5y ago"We'll invade you if you join NATO" loses its power a bit when you invade people who haven't joined NATO.
- rhino369 5y agoEven worse, when you invade someone who tried to join NATO, was given the same warning, didn't join NATO, and then was invaded anyway. Finland and Sweden should join now while Russia doesn't have the ability to invade (because their forces are busy in Ukraine).
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoWhether they join or not, Finland and Sweden better beef up their defenses, starting yesterday...
- avgcorrection 5y agoWhat are you talking about? Sweden placed patrolling troops in Gotland right when Russia increased their presence in the Baltic Sea during this buildup.
- CRConrad 5y agoSweden has almost fuck-all to place anywhere compared to what it had a few decades ago. It's not like the Swedish Air Force is the fourth-largest in the world any more...
- Someone1234 5y agoI agree; I think there was this kind of default assumption (due to MAD) that wars in Northern Europe were mostly over. All these recent events have done is prove that nuclear nations will swallow up non-nuclear nations if they don't have a MAD assurance from an alley. Finland and Sweden should decide themselves what is best, but I only wish the best for both countries and after this I cannot bring myself to believe it couldn't happen again. The only major benefit Finland has over Ukraine is geography.
- vinceguidry 5y agoIt's like Russia was expecting to be able to conduct the largest aggressive conventional military operation in Europe since WW2 and not completely flip the apple cart of the global order.
- ch4s3 5y agoIt's starting to look like Putin may have miscalculated here.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoYeah, I bet they didn't count on losing the Champions League final. That's about the worst of impact so far.
- ch4s3 5y agoGermany froze the Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline project. Russia has a ton of reserves, but this will hobble them economically once the reserves are drawn down. The UK and US are debating seizing property belonging to Putin's circle of supporters, which could be very precarious for him domestically. Protests are breaking out in St. Petersburg and Moscow, and videos are turning up of captured Russian soldiers saying they didn't want to be part of the invasion. Things aren't going swimmingly for Putin.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoFreezing Nord Steam 2 was an obvious consequence. It must have been priced in to what ever calculation Putin is making. It wasn't in operation yet so it's not clear to me that it has any significant financial impact. Similarly, assets belonging to Putin and his supporters will have been well hidden before this kicked off. I agree though, the one positive light is the protests and people putting their lives on the line to come out against the invasion.
- CRConrad 5y ago
- belter 5y agoAs I wrote in another thread today, current EU and US leaders are asleep at the wheel. We have a different dynamic. Talking about sanctions looks almost pathetic. The analogy here is, you live in a community and one of your neighbors just lost it completely and is shooting and shelling another neighbor. Not to raise the hostilities...you scream at him he wont be invited anymore for the Christmas party and you will complain about the noise to the gated community administration /s
- prettygood 5y agoThis is a very delicate situation that can't be resolved by just sending troops and fighting. Neither the US nor Europe wants to have another world war. Definitely not now nuclear weapons are much more powerful.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoI'm pretty sure that we're in World War III. We're just trying to pretend that we're not. We're at least at the buildup to it.
- GoodJokes 5y ago
- tyre 5y agoThis is not a world war. The fighting is specific to a single area. The Vietnam War involved at least double the number of involved countries and wasn’t considered a world war.
- djxfade 5y agoWorld War II also started with fighting in a specific single are, until suddenly it wasn't in a single area anymore...
- 5y ago
- globalise83 5y agoNow is probably the only opportunity they will get. With much of Russia's army tied up in Ukraine they could join in secret overnight and in the morning the rest of NATO could land huge numbers of airborne reinforcements and the whole thing would be a fait accompli. The only response Putin could make would be to trigger WW3.
- cjbgkagh 5y agoMaking triggering WW3 his only remaining choice does not sound like a good idea
- iso1631 5y agoWhen do the billionaires backing him decide they don't want to rule over a nuclear wasteland? Can they even stop him?
- zajio1am 5y ago> billionaires backing him I think that you misunderstood their relationship. It is less 'billionaires backing him' and more 'billionares who are obedient to him, so they do not end with poisoned briefs'.
