4 ms·
How is neon extracted and why does one country have a 90% monopoly (in this specific grade)? edit: Found this C&EN story from 2016 that adds context: - "Chip
by perihelions 5y ago
How is neon extracted and why does one country have a 90% monopoly (in this specific grade)?
edit: Found this C&EN story from 2016 that adds context:
- "Chip makers, which account for more than 90% of global neon consumption, are already experiencing high prices and some shortages stemming from the Russian conflict with Ukraine, Shon-Roy says. The war, which started in 2014, interrupted global supplies of the gas, about 70% of which comes from Iceblick, a firm based in the Ukrainian city of Odessa."
- "Iceblick gathers and purifies neon from large cryogenic air separation units that supply oxygen and nitrogen to steelmakers. Most of the air separation units equipped to capture neon, which makes up only 18.2 ppm of the atmosphere by volume, are in Eastern Europe."
https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/cen-09410-notw7 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/cen-09410-notw7
This is puzzling to me, because I don't get why air separation should naturally concentrate in exactly one place. It's not tied to a rare and localized geologic formation, like helium sort-of is.
Also there's cryogenic air separation plants all over the planet, why don't they do neon too? (Asking in the spirit of curiosity)
edit #2: I've just found something that offers a possible explanation and it's far more interesting than I expected:
- "Neon was regarded as a strategic resource in the former Soviet Union, because it was believed to be required for the intended production of laser weapons for missile and satellite defence purposes in the 1980s. Accordingly, all major air separation units in the Soviet Union were equipped with neon, but also krypton and xenon, enrichment facilities or, in some cases, purification plants (cf. Sections 5.4 and 5.5). The domestic Soviet supply of neon was extremely large but demand low."
https://www.deutsche-rohstoffagentur.de/DE/Gemeinsames/Produkte/Downloads/DERA_Rohstoffinformationen/rohstoffinformationen-39_en.pdf https://www.deutsche-rohstoffagentur.de/DE/Gemeinsames/Produ... (chapter 5.2)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- staplers 5y agoAs with chip making, it can be done anywhere but the tools and factories setup to mass produce are concentrated in certain areas. That's just how industry works sometimes. It takes time to setup new supply chains for mass production.
- jagger27 5y agoWe’re seeing this with lithium. Canada and the US have significant amounts in the ground but the mining and refining infra simply isn’t there. Neon distillation does seem much simpler and cleaner, from my layman perspective.
- roughly 5y agoMining (and refining) especially tends to come with some nasty environmental effects that we've been quite happy to outsource to other parts of the world with less empowered citizenry (and often cheaper labor). Rare-earth elements are the same way - they're relatively abundant, but China is enormously over-represented in the market because the west doesn't like mining and China doesn't care.
- martyvis 5y agoNot just lithium. This program aired on the Aussie ABC last night on the terrible way Cobalt mining is being done in Congo and the total dystopia that has been allowed to occur. https://youtu.be/_V3bIzNX4co https://youtu.be/_V3bIzNX4co
- daniel-cussen 5y agoLithium mining is not that nasty. And Tesla for one wants to make it even less toxic. Besides there's just not that much life on the salt flat, yeah flamingos great, and the brine shrimp they eat, but come on. That's one of the meaningful defenses for mining in the Atacama, there's very little life to harm. Much better than mining in the middle of the Amazon, making four species endemic to the orefield extinct, don't you think?
- AlanYx 5y agoLithium is a great example. Canada used to be one of the major lithium producers in the 1950s and still has huge deposits, but output has fallen dramatically over the years and actually declined to zero in 2020.
- tempnow987 5y agoI think it might be tied to steelmaking? Ie, if you are already doing work to generate oxy and nitrogen, getting a byproduct like neon is easier? So CAN the USA separate air? For sure. Maybe it's just cheaper. A lot of these stories about disruptions are disruptions of the CHEAP option.
- belorn 5y agoIt not really a byproduct per say of oxygen and nitrogen, but the byproduct of that process has a higher amount of neon than air by about 99 times. Still, the gas that we got is about 93% argon, and then you got to remove the carbon dioxide, but then its mostly neon left I think.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- saba2008 5y agoIt can be also tied to bespoke equipment, hard-to-transfer expertise and experience. If consumption grows relatively slow, it makes sense to expand single installation, rather than duplicate it with 'copy exactly (which might take too long to pay off).
- nbernard 5y agoAs I understand it, it could be that air separation occurs elsewhere, at different places, and that only purification to extract semiconductor-grade neon is done by Iceblick in Odessa.
- roughly 5y agoScale and geographic concentration tend to push prices lower, even if just fractionally, and relatively low costs of transport for basically anything in the world mean there's no penalty for buying from far away, so there aren't many factors pushing back from geographic concentration. Add to that concentration in other industries - a market with fewer larger buyers means larger average individual demand than otherwise, which pushes towards larger or more concentrated suppliers. Loosely, there's a lot of economic push towards concentration, and not a lot pushing against it. Geopolitics usually operates on a slower scale than market pressures, which means we get weird things like a vested interest in Ukrainian national security due to it being the only country bothering to manufacture neon in the world.
- ajross 5y ago> Scale and geographic concentration tend to push prices lower Neon is extracted from the atmosphere. There is no geographic concentration to exploit (well, I guess technically Antarctica is coldest and so has a volumetric advantage). If Ukraine had the bulk of the supply it's simply because someone decided to invest in a bunch of manufacturing infrastructure there.
- roughly 5y agoI didn't mean geographic concentration of the resource (although that can be a factor) - geographic concentration of firms can often have a knock-on effect on both infrastructure and other supporting resources (a dock that can support exporting neon, neon-extraction-machine repair & service companies nearby, concentrated local expertise, etc).