- twox2 5y agobillionaire's do not "back" him, they are his proxy. It's his money they are holding, not theirs.
- ledauphin 5y agoNo it doesn't, but at some point you have to consider the possibility that Putin isn't sane or rational in the way you would hope the person in charge of a major part of the world's nuclear arsenal would be. And if he is not sane, then it would be equally insane for the west to keep giving into his demands, given that we cannot then expect him to stop making them at any foreseeable point. No one "wants" WW3, much like no one "wanted" WW2 or WW1. But history has proven time and time again that simply backing away doesn't _necessarily_ reduce the chances that the war will occur. I am very, very curious how this is causing western intelligence agencies to update their analyses of Putin's psyche.
- usrme 5y agoAt this point is there anything substantive any country could do at all that wouldn't irritate Russia? It seems as if the powers that be have become so utterly delicate that even something as innocuous as Sweden joining NATO is deemed to be advancing far beyond the "proper" limits.
- ceejayoz 5y agoAbusive partners are rarely satisfied, and giving in to their demands rarely appeases for long. The same is true in international politics. If NATO's response isn't "we do what we want, fuck off" they've lost the next war already.
- wanda 5y ago> the powers that be I think the powers that be are the ones who are resisting intervening or even bearing their teeth ~ because in reality, they'd rather just go back to trading with or at least ignoring Russia. So much so that they'd far sooner appear indecisive and capricious, avoid direct involvement, and have scope to return to the status quo (regardless of the blood being spilled) as quickly as possible, never mind what happens to Ukraine.
- FrenchAmerican 5y agoConsider Sweden's geography along coast of the Baltic Sea ; joining NATO would basically close this path to the Atlantic Ocean for the Russian Navy. Well, at least if enough missiles and/or fighter jets are placed on its soil by NATO countries to effectively close the Baltic Sea in case of war.
- CRConrad 5y ago> Consider Sweden's geography along coast of the Baltic Sea ; joining NATO would basically close this path to the Atlantic Ocean for the Russian Navy. Given how narrow Öresund is, I'm fairly sure conventional artillery (not to mention missiles...) could cover the entire strait from the coast of NATO member Denmark. I doubt Sweden would protest too loudly about this incursion on her territorial waters, if she lets the Russian navy do the same first... And even if she does, so what?
- bjoli 5y agoWell then, Congratulations Russia! You have just given the Swedish NATO-movement more support than they could have ever mustered themselves! I have always been very sceptical of NATO membership, but the last month I changed opinion.
- pakitan 5y agoYou mean so far you've lived a peaceful life and were skeptical of joining NATO but now that you've seen what Russia did to Ukraine, you're tempted to share their fate?
- bjoli 5y agoDon't be stupid. You understand as well as anyone that there have been many good reasons not to join NATO. The other reply to my comment has a discussion about this that captures some aspects of it.
- hnarn 5y agoUkraine is not a member of Nato. Reconsider the logic in your line of thought.
- pakitan 5y agoMaybe you should reconsider your logic? Ukraine wasn't attacked because it's a NATO member, it was attacked because (among other things) it wanted to become NATO member. There isn't a process where you just submit your wish to become a member and the next day, voila, you're accepted! It's a long process and that's when you'll be most vulnerable to attack.
- hnarn 5y agoThe logic is that attacking a country that attempts to join a defensive alliance (Ukraine) underlines the undeniable necessity of that alliance existing in the first place. There would not be a point in joining Nato if Russia was a paper tiger, but they're working very hard to prove that they are not. They are painting a picture of themselves as violent, unpredictable and hostile to democratic values that we (Swedes) value highly. By your logic, if Russia ever did invade Sweden, the "logical" thing to do would be to lay down arms immediately: after all, we all want to live a "peaceful life", right? Presumably the same would go for Russia making demands on the size of Sweden's military budget.
- darksaints 5y agoGood, let them join. This whole cat and mouse game of petty escalations won't end with Putin on one side. This only ends with Putin dead or in prison. Let Finland and Sweden join NATO, grant Ukraine membership in NATO while we're at it. Our best chance at fighting Russia under Putin is to escalate to 100% all at once. He's betting that we'll go full Neville Chamberlain, and we can't give him that luxury.
- QuikAccount 5y agoFor those wondering why Sweden is included in this threat despite not sharing a border with Russia, Finland and Sweden are like best friends and have been approaching anything regarding NATO and Russia as a unit together. Sweden joining NATO pretty much automatically means Finland also intends to join NATO. Anyway, this threat loses a lot of teeth when the reason Ukraine is getting destroyed at the moment is because they are not in NATO.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Anyway, this threat loses a lot of teeth when the reason Ukraine is getting destroyed at the moment is because they are not in NATO. It is because they are not in NATO and also did not explicitly abandon the aspiration of joining. The threat is intended to get Finland and Sweden to explicitly disclaim any intent of joining NATO (and maybe make binding commitments), not just to get them to not apply. OTOH, as you note, it also underscores the benefit of getting into NATO and under the umbrella while Russia’s military is committed to Ukraine.
- edmundsauto 5y agoHonest question, do you really believe that Russias attack was based on the NATO aspirations, or is that just an excuse? I don’t take what Putin says at face value.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Honest question, do you really believe that Russias attack was based on the NATO aspirations, or is that just an excuse? Yes, and no. I think that acceding to Russia’s demands here could have forestalled an invasion for the time being, but would have led to increasing Russian demands to direct policy, backed by threat of force, with even less available outside assistance. Ultimately either invasion or becoming a Russian puppet state would be the end, unless something else altered Russia’s course. The long game is empire, but close NATO association is an urgent obstacle to the long game.
- _trackno5 5y ago
- travisgriggs 5y agoWe seem to be at an impass. NATO exists to help people not feel threatened by Russia. Putin has decided that the mere existence of a real NATO is a threat to Russia (he's fine with a paper tiger institution that is all but imaginary). It's like a European version of 1860 in the US. As an American, I'd be (emotionally, but not rationally) glad to just put an end to 100 years of Russian aggression, mostly because I'm a child of the cold war and do not want to go back to that existence. But this lies on Russia's neighbors first. EU countries need to lead the way here.
- Ekaros 5y agoIt really makes perfect sense. USA has long history of imperialism and anti-democratic actions. And USA is core of NATO. Any sane country knows that only safe way is to have reasonable buffer zone against such well known aggressor.
- 988747 5y agoWell, if Russia didn't act like a total asshole towards all their neighbors then maybe some of them would like to be their allies. The fact that Baltic states or Ukraine prefer to side with a "well known aggressor" instead of their "Slavic brothers" from Russia really tells you everything. Putin has no one to blame for that but himself.
- jacquesm 5y agoNo country that has experienced decades of Russian occupation wants to go back there.
- ledauphin 5y agoI want to keep the conversation substantive, but I also would like for you to see what you've said and see if you think you've contributed to the conversation so far: "[Russia] has long history of imperialism and anti-democratic actions. Any sane country knows that only safe way is to have reasonable buffer zone against such well known aggressor."
- 5y ago
- mupuff1234 5y agoDoesn't the EU membership also include some sort of mutual defense agreement?
- 988747 5y ago
- unpopularopp 5y agoYes, Treaty of Lisbon https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A12008M042 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A... >7. If a Member State is the victim of armed aggression on its territory, the other Member States shall have towards it an obligation of aid and assistance by all the means in their power, in accordance with Article 51 of the United Nations Charter. This shall not prejudice the specific character of the security and defence policy of certain Member States.
- hardlianotion 5y agoApparently! I found a link here that mentions France calling upon the obligation in 2015. http://euromil.org/france-invoked-mutual-defence-clause-for-the-first-time-in-eu-history/ http://euromil.org/france-invoked-mutual-defence-clause-for-...
- jacquesm 5y agoAbsolutely. Co-defense is now one of the pillars of the union, just Denmark and Malta that aren't in there: https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/defence-security/ https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/defence-security...