- daniel-cussen 5y agoIt's funny I was talking to precisely a steelmaker about imports and exporters some time ago: "The American is no patriot, if steel is 30% cheaper in Japan, he will buy it there rather than at home." It looks like, in fact, these Ukranians, also in the steel industry, might actually be doing something patriotic--like people all over the world, America too--and keep the surely very tricky and specific technology to themselves. It's not unlike German "hidden champions", companies that figured out a niche safe from industrial espionage, usually something involving very precise know-how regarding something analog, and nobody can do it like they can. German hidden champions are generally family-owned, rather than public companies, and prefer it that way; they stay in Germany typically; and there are 300 of them by some reasonable reckoning. They make the critical thing that goes in the thing that goes in the thing. Taiwan does something similar--they see their chip industry, which is also very dependent on human know-how and highly analog, high precision--as a patriotic endeavor that protects their sovereignty economically and geopolitically. So, apparently the reason neon comes from Ukraine is some pretty smart Ukrainians wanted it that way, for the good of Ukraine, and specifically for Ukrainian sovereignty to matter to the rest of the world.
- eru 5y ago> So, apparently the reason neon comes from Ukraine is some pretty smart Ukrainians wanted it that way, for the good of Ukraine, and specifically for Ukrainian sovereignty to matter to the rest of the world. Nope. See the other comments here, that explain that the Soviet Union overinvested in this technology because they wanted to build weapons with it. It would probably have been better for the people of the Soviet Union (or Ukraine now) to have invested these billions into something else, or even just consumed them.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoYou seem to be right, it was a military-industrial move by the Soviet Union to counter the Strategic Defense Initiative (Star Wars). Having read a briefing describing the rocket involved, it Star Wars was cutting-edge 2060's technology that happened to be possible in the 80's due to a long list of edge cases. Well in the end, those neon producers harmed capitalism as intended.
- Jiro 5y agoNeon is not the main reason they are doing it. It's a byproduct that gives them a little extra profit once they've distilled the air anyway for other reasons. Distilling the air just to get neon wouldn't be profitable.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoNo. But if you're Air Liquide or somebody in the US, and you're distilling the air anyway, adding the capability to extract the neon might make sense.
- lazide 5y agoOnly if the soviets hadn’t already spent until billions adding the capacity to overproduce it due to a perceived national security need that didn’t pan out. It’s essentially free for the company to do this since the gov’t already sunk the cost decades ago. No one has done that for Air liquide, at least not yet.
- robertlagrant 5y agoSometimes even a non-invisible hand of the market can get it right, if only by accident.
- eru 5y agoWhat do you mean by 'get it right' in this case? How would getting it wrong look?
- robertlagrant 5y agoGetting it wrong would be something that was a waste of money or deadly.
- adrian_b 5y agoObviously the monopoly was due to the fact that they were able to sell it at the cheapest price for the required purity. There should be no significant problems to create production capacities in other places, but then the price would become higher and, more importantly, a few months or even years might be needed until the neon production would be increased enough to compensate for a sudden loss of the source from Ukraine.
- baybal2 5y ago> How is neon extracted and why does one country have a 90% monopoly (in this specific grade)? "Specific grade" - you need very, very, very high purity gasses for lasers. Noble gasses are very, very, very hard to purify because they are chemically inert. Welding gas (argon) is dirt cheap, 99.99% pure argon is surprisingly expensive, and semiconductor grade Argon, or Neon at 99.99999%+ purity far more. Ultrapure neon is a great example of a single source critical input for the semiconductor industry. There are hundreds of similar small companies around the world supplying something completely irreplaceable. Semiconductor industry is extremely fragile.
- eru 5y ago> Semiconductor industry is extremely fragile. Not sure that's true. After all, it doesn't break down all the time, does it?
- Supermancho 5y ago> How is neon extracted and why does one country have a 90% monopoly Monopoly is a misused term. Many monopolies around the world are market capture due to being sunk cost low price leaders. Replace "monopoly" with "cornered the market".
- xracy 5y agoThat's what a monopoly is... They've entirely cornered the market for a good...
- alex_sf 5y agoNot quite. They don't have complete control of the market to where they can bring on the onerous things that come with what we'd traditionally define as a monopoly, price gouging, etc. They can just make it cheaper.
- CharlieFinch 5y agoHi, is Neon the reason Elon Musk is exploring Mars? Apparently it's meteors are rich in Neon, its atmosphere is rich in Neon and its mantle is possibly richher in Neon? https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0019103521003419 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S001910352... Mars’ atmospheric neon suggests volatile-rich primitive mantle
- CharlieFinch 5y agoUkraine supplies 90% high grade semiconductor global neon from it's iron ore mines. https://venturebeat.com/2022/02/24/ukraine-supplies-90-percent-of-us-semiconductor-grade-neon-what-it-means-to-chip-supply-chain/ https://venturebeat.com/2022/02/24/ukraine-supplies-90-perce... Key iron ore mine locations have been ''annexed'' by recent Russian invasion - Crimea, etc. in a pincer like strategic configuration. Please see map https://www.mining-technology.com/projects/shymanivske-iron-ore-project-dnepropetrovsk/ https://www.mining-technology.com/projects/shymanivske-iron-... Ninety per cent of neon production is in Russia and Ukraine.[43] As of 2020, the company Iceblick, with plants in Odessa and Moscow, supplies 65 per cent of the world's production of neon, as well as 15% of the krypton and xenon.[44][45] Neon gas is extracted as a byproduct of iron smelting from neon rich iron ore.