- watwut 5y agoAt this point, being in NATO feels safer then not being.
- Ekaros 5y ago
- watwut 5y agoNah, if this is dig at Biden, he is not doing that badly and is actually better predictable. Also, you don't seem to know what NATO is.
- Ekaros 5y agoI know, but I have observed what countries in NATO have done. And it's nothing but pure evil. And sadly there has been zero consequences...
- watwut 5y agoNato is mutal defense act. That is what it is. If your Russia attack Poland, other NATO members should treat it as attack on themselves. That is what it is.
- unethical_ban 5y agoSerbian?
- BuckRogers 5y agoI'm ashamed at our (the USA's) response. We have no choice here. When will this stop? Do we allow mutually assured destruction be used to have Putin march his troops into our beloved nation too? What about Georgia, Bosnia, Finland, Sweden? The only option, better done now than later is to ready, arm and prepare all our nuclear warheads, point them at Moscow, and then send our forces into Ukraine, repelling the Russians. If Russia fires a nuke, we let it all go. I'm prepared to head to the army recruiter today if we do this, the right thing. In that event, I hope the rest of my countrymen choose to join me. I wish Russia could've been integrated with the west long ago, and I think the only other way to prevent this conflict was to station NATO troops in Ukraine. The ship has sailed on both fronts. The only options are to fight now, or fight later. God bless the heroes of Ukraine. I hope we, myself included, are there soon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u0-Yeqh4PFY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u0-Yeqh4PFY
- dragontamer 5y agoWhat's the point of NATO if we just defend other countries who don't meet our requirements of NATO? NATO is _already_ in a tough spot, many countries will fail the 2% spending on defense requirement (though I'm sure Russia is making them reconsider). We can't just be throwing NATO's guarantees around to countries who didn't make it into the alliance yet. NATO is an alliance, and a defensive alliance at that. The line is literally drawn at Poland and Romania right now. We are debating if that line should include Finland and Sweden. ------- There are several requirements to join NATO: 1. The country must want to be part of NATO (and neither Finland nor Sweden wanted to join until recently). 2. The entire rest of NATO must accept them. 3. A few other things, but #1 and #2 are probably the most important. If we get those two things figured out, everything else is cake. ---- That being said: support to Ukraine economically and militarily (military aid) is still on the table and looks like its happening. Ukraine will fight its own war, but they can use our weapons while doing so. That was enough for France when it helped USA during the 1700s Revolutionary war, and the USA certainly remembers France's help in those troubling times. The "Arsenal of Democracy" approach. We likely will offer that to Finland / Sweden if they get attacked by Russia before they join NATO as well. But getting our blood directly involved in other people's wars is still a very difficult prospect. USA shouldn't overcommit, nor should NATO.
- camhart 5y agoRussia shouldn't be allowed to force decisions like this on any country. Let them join. We kicked the can down the road with Ukraine and look where that landed Ukraine. 2008 and 2014 we gave in and allowed Russia to do what they wanted. 2022 and Western countries are allowing it again. Its despicable. I don't want war. I don't want to go to war. But when someone approaches you and says "I own you" you either fight back or give in to being owned. Ukraine is facing that decision now, and they're fighting back. We should be doing more to help Ukraine. Other countries will face the same fate eventually if we don't put a stop to it now. Our responses since 2008 have failed in the long term. We need to do something different. I don't claim to have the right answer. I don't want to send our troops off to die. I don't want to get nuked or have to nuke anyone. But I honestly feel sick to my stomach right now over this. I know this isn't the only atrocity to occur without sufficient response from the Western world... but it's the one that's hit home for me for some reason.
- avgcorrection 5y agoWho are your troops?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ROTMetro 5y agoBy kicked the can you mean denied their pleading to allow them to join after they threw out the Russian backed government like the USA Clinton State Department encouraged them to do resulting in current events happening to them while the West looked on?
- ynfnehf 5y agoNote that it has been the choice of Sweden and Finland not to be a part of NATO. NATO would be more than happy to let them join, and the process would probably be quite quick as well. I think this is quite a significant difference from the situation with Ukraine.
- stunt 5y agoReplace Ukraine and Russia with Ireland and UK, and apply the same events that happened since 2000, you will end up with UK invading Ireland in 2022. I think this lecture (2015) explains the situation very well https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4
- anonyfox 5y agoAs a German I was today years old when I learned that sweden isnt part of the nato already … like the current secretary even sounds swedish by name … whelp Edit: really don’t want to sound ignorant here, just that while growing up and traveling around Central Europe there was a strong belief that we‘re all in the same boat and I even remember maps showing all countries (except Switzerland) in shades of „blue“ but … I never looked more deeply into that - until now
- sandman1906 5y agoJens Stoltenberg is Norwegian
- hnarn 5y agoYou haven't heard about Sweden being neutral for 200 years?
- jacquesm 5y agoJust in case: Neither is Switzerland. https://www.mappr.co/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/image-1.jpeg https://www.mappr.co/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/image-1.jpeg
- anonyfox 5y agoAnd austria too… somewhat shocking- I took this for granted for some reason
- bluGill 5y agoWhile Sweden was never part of NATO, there are rumors that under the table they were given assurance that if there was trouble NATO would be there. Sweden used to be a big world power.
- FrenchAmerican 5y agoWe don't even need rumors here. Now that Putin has invaded Ukraine, an invasion of Sweden will trigger boots, planes and vessels be sent from the USA and most European countries. Being part of NATO make it automatic. But Sweden would just have to ask for help. At first news of invasion, the USA, the UK, France (e.g. 3 nuclear powers) and most other EU countries will start prepare, awaiting for the Sweden to call. Fighters would be up in the air, patrolling along Sweden territory, ready to act immediately. Anyway, that won't happen soon. The Ukraine war is far from over ; it's likely to turn into a guerilla with money and weapons provided by the West. Ukrainians will come and be trained to guerilla warfare by the Eu countries and Russia will bleed. As large as the Russian army is, it can't control a rebellious country of 50M people. Some Ukrainians will join the Russians for sure, and most of the population will turn a blind eye, enabling the guerilla. The more the Russians react by punishing civilians trough indiscriminate shootings or mailings, the more recruits will join the guerrilla. This is going to be bloody for both sides. Ukrainians have tasted enough democracy and freedom for long enough to go back to an authoritian regime like Putin's or a dictatorship like Belarus. This could cause Putin to turn into an overt dictator in its own country. It will work for a while. And then he'll fall. That will be painful for all the peoples concerned: Ukraine, Belarus, Russia.
- sandworm101 5y agoI don't understand why Russia, or anyone else, thinks that Ukraine was anywhere near joining NATO. Ukraine had bits of it that were occupied by Russia, specifically Crimea. There was no way Ukraine would have been allowed to join under such circumstances because such occupations would have immediately triggered Article 5. Letting Ukraine into NATO would be tantamount to declaring war on Russia. It was never a real option. What Russia feared was some sort of non-NATO but friendly partnership deal that might see NATO weapons in Ukraine. Actual membership wasn't the issue.
- jopsen 5y agoSpot on, Ukraine wouldn't have joined NATO until their border disputes was resolved. So probably not anytime the next 20-30 years. Demands by Russia were disingenuous, because they would never have been honored. And I doubt honoring them wouldn't have stopped anything.
- CRConrad 5y ago> I don't understand why Russia, or anyone else, thinks that Ukraine was anywhere near joining NATO. I don't understand why anyone thinks that Russia thought that Ukraine was anywhere near joining NATO.
- speeder 5y agoUkraine added that they will join NATO to their constitution, and in the past months NATO started to ramp up the amount of NATO weaponry in or near Ukraine. Russia reaction is basically the reaction of anyone cornered, something Sun Tzu warned about, if someone is cornered they will fight back hard because they can't retreat, they can only go forward, through whoever is cornering them.
- svarnypetr 5y agoI did not make a reconstruction of the timeline, but weren't the NATO amounts growing only after the Russian troops started growing and doing their larger and larger exercises that seemed worrying (and escalated now into the invasion)?
- jjtheblunt 5y agoisn't St Petersburg like an easy target for surrounding countries if they wanted to pester Putin?
- hnarn 5y ago
- cjblomqvist 5y agoThere's a lot of comments about how outrageous the lack of a harsher response (in particular the lack of military action) from the west/NATO/USA is. But, whatabout the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan? Weren't they quite similar (the big difference being that those countries were not close to the US geographically and not really posing a big threat). Why was those invasions ok but not this one? Just to make clear: I'm definitely not in favor of the current invasion.
- jacquesm 5y ago> whatabout Yes, that's what that's called.
- phaistra 5y agoAre you going to address his point?
- LaMarseillaise 5y agoJacquesm demonstrated that there was no point, and therefore nothing to address.
- jopsen 5y ago> But, whatabout the invasions of Iraq and Afghanistan? "whatabout" doesn't justify anything else. But I'll play. In both cases, there was a broad coalition. Troops didn't start an invasion without clear demands. Russia lied about their demands, said their troop deployment was for exercises. Until recently they maintained they weren't going to invade. Say what you want about Iraq and Afghanistan, but the intention of the coalition forces was clear. It's also worth noting that: (1) Afghanistan was self-defense, perhaps an overreaction (that can be debated). (2) An American president actually admitted that Iraq was a mistake. Did it take 6 years for Obama to get elected. To be clear I don't think Iraq or Afghanistan wars were completely justified (or good ideas). But there was plenty of diplomacy around it (all diplomatic attempts by Russia in Ukraine have been disingenuous). Russia didn't threaten the coalition forces with sanctions prior to the invasion. > There's a lot of comments about how outrageous the lack of a harsher response (in particular the lack of military action) from the west/NATO/USA is. There would probably be more outrage, if there was an intervention :D I'm certainly not arguing that it would wise for NATO to intervene.
- _0w8t 5y agoThose threats are for internal Russian consumptions. Those around Putin, as good servants, try to predict what their master wants to please him or at least avoid humiliation. And if they do not do that, then others will report.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sto_hristo 5y agoSo basically Russia said: We will murder you if you don something we don't like. This clearly calls for an economic sanction against <some random guy that brushed elbows with Putin once>.
- sofixa 5y agoPutin and his minister of foreign affairs are hardly "some random guy that brushed elbows with Putin once".
- sto_hristo 5y agoPost written before the sanctions on Putin and Lavrov were implemented. Nevertheless, killing continues. And now China is getting in the mood for some exercises. Around Taiwan. Gotta get fit for that hot summer that is coming. But that is nothing that some demonstration on the street, little bit of sanctions here and there can't avert, right? WW2 also started like that. Someone took some land, others didn't do jack shit about it. Then it escalated and everyone was at it. But without nukes as they were yet to be invented, shortly after.
- jleyank 5y agoPerhaps it’s time to make a European force that can share assets with nato but is independent of the whims of the us. They’re too willing to play their own game or just take their ball and go home.
- iso1631 5y agoWhims of the US? In what way. Article 5 was invoked once, for September 11th. I don't have too much problem with that in principle (although worth noting that other NATO countries don't invoke it when foreign terrorists attacked their cities). The only country I don't think would respond to an Article 5 invocation from a Russian invasion would be Turkey.
- jleyank 5y agoTrying to drag it in ways it thinks best (such as the Middle East) or threatening to leave entirely like the Orange guy was mentioning. The battleground is in the Polish or German plains so one would think they have the most to lose (again). Recall, Germany was only united in 1870, and Poland was both huge and missing in Central Europe over the centuries.
- Shadonototra 5y agoyou know it's all a comedy when you hear declarations like this there is a global agenda behind all this tragic story
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThat would not go well for them. That would definitely get NATO going on the offensive. I say we make both countries honorary NATO members right away.
- koonsolo 5y agoIt seems by the time they have to end the Ukrainian war, there won't be much Russian army left to go up against NATO. Especially since China seems to withhold itself from Putin's decisions